When Tears Don't Fall Samrat Shergill

EkPahelii thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#1

Is it me or is there something incredibly fascinating yet disturbing, heart-breaking yet alluring about tragic heroes.

Somehow one of the most beautiful smiling faces I've ever seen has walked down that way too.

Yes he was somehow always there an enigma wrapped up – a puzzle hard to solve – yet as complex as he was he was so simple as well – he is Samrat.

The unsung heroes are often acknowledged in one word – warrior.

But never are there somehow praises for the tragic ones – heart breaking as their tales are - they are on a pedestal of their own.

For me somehow in reality Karana of the great epic Mahabharata seems to be the most perfect glorious example of it – somehow hard as it may be to believe he is my favourite character in the epic.

I admire him for all his strength valour and dignity but mostly I admire this great tragic hero for what he had become and yes had been – bravely fighting even in the face of death he was a hero – of unmatched calibre strength and bravery.

Today somehow Samrat reminded me of him – as I saw a reflection of Karana in him.

Yes I am a huge SaJan fan – I make no bones about it nor is it a secret here – I have also adored and admired Samrat Shergill. He whom I haven't picked for Mohit the actor here; but the character Samrat Shergill.

To me it was him who had attracted me to watch and be a part of this epic love story – yes him – cause as a dear friend of mine Sabah says he was the most wonderful enigma a most wonderful mystery in MJHT.

Yes as I said there is a raw appeal a heart-breaking yet unmatched appeal to the tragic heroes list of qualities.

As I had first seen him long ago in the initial episodes of MJHT he seemed just another regular, a run of the mill character to me, he wasn't special, new; he had nothing different to offer just seemed to me like another one of those tom dick and harry.

And I had ignored him.

However destiny I suppose had other plans and yes so did the CV's.

So somehow in a way only fate knows how it managed I a person who when decides to avoid a show like plague once she dislikes it somehow managed to tune into this one again.

Perhaps Khuda Jaane truly has an unmatched appeal, yes because somehow it was due to it – the promos that I had to see this – again.

And so it hit me, SaJan mania and MJHT fever and I was never the same again.

That night as we saw Samrat Gunjan celebrate post the valentine party – I somehow started to fall in love with him – there he was the coolest dude in the college – every girl's dream – yet his eyes only searched her – for she was only what mattered to him.

And so when she came he managed to once again start the process to woo her – a flower in white to bring back peace between them his only purpose and only dream.

And yes as fate had it – thou with a few bumps and misunderstandings she finally found it was him – her 'SECRET FRIEND' who had helped her out all along who she always felt in her heart could only be him.

That night on a day meant to celebrate for lovers – they had the beginning of their journey as friends.

This year in a strange twist or cruel joke of fate as they now having gone through a journey when found life come a full circle again as lovers –one line said by her was so true– humme raj aur simran banna chahiye tha Samrat, Maine Suna Hai Samrat har movie ki end main Raj aur Nargis ka pyar adhura reh Jaata tha.

And today so it is… as they had come dressed this year as Raj & Nargis too.

Their love story – halfway told – remains incomplete – unfulfilled.

Today in Samrat I find that tragic hero he had always so managed to hide and yet today just can't be anything else but that.

She was his ray of hope, his only dream – the only thing he ever asked for – ever wanted and it is her whom now he will never have.

It has just been now not even that long but in those few moments I saw of him all I can think of in these moments lately is how and why life is so cruel sometimes?

Wasn't he already much ignored by fate, didn't he already have his share of miseries wasn't it right for him to deserve this – his one chance of happiness and why is it also now taken away from him?

Seems to me like destiny has its favourite children; so does misery.

What else could but help explain the crumpled piece of a soul trapped in the body of a dead man walking today?

Doomed to love and doomed in love – is just his fate I think.

He never had anyone ever even his parents ever beside him his sibling too couldn't stay long with him – his friends became his only joy and took over as family too for him and it was in them – that in one of those faces she had come to him.

SHE -the love of his life, his soul mate, HIS CHASHMISH.

And now today fate played a cruel joke and took her away too from him.

He is now a dead man walking trying to kill himself with his every breath; he is lost again he is doomed.

He who once had never taken love seriously today is demolished in love.

I never pitied him never was I sorry for him – for he himself had made himself a bundle of such abundant joy that when you looked at his face you couldn't help but smile with him , for him.

But today as I see that man – the wreck that now he truly is as life as managed to give him his biggest blow – finally hit him so hard that he has managed to give up hope – his nerve to give it back and his will to fight for life – and the zest he had too for it within him

As I saw in a cruel sentencing of fate instead of killing him, he is destined to be tortured for the rest of all his days in his every breath; my heart wept for him.

He for whom another dear friend of mine Naveen in a FF of her's had used this line to describe him – Samrat jaise ladke jab pyar karte hai , toh woh pyar unka junoon bhi hota hai aur sukoon bhi – made me cry today as I looked at him – in a contradiction - when his own tears don't fall.

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

3.6k

Users

20

Likes

113

Frequent Posters

Ocean.eyes thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
res
edited
awsome post aahana
sam is the heart of mjht
he always makes his fans go faint on his superb outstanding acting
Edited by cutekins - 15 years ago
AnotherAdmirer thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
res
edited

Ahaana dear beautiful post! 👏
I was waiting for one, i knew u wud make it sooner or later:)
Samrat Shergill is a character i truly adore in MJHT.

It may be said that samrat is waiting for death with welcoming arms..every night he offers himself..but death betrays him.

What can be more painful to live with the thought that he was the reason for tht accident.
Am not saying tht its his fault, but thts wat he thinks right now as the precap indicates.

I had this huge lump forming up in my throat at the end of d epi...he changed so much.

For Mohit its a makeover and he looks really cool but for samrat it expresses his sorrow his misery.
His attitude, his words, his hard eyes, ah killed me.

I feel really bad, maybe pity i dont know.

But i have this question doesnt samrat deserve love in his life?
First his parents and when he let tht thought away, and became an individual self, evry1's fav in excel with his gang Dia, Uday and Benji came another frnd Gunjan and as u say he found love, his life.
He got his sister back but she also left him.

And now after 3 years we see him all alone again.
Destiny took away his frnds, yes uday benji and dia and Also mayank.

He's alone walking through the college corridors, thinking of her..them.
Guilt is clear in his eyes.
His first scene.. it was loaded with Angst. So much angst tht i couldnt hold it, tears stung my eyes.

I love the title...Its really apt. Cant express the awesomeness(i think i just created a word) of ur post.

But the main fact still lies here.
He still love's.

That undying love he still carries in his heart.
Did u notice his expression when he imagined Gunjan and Nupur, did u see the flicker of hope of joy?
It killed me coz i knew he's imagining dem:(

One of my fav lines from a novel

Love Goes far beyong the Physical person of the beloved. It finds its deepest meaning in his spiritual being, his inner self. Whether or not he is actually present, whether or not he is still alive at all, ceases somehow to be of importance.

Its true and holds meaning wen it comes to samrat.

Samrat is my fav character wat attracted me initially to him was his name...it holds a deeper meaning to me.

I saw someone special in him then...and then i bonded with him so well.

I fell for this guy, not Mohit first...but Samrat shergill.

I truly adore actually admire him.
A friend of mine said tht he's turned suicidal and few members have been saying tht 3 years and he has not moved on.

I just have one thing to say.

They havent experienced loss in their lives. When they truly feel the unbearable non-existence of a beloved will they understand, that's its not easy to move on.

And that too when guilt drives the heart that the reason of it all was him.
Edited by VampirePrincess - 15 years ago
-Nymphadora- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
awesum post ahaana!...i frankly speaking wasnt to fond of samrat he always was the cute run of the mill characters...even thoiugh im really angry with the cvs,the progression that they have given samrat shergill the charec6ter is unbelivable.....
thats what i love about samrat he has layers to him,like you said quite a bit like karana of mahabharat......they live fight and love with all passion and vigour but sadnly never get thier due...
i feel liike crying when i see his picks...the pain he has in his eyes,but he still isnt crying....it hurts to see it...
but ya as you said whena guy like samrat falls in love it does not only becaome a way of his life but also a reason to live
me_mohit thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
outstanding post aahana!!!!!!!
Samrat Shergill has an enigma wrapped around him!!!!!!!
The pain doesn't allow him to smile nor to cry!!!!!
Smile........for whom?????? Cry..........For whom????????
No reason left to live!!!!!!!!!
Mayank aur Nupur ne GUNJAN ko khoya hai lekin Samrat ne APNI ZINDAGI,,,,APNI JAAN,,,,,APNE AAJ,,,,APNE KAL,,,,,,,APNI CHASHMISH KO KHOYA HAI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ramramramram thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
Aahana\dear, love your post 👏👏 You said so much and it was truly heart touching, no wonder without your posts even an episode of MJHT feels incomplete.
You know i was so not intersted in season two, but when i watched the first scene i got hooked obn because of sayank, especially Samrat. There was something in his eyes, that helplessness. He was completely lost without someone, alone in the dark. The way he spoke,in just a few words gave a reflection of those three years.
I have never felt god odes anything bad to good people but yesterday don't know why but i felt he doesn't deserve this. He, who brought a smilr on everybodys face, lit up everybodys days deserved and needed to have someone in his life with whom he could share everything and anything.
Then came gunjan and i felt relieved that atlast he will have someone by his side.
There are loads of sajan scenes but three scenes which i think belong to Samrat where he tells gunjan while studying that my parents are in France. He never accepted that he missed them but you could clearly see a lost child thirsty for love, who wants to meet his mother. Thats when i fell in love with Samrat Shergill. Then there was a scene when Gunjan wanted to break her friendship with Samrat and he asked her " Kya main itna bura hoon, chashmish". I felt like crying. The child inside him, the soul inside him was so and is so innocent. He hated himself though he never blamed anyone but deep inside he thught that it must be me where all the fault is thats why everyone left me. I could so feel his pain,don't know why.
Then the final bus scene coming back from Morena, although the whole Morena track actually highlighted Samrats weak side but that particular scene where he says that i finally have someone who is mine. Now this showed how much he longed for someone to be by his side.
I never expected this death track, i thought finally hisrestless soul would find what he longed but yesterday he was heartbroken, he was back where he started,alone but this time the pain was deepeer. He was lost, seriously fate played a harsh game, god knows how long it took him to get that mask of cool dude Samrat to cover his pain and now he found a new mask to cover his loss, and only Gunjan can uncover this, she has tocome back for him.
Edited by ramramramram - 15 years ago
EkPahelii thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
@ Zeejay

hey hun 😊

wow so glad to see u back in my post - thx 4 turning vocal on my request 😳

wow never knew my posts are so awaited ☺️ gee thx .. ahh my net stupid thing bothered me keeping me away 😡

yup Samrat actually to me hun is d most wonderfully versatile character the cv's have created - such layers profound shades make him incredible - yup to say he is my favorite character in MJHT is not a huge puzzle

but it isnt solely because of mohit am saying this but a combo of his talent and the traits Samrat has been given - no wonder he is somehow always the crux of major tracks😉

last night not just his new look blew me away but also the whole way he shaped up !!

Mohit deserves an applause for this - man his voice, his eyes, his body language made me feel like he is someone else all together and the biggest treat he managed a master stroke - a uber cool confident death streak colored him in his biker look and in the formal one with glasses and all he looked strong yet somehow his most vulnerable

truly as i said Sam has been made miseries fav child here hun he is born to bleed 😭😭

and yes that 1 scene his intro just gives it away how life has transformed and tortured him and makes u instantly cry for what it has done to him and he his eyes seem as if they just cant even cry anymore

and hence the title 😳

beautiful quote Zeejay and hey Hi5 hun me too fell for Sam 1st and then my obsession for mohit begun 😆

and yes i love him as Sam and as Mohit ..

truly hun ppl dont understand the pain someone else feels until they go through it themselves ..sad yet true - and when darkness and guilt engulf someone it is truly not only blue but a lethal combination
EkPahelii thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: shruti.nil

awesum post ahaana!...i frankly speaking wasnt to fond of samrat he always was the cute run of the mill characters...even thoiugh im really angry with the cvs,the progression that they have given samrat shergill the charec6ter is unbelivable.....
thats what i love about samrat he has layers to him,like you said quite a bit like karana of mahabharat......they live fight and love with all passion and vigour but sadnly never get thier due...
i feel liike crying when i see his picks...the pain he has in his eyes,but he still isnt crying....it hurts to see it...
but ya as you said whena guy like samrat falls in love it does not only becaome a way of his life but also a reason to live




Shruti exactly hun... this i suppose is the master stroke on the part of the cv's to make sam of what he has become and yes Mohit for actually making us cry by holding back the tears samrat has in his eyes and make them come alive with such pain that they truly make ur heart pierce

i was so pissed by this leap but i think i have to seriously thank the cv's for this 1 sphere that came off from it actually - no not his looks but the changed sam who has appeared - would have never imagined it - couldnt have asked it any better

EkPahelii thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: me_mohit

outstanding post aahana!!!!!!!

Samrat Shergill has an enigma wrapped around him!!!!!!!
The pain doesn't allow him to smile nor to cry!!!!!
Smile........for whom?????? Cry..........For whom????????
No reason left to live!!!!!!!!!
Mayank aur Nupur ne GUNJAN ko khoya hai lekin Samrat ne APNI ZINDAGI,,,,APNI JAAN,,,,,APNE AAJ,,,,APNE KAL,,,,,,,APNI CHASHMISH KO KHOYA HAI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



thx hun well he is a wreck hun
_symphony thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
first of all missed u terribly jaan...welcome back..🤗
now what shud i say aahana after what all u have said...off from writing a post on gunur and feeling so drained..i need more courage to right on sam...but i agree with what all u guys said...completely!!! his eyes yesterday...yesterday's biggest feature of samrat shergill...they were enough of tearing me apart...!!!
sometimes u have so much to say aahana that u end up being out of words...the similar is with me for samrat...dont know whether i wud update this or not..coz it needs courage hon...but simply all my salutations to mohit for that one expression of pain in his EACH FEATURE...that broke my heart completely...coz i lost my jovial and innocent samrat yesterday!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".