How would YOU have shown the MN track?

Lol...the creatives version of MN hardly seems to please any MN fan these days 😆

So, was wondering how would the hardcore MN fans run the MN story?

How do you think the MN story should have gone?

From which point did you feel that the story went awry and how would you deviate(with the Cvs) from there?

How would you developed their story...keeping the original characters of M and esp N intact....

I wonder....would MN have mostly met in the library at M's insistence....which could have annoyed N😆
Also, how would have M and N handled the differences in their varied approaches to life...would Nupur have made Mayank bunk classes? Would Mayank have let her?

These are just some questions that struck me as I was drowning in studying plants🥱

Please, no bashing..of anyone...creatives, other members.

This is NOT a suggestion thread as I ain't suggesting anything for the creatives to incorporate into their show...just mere discussion...a sort of "what if" ..or "alternate universe" kinda thing 😆 so please try not to lock/converge this topic in the suggestions thread 😉

Okay,from the time they fell in love..it was a steep downhill for them.if I were the creative,from this point it would be easy,since the character creation was superb,but the development was not.

I would have made nupur in charge of date planning.she always wants high funda dates,so she could plan a typical filmi date.mayank was never filmi,so their first date was great until his plan flopped. After that they should have sat by the beach n talked.mayank still enjoying and nupur wanting cozy romance like other couples on the beach.
Mayank should be shown trying hard to juggle between studies n nupur, this twist would have been better than the locket track.
I have more, will add later

Originally posted by: rose82

Okay,from the time they fell in love..it was a steep downhill for them.if I were the creative,from this point it would be easy,since the character creation was superb,but the development was not.

I would have made nupur in charge of date planning.she always wants high funda dates,so she could plan a typical filmi date.mayank was never filmi,so their first date was great until his plan flopped. After that they should have sat by the beach n talked.mayank still enjoying and nupur wanting cozy romance like other couples on the beach.
Mayank should be shown trying hard to juggle between studies n nupur, this twist would have been better than the locket track.
I have more, will add later

I so agree!!! I think Mayank would have been first irritated, then annoyed and then progressively frustrated with Nupur's laidback attitude...and he would have snapped.

And I dunno...he seemed like the sort of guy who would roll his eyes at all the "filmi" romance that nupur wants.

N would be wanting him to gift her romantic gifts all the time...play her fairytale guy...plan romantic surprises for her....however i think the "romantic surprises" would be time alone on a beach (where they don't dance around trees mind you) but just cozy up and talk....

She might like him to spring surprises like a candlelit dinner or something like that. That would be her idea of romance.

😆😆😆.........very tough question ......

wow!!!! anu........after a long time c u writting..........i wish the MN track was like the way u describe...........

Originally posted by: mou.2.shi

wow!!!! anu........after a long time c u writting..........i wish the MN track was like the way u describe...........

LOLz Mou....couldn't resist.......😆😆...aadat ki mazboor hoon....

Originally posted by: aj_observer

😆😆😆.........very tough question ......

lemme think......

The whole play.....is not Mayank in my view......this guy is romantic in private....the whole Intelligent cornering her to make her realize her love for him was distasteful........don't get me wrong......I loved watching them...the chemistry...the dances and the hugs......LOLzz...Just not mayank......

Nupur......Sharmaoing.......LOL.....this girl is a spitfire....she will say what is on her mind......she is loud but never disrespectful.......total massacre of the character

Having said that..........He would have stared off by being a friend.......they jumped from being enemies to part time friends to lovers.......He would have loved to establish his connection with her which he felt during academic meet......Since he noticed the change in her feelings towards him...he would have encouraged that change......Subtlety is this guys forte......and she would have said it right away....

I am a huge Nupur fan...And my dear friend is mayank's....So I can tell you what Nupur would do....Once they confess.....he would discuss with her what his future plans are because he is a no nonsense guy...and she would have understood him because like they said in many occasions ...she is the only one who could have known him other than his mother and may be CJ...

In all her nautanki....she would have asked him to go to a movie or beach...bunking classes.....he would have gone with her...after the classes....he would insist on her studying with her and she would have obliged.....their first date would be simple and elegant in Mayu's lawn ...Mayu cooking.....his first gift would be taking her to a sharukhkahn movie.......she would have loved that....

her first gift to him would be a good book...she would have asked CJ or Gunjan......She would have make him read out loud just to annoy him....he would have hated it and gave the look....

she would have talked about her fears and her childhood...her dreams and desires.....she will put up dance performance for him and makes him dance with her......she would respect his wish to not to disclose their relationship..she would plan her career with him and encourage him in making his....her style........she would talk incessantly....and he would just watch her....

she would fall asleep studying with him and he would have just watched her......and woke her up to study she would have resisted because she is tired.......She would have snuggled with him in private watching a movie with him.....

She would have made him do the other "cool stuff" and he would have raised his hand and say nope...but be with her when she does......she would have tried to make food for him because she thinks that's what a GF should do like in movies LOLz....

She would have planned a study date at her house and turns it in to romantic night...She would have noticed his pain and sorrow and would be there for him...she would love and trust him unconditionally......She would have told her father and Bui that she loves him....

Wow...long post...I will stop....

Nupur in essesnce would do anything to add fun in his life but also knows to respect his wishes...as forceful as she is she is a delight in his life and he is hers......

FANTABULOUS ! ! ! ! 👏

Originally posted by: aj_observer

😆😆😆.........very tough question ......

lemme think......

The whole play.....is not Mayank in my view......this guy is romantic in private....the whole Intelligent cornering her to make her realize her love for him was distasteful........don't get me wrong......I loved watching them...the chemistry...the dances and the hugs......LOLzz...Just not mayank......

Nupur......Sharmaoing.......LOL.....this girl is a spitfire....she will say what is on her mind......she is loud but never disrespectful.......total massacre of the character

Having said that..........He would have stared off by being a friend.......they jumped from being enemies to part time friends to lovers.......He would have loved to establish his connection with her which he felt during academic meet......Since he noticed the change in her feelings towards him...he would have encouraged that change......Subtlety is this guys forte......and she would have said it right away....

I am a huge Nupur fan...And my dear friend is mayank's....So I can tell you what Nupur would do....Once they confess.....he would discuss with her what his future plans are because he is a no nonsense guy...and she would have understood him because like they said in many occasions ...she is the only one who could have known him other than his mother and may be CJ...

In all her nautanki....she would have asked him to go to a movie or beach...bunking classes.....he would have gone with her...after the classes....he would insist on her studying with her and she would have obliged.....their first date would be simple and elegant in Mayu's lawn ...Mayu cooking.....his first gift would be taking her to a sharukhkahn movie.......she would have loved that....

her first gift to him would be a good book...she would have asked CJ or Gunjan......She would have make him read out loud just to annoy him....he would have hated it and gave the look....

she would have talked about her fears and her childhood...her dreams and desires.....she will put up dance performance for him and makes him dance with her......she would respect his wish to not to disclose their relationship..she would plan her career with him and encourage him in making his....her style........she would talk incessantly....and he would just watch her....

she would fall asleep studying with him and he would have just watched her......and woke her up to study she would have resisted because she is tired.......She would have snuggled with him in private watching a movie with him.....

She would have made him do the other "cool stuff" and he would have raised his hand and say nope...but be with her when she does......she would have tried to make food for him because she thinks that's what a GF should do like in movies LOLz....

She would have planned a study date at her house and turns it in to romantic night...She would have noticed his pain and sorrow and would be there for him...she would love and trust him unconditionally......She would have told her father and Bui that she loves him....

Wow...long post...I will stop....

Nupur in essesnce would do anything to add fun in his life but also knows to respect his wishes...as forceful as she is she is a delight in his life and he is hers......

WOW..jus reading this makes me fall in love wit the characters called mayank and nupur..the ones that u hav described tho !!! 😳

wonderful topic

and aj_observer wonderful post the whole essence of nupurs character in that last line....

in my story both MN wudve taken much longer than in the serial to understand each other even after they started going out-- mayank says it best before the confession-we ve never understood each other and thats y we ve never been friends----and another time he says main tumhare dost nahin hoon---
for me theirs not a love story based on friendship though those r the latest fashion ...its only and only love-the passion for each other esp mayanks for nupur- the attraction for each other both equally-the need to be with each other to feel complete- the respect for each other more for mayank from nupur...theyve always been incharge of their lives and those closest to them-with each other they r vulneerable with each other they can get hurt and they know they can hurt the other person as well---my MN wudve def said those things which said before the song-pehli baar....more than understanding each other lik gunjan says once - they can handle each other -- bcoz they listen to each other ..they need to become friends

my MN story wudve included all that u said but i def feel maynak not wanting to disclose to evryone and not being comfortable with public display of affection wudve been problematic fro nupur....and nupur wud be shy ...my nupur wud never be lik say priyanka in kaminey- maynk wud still be the one calling the shots most of the time.....nupur with all her confidance in her own charms wud still be insecure of mayanks love for her...wud still think hes ashamed of her

as far as real scenes go- i wudve included the locket track but made nupur realise without maynak jumping into the pool how unreasonable she was ....i wud maybe never ahve more than few min serious convo between them , their USP for me lies not just in the beach convo but rather in the song following the conversation----in throwing water on each other.....rather than in a quiet walk in the moonlight...even in a subdued version of the date the artificial flowers etc., rather than in any elegant way.....its an insult to maynaks intellectual superiorty and he wud ve ignored it fro nupurs sake ..... in my story mayank wudve analysed the technical aspects of the movie they watched much to nupurs frustration....

i wudve made nupur do a few things for mayank though ...lik saving a seat for him...making sure no other girl in college gets to talk to him. i so agree with you on the study date though i doubt my nupur wud ve thought of a career..mayank wudve planned both their careers

in my story mayank wud be incharge of all that as practical and nupur all thats imaginary in their lives... he wudve tried to make imaginary things come real initially and then given up while she wud blissfully ignore anything that wud damage their relationship till it hits her on the face...

my story wud be more in the lines of making themselves fro each other bcoz they r in love than already custom made for each other...

actually im pretty okay with the story thats on air, its the direction and dialogues that shud be bettered....i specifically like their long distance relationship track(god knows how long that ll last)...esp with adhi RAJ in picture....as long as i dont get to hear nupur ki pyaar mein shaheed ho jaaoonga kind of stuff again im happy.

just one more thing---mayank wudve never bunked classes....nupur wudve gone to canteen/movies with her other friends