Khuda Aur Mohabbat 3 | Discussion Thread #9 - Page 41

Originally posted by: rivaanvira

I should've added a disclaimer: This excludes scenes pertaining to Feedi and anyone interacting with Feedi including his relatives and friends and so called relatives & friends with the sole exception of Mahi and her relatives and friends and her so called relatives and friends ..

😆

Baki sab changa hai ji ..

I do not care about who meets him and how they meet him, because now everyone have their own reasons to meet him, Roma meets him to get his dua, Mahi will want guilt free maafi, Sikka will want shifa, everyone needs something, but only Amma and Dil will meet him because they genuinely loved him.

I wnat the reunions so badly Riv, I feel like a desperate loser now, who does not care about the male lead and female leading meeting anymore, who just wants the mom-son reunion to happen.

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

His voice though, the performance is a silent killer here.

And even the dialogues here, it felt like i could see a reflection of the old episodes here.

'Tumhe sach kahu'? that line itself had so much power, sach bolna, yes exactly, yehi hai Feedi, jiski dua kabhi kabool hi nahi huyi, usko duya karni nahi aati.

I am appalled that if HN could give so much depth to Feedi and Romana why did not he do that for Mahi also? Like we at least know that the effect of Dua and mohabbat and even baddua's concept is high in this show, but neither he showed Mahi having any Dua, nor mohabbat, not even a desire to have mohabbat, WTH is the character in a show like KAM3?

Its just unfortunate that wasted away Mahi's character growth ..

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

I do not care about who meets him and how they meet him, because now everyone have their own reasons to meet him, Roma meets him to get his dua, Mahi will want guilt free maafi, Sikka will want shifa, everyone needs something, but only Amma and Dil will meet him because they genuinely loved him.

I wnat the reunions so badly Riv, I feel like a desperate loser now, who does not care about the male lead and female leading meeting anymore, who just wants the mom-son reunion to happen.

Honestly, the desolate love no longer needs redemption .. everyone is approaching with a selfishness .. hence we no longer feel the need as well .. the only unselfish relationship that he carries is with his mother & dilawar .. lets see how that unfolds .. hope it unfolds ..

Originally posted by: rivaanvira

I was like aur kitna bacha hai .. I wasnt even listening to them .. every scene was more ridiculous than prior one ..

even the rumana-mahi scene .. dehleez ki dua .. naseebo wali koi dehleez .. what kind of dialogues were these .. !!

This reminds me of that movie - Hamari Adhuri Kahani and boy those dialogues said by ML's mother to FL .. 👎🏼🤢 puke fest .. I was like koi mere kaan ke keede bhar do before I hear these dialogues again ..

Roma-Mahi scene was another one, like it gets lamer and even more bizzare, why so much emphasis on becoming a haveli's bahu, the writer has obsession kya, matlab ladkiyo ke paas haveli ki khwab dekh ne ke ilava koi kam nahi hai kya? no matter how regressive the insaan in those haveli are, inko haveli hi chahiye.

This show traumatizes my intelligence, matlab jisko bhi mohabbat hojaye galati se, woh bhikhari hojata hai, and mind you jagirdar logo ko free ticket miljata hai to be eligible for being the object of affection.

Romana sikka ko pane ke liye wants prayers, only if she would see that Sikka cares about ding dong at this point, nothing more.

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

Farhad said 'Khwab bhi woh jo maine dekha tha', because there was a clear cut argument between Mahi and him where he asks her that 'Mere khwab jhoote hai'? and she says 'yes'. So Farhad implying all his khwab are delusions, only rooted from the fact that entire humiliation, there was a good enough chance that Mahi only pretended to break his heart while being in love (which was our theory), but seems like she did not and to a n extent was genuine with her words, so all the hocus pocus was basically because we were not given a clear indication from the execution that what Mahi actually thought.

Yeah .. her portrayal on screen left lot to be desired and led to us getting deluded .. otherwise the OST is very clear in giving us the message about what the story would be overall .. minute details mein hi gadhon ne khachar pane kar diya ..😡

Originally posted by: rivaanvira

Honestly, the desolate love no longer needs redemption .. everyone is approaching with a selfishness .. hence we no longer feel the need as well .. the only unselfish relationship that he carries is with his mother & dilawar .. lets see how that unfolds .. hope it unfolds ..

I just want his amma to see him alive, and he needs to redeem the son he is, I do not care about any other aspect at this point, the fact is that he forgot hi whole life for a woman who did not care much about him, and he ruined himself beyond repair now, and the mother of Lahore's Farhad never deserved it, who knew that her son was in some sort of grief, who wanted to share with him, but he did not give her a chance to help him get out of the grief. The only complain I have with Feedi is he abandoned the woman who loved him, for a woman who only humiliated him.

FeeDil are the most genuine and unselfish bond that this show has, and a re-union is necessary, they could not see off each other in BP, in Multan they will, Feedi should die only after these 2 reunions.

Originally posted by: rivaanvira

Its just unfortunate that wasted away Mahi's character growth ..

Not even waste, there was no foundation for the character itself.

Like what are her basic traits? Do you know? I mean I do not.

For example we know Farhad wanted to have a fairy talish love saga, we know he can never lie, we know that he is stubborn, we know that he is gullible and lets himself played easily, we know what he wanted.

However for Mahi, what is she? what she wanted? what was her life's motto? What was her biggest flaw? What is her strength? Do you know? Nahi na? Matlab itna bakwas writing for the female lead? What on earth? Omigod, my head hurts😡

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

Roma-Mahi scene was another one, like it gets lamer and even more bizzare, why so much emphasis on becoming a haveli's bahu, the writer has obsession kya, matlab ladkiyo ke paas haveli ki khwab dekh ne ke ilava koi kam nahi hai kya? no matter how regressive the insaan in those haveli are, inko haveli hi chahiye.

This show traumatizes my intelligence, matlab jisko bhi mohabbat hojaye galati se, woh bhikhari hojata hai, and mind you jagirdar logo ko free ticket miljata hai to be eligible for being the object of affection.

🤣Its like watching brainless comedies for laughter sake ..

Romana sikka ko pane ke liye wants prayers, only if she would see that Sikka cares about ding dong at this point, nothing more.

Honestly speaking I do not know what HN was thinking when penning this story .. I mean what was his objective here? KAM ke naam pe kya karna chah raha tha woh?

And the dialogues are cringe-worthy .. at its best .. imagine in the worst scenario ..

See I lost all hopes, faith, expectation from the Paro run wala episode and now I do not see any redemption left in the show except for Feedi scenes .. (minus Mahi in them) ..

Nothing that these characters do outside of Feedi perimeter make any sense at all ..

Just let the logic go.. dont waste anymore energy or time ..

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

I just want his amma to see him alive, and he needs to redeem the son he is, I do not care about any other aspect at this point, the fact is that he forgot hi whole life for a woman who did not care much about him, and he ruined himself beyond repair now, and the mother of Lahore's Farhad never deserved it, who knew that her son was in some sort of grief, who wanted to share with him, but he did not give her a chance to help him get out of the grief. The only complain I have with Feedi is he abandoned the woman who loved him, for a woman who only humiliated him.

FeeDil are the most genuine and unselfish bond that this show has, and a re-union is necessary, they could not see off each other in BP, in Multan they will, Feedi should die only after these 2 reunions.

@bold: Agree 200% and here I feel he turned out to be so selfish in love that he completely forgot his mother's love .. and thats my disappointment too ..

If we compare this to Devdas story .. father never liked him, mother's fav was elder son .. and on top they played a game with this love & told him to quit the gaon ..

whereas, here the case was completely reversed .. loving family vs deluded love .. utter nonsensical ..

lagta hai HN probably got blinded by Bhansali larger than life cinematography of Devdas that he forgot to focus on story ..😵

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

Not even waste, there was no foundation for the character itself.

Like what are her basic traits? Do you know? I mean I do not.

For example we know Farhad wanted to have a fairy talish love saga, we know he can never lie, we know that he is stubborn, we know that he is gullible and lets himself played easily, we know what he wanted.

However for Mahi, what is she? what she wanted? what was her life's motto? What was her biggest flaw? What is her strength? Do you know? Nahi na? Matlab itna bakwas writing for the female lead? What on earth? Omigod, my head hurts😡

Nah I think there was some foundation but they didnt establish it well .. it was a weak foundation .. Its like the dedication that Farhad's character got & deserved, they didnt find it worthy enough to give it to her character ..

had they spent little more time establishing her character arc well instead of focusing on saas-bahu politics and slo-mo stretching of episodes .. even that wouldve done justice to the show ..

itna delusion & headache na hota hame