What Hurts The Most - Samrat - UPDATED - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

3.9k

Users

21

Likes

101

Frequent Posters

EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: ash_sajan

Awesome and beautiful post aahana di👏
I agree that the one who is most suffering is Sam and the guy who was abandoned by everyone in the past is still helping his friends to reunite.Mohit plays a great part in potraying Samrat,s pain which i really like about him.So heads off to Mohit for his brilliant performance👏
The pain is clearly visible in his eyes.He is just so different from everyone.People like him are truly rare and i would like to thank Mohit for potraying this charcter so beautifully and so perfectly.
Again it was a lovely post and i just love commenting on your,s and aashi,s topics.
Love
Ash



ash thanks a lot for ur sweet words

we all have really not liked one bit the fact sam is so sad ... poor guy perhaps as he was the one who always made everyone smile and now he himself has forgotten it ... as it seems 😭

so i hope we see him smile again and that mohit may once again leave us spellbound with his wonderful talent as the sam we see now is so diff from season 1 so def the situations this time would be worth watching
368758 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#22
Aahana fantastic post.Mohit was outstanding today.The expressions were mind blowing..He is really a very good versatile actor.The pain on his face and voice made us cry 😭 .He rocked totally today. 👏 👍🏼 ❤️
ayesha_80 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#23

So, as per the order given to me, i'm here Aahana. U know, i don't post on IF now...but i cudn't refuse ur order. Well...i'll try my best to make SOME sense here..but i know..a lot of chappals will be coming my way after this post. So, i think..i shud start wid a diclaimer.

The content below is purely my POV. I do NOT intend to bash anyone here...and watever i'm writing involves the 4 leads of the show...coz nowadays they all are sooo connected.
Well..well...well... Let me start by a confession. Most of u know, that I am one of those SG fans, who are ALWAYS tilted and biased towards Gunjan. She was, is, and will b my reason of watching the show, coz i've always related with that girl. Needless to say, this makes me a HUGE Sanaya fan..coz SHE has made Gunjan sooo sooo special for me. Had it been any other actress...mayb, i wudn't have related to this character soooo much. Thus, for me...Sanaya/Gunjan are the soul of MJHT.
Having said this...another confession---Since the beginning of S2, i have fallen in love with Samrat. His transformation from a boy..to a MAN...leaves me speechless. His pain, his guilt, his loneliness, his selflessness, makes me teary-eyed whenever I watch his scenes. The guy who used to be the life of the college..brought a smile on everyone's face...was left in tears only...tears of pain, grief and worst..of GUILT. Mohit did a fab. job here... I've always believed and we've discussed it several times that MoNaya are soooooo great, in fact, experts in doing emotional stuff. They make us connect wid them instantly and we start feeling their pain...Be it the scenes like "LOOK AT ME.." or the ones where Gunjan hugged Sam...or Sam making Gunjan realize that watever she says...her eyes always tell the truth, which is that, she still loves him.
First and foremost, I'm now seriosuly concerned abt the dialogues of the show. SG, as we all know, have always had the MOST beautiful and soulful dialogues...and that's why in every track, and even now...we want them to talk things over. But NOW..with this new person, i'm very much worried on this front. The likes of "LOOK AT ME.."...the ones like, "kal ka sapna, aj ki haqeeqat"...etc. etc..seem to have vanished now. These days, the dialogues are not connected and at times, they seem to be very incomplete.
Coming to the epi...well...i have a somewhat different take. I agree with u all that Sam's pain came to surface, when Nups asked him abt his relation wid her. If we see, Sam was the only one who was a bit in his senses after seeing Nups and also...he was the one, who was trying to raise questions. Reason---the guy has suffered like hell for no fault of his..and now, when the reason for that fault doesn't exist anymore...he can't let this opportunity go. Also, if we see, Gunjan and Mayank are more closely related to Nups, as compared to Sam..and this is wat puts him in a questioning position. The other two just want Nups back..in ANY way, at ANY cost...whereas, Sam has to ensure that Nups comes back.
Honestly speaking... I wasn't too happy with Sam's dialogues today (ooopppsss...did i actually say this?? 😆😆) I mean, they could have been better. Before killing me, lemme explain....Nups asked Sam that "tum bhi bata do, tumhara bhi koi rishta ho ga merey saath..ya tum in dono se alag ho?"...Well, acc. to me, it was a golden opportunity that was not utilized coz of poor dialogues (i'm not saying anything abt Mohit;s acting..am refering to the dialogues only)... Sam replied, "Haan, mein tumhari behen ka mangetar tha...aur tum hamesha mujhey dhamkati thi..ke kuch bhi kerna, magar meri behen ko kabhi hurt mut kerna..lekin mein ne chashmish ko hurt ker dia...woh accident meri wajah se hua tha, aur tum hum se alsg ho gayi..aur Chashmish 3 saal tuk tumhara intezar kerti rahi"...Selfless again...bearing the pain again..taking the blame on himself again...not thinking abt himself..but abt his Chashmish and her sister...This guy is really unbelievable..How can someone be sooo selfless??? But....in my opinion..this wasn't the time to take self-blame... I strongly feel that in response to Nupur's question..Sam shud've thrown the ball in her court. You know, something like "Haan, mera tumharey saath rishta THA...per ab mein in sab se alag hun, in sub ne mujhey khud se alag ker diya...TUM ne mujhey in sub se alag ker dia..." This wud've created a multiple impact...i,e, on Nupur, as well as on Gunjan.
Don't u think, Aahana...instead of SG and M taking blame on themselves, they shud state the facts for Nupur?? Wat I mean to say is...even if she's angry or its a case of memory loss...Nups needs to know that she is not the ONLY ONE who suffered coz of that accident. She WAS not alone, she IS not alone. The other three also lost EVERYTHING and for three years, they literally stopped living LIFE... Also, when Sam said that i was ur sister's fiance' and u told me never to make her shed even a songle tear... I wasn't convinced as such...coz, the same sister was crying sooo helplessly in front of Nupur, just a while ago.. If her tears didn't move the lady..i don't think Sam's words wud've had any impact on her.. Also..if her hubby and sister, who are the most closest relations..almost begging in front of her, didn't do anything...how can she react to her sister's fiance' (hate to write, but supposedly Ex-fiance')...But yes, mayb if he said something like...I'm alone, coz of u..we're all shattered, coz u left us..mayb that made Nups realize (if she's angry) that after her SG and M were also as devastated as she was. Thus, i believe...SG and M have to throw the ball in Nupur's court and instead of blaming themselves...they need to make her believe..that YES...we were alive after u, we survived in the accident..but we haven't LIVED since then..only coz, we LOST u.
Also, as i said earlier, this wud've made Gunjan see Sam's pain. I seriously don't want Sam to show his wounds himself (and I request the CV's, the new writer not to take it this way). I WANT Gunjan to see...feel..and realize Sam's pain HERSELF.
Lastly...I strongly feel that Sam will be the one who will reunite Gunjan, Nupur and Mayank....and this way he will be relieved of the burden that has made him life a live worst than death every second. I think, and I hope that HE will bring back the family together...for this he will make a plan...or just like, he's taking the lead..he will continue to do so...and in this, Gunjan and Mayank (mayb) might help him. While executing the plan..there will be every possibility of Gunjan seeing his pain..coz to bring Nupur back, he will have to go down the memory lane and rewind wat all happened in the 3 yrs that changed everyone's life. He was blamed to be the one who took Nupur away ... now, he will be the one who will give Gunjan and Mayank their Nupur back...and that will end his misery. After this, I want him to distance himself...coz his wounds are still very much there and uncured...they need to be and they WILL be seen, felt and cured by Gunjan.
So, i think, this track has potential...and i hope the new writer doesn't messes it up.
Me n my never ending thesis 😳 but it isn't my fault..Who told me to write this.....YOU!!! 😆😆 So, now read it, and be prepared to defend me also 😆😆
BTW Aahana..if i'm not mistaken..i heard the mention of "bauji" in the epi..This means, he's still in the loop and can be called as and when needed. I genuinely hope that he's invited on his younger daughter's wedding 😍😍, to give his blessings.
I'm very sure that after this nonsensical post of mine, u will never ever ask me to write my take anywhere Embarrassed. Take care!!!
saraaa. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#24
Damn...Haven't seen todays episode! Loved the line you used to describe Sammy's feelings 3 years ago😳
Will edit soon
-edited-
Firstly, wonderful post. I didn't see anyone else point this out in the forum. Finally a SaNu scene. And a very painful one. When he said that he hurt Chashmish I was hoping for some reaction from Gunjan. I didn't see Gunjan react much to what he said though😕 I must say that Mohit did brilliant during those few moments. There was pain in his eyes. Even in his voice👏 Samrat is a true friend and soulmate as he was with Gunjan and Mayank all along. Not once did he leave their side. Being the one to take the blame (he doesn't deserve all that harsh treatment from Gunjan) he actually said it. He simply said it was his fault.
Edited by KaShBaarish..xx - 15 years ago
Ritu.V thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#25
Very well said Ahana..👏

Samrat was too good today.. true friend .. I loved Samart -Nupur Nok Jhok.. I love their communication.,.. samrat taking blame to himself for the accident .. I love Nupur and Samrat today . .they were awsome.. Mayank was good also .. sanaya did good job agai.. on the whome i loved MARS today.. I am glad MJHT is back with BANG..I hope Cvs does not ruin this track .. this track has got huge scope for all four characters because all these character are inter-related to each other and revolve around each other.. Looking forward to watch tomorrows episode..😊
Edited by Ritu.mjhtrv - 15 years ago
gunjanmariya thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#26
wow ahaana.....
awsome post honey...🤗....i mean seriously yr it was amazing...
after the engegment he was soo sooo soo happy....he was eagerly waiting for that day to come in his life.....and who knows whats gonna happen next.....
that one accideint have changed thier lives completely...sam have blamed himself for that accidient....!!!at that time he was ready to kill himself 😭but everytime he tried to kill hiomself,he was stopped by the love of his life....his chashmish......even when she left him...!!
then he meets her again and tried to suck all the saddness of her life...but still gun blames him...and he have promised himself not to hurt her anymore....coz he thought he is hurting her.........he thinks that he is responsible for nups death...!!
and today
i love the scene where sam told her that...im ur sister's fiance......
and all that...!!
that was soo sooo sooo touching.....i mean after 3 years when nups is standing infront of him...he was again blaming himself for what has happend 3 years back...!!
there were many emotions on his face......
the guilt........guilt of killing a good friend
happiness....of getting her back.....
sadness.......coz she is not understnading their pain....and they have suffered in these three years......
and his EYESS........ufffffff.....😍
MY GOD...!!
how can someone be soo soo soo sooooooo dammmm good mannn!!!!!and the credit goes to mohit....!!!
hugs to mohit for showing so much pain and so much guilt in his eyes...and hugs for such brilliant acting...!!🤗
awsome mohit...!!👏
and great topic yr ahaana........
u rock..!!
love,
gunjan mariya...

aa123.80 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: ayesha_80

Honestly speaking... I wasn't too happy with Sam's dialogues today (ooopppsss...did i actually say this?? 😆😆) I mean, they could have been better. Before killing me, lemme explain....Nups asked Sam that "tum bhi bata do, tumhara bhi koi rishta ho ga merey saath..ya tum in dono se alag ho?"...Well, acc. to me, it was a golden opportunity that was not utilized coz of poor dialogues (i'm not saying anything abt Mohit;s acting..am refering to the dialogues only)... Sam replied, "Haan, mein tumhari behen ka mangetar tha...aur tum hamesha mujhey dhamkati thi..ke kuch bhi kerna, magar meri behen ko kabhi hurt mut kerna..lekin mein ne chashmish ko hurt ker dia...woh accident meri wajah se hua tha, aur tum hum se alsg ho gayi..aur Chashmish 3 saal tuk tumhara intezar kerti rahi"...Selfless again...bearing the pain again..taking the blame on himself again...not thinking abt himself..but abt his Chashmish and her sister...This guy is really unbelievable..How can someone be sooo selfless??? But....in my opinion..this wasn't the time to take self-blame... I strongly feel that in response to Nupur's question..Sam shud've thrown the ball in her court. You know, something like "Haan, mera tumharey saath rishta THA...per ab mein in sab se alag hun, in sub ne mujhey khud se alag ker diya...TUM ne mujhey in sub se alag ker dia..." This wud've created a multiple impact...i,e, on Nupur, as well as on Gunjan.
Don't u think, Aahana...instead of SG and M taking blame on themselves, they shud state the facts for Nupur?? Wat I mean to say is...even if she's angry or its a case of memory loss...Nups needs to know that she is not the ONLY ONE who suffered coz of that accident. She WAS not alone, she IS not alone. The other three also lost EVERYTHING and for three years, they literally stopped living LIFE...



Ayesha, I totally agree with you on everything you said. But most importantly, what you aid here is just bang on!!

@bold: I know!! I was thinking that time that he should've said something like "Nahin, main tum sab se alag hoon.... Sab ke saath hote hue bhi main bilkul akela hoon...... " I so wanted his pain to come out at that moment. I really don't like the fact that they're just concentrating on Samrat being selfless and taking the blame for everything. He's bearing the guilt for 3 years..... That was the perfect opportunity to highlight his suffering. Too bad, the CVs totally missed it!!

@red: Agree with you again. I think it's time for them to start telling Nupur what hell they've been through these 3 years, tell her that they stopped living the day that accident happened.... And specially Samrat, cause he's been blamed by Mayank and Gunjan both, so I think he has every right to question them now.
itzMYattitude thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#28

aahanaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

awesome post dear just loved it
brilliantly written
ok these were the lines that r must in every post of urs
now come towards samrat
outstanding acting
infact when he was convincing majan
nupur 3 saal baad ae hy thora footage to khae gy
the fear, the pain that y nupur is behaving like could easily be sensed in her sound but he was trying to calm both of them
i love his acting over there
infact love him every where
muuuuahhhhhh
to both u n mohit
mohit roxxxxxxxxxxxx
itzMYattitude thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: aa123.80



Ayesha, I totally agree with you on everything you said. But most importantly, what you aid here is just bang on!!

@bold: I know!! I was thinking that time that he should've said something like "Nahin, main tum sab se alag hoon.... Sab ke saath hote hue bhi main bilkul akela hoon...... " I so wanted his pain to come out at that moment. I really don't like the fact that they're just concentrating on Samrat being selfless and taking the blame for everything. He's bearing the guilt for 3 years..... That was the perfect opportunity to highlight his suffering. Too bad, the CVs totally missed it!!

@red: Agree with you again. I think it's time for them to start telling Nupur what hell they've been through these 3 years, tell her that they stopped living the day that accident happened.... And specially Samrat, cause he's been blamed by Mayank and Gunjan both, so I think he has every right to question them now.

@bold
yr i was thinking the same the dialogue were really not upto mark
he had said nothing
i wasalso waiting for that
but my sis's opinion is that nupur is pretending all that
if samrat would tell her everthing then nupur would realised that all 3 of them yet cares for her
while right now she is thinking that they were living happily left me over there for dying
n story will failed to move further
according to my sis
now nupur will think that they r really selfish that even gunjun forgets his first love
then y couldn't she can do this to me
i think may b bad oppinion of my sis
but wanna share it
Alpenliebe thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#30
Hey Aahana you left me speech less once again dear, beautiful post dear...you once again described Samrat's feelings beautifully, infact the pov of an abandoned guy by his near n dear ones whom he loved more than himself!!!!!

"Main tumhare behan ka mangetar tha!!!!" this dialogue really took my heart away.....one can feel the pain filled in his heart when he used that word "THA".....

Samrat planned to spend his whole life with Gunjan, no second thoughts...but as I have in my signature destiny always plans the opposite...

Samrat, I must say, has always a perfect prey of destiny....he never got the desired love from his parents, he pretends to be happy but the fact is quite opposite...When he found that long lost love in Gunjan, his Chashmish, destiny snatched that too!!!!!

I remember one quote by T.E Kalem The heart is the only broken instrument that works!!!!

Samrat is heartbroken, he lost his love, leading a miserable life with a blame of killing his own friend, but still he is like a guiding light which shows others the correct path to move ahead.....he is broken completely still he is always there for those who need him!!!! A character like Samrat only found in fictions, so selfless, always cared for others, not considering the depth of his own pain he can measure other's!!!!!

Thanx a lot for this beautiful post Aahana dear n for ur awesome description!!!


*Aditi*

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".