When Tears Don't Fall Samrat Shergill - Page 2

Dear..........thnx for posting.......you know your importance na!!

Beautiful post Aahana. I can't really comment on the episode because I haven't watched it and I know I can't watch it. Hurts so much to imagine Samrat that way. Its hard enough to not see Gunjan, and to see Samrat so broken would be so much more painful.

Samrat Shergill. The cool dude of the college. The guy everyone "loved" and yet he desired love. Because no one knew him, understood him. No one really loved him. And his entire life, that's what he craved for. Someone who would love him, just the way he was. Not the "cool dude". But the real Samrat. And then one day, he finally found that someone. His Chashmish. Wasn't everything so perfect? Like a dream? A dream that shattered…

And now what? He lost that one person whom he couldn't even imagine his life without. How is he really supposed to "move on"? When the one person whom he loved more then his own life has left his life forever. And the reason behind it all, was him? His one careless mistake that took away everything from him? His strength, his hope, his smile, his love, his life, his Chashmish…

This Samrat isn't alive. He died long back with his Chashmish…

I have really know idea what I've rambled above. It hurts so so much that the most beautiful love story had to end this way.

Originally posted by: VampirePrincess

res
edited

Ahaana dear beautiful post! 👏
I was waiting for one, i knew u wud make it sooner or later:)
Samrat Shergill is a character i truly adore in MJHT.

It may be said that samrat is waiting for death with welcoming arms..every night he offers himself..but death betrays him.

What can be more painful to live with the thought that he was the reason for tht accident.
Am not saying tht its his fault, but thts wat he thinks right now as the precap indicates.

I had this huge lump forming up in my throat at the end of d epi...he changed so much.

For Mohit its a makeover and he looks really cool but for samrat it expresses his sorrow his misery.
His attitude, his words, his hard eyes, ah killed me.

I feel really bad, maybe pity i dont know.

But i have this question doesnt samrat deserve love in his life?
First his parents and when he let tht thought away, and became an individual self, evry1's fav in excel with his gang Dia, Uday and Benji came another frnd Gunjan and as u say he found love, his life.
He got his sister back but she also left him.

And now after 3 years we see him all alone again.
Destiny took away his frnds, yes uday benji and dia and Also mayank.

He's alone walking through the college corridors, thinking of her..them.
Guilt is clear in his eyes.
His first scene.. it was loaded with Angst. So much angst tht i couldnt hold it, tears stung my eyes.

I love the title...Its really apt. Cant express the awesomeness(i think i just created a word) of ur post.

But the main fact still lies here.
He still love's.

That undying love he still carries in his heart.
Did u notice his expression when he imagined Gunjan and Nupur, did u see the flicker of hope of joy?
It killed me coz i knew he's imagining dem:(

One of my fav lines from a novel

Love Goes far beyong the Physical person of the beloved. It finds its deepest meaning in his spiritual being, his inner self. Whether or not he is actually present, whether or not he is still alive at all, ceases somehow to be of importance.

Its true and holds meaning wen it comes to samrat.

Samrat is my fav character wat attracted me initially to him was his name...it holds a deeper meaning to me.

I saw someone special in him then...and then i bonded with him so well.

I fell for this guy, not Mohit first...but Samrat shergill.

I truly adore actually admire him.
A friend of mine said tht he's turned suicidal and few members have been saying tht 3 years and he has not moved on.

I just have one thing to say.

They havent experienced loss in their lives. When they truly feel the unbearable non-existence of a beloved will they understand, that's its not easy to move on.

And that too when guilt drives the heart that the reason of it all was him.

I agree with each letter of you word.... 👏 👏 👏 Well put..
Aahana.. Brilliant post

hey aahana awesoooooooooooome post dear.........
loved ur each and every single line........
u have described samrat's character so beautifully.........
loved it......and love my sammy from the core of my heart...........
hats off to mohit for portraying this character so perfectly..........
for giving life and soul to it...........samrat is truly the heart/soul of MJHT and mine too........thanx for this post dear..........

i cant see samrat like that...cv's i hate u for this..

aahana, ur post always gives a meaning to MJHT which is basically illogical.

first of all a very stupendous post!

we have seen a glimpse of such samrat even b4 but the change tht 3 years gave him is so overwhelming and heart wrenching. today my heart just stopped and tears cudnt when i heard sayank convos. mayu saying samrat to die n samrats expressions.....it looked as if he had knife in his hands, he wud have just cutt off his hand without thinking for a sec.

and the cliff part. i dont know what my was position looking at him. omg, i watched it with a heavy heart. samrat was so helpless. if he cant stay with his love in this world then better not stay only. but he is not allowed to do the same. the way he shouted.... my heart sank.

at the end i wud like to say mohit got the best progress in mjht. and he proved it!

i m quite speechless after reading your post aahana...!!
excellent job ya... it is posts like these that make me come back to this forum and write again!!!
i think no one else could have described Samrat better than you have today!!!
honestly.... i was never a samrat/mohit fan.... i have always loved mayank as a character and arjun as an actor!!(i still love him to the core)
but today i happily announce i m in love with this new samrat.... it is strange that i never liked him when he was happy, cheerful and smiling....!!! i m liking this samrat who is sad,grief stricken and who's smile has vanished along with his loved ones..may be forever!!!

so i feel strange why i didnt like the then samrat???? do i like tragic lover more ?? or did i never truely understand the old samrat...as u and sabah said... he is a mystery and may be i could never even understand that he was a mystery or may be i never attempted to understand him for once....!!
or is it like this....
am i liking mohit now or am i liking samrat..??? am i in love with mohit who i think has raised the bar of his acting 100 times with his portrayal of tragic lover!!! boy.!! is he acting like a dream!!!!

i take the blame for underestimating mohit all these days!!! or was he never given what he deserved by the cvs??? the pain and guilt in his eyes is soo much evident..... i for once feel if he is really missing his old colleagues!!! so now i have to figure out.... am i in love with samrat shergill the character or mohit sehgal the actor!!!!

thanks for this lovely post aahana...for your post gave me an opportunity to applaud samrat as well as mohit... may be for the first time on this forum!!!

regards
abhinaya

@ reeshu

gee hun thx 4 those kind words 😳

hun u took the words right out of my mouth !! 😲 i mean even i thought i would not watch season 2 .. but the hopeless addict in me lured me to it plus i was dying to know the mystery 😳 .. but seriously 1 scene 1 shot i saw Mohit as this new Samrat and i knew boy would i have been a fool to quit .. nope not for the new looks but for the new samrat

to have missed this would have been foolish and yes my loss as a sajan fan 😳

hun sometimes it is the good people who are tested the most in life to test their strength to see how much can they stand it and yet remain true to the path

OMG reeshu u r a genius ⭐️ 👏👏👏wow all these scenes which do i pinpoint and which do i leave ... damn i am at a loss 4 words hun.. yes Samrat is the most amazing creation of CV's is all i can say hun

hun all i know is the pain in his eyes is so much evident that it takes u away to another place another destination... i initially had rejected mohit's acting capabilities when he was raw and new but today he deserves an ovation 👏👏👏👏

Originally posted by: princessyashika

first of all missed u terribly jaan...welcome back..🤗
now what shud i say aahana after what all u have said...off from writing a post on gunur and feeling so drained..i need more courage to right on sam...but i agree with what all u guys said...completely!!! his eyes yesterday...yesterday's biggest feature of samrat shergill...they were enough of tearing me apart...!!!
sometimes u have so much to say aahana that u end up being out of words...the similar is with me for samrat...dont know whether i wud update this or not..coz it needs courage hon...but simply all my salutations to mohit for that one expression of pain in his EACH FEATURE...that broke my heart completely...coz i lost my jovial and innocent samrat yesterday!!!

thx Malli 🤗

jaan i know what u feel for him too cause i know u love him so too

trust me i can write so much on him and yet feel am i missing something😳 😆😆

@ bold - malli i tell u last night i didnt see his face his new look his appeal to me what first caught my attention was these - these empty yet painful eyes too god mohit he is amazing 👏👏⭐️⭐️

Originally posted by: yasri

Dear..........thnx for posting.......you know your importance na!!

I would say so many things about Sam but I don't have enough time.......If I couldn't post in this topic, I'll post in your next thread.....

But I have to say..........completely agree with u

omg yasri pls u r embarrassing me 😳

hun i am just glad 2 have thoughts to share with such beautiful minds is all i can say .. so nope its not me whose imp ... but the chance we all gotta meet 😳