Do we really need to save the show from going off air? - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

112

Views

6.8k

Users

21

Likes

281

Frequent Posters

-Ila- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
i think we can agree to disagree in this matter
yaar i am a huge fan...i will be sad to see the show ending...but i was still ok with it ending on July 17...but then they brought june 27 and that is like 12 epis more...they cant show a proper closure in such a short period ...i am ready to fight for the show for 2 more weeks😆
Shwets1502 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: love_taher

Ohkay, im sorry but seriously, this topic was nt for u guys to spam


@Shwets1502 the LA track was about nisha finding an aim, a goal in her life. And she found it in shooting. The show is about Nisha and her cousins,nisha is the protagonist...its a nisha centric show mainly. And given her backstory, the LA track was necessary. A male lead WAS necessary, simply to make her realise that all men are nt the same, that she too can trust a man, she too can love, she too can be made to feel beautiful. All about shekhs, gaya, was to establish the male lead...Viraj's backstory.

I can c that the LA track shifted some focus from ramy-nisha-lakshmi, and given that ur a ramy fan u wud nt like it. Understandable. But even during the LA track we had the basic gist of the story intact. We did have really wonderful RLN scenes, the song-remember? There was something abt the cousins too- Umesh-Aman's marriage- which portrayed all the problems faced by 2 ppl who do nt belong to the same caste and are in love. Kirti's track- which showed us the repercussions of not finding abt the guy enough before giving ur daughter's hand in marriage to him.

What did cm track give us? Lying to ur parents, bringing in fake relatives at ur wedding, marrying on rebound? This track was so clichd, im sorry. And the fj track, dont get me started abt it.


And abt the seasons, if American shows are doing it, and its being accepted by the indian audiences,why cant we? Its a youth show, if u love a show, u will eagerly wait for it and watch it wen it comes back. Thats the whole point of having seasons, keeping the storyline and wid it the audiences intact,while giving a break to the actors and writers.


First...that wasn't spamming. That was chatting off topic.

A male lead wasn't necessary to make Nisha realise all men were the same. A male was enough. It could have always been (it is still) one sided love which could have ended in a rejection. There was no need for a story for Viraj or to bring in Kabir later. Nisha is 23..and she can be single and lead her life and career.

Point 2. Nisha was interested in shooting because Viraj was a shooter. She never had a aim or a goal. She could have been shown struggling to follow rules and control her temper in a normal office environment too where she could have met different people.

@bold There is no need to bring in "fan" now. That's judgmental. I could have easily judged you by the user name and the topic you have opened. But I didn't. I guess there is no point in discussing further.
_UptoNoGood_ thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
Woah! Woah! That escalated quickly!😲
To people who got offended by the "no work" comment-
My POV is that petitions should be for more serious/useful purposes. OK, you think this is serious enough... Still, at least play fair. Multiple ids to make it look like there are more people? Really? You're going to fool the channel into thinking that? FYI they're ahead of the curve and very much aware of the fooling tricks. Also, ethically wrong. Pestering them.. Etc. Ummm... Whatever, I don't think it is a good idea and hence a waste of time.
Plus, this whole fandom thing is not exactly productive stuff. But we don't have to be productive all the time. This.Is.Not. Productive. But. We. Are. Doing. It. Still a waste.😛
P.S.I have a lot of free time. Read: No work. Nothing to be offended about.
@Shwetha di- Just a question: you have issues with being called a Ramesh fan? Kyun?
Shwets1502 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: _UptoNoGood_

Woah! Woah! That escalated quickly!😲

To people who got offended by the "no work" comment-
My POV is that petitions should be for more serious/useful purposes. OK, you think this is serious enough... Still, at least play fair. Multiple ids to make it look like there are more people? Really? You're going to fool the channel into thinking that? FYI they're ahead of the curve and very much aware of the fooling tricks. Also, ethically wrong. Pestering them.. Etc. Ummm... Whatever, I don't think it is a good idea and hence a waste of time.
Plus, this whole fandom thing is not exactly productive stuff. But we don't have to be productive all the time. This.Is.Not. Productive. But. We. Are. Doing. It. Still a waste.😛
P.S.I have a lot of free time. Read: No work. Nothing to be offended about.
@Shwetha di- Just a question: you have issues with being called a Ramesh fan? Kyun?


I am a proud Ramesh fan...😊

But bringing that inside the discussion wasn't needed. It was more like...you did get Ramesh scenes during LA track..why do you complain then? My problem was the story of the LA track and how the other parallel story never took off.
princessglory thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Just one question anybody can give reply ppl complaining that during LA track the other tracks were not given importance Now other tracks all other cousins tracks r going on matlab Saare cousins ka track bhi chal raha hain kya Dont know as I am not watching the show becoz I heard Umesh and Kirti left now Jwala also left so just curiosity
_UptoNoGood_ thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Shwets1502


I am a proud Ramesh fan...😊

But bringing that inside the discussion wasn't needed. It was more like...you did get Ramesh scenes during LA track..why do you complain then? My problem was the story of the LA track and how the other parallel story never took off.

I think it is really convenient how Viraj fans being tagged was OK...and this isn't. But well, back to the topic.
@bold-I'm not sure exactly what you mean but I agree that its become a fiasco. OK they didn't want Nisha with Viraj. But I believe you will agree that a guy was required who could do away with paranoia. OK she fell in love/developed a crush. If you wanted to show how first crushes don't always work out... Did you have to make such a scene of it? What does a girl learn? Every man is after all attracted. Perfect.
Then we had Nisha wanting to pursue a dream, take some time off etc. All against Dadaji's wishes. Now, she goes on and gets married. Then it starts to work out. So Dadaji was right? A girl should be married off at the earliest so her life remains sorted.
And CM... If any good comes out of something so silly and wrong... Well, definitely, I'm not rooting for extensions.

Edited by _UptoNoGood_ - 10 years ago
Shwets1502 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: _UptoNoGood_

I think it is really convenient how Viraj fans being tagged was OK...and this isn't. But well, back to the topic.
@bold-I'm not sure exactly what you mean but I agree that its become a fiasco. OK they didn't want Nisha with Viraj. But I believe you will agree that a guy was required who could do away with paranoia. OK she fell in love/developed a crush. If you wanted to show how first crushes don't always work out... Did you have to make such a scene of it? What does a girl learn? Every man is after all attracted. Perfect.
Then we had Nisha wanting to pursue a dream, take some time off etc. All against Dadaji's wishes. Now, she goes on and gets married. Then it starts to work out. So Dadaji was right? A girl should be married off at the earliest so her life remains sorted.
And CM... If any good comes out of something so silly and wrong... Well, definitely, I'm not rooting for extensions.


There was no need for Buaji or Shekhs and bring in negativity there...Male was needed...not a male lead. I made it clear before itself. I loved the concept of crust, first love, rejection...everything. I never had any problem with that...but they over did it at the end. Now with this on going on one side...what did we get on the other side? There was again no reason to get Viraj involved in GF through Aman which made no sense till the end. My problem was the importance given to love and marriage and not career. What happened in LA was all revolving around just love and nothing else.

There was Umesh and Aman track...where both had nothing to do but Nisha. Yes she is the central character..then there was no need for having the cousins around. The dance competition made no sense too as LA pretty much isn't running now.

@bold Dadaji wanted Nisha to marry...but he allowed her to work, go for her dreams too...One has to be determined...and Nisha was.

As for CM...i never said it was interested or good.

My conclusion...LA track could have just shown and kept focus on Nisha's life and her crush on her boss and rejection and moving on...Lead could have been introduced later.
_UptoNoGood_ thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Shwets1502


There was no need for Buaji or Shekhs and bring in negativity there...Male was needed...not a male lead. I made it clear before itself. I loved the concept of crust, first love, rejection...everything. I never had any problem with that...but they over did it at the end. Now with this on going on one side...what did we get on the other side? There was again no reason to get Viraj involved in GF through Aman which made no sense till the end. My problem was the importance given to love and marriage and not career. What happened in LA was all revolving around just love and nothing else.

There was Umesh and Aman track...where both had nothing to do but Nisha. Yes she is the central character..then there was no need for having the cousins around. The dance competition made no sense too as LA pretty much isn't running now.

@bold Dadaji wanted Nisha to marry...but he allowed her to work, go for her dreams too...One has to be determined...and Nisha was.

As for CM...i never said it was interested or good.

My conclusion...LA track could have just shown and kept focus on Nisha's life and her crush on her boss and rejection and moving on...Lead could have been introduced later.


@bold- I think we have had this discussion before, all of that seemed to be designed to establish Viraj. Then the CVs changed their minds. This I believe took away the crispness of the story. All that now seems like a waste. I believe every moment in a story should add up to something. Somewhere NAUC has messed up that equation.

What is Nisha's dream exactly? Yes, Dadaji allowed her all that but AFTER marriage. With marriage. The whole concept of marriage being irrelevant/secondary is not established.
But you want things to fall into place right? Nisha-Kabir, Ramesh-Kabir... Etc. My point is, such an idea should have brought only humiliation. This, according to me should NOT work out. Everyone is cool with it.
Edit- sorry wrong usage: I mean marriage being optional.
Edited by _UptoNoGood_ - 10 years ago
Shwets1502 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: _UptoNoGood_


@bold- I think we have had this discussion before, all of that seemed to be designed to establish Viraj. Then the CVs changed their minds. This I believe took away the crispness of the story. All that now seems like a waste. I believe every moment in a story should add up to something. Somewhere NAUC has messed up that equation.

What is Nisha's dream exactly? Yes, Dadaji allowed her all that but AFTER marriage. With marriage. The whole concept of marriage being irrelevant/secondary is not established.
But you want things to fall into place right? Nisha-Kabir, Ramesh-Kabir... Etc. My point is, such an idea should have brought only humiliation. This, according to me should NOT work out. Everyone is cool with it.


My problem was always why the first guy should be THE GUY. I am not talking in support of Kabir or Nisha's marriage here. But I am actually satisfied with the fact that they didn't show Nisha ending up with Viraj...because most of the times that doesn't happen in real life. It would be a fantasy story.

Nisha never had a dream. She wanted to be independent..that's it. It's upto the girl...and not everyone will have dreams all the time to follow. I don't know what to do in my life even now...But things would definitely strike. Shooting wasn't Nisha's dreams. Independence was her aim.

What else can be done now? She is married and it's a stupid decision made...Marriage isn't something to play with. Family can't wrong this marriage...erase everything and start afresh...but see how to make this foolish decision work.
Teogapi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
@ shivi: people do signup for more serious petition too... Its not a crime that we are signing up to save the show... We do support social petitions as well..so when kabir nisha marriage was finalised people did sign petitions for niraj reunion so why are they calling us vele when we are singing up for the show.. We are not harming anyone... Once I read a comment in the forum where viraj fans were asked to complain to the broadcasting forum and sent hate mails to sp... So why are we targeted now for trying to save the show...

IMO viraj nisha love story was not needed at all... A male lead wasn't needed... Nisha knew that all men are not the same coz she was friends with saurav and loved her family... And to those who were saying nisha moved on I would say it was majorly because she told her parents about that incident and that session with sheks helped too...
Edited by Teogapi - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".