Comment about 3rd semi's Shaan Vs Shankar Match - Page 5

Originally posted by: bambooshoot

Oh Pinky...my dear Pinky! We've been missing your great comments here.

And talking about Niti's singing and BEAT HAALUM HAALUM's comments on the great qawali medeley, I literally had to take off my headphones when she screeched "O Laal meri" into it.😆

http://www.india-forums.com/video/video.asp?vc=E71A3123-1EB7-453B-A79D-587989C24393

Did u watch this video, di? Why is Anu crying at the end? I feel so bad for Shaan. He truly is a genuine person and taking a 'righteous stand' in his own words for his contestants. His career might go for a toss after all this .....

I am so sad to see how Neeti is being defended for singing 4 lines in a duet and for managing to forget two out of four lines....How incompetent was that?

Thank God that Shreya Ghoshal participated in shows where musical stalwarts like Kishoribai Amankar, Pandit Jasraj and the likes of them were judges who were loyal to only music and not music directors..Wonder what would have happened to her if she participated in this kind of musical mockery shows. My heart feels so heavy. Shaan has to learn acting neutral and disinterested like Mohit did for his fighters. He is genuinely involved with his team...
Shaan aap shayad jeetenge nahin par humein garv hai ki aap bohot shaan se lad rahe hain... 👏 👏

Shankar ji played safe.He (mis)used the format of the show.May be we can see MORE shankar ji in the finale.😉😛

@PIPC : Lovely post! I agree with you on every point - especially the musical shows of today which truly are a mockery compared to real musical shows. In this show, Mika proudly argues that performances should be marked on 'josh' and connecting with the audience. Himesh downmarked Ameya for not having Josh even though he had perfect sur!

Today the definition of music seems to have changed. Nasal HR sells CDs and concerts. Remixes top the charts. Josh is more important than sur. The only purpose of music is to dance.

But Reading posts like yours makes me realise that true music lovers exist after all! thank you :)

EDIT:

Disagree with you on won point, though: Shaan will win for sure.

Jeetenge SHAAN Se!

well shan was right too she forgot the word but why mika fighting

Originally posted by: PIPC

http://www.india-forums.com/video/video.asp?vc=E71A3123-1EB7-453B-A79D-587989C24393

Did u watch this video, di? Why is Anu crying at the end? I feel so bad for Shaan. He truly is a genuine person and taking a 'righteous stand' in his own words for his contestants. His career might go for a toss after all this .....

I am so sad to see how Neeti is being defended for singing 4 lines in a duet and for managing to forget two out of four lines....How incompetent was that?

Thank God that Shreya Ghoshal participated in shows where musical stalwarts like Kishoribai Amankar, Pandit Jasraj and the likes of them were judges who were loyal to only music and not music directors..Wonder what would have happened to her if she participated in this kind of musical mockery shows. My heart feels so heavy. Shaan has to learn acting neutral and disinterested like Mohit did for his fighters. He is genuinely involved with his team...
Shaan aap shayad jeetenge nahin par humein garv hai ki aap bohot shaan se lad rahe hain... 👏 👏

Don't worry Pinky! I have great hopes for Shaan's team this time. We have all gone through a lot of pain and heartbreak as we witnessed the injustice that was meted out to Shona last time, because of which our love for her has multiplied ten fold. I know that we had all given up on Gajendra Singh at that time. Harshit had also suffered to a great extent.

But I truly believe that there is something called a conscience which every single person has. Shaan has got some of the best members in the team, each of who have managed to bring in at least one SOD award. His popularity that was always there has grown even more. Anu is shining like the brightest star. I feel very positive this time. Please don't lose hope😃.

Originally posted by: xobile

@PIPC : Lovely post! I agree with you on every point - especially the musical shows of today which truly are a mockery compared to real musical shows. In this show, Mika proudly argues that performances should be marked on 'josh' and connecting with the audience. Himesh downmarked Ameya for not having Josh even though he had perfect sur!

Today the definition of music seems to have changed. Nasal HR sells CDs and concerts. Remixes top the charts. Josh is more important than sur. The only purpose of music is to dance.

But Reading posts like yours makes me realise that true music lovers exist after all! thank you :)

EDIT:

Disagree with you on won point, though: Shaan will win for sure.

Jeetenge SHAAN Se!

Thank you xobile...Even I want Shaan and his team to win as his team is the most deserving one. But, because of this sorry state of affairs in these musical reality shows, I just prepare myself for the worst outcome.
We all are music lovers and that's why we are rooting for the best team in the show, right?
Cheers to us all shaan fans and here's hoping that Shaan and his team rock the show and win it by a huge margin ... 😊

Originally posted by: bambooshoot

Don't worry Pinky! I have great hopes for Shaan's team this time. We have all gone through a lot of pain and heartbreak as we witnessed the injustice that was meted out to Shona last time, because of which our love for her has multiplied ten fold. I know that we had all given up on Gajendra Singh at that time. Harshit had also suffered to a great extent.

But I truly believe that there is something called a conscience which every single person has. Shaan has got some of the best members in the team, each of who have managed to bring in at least one SOD award. His popularity that was always there has grown even more. Anu is shining like the brightest star. I feel very positive this time. Please don't lose hope😃.

We were together through Anwesha's 'Chhote ustaad' journey and you know how it was. When somebody so deserving and talented has to go through this kind of treatment, he/she starts losing his/her belief in one's self. The first day itself Anwesha got very high marks from the judges and broke into tears. Because, the poor child's belief in herself got crushed by that notorious defeat. Acknowledgement of true talent helps it to thrive and the lack of it stifles it.

I am so glad that her belief in herself is getting reinforced. I was so happy to hear Shankar's comment that Anwesha is the next best find of the reality shows after Shreya Ghoshal 👏 ⭐️ .
I just want that Anwesha gets noticed by the great music directors and gets her due. When I saw that poor child crying again today my heart went out to her. Hope this is her last reality show as a contestant and she gets the well-deserved break in the music industry and makes it really big....
⭐️

well I agree Shaan's team has better singers than Shankars, but singing wise I think Shankar is a genius and altogether in a different league compared to others on the show.

All Shankar said to the judges that just make a note of the presence of mind they used during the song when neeti forgot her mistakes. Everyone makes mistakes how a person comes out of the mistake is also important. Although I am no big fan of rahul or neeti but it looked wonderful the way they came out of it. I think Shaan completely overreacted. Even when there was so much yelling and shouting by shaan, Shankar was cool, that says lot about the person. He would never have reacted the same way shaan did if shaan did the same thing as Shankar.