Judge comments

Page

ShivTRSS

@ShivTRSS

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

I am a little disappointed(as always) with Judges comments

I really feel this is all partiality

Saravi performance was amazing, still they got a little weird comments don't you think? I felt like, just because Sajid commented that there was less dance, Terrance and Shilpa both were avoiding to give good comments
Terrance did say that there are different types of dancing(obviously regarding Sajid's comment), but he didn't praise them much.
Maybe I am completely wrong, this is what I felt. I wonder, why Sajid is judge. He does not know any thing about dance and gives so weird comments.

When they dance, he does not like it. When its entertainment(except Neelu Arvind), he wants more dance. So how do they judge exactly.

Also in past, when new concepts were tried, they don't seem to understand the concepts when the audience does. So how will the standard of their dancing rise?
Obviously, it is raised, being in top 6, but I want some honest comments.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Holla1

@Holla1

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

Exactly what I felt.

I feel that the contestants this year are great, they are capable of dancing, especially some couples...but the judges this year are horrible!

First off, What on earth is Sajid doing there? I understand many directors have started to judge reality shows, but seriously, him...of all the people? Neither have I enjoyed his films, and then to add to it, his arrogance and rude behaviour, nor do I feel he even knows the ABC's of dance.

In the end, I really just ignore him because for me, he wants dance when he sees emotional acts...and when he sees senseless comedies, he gives them 11...and after rahul-dimpy he is being wayy too partial to neelu-arvind. Sure, they are great dancers but Im sorry, I did not find their act worthy of 33 today...the others were much much better. Do they give them good marks because they are older in age, or that Sajid really just LIKES Arvind...Its all rigged for me!

Shilpa is alright but she barely has a say in all this.

Terrence I feel is the true and just judge. He is obviously a choreographer, so he knows it the second he sees the first step of the act. And, he gives points accordingly...if you notice, he refrains from giving perfect 11's lately, and ends it off with 10...also, in the beginning, often times, he has tried to contradict Sajid's statements, but now he is also realizing that there is no point talking to a dead wall...

and star plus is not smart to keep pushing and promoting sajid...do they read the views of the audience, perhaps, they should come here...because most of us agree with the biased and partiality of the judges...

though i do agree with their one point today...neither shefali parag nor sargun-ravi deserved to be in the bottom 2 today...well then, shouldnt they themselves start judging accordingly because their marks obviously play a big role!

i liked sarguns and ravi's act today, but you could tell that terrence was restricting from contradicting sajids point today like you mentioned...pray i still ask, why is he sitting on that chair?

Edited by Holla1 - 12 years ago

Quote

Judge comments

Related Topics

Explore Topics