What makes Mayank and Nuper -- Mayur? - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

96

Views

9.1k

Users

36

Likes

235

Frequent Posters

-ananya- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#81

Originally posted by: Sookie*



. I understand some what like Mayank in the way behaves. So if I have to connect with a person like Nupur, then there has to be something that I and the other person share to the T. I am looking for a commonality which brings them down to their most vulnerable/strongest self and that is when...bang! It is that connection I am looking for. (Probably this is all me!)
Currently they being on the opposite side of the spectrum seemed to be attraction factor.
I am finding it very hard to explain :-(

I think each of us are putting ourselves in his position and interpreting it.. ive seen absolutely opposites couples who have NOTHIN in common together... can't explain it either...



1)--She has a very strong stubborn streak and always rises up to a posed challenge. Even when she knows that her smartness is no match for the college topper, she still challenges him to a dare; a dare to beat him on his own turf. It is only then that one realizes that a challenge that could hurt her ego or a challenge to prove someone wrong were the only things that could bring her out of semi-crazy state and show her intelligence, smartness and what a hardworking individual she can be.

I think Mayank finds this quality in her intriguing (and may be some level reminds him of will power his mom possess) .
That she can be strong-willed yet have fun in life is combination he never thought would exist.


3)--She could find something to look fwrd to in the dullest of moments, she could find happiness in saddest of situation and she could mess up the most planned out situation... something which Mayank never was able to do...Her chirpiness was probably infectious to the strongest of the lot. Mayank never did that mainly due to his upbringing and 'no father figure' around to take the responsibility.
First time he really wishes he could behave 20 and not older. (ref diwali scene, Academic meet)


He surely didnt miss partying around with hundreds of ppl around ..going to pubs... but it made him 'alive' to sit with that girl on a beach NOT discussing his studies for a change ( something like Jadoo ki Jhappi effect)



2)--Her craziness emerges from a part of the head which seems to be stuck in a cloud of fantasy and the one which rarely connects with reality.
and yet when shes completely lost in the entire fantasy land (she so wanted to be in) she tries to find her 'morena's simplicity in Mumbai (ref: before beach scene).. At deeper level he could connect to the simplicity and emotional support she wanted...

I agree. Though looking for something un-complex and clean is what attracted to him, but I have not seen that in his behavior. Probably, this backs up his prejudice. He thinks his peers are superficial.

Please do watch the beach scene-- I think he prefers somethin uncomplex and clean..
rather say simplicity





4)---
strength, this confidence that she has in herself which makes her stand out in a group of girls and not her beauty.. The quality no girl around him possess.. they either swoon at him or are devotees per say(please give me a right word) at his intelligence.

I disagree for the bold part. Reason: CJ. Think about it. Why not CJ?

CJ might not be devotee of his intelligence .. but she doesnt challenge him either.. she believes he is the TOPPER and she cannot surpass him.. she is also the 'cool' variety.. and I dunno abt you but I do feel Mayank prefers simplicity




AS for why these two can be together apart from the individual reasons.. i think at a very raw basic n conceptual level both are simple, caring towards their dear ones, sensitive. Thats where their frequency matches and they share that comfort level.

I dis-agree. How is this different from Gunjan? But with all other characteristics that Nupur has, this is added as a bonus point and not as an exclusive one.

Please read @ green... thats how Nupur creates stronger impression than Gunjan..Yes as you said... This is APART from the individual reasons... Please do watch the beach scene...



Dear Ananya,

Writing this series was just for fun and some basic research (I don't know how many actually cared for that, but well...). I have learned many things and has been shown with different points of view with the above post. So I thank you for that.

My apologies if I come as rude and overbearing. If I disagree to something, I do not sugar coat it. :-)
Thanks again for your input!

Sookie



I think each of us would be intrepreting the sccene in our own way.. thats were differenece of opinions comes.. thats why you see a divide in the forum too... somewhere all of put ourselves in the positiona nd judge... end of the day they are fictional characters and the connection ends after we turn off the television... so please do not apologise on that...
-ananya- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#82
And I agree with Anu on CJ point too .. i missed out on them
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#83

Originally posted by: -ananya-



CJ might not be devotee of his intelligence .. but she doesnt challenge him either.. she believes he is the TOPPER and she cannot surpass him.. she is also the 'cool' variety.. and I dunno abt you but I do feel Mayank prefers simplicity

.



Great point, Ananya.....I'd almost forgotten that....yes, CJ never really challenges Mayank truly either....Nupur is the first and only girl to do that...REPEATEDLY😆😆😆...And I agree...Mayank does prefer simplicity...

Sookie, you haven't watched the beach epi??? Woahhhhhhhhh! It's a LANDMARK MN epi....must watch in my opinion.
-Sookie- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#84
Hmm...About CJ. I think she would challenge him intellectually in the way he thinks. But the way Nupur challenges him would be different. Guess you are right about her.

Anu, I have not watched many episodes. :-) I am catching up with them only now. I think I have to watch episodes from Jan - May.

Alright ladies - Anu and Ananya - Hands down -

Queens of (Mayur) behavior specialists! :-)


Still, I am going to agree to disagree. :-)

Sookie.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#85
Sookie, the beach epi is from October last year....not from Jan-May this year.

Ofcourse we can agree to disagree....but about CJ...in almost all of her scenes with Mayank, it's pretty apparent that they are both nearly mirror images of each other mentally except that CJ is more of a punk....but Mayank is never thrown off-balance by her....nearly each and every reaction of hers is something he expects....but with Nupur, it's a wholly different story....the girl has done nothing BUT throw him off-balance since day one.....she has that capacity to constantly surprise him and keep him on his toes that way.
-Sookie- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#86
Hmm...Last year October...I saw all those episodes back in July. Perhaps my memory has some issues.

Agree to disagree was not for CJ.
CJ, you are right. I agree there. :-)

Sookie.

PS: You should watch Criminal Minds where this kind of analysis of human behavior is actually done...if you are not already watching it!!
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#87
This was the scene from the beach epi that we were talking about, Sookie.

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ioj_TnpaGuk&feature=channel_page[/YOUTUBE]
-ananya- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#88

Originally posted by: Sookie*


Queens of (Mayur) behavior specialists! :-)


Still, I am going to agree to disagree. :-)

Sookie.



@blue--- 😲 😲 😲......... 😆😆

@red -- Thats bound to happen when 3-4 sit to discuss.. everybody has their own perspective.. we respect each others opinion.. so its fine...

@anu - and the one leading to the beach scene is also relevant
Edited by -ananya- - 15 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#89
Ahh yes, Ananya....that one is relevant too.....ok, here's the vid for that:

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0SF4U5wiLDE[/YOUTUBE]
-Sookie- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#90
OK! Anu, I love you !!!

If I had known about this scene, the whole analysis would have changed.
Thank you for sharing and I loved this!!!

I don't know how this got missed! Arrghh!!!!

I generally skip song sequence because they rarely add any value (be it movies or television), but I think this particular video goes to my PDA (I am not much of a fan of the original actors of this song, but these two rock!!!).

*Sigh*

Sookie

Edited by Sookie* - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".