Nupur's Return - Page 17

Created

Last reply

Replies

363

Views

21.2k

Users

89

Likes

1.5k

Frequent Posters

mads thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
WHOA 20 pages !!! 😲 cannot believ thers healthy discussion going on.. wud like to add something, but I wud request MN fans to please read objectively ( if they want to read my post at all in the first place ) .. and wit an unbiased miind if possible .. n keep the discussion as healthy as it is right now..if I see tht my post leads to fights, I apologise in advance..thts not my intention at all ..

anyways .. my brain thought of the fact of her coming back..or mayb coming back..or something of the sort tht day itself, when they showed FBs of the accident n they didnt show her body .. thats when I knew, they are deffo playing safe .. how easy it is to "show" a character dead..n get her back if storyline/viewers demand it .. its the tried n tested formula works in every show .. that was my first thought when I saw the FBs ..

but later on, things changed on the show, for me, and I conveniently ignored it ..

also, the statements made in various different interviews n articles r very confusing..and both of them - RP and PH seem to be contradicting themselves in every next interview .. so I hav no idea what the hell is going on..neither do I care, to be honest ..

but, I can see, after yest's epi..that they are rushing thru the tracks now..their usual story, give a nice build up..n end into a pathetic, disastrous n shabby ending..I can see that happening for SG now ..anyways, thats not the point of concern here ..

abt nupur's come back ..I can see various options -

1. nupur was the reason for separation of SG, so she wud be the reason for their union too .. as she comes back, SG get back together n ofcourse MN get back together too - the option I HATE the most .. because tht wud turn gunjan into the lamest character ther ever is!

2. SG get back together n get married..go off for their honeymoon - exit of MoNaya ..on the day of their wedding, they show nupur coming back .. or alive atleast n RP comes back, either as a new character or as nupur, mostly wit amnesia or something ( sorry, but thats the only thing tht makes sense if they hav to get back a dead character ) .. n therein starts MN's new story .. all over again - now this is the option I LOVE .. for various reasons..n I m sure most of the MN n SG fans alike wud agree wit me on this .. ( if nothing, atleast it puts an end to the fights on the forum )

3. SG get back together..but arent married yet .. they show nupur alive .. mayb memory loss again ( sorry cant think of anything better 😆 ) .. n all the three thats MSG help nups get back to who she is..or atleast an attempt..or mayb, they show M taking her to his house .. mayb she hasnt regained her memory yet .. but thers a hope tht she will .. n then they show SG wedding, MN back together .. n end the show, since I hav heard its wrapping up soon - I wud love this option too ..

4. same as option 2..but RP coming back as a new character.. n M trying very hard not to be drawn towards her because she has the same face.. starts the new story of ArTi - I think MN fans wudnt really like this ..

apart from tht, at the moment I cant see any other option .. but ofcourse, theyr are creative enuf to think of many more .. 🤣

ok..all this is considering tht she comes back to the show .. but after yest's epi .. I m 99% sure something of tht sort's gonna happen..because right before the garland falls, thers another sign, that M is drinking a coffee made by his servant..n the taste of the coffee is jus like the one tht nups used to make .. so he is reminded of that, which indicates that he isnt needed to forget the taste of the coffee ( since he'd previously stated that he has stopped drinking coffee ) .. n then the garland falls too .. in hindi shows when the garland falls, thers only one sign..that the garland isnt meant to b on the photo ..

so yup..I think she will return .. although I do not think tht such an extensive pre planning could be carried out..or mayb, it was pre planed in their heads, like I said..only the creatives knew/thought abt it..never voiced it out to their actors, like they never told them who wud die .. so it might be pre planning on their side .. but I dont think RP is involved in this .. otherwise she wudnt hav been so dismissive abt S2.. the fact tht she was, shows tht she didnt kno she is coming back ..
Edited by mads - 15 years ago
sonalkhanna_19 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Just I want is my Rati(my most adorable Nupur) back at any cost. I want back my MAYUR/ARTI MAGIC again.
Mou. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: mads

WHOA 20 pages !!! 😲 cannot believ thers healthy discussion going on.. wud like to add something, but I wud request MN fans to please read objectively ( if they want to read my post at all in the first place ) .. and wit an unbiased miind if possible .. n keep the discussion as healthy as it is right now..if I see tht my post leads to fights, I apologise in advance..thts not my intention at all ..

anyways .. my brain thought of the fact of her coming back..or mayb coming back..or something of the sort tht day itself, when they showed FBs of the accident n they didnt show her body .. thats when I knew, they are deffo playing safe .. how easy it is to "show" a character dead..n get her back if storyline/viewers demand it .. its the tried n tested formula works in every show .. that was my first thought when I saw the FBs ..

but later on, things changed on the show, for me, and I conveniently ignored it ..

also, the statements made in various different interviews n articles r very confusing..and both of them - RP and PH seem to be contradicting themselves in every next interview .. so I hav no idea what the hell is going on..neither do I care, to be honest ..

but, I can see, after yest's epi..that they are rushing thru the tracks now..their usual story, give a nice build up..n end into a pathetic, disastrous n shabby ending..I can see that happening for SG now ..anyways, thats not the point of concern here ..

abt nupur's come back ..I can see various options -

1. nupur was the reason for separation of SG, so she wud be the reason for their union too .. as she comes back, SG get back together n ofcourse MN get back together too - the option I HATE the most .. because tht wud turn gunjan into the lamest character ther ever is!

2. SG get back together n get married..go off for their honeymoon - exit of MoNaya ..on the day of their wedding, they show nupur coming back .. or alive atleast n RP comes back, either as a new character or as nupur, mostly wit amnesia or something ( sorry, but thats the only thing tht makes sense if they hav to get back a dead character ) .. n therein starts MN's new story .. all over again - now this is the option I LOVE .. for various reasons..n I m sure most of the MN n SG fans alike wud agree wit me on this .. ( if nothing, atleast it puts an end to the fights on the forum )

3. SG get back together..but arent married yet .. they show nupur alive .. mayb memory loss again ( sorry cant think of anything better 😆 ) .. n all the three thats MSG help nups get back to who she is..or atleast an attempt..or mayb, they show M taking her to his house .. mayb she hasnt regained her memory yet .. but thers a hope tht she will .. n then they show SG wedding, MN back together .. n end the show, since I hav heard its wrapping up soon - I wud love this option too ..

4. same as option 2..but RP coming back as a new character.. n M trying very hard not to be drawn towards her because she has the same face.. starts the new story of ArTi - I think MN fans wudnt really like this ..

apart from tht, at the moment I cant see any other option .. but ofcourse, theyr are creative enuf to think of many more .. 🤣

ok..all this is considering tht she comes back to the show .. but after yest's epi .. I m 99% sure something of tht sort's gonna happen..because right before the garland falls, thers another sign, that M is drinking a coffee made by his servant..n the taste of the coffee is jus like the one tht nups used to make .. so he is reminded of that, which indicates that he isnt needed to forget the taste of the coffee ( since he'd previously stated that he has stopped drinking coffee ) .. n then the garland falls too .. in hindi shows when the garland falls, thers only one sign..that the garland isnt meant to b on the photo ..

so yup..I think she will return .. although I do not think tht such an extensive pre planning could be carried out..or mayb, it was pre planed in their heads, like I said..only the creatives knew/thought abt it..never voiced it out to their actors, like they never told them who wud die .. so it might be pre planning on their side .. but I dont think RP is involved in this .. otherwise she wudnt hav been so dismissive abt S2.. the fact tht she was, shows tht she didnt kno she is coming back ..

@bolded one sound the best option
315925 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Mads the 2nd and 3rd points do make sense
I am pretty sure Rati had nothing to do with this.
-Preeti- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
Mads
that wht you said is the after story and we are talking about the present and past situation ....

My only objective here is had this been pre-planned then we have to assume that the CV's, Sushmita and thers who at FB advaries other sites gave varried replies to members that "None would die" or "Rati would not be back" or "That she threw tantrums" was false .... thats if we believe ths to be pre-planned by the CV's

About the Dead Body not shown ..... i told you they kept that point open to play it safe ... thats just INCASE season2 does'nt work then they would play with this open end ..... had Season 2 got pick up and done well I am sure by now MJHT ka haal kuch aur hota🤔


And Dear
dont you feel you thinking tooooooo fast forward😆 mein? I mean i still do not wanna raise my expectations sply after all that happened in the past. And did u notice ..... SBS reported of SG ka child ... which has'nt happened yet .... so can i assume that this track got axed last minute? (If they have done that .... I am glad they took One RIGHT Decision there)
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
wow this is quite some topic ... hmm great to see some peace here ..

well i think somewhere i agree with the topic starter's POV she has some logical reasons.. may be this was all preplanned to create a hype for season 2 as well as the show overall - cos as we know previous to this track MJHT cv's fell flat on their faces with 2 miserable back to back tracks - the RDB rip off ( man what made them think of that in the first place ) and next Hey baby 🤪 - totally screwed up - none of the fans of either pair appreciated those tracks not to mention we all were united too 🤣 a lets say forced down the throat pair AdhAni united MJHTians after so long cos we didnt care atm about who gets what screen space or scenes we just wanted em out 😆😆

and next Pari and Kavya have made logical points - abt Sushmitaji saying all 4 would be in season 2 well in advance - when she mentioned the even would change their lives and also that they wanted to figure out a safe way to sort the storyline for the upcoming tracks for both the pairs

when they got MN married as teenagers they were severely criticized so probably they didnt wanna do the same thing with SG - for which the couple had to split - and for SG to split the reason had to be a pretty strong one - a gal blaming her fiancee for her sister's death is pretty strong at that - we know ultimately SaJan will marry - but now post leap when they do - their ages wont be taken as too young or the whole teen marrying fiasco wont be repeated as early 20's is pretty much an OKish age to marry and like Kavs said in the suggestion thread Gagan had created many MN fans were unhappy with the plot MN were given so may be they tried to solve this issue via this leap too

but ... but my only grievance is - i wish they had made the accident more believable for that - i mean as per what the signs are nupur is coming back in a while - but had the accident been more .. lets say well planned - like they had shown her body been untraceable cos she fell in some river or down a cliff it'd have made sense - i mean how did her duppatta stained with blood was discovered and her body disappeared 😕 when all of them were a few inches apart after the accident - and everyone thought she is dead 😕😕😳 .. how ?? why did no one look for her ?? 😕😕

i guess we may see those cliche memory loss or coma tracks to explain her disappearance for 3 years too may be even both clubbed heck !! - but had the accident been that logical to make sense of it - but then again who am i talking about MJHT cv's sorry i forget 🤣

hey no intention to hurt anyone guys just trying to get the workings of the convoluted minds of a rare species called CV's that's all 😉- no offense
Edited by aahana86 - 15 years ago
-Preeti- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: aahana86



and next Pari and Kavya have made logical points - abt Sushmitaji saying all 4 would be in season 2 well in advance - when she mentioned the even would change their lives and also that they wanted to figure out a safe way to sort the storyline for the upcoming tracks for both the pairs



Ahaana

Finally me digged the post for this particular topic😆

Ohkay had things been pre-planned ...... had they already planned this come-back and all Y would this reply from Sushmita come?
cvs wrst thn ekta....sushmita wrote..

Also for your rest of the queries i have already replied at Page 20 with all the justifications .......

and i have to say
am loving this Discussion😳
430105 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
@Aahana- The only reason for them finding Nupur's dupatta and not her body would be the fact that when Nupur fell out of the car, her dupatta fell at a distance from her body. Dupatta was NOT on her at the time. (Yeah I observed that😆)Ofcourse, it was just beside her, which is the strangest part😆 And she wasn't even on a steep cliff, where her body could just fall off, while the other three were found. The only logical reasoning I can think of is wild animals/or tribals took her body into the jungle🤣 Sorry, off topic😆
Mou. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
I agree Actor actresses r sometimes treated like god .which is not good........but yeah sometime ppl forget they r plain & simple human being too .The theory that is presented by the topic maker here.though in nice words.but sure is a disgrace for rati.....actually dekha jaye to MN fans hv beard the loss of their fav character, they r still in pain, but none of them opened a topic like such ( ofcourse another theory behind this "preplanned" death drama & publicity stunt exist somewhere in this forum ). It is good to c this was taken in healthy manner.( after sooo long in this forum) but i sure disagree with topic maker & i really don't appreciate opening such topic!!!!!
Edited by Mou. - 15 years ago
mads thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: -Preeti-

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2">Mads
that wht you said is the after story and we are talking about the present and past situation ....

My only objective here is had this been pre-planned then we have to assume that the CV's, Sushmita and thers who at FB advaries other sites gave varried replies to members that "None would die" or "Rati would not be back" or "That she threw tantrums" was false .... thats if we believe ths to be pre-planned by the CV's

About the Dead Body not shown ..... i told you they kept that point open to play it safe ... thats just INCASE season2 does'nt work then they would play with this open end ..... had Season 2 got pick up and done well I am sure by now MJHT ka haal kuch aur hota🤔


And Dear
dont you feel you thinking tooooooo fast forward😆 mein? I mean i still do not wanna raise my expectations sply after all that happened in the past. And did u notice ..... SBS reported of SG ka child ... which has'nt happened yet .... so can i assume that this track got axed last minute? (If they have done that .... I am glad they took One RIGHT Decision there)
</font>



preeti..I can understand u all dont wanna raise ur hopes..its easy for me to think [ractically in this case since I m not as emotionally attached to MN as u all are! so yup, it was easy to speculate into the future for me .. 😆

abt SG's child..well, I for one, always thought ever since they reported the news tht it wud b a rumour .. n I guess tht was it..because they never had MoNaya's interview for it too .. same abt MaRia track..they only speculated ..based on what they saw on the sets .. n looking at the way SG track's going..I dont think thers any place for child .. 😆 gunjan isnt a super human being to hide her child away for so long..because M wud deffo kno if she has a child, n if he doesnt kno..then its sure ther IS not child ( thank god, first time in a show a woman doesnt get pregnant after her very first consumation ) .. anyways, thats not the point here! 😆

well, mayb I dont kno much abt whats going on behind the camera..I only speculated on what I saw or read from the interviews..n what they hav shown in the show uptil now ..

n yup, abt dead body not shown..its ofcourse a very very old n cliched formula .. thats why they showed the car running into a cliff .. so body gets "lost" if the post death scenario n tracks are accepted n loved by majority of viewers .. n the character "returns" if their show isnt doing well for majority of the audience..they wud always play it safe..esp if they hav killed off the most popular character .. so obviously they werent dumb enuf to not anticipate the wrath of viewers .. they had to keep a back up for themselves ..

abt the statements made to viewers, well, I for one think they plain lied to us ..if they made such statements..although I m not the one tht wud judge them on basis of tht.. n reading b/w the lines, abt one of the articles given before the accident ( dont rem the source now ) ..it said - "one of the characters will be SHOWN dead" .. v didnt think much abt it because of the various incidents tht happ later .. but mayb, they had thought abt this before too!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".