Supporting the Creatives! Especially PD! - Page 7

Originally posted by: OHYE

There are two types of criticisms: destructive and constructive as implied by the topic starter. Constructive criticism is helpful, whereas destructive ruins the unity and halts progress. There is also something known as humanity. The individual who provides us information about her work should be respected as well as her ideas. As loyal viewers and fans we should provide her feedback and critique her work in order to help her do better in the future that is what the forum is all about, suggestions, thoughts etc. However, as viewers we do not have the right to hurt an individual and her feelings to the point that she has to feel disheartened; therefore I do not see anything wrong with apologizing. I appreciate her hard work and her teams', if I feel sad or happy about a particular part of the show one should write it to her, because she needs to know how her work connected with her viewers, but she cannot be blamed or attacked so ruthlessly like I have seen in the creative thread. I like reading all the thoughts here and post mine from now on, because it enhances our favorite show. Again, like the topic starter I would suggest to everyone that let us be constructive and maintain the forum's positivity, as I have seen as a silent reader for months.

Hey dear, couldn't agree more! PD takes all her time especially for MJHT fans to discuss the show further and gives us the latest scoops. Amongst many members , im one of them who never criticises the creatives of MJHT, i've always appreciated every post made by PD. For eg. the SaJan track, many fans have made an issue that their track is not good and so on and so forth, but im pretty happy with the way their track is, the slower - the better, because i believe that it'll be worth a wait for SaJan love track.

Hello to all the sudden Newbies!
welcome to the forum!

Some information on the existence of the forum and I-F in general!

MJHT forum was started around teh time the show was started. PD posted her first post sometime around the talent parade track when Mayur fans as a whole threatened to quit. the forum has always had conflicting arguments and issues regarding the plot before her existence on I-F!She was probably a silent reader way before she made her FIRST POST!


I-F has several different forums and we may have more thanone creative lurking around./ MJHT forum is one of the forums with strict rules controlling expression of views as the CREATIVE visits the forum! DO you want it to increase? Already some mebers equal criticism as bashing... I dont know how long it will be before this becomes an exclusive fan club!

Maybe in future all forums need to be renamed as fanclubs as we might have some silent creatives visiting too!!we would not want to hurt the feelings of the lurking creatives? DO WE???

BTW
MJHT forum is not THE CREATIVE's FANCLUB for us to sugar coat or something. IF Arti made a crappy scene work, there is nothing offensive it telling that. as Kanika mentioned, PD's posts saying they inadverstly screwed up mayurs track is also there... so its okay fr her to say she screwed up teh track but not okay for us?? GOOD LOGIC!!!

I think the moderators know how to run this forum better than fellow members itself and one of the rules psoted is that nobody should tell another member what to do as we all have brains enough to voice our opinions :)
So if u want to send a personal apology letter nobody would forbid u! the other option is a big question mark!


This is a free forum! those who want to praise can praise! those who want to criticise can criticise! If u guys still want to separate urself into PD supporters and us as anti-PD gang.. it is fine by us! let me just put it down that this topic was inadvertly made to split the forum and have more issues between members than it already has! and WE DID NOT INITIATE THIS DIVISION :)

thank u!

Caro: Awesome post! 👏👏👏

I truly fail to see why this now has to be turned into a 'humane' v/s 'inhumane' argument just cuz PD is questioned when the show is going DRASTICALLY off-track...I think she should be happy that ppl question her about it...shows that they still CARE...would she rather that they be indifferent and not give a damn??😕😆.....all the fans communicate their happiness and disappointment in equal measures to her...I consider these to be HONEST reactions...I'd like to believe that PD appreciates HONESTY rather than false feedback just in order to mollify her??🤔

Can someone please give me a quick summary? Haha.

Zainab
In short
the summary is

We are blessed to have a creative of the show in the forum who listens to us..

we should not give destructive criticism

the forum has seen a LOTTT for destructive criticism ..hence an apology letter is a good idea..that is the condensed version of the post.. if anybody corrects me..Id be glad to accept it...


ah well
as usual we are against it..ROFL

Originally posted by: carolinecj

Zainab
In short
the summary is

We are blessed to haev a creative of the show in the forum who listens to us..

we should not give destructive criticism

the forum has seen a LOTTT for destructive criticism ..hence an apology letter is a good idea..that is the condensed version of the post.. if anybody corrects me..Id be glad to accept it...


ah well
as usual we are against it..ROFL

ok, WTH? I didn't even bother reading all the pages.

Criticizing a show is NOT a crime, we criticize because we want the show to get BETTER, not worse.

I know some people don't care about anything else, but romance. But you know what, we don't want mush!! We want a good storyline, something that goes with the character's true self. We do not want the creatives to deviate from the main plot so we are here to help.

Some people really need to understand the difference between bashing and criticizing.

I have already taken a break from watching the show because it SUCKS at the moment, but we're talking to PD to make it BETTER. People are only going to stop watching if it gets worse.

Originally posted by: nureat01

Caro: Awesome post! 👏👏👏

I truly fail to see why this now has to be turned into a 'humane' v/s 'inhumane' argument just cuz PD is questioned when the show is going DRASTICALLY off-track...I think she should be happy that ppl question her about it...shows that they still CARE...would she rather that they be indifferent and not give a damn??😕😆.....all the fans communicate their happiness and disappointment in equal measures to her...I consider these to be HONEST reactions...I'd like to believe that PD appreciates HONESTY rather than false feedback just in order to mollify her??🤔

ROFL Anu
why judge another persons view when it is none of my business to do so?
as KAnu said Live and LEt Live!

well from her side the view has been if u feel anything is wrong..tell me and I will see what can be done..when PD doesnt seem to have that much of a problem I dont understand the conflicting views..

maybe this is the usual reaction to build a mountain out of a molehill!


I cannot sing PD U ARE THE BEST every single time and especially when I dont like a track! However people fail to realise that we have posted a lot of appreciation posts too...

anyway

Lage Raho!

Originally posted by: Ms.GoodMorning

I have already taken a break from watching the show because it SUCKS at the moment, but we're talking to PD to make it BETTER. People are only going to stop watching if it gets worse.

WORD!😊