Nupur's Condition-New Theory-My Take - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

116

Views

5.6k

Users

25

Likes

228

Frequent Posters

act12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: KiranSD1

that does make sense, but what i always wondered about memory loss, is why they don't forget how to speak, write, read, they they would learn while growing up, and nuupur lost all her memories

actually there are different part of the brain that is for each of this function like the ocipital lobe is for eyes n temporal for active thinking..that why! our brain has functions that it devides amongst each part of the brain so if they damaged the tissues of the part of ttheir memory...tht doesnt damage the part which is associated with leaning new things or even old things n that is why language and speaking n walking (those common characterisitc) is always preserved even if you lost your memory😊
-Rinky- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
wonderful topic...will reply in details later
Mou. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
sorry wrong post😛
Edited by Mou. - 15 years ago
iHeartMoi thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: Mou.

@topic starter .nice topic & nicely explain though i doubt cvs will go for such thing!!!!
anyone here saw the ajay -kajol film U, me aur hum? there kajol actually hva disease like that she forget everything for sometime & then again remember everything.like her memory works perfectly for sometime & then aagin she lost it complete;y....so when she realize that she has this disease , she pretend not to recognize her husband ajay so that he leave her in mental hospital & can hv a better life...
i donno sometime i think may be they can copy this film.......( they hv habit of copying from films.LOL) but again it is too complicated😕 ........


Alzheimer? MJHT CVs itne akalmand kabe ho gaye? 🤣
Not possible yaar!
brainychild92 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: act12


</div>
<div>
actually there are different part of the brain that is for each of this function like the ocipital lobe is for eyes n temporal for active thinking..that why! our brain hasfunctions that it devides amongst each part of the brain so if they damaged the tissues of the part of ttheir memory...tht doesnt damage the part which is associated with leaning new things or even old things n that is why language and speaking n walking (those common characterisitc) is always preserved even if you lost your memory😊



omg i cant wait for psych! actually i'm a first year student(starting in a week!!!!!) u ake it sound so cool!!lol
act12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: brainychild92



omg i cant wait for psych! actually i'm a first year student(starting in a week!!!!!) u ake it sound so cool!!lol

lol😆...actually I took AP psych in my 11th grade (last yr) n i luved it too...on top of tht i am a psych major so i need to know these things.....n yh Psych ROCKS!!😃
Mou. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
@ayesha.MJHT cv akkelmand nehi hue..i said COPY from the film😆 😆 😆
but then this is a complicated story to copy from .so i guess no chance.......
rooj-i thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
@viggy123: I understand that DID is a serious Issue and I am giving that respect to it but simply stating that maybe Nupur's behavior falls under that line.

You are right about MJHT viewers and be it any group, I'm sure we all want a sensible story and valid reasons to explain behaviors our favorite characters. But unfortunately, the CVs don't know how to handle sensibility. It's like the word doesn't exist in their dictionary.

honestly there are so many misleading bloopers that are left alone on purpose and I can 100% bet that they are created purposely for suspense and then just left alone. you can tell when CVs don't hint it in the next 4 episodes or when truth finally comes out. It's always been a trick of poor writing.

You are right about characters tho, I wish the same but alas it's CVs we can't expect anything but discuss and dissect their mistakes. lol

@Tanvi: thanks for liking my idea.

@Debz: I don't think her bhagofying Gunjan and then her being cautious about the call really describes that she is faking it. I mean a person behaves such ways regardless, especially where they are accused and forced to be someone they are not. her dialogs didn't make her sound like she is faking it. at least that is what I think. i mean, even when she is alone her expressions and her wordings suggest that she really doesn't know anything about Nupur Bhushan. At least that is how i feel.

As for TCP, yes she did feel something even when a person is in a multiple personality, they do remember about their other personality. So yes, feelings, touches and closeness from her loved ones is making her feel something but as far as words and memories go...so far nothing.
and Debz: i think project is just another one of gang's plan to make her remember or just another suspense creator sort of thing...

@Ayesha: As much as we all want Nupur Bhushan, I doubt that this is her. I seriously believe it is not a faking issue...I really think that it is Amnesia to say the most and DID the least...Personally I would prefer something new and fresh. as for the truth being unveiled...doubt one week would do because all CVs work the same way. As story progress, they change scripts daily and it will be another month or few weeks before it is revealed what it is...

@Aysha_mayur: you are right about CVs that is why in the closing I did state I can't expect anything more. lol

@Tanvi: your tracks and ideas are soo day-dreaming but alas...it's only a dream...

@talkativetaurus: thanks hun and you are right i doubt they do. lol

@Kanky: thanks and hun we all wish the same but u know how it is. As for amnesia-I think you misunderstood me. I don't think she has Amnesia, I think she has multiple personality. Amnesia is where a person loses memory and doesn't remember the recent stuff about her life (say past year or so) but remembers her family and friends with whom they grew up with. In this case if she had Amnesia, Nupur would remember Gunjan, no matter what. But my theory states that she has possible DID, which is when a person has a different personality that takes over the body and has no memory what so ever of the people around her. To her, they are strangers if they grew up together. however one personality, strong personality, can over-power the existing one. I hope this explains.

@Sarzz: oh so you know about psyc...nice. lol since many don't really think CVs can handle this (me included) i think it's Amnesia too but faking def. not (at least not yet).

@Mou: thanks and i doubt the same. The disease you are describing does exist. I know a friend who has a friend who routinely goes through that. and it's a sad thing but that friend forgets about her/his life every time there is something around her. it is a possibility that Nupur is acting such way to hope for her family members to have better life but one thing doesn't add up. and I doubt the CVs would show that deliberately, which is why would Nupur herself come forward and show herself in the first place. Forget the first or second meeting of Mayank and Nupur, the bus stop scene is what says that she is not faking or she doesn't want to be found.

@Rinky: thanks and looking forward to it!

viggy123 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
rooj-i, Hi! All I meant by the 'serious issue' comment was that I don't think MJHT is the kind of show that could deal sensibly with a true psychological disorder. They just don't have that level of maturity among the creative team. So, I'd rather they not even approach it with a long barge pole.

I agree with you that Nupur's reactions when she is alone lead you to believe that she isn't faking amnesia. But on the other hand, those could also be brushed off as bloopers.

At the end of the day, it's going to come down to one of the more mundane explanations that's not going to make much sense. But I've been prepared for that since the day Rati returned. For now, I'm just enjoying her acting and of course Arjun's as well. I hope the makers realize the worth of the actors they have and come up with something new and original rather than just rehashing old stuff!
503046 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
yaar i loved it but u know mjhtt ke cvs mein itna brain nahi hai

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".