Comment about 3rd semi's Shaan Vs Shankar Match - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

163

Views

17.9k

Users

44

Likes

155

Frequent Posters

safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: baghabayen



They are very professional..This incident not going to hamper shaan's career for sure.But there will be a doubt in audience's mind why shankar ji stood up against shadab?not only once but twice..that means he do not have confidence on his team members.They do not have ability to score 9 against shadab 😆



Hmmm funny question .
No one can stop them..Shaan is not rising question against him,if he think so like that,he just saying wat injustice happening with him,and y judges gave10 Marks while all know wats wrong happened in Neeti's and Rahul performance..

Many,Lot Of MD's Love to work with Shaan,We never mind if Shaan is not Part of him,Hope he wont think like that..

Edited by safeenafarheen - 15 years ago
bgirl thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#32
Folks! I have gone from 😭 to 😃 through a path of enlightenment! I will only focus on positives such as:

1. Shadab sang well. He forced Shankar himself to stand up against him.
2. Anwesha sang great. Once again Shankar was forced to compete.
3. Shaan spoke up for his team, and his beliefs. Got to love principled arguments!
4. Have you seen how Shaan's medleys are rocking and more importantly sureeley? Can't say the same for all medleys on this show. (my opinion, don't kill me people)
5. Every member of Shaan's team gets great scope on a regular basis to demonstrate their talent as singers and team players.

Sab achcha toh chal raha hai! Scores ko goli maro.

xobile thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: bgirl

Folks! I have gone from 😭 to 😃 through a path of enlightenment! I will only focus on positives such as:

1. Shadab sang well. He forced Shankar himself to stand up against him.
2. Anwesha sang great. Once again Shankar was forced to compete.
3. Shaan spoke up for his team, and his beliefs. Got to love principled arguments!
4. Have you seen how Shaan's medleys are rocking and more importantly sureeley? Can't say the same for all medleys on this show. (my opinion, don't kill me people)
5. Every member of Shaan's team gets great scope on a regular basis to demonstrate their talent as singers and team players.

Sab achcha toh chal raha hai! Scores ko goli maro.



That's true!

Plus in the competition overall, nobody can stop Shaan's Strikers from getting to the final - they are popular, they sing well, they have a good position on the scores table. This team is definitely in the final.

And it is a TEAM where EVERYONE sings - not like Shankar's team where there is one singer (Shankar) and four others who want to sing but aren't given the chance. His team should be called Shankar's Cheerleaders not Shankar's Rockstars.

Jeetenge SHAAN Se!
baghabayen thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: bgirl

Folks! I have gone from 😭 to 😃 through a path of enlightenment! I will only focus on positives such as:

1. Shadab sang well. He forced Shankar himself to stand up against him.
2. Anwesha sang great. Once again Shankar was forced to compete.
3. Shaan spoke up for his team, and his beliefs. Got to love principled arguments!
4. Have you seen how Shaan's medleys are rocking and more importantly sureeley? Can't say the same for all medleys on this show. (my opinion, don't kill me people)
5. Every member of Shaan's team gets great scope on a regular basis to demonstrate their talent as singers and team players.

Sab achcha toh chal raha hai! Scores ko goli maro.



Agreed with you.Enjoy good music in this episode.specially the song shankar sang against shadab and his medley based on qawali ....One of the best medley in MKMM so far.Shankar is too good..After A.R.Rahman if anybody can make it to Oscar he is Shankar Mahadevan.A great singer and a great MD.
Edited by baghabayen - 15 years ago
rudr_26 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#35
Shankar is great singer and MD but he is showng his true colors here. He is really cunning and unfair whn it comes to winning.

If he wants to listen to him , then have a concert and give free entry to all, why robbing the new singers in a reality show. everyone knws Anwesha and Shadab cant compete against SHankar.. But i m proud of both of them. they did the best they can do. I also appreciate Shaan that he is the best captain giving fair chance to everyone..

Apart from it, enjoy music. Anwesha got the best comment in the show. and anyone who doubts her standard should eat a humble pie.

safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: baghabayen



Agreed with you.Enjoy good music in this episode.specially the song shankar sang against shadab and his medley based on qawali ....One of the best medley in MKMM so far.Shankar is too good..After A.R.Rahman if anybody can make it to Oscar he is Shankar Mahadevan.A great singer and a great MD.



Ya that qawali medly was good,enjoyable,if any other team too sing a song on qawali medelys it will look good,its Shakarji only who is doing any unfair for winning the match and how he can be too good,he is not grooming his team properly and he is not giving chance to his team members so that thy can show talent if he give chance it will be only rahul,quite Sharib..Team wise Shankar's team was worst..But in MD Wise,Singing wise Shankarji was grt..

In MKMM thr is no Match between Music Directors,the Match is between team and the captaincy from Mentors as Shaan doing grt Job in that while compare to rest..

But i want to say to Gajji,dont bring MD's,Just keep competition between singers..
Shankar is a very good singer,but he is not good in grooming his team,he will support his team wen rahul argues and behaved so badly,wen sharib against mohit etc lot of attituteds,Shankar will say to Rahul chill chill and keep silent wen rahul screaming those days..
If we think like that as u said then we cant compare Shankar with others,Shankar is good in songs which brings lot of energys,Shaan is good in romantic,disco type,remix type songs, and many singers in thr way ..


We not here to appreciate Only Captains,we want to appreciate by teamwise along with thier Mentor..We know Shankar is a grt MD..But if we think like that means we cant compare with him along with rest singers,,..

PIPC thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#37
Don't worry guys. This act of Shankar goes on to show how much faith Mr Mahadevan has on his team members. After all he is a very talented person when it comes to music. He knows how pathetic Sharib will sound against Anwesha's melodious voice. So, he saves his face by deciding to sing himself. And the same thing goes for Shadab too.

That Neeti girl is a 'bakwas' singer. I still get nightmares about her 'dola re dola' tribute to Shreya Ghoshal 😆 😆 ....Can imagine what Shreya's condition have been after getting that tribute 😉 ..............

This is all our great Gajji's fault. Why doesn't he get judges who have some parity in status and talent as mentors? He gets two MDs and four singers. It is very much known to everybody that the singers won't risk their career by going against the MDs. They might go to a certain extent but, will eventually give up since it goes against their basic interest..


I can understand that the MDs are those who give chance to the newcomers and if they are involved there, the newcomers have more probability of getting work. He could have got six singers to groom and mentor the contestants and any number of MDs could have been entrusted with the final decision making thing... Instead, he gets Himesh Reshmmiya and Shankar Mahadevan as captains along with four singers, amongst which two are extremely successful and one is an upcoming singer. Mika Singh was brought in just to add to the show's CONTROVERSY QUOTIENT' and he did a brilliant job there....Mika was lucky enough that he didn't get a nice bashing from Mohit when a trashy singer like him started acting like Pandit Jasraj and questioned Mohit's knowledge of 'raaga' on national Television. My respect for Mohit increased manifold that day. I believe his humble attitude won the hearts of many.

If Anwesha or somebody else forgot the lyrics like Neeti did, then all these big talks about 'no excuse on stage', 'being less serious about music' or 'manch ki tauheen' like things will crop up... These judges know what's wrong or right in their heart of hearts but none wants to mess with big MDs.... I would have enjoyed the show more if Sonu, Sunidhi replaced these two MDs as captains. These MDs could be termed ' super captains' or somethin 😆....

Shankar just wants the 'winner' title and hence just doing a 'one man show'. But, I sincerely hope that he will use this discretion while making songs for his movies and will call Anwesha and Shaadab to sing for him as he doesn't think Sharib or anybody from his team to be at par with Shaan's strikers. So, we can conclude that Shankar considers Shaan's strikers as better singers and they are more likely to get chance if the already established singers are not called.. I may be wrong and don't blame me if Shankar decides to sing all the songs himself in is movies too 😆 😆.....

Doston, yahan music ki nahin strategy ki jeet honi hai... Shaan is the best captain by far and I have full faith in Gajji's strategies and I am sure Shaan will not win. I really want that old Gajendrrrra Singhhhh back who brought singers like Shreya Ghoshal, Sonu Nigam, Shaan and others in limelight.

Till then, enjoy good music, spend your hard earned money and don't expect the best team to win... Drama abhi baki hai mere dost... 😛 😛 😛
Edited by PIPC - 15 years ago
bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#38


Oh Pinky...my dear Pinky! We've been missing your great comments here.

And talking about Niti's singing and BEAT HAALUM HAALUM's comments on the great qawali medeley, I literally had to take off my headphones when she screeched "O Laal meri" into it.😆

baghabayen thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: bambooshoot


Oh Pinky...my dear Pinky! We've been missing your great comments here.

And talking about Niti's singing and BEAT HAALUM HAALUM's comments on the great qawali medeley, I literally had to take off my headphones when she screeched "O Laal meri" into it.😆



You all got me wrong..i was talking about the upcoming shaan v/s shankar episode,and was referring to THAT medley based on qawali,this episode going to be aired on 21st feb 2010 on star plus @9 pm IST .😃😃


bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: baghabayen



You all got me wrong..i was talking about the upcoming shaan v/s shankar episode,and was referring to THAT medley based on qawali,this episode going to be aired on 21st feb 2010 on star plus @9 pm IST .😃😃


I know. I know. I was listening to it on the teaser😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".