PIPA/SOPA- Ban on Internet Freedom-FAIR/UNFAIR?

Aahaana thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

Hey friends,

Many of us may of have heard about PIPA (Protect IP Act) and SOPA (Stop Online Piracy Act) lately, esp. those who living in USA. For others, we may not be affected directly but indirectly, it will affect us. The Internet is an arena where you can find all kinds of information that you are looking/searching for, it's mostly just a click away - but it's also pirated material. Both SOPA and PIPA gives us the U.S. government and copyright holders are the authority to seek a court order to block any website associated with infringing, pirating or counterfeiting intellectual property. It's okay to stop piracy and we do support it. But it's getting out of hand now. But now its getting out of the hands, with SOPA, they can shut down sites they suspect to provide piracy and you are no longer innocent until proven guilty - now you are guilty and must prove (within 5 days) that you are innocent😳.


How will it affect us on India-Forums??

Almost everyone here loves using signature while posting in the forums. Being a creative artist, do you love to make use of it and make creative signatures and avis or even Video Mixes...Don't you love to use icons, pictures of your favorite television soap operas/movies? Even making videomix of your favorite couple with your fav song may be illegal and be blocked. What if you come to know if a new rule is passed which all of the above is illegal and should be banned. A medium of Internet, which is free for sharing, would be censored. Yes you hear it right CENSORED. We don't say piracy is right but the Internet is a media where freedom of sharing your creativity, views is considered to be one of the vital factors. The liberty of Internet is under the scanner, not only the websites that uses the promotional pictures or any content would be permanently close if the bill comes into effect. Yet millions of websites/organisators are currently protesting by signing the petition. Even some websites such as Wikipedia went on a BLACKOUT for 24 hours on 18/01/2012 in order to support the cause. Other sites like Yahoo, Reddit, Google, Wordpress etc is also against the new bill. Come to think about it, what if you come to know the social networking sites might shut down in the future because of this rule... Do you think it is right?? And is it the only solution to stop piracy??

People who are involved in piracy would come and get other means but stopping the liberty of Internet, which is one of the primary factors and vital ingredient of Internet, has stopped. Do you approve of it?? If not please support the users by sign the petition to stop this bill to be passed. Raise your voice protest and join hands with those people who are protesting this. The Parliament would start voting on 24th January so join hands and help people to stop PIPA and SOPA bill to be passed...!





Edited by Aahaana - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

94

Views

13.4k

Users

74

Likes

242

Frequent Posters

Aahaana thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Few articles about the same and facts:

(Reuters) - The House of Representative's Stop Online Piracy Act and the Senate's Preventing Real Online Threats to Economic Creativity and Theft of Intellectual Property Act have generated fierce opposition within the technology community. Here are some facts about the bills:

What would SOPA and PIPA do?

** The legislation, known as SOPA in the U.S. House of Representatives and PIPA in the Senate, would use court orders to curb access to foreign websites "dedicated to theft" through techniques such as disabling links to those sites.

** They also cut off U.S.-based payments processing for those overseas websites that traffic in stolen content or counterfeit goods.

Why do copyright holders say the law is needed?

** Entertainment companies and other copyright holders say many legal copyright remedies aren't effective against big foreign sites such as PirateBay. They say the bills will help curb online piracy that they claim costs them billions of dollars a year. Technology companies say they too oppose such piracy but argue that the proposed laws go too far.

What is the current status of the bills?

** The White House weighed in on January 14 with objections to the legislation, particularly a provision that would have required Internet service providers such as a Verizon Communications and Comcast Corp to cut off access to infringing sites through a technology known as DNS blocking.

In the days before the White House statement, backers of both bills had said they planned to move away from those provisions. The Senate bill is scheduled for a vote on January 24, although some supporters of the bill have asked to postpone that vote. The House bill is still before the Judiciary Committee.

Why do technology companies oppose the bills?

** Technology companies say the legislation would undermine an existing law called the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and its "safe harbor" provisions for websites and others that act in good faith in their handling of third-party content on their sites. Content companies say the bills simply fill gaps in the DMCA and wouldn't affect the safe harbor provisions.

** Technology companies express concerns that the legislation would encourage frivolous litigation. Content companies believe the difficulty of squeezing large payments out of illegal overseas sites would discourage frivolous litigation.

** Technology companies say users would circumvent new restrictions and piracy would still occur. Content companies say the law would create important tools for fighting piracy.

** Technology companies worry they would have to police their services for links to overseas pirated content. Content companies say the technology companies would have to act only if notified.

** Technology companies say part of the House legislation encourages providers to act against foreign sites on their own initiative by providing immunity from liability, which could lead to overaggressive actions against foreign sites. Content companies say that sites that act against pirates in good faith and with evidence to back up their actions shouldn't have to worry about lawsuits.

** Technology companies say there is no due process for overseas sites that are accused of piracy. Content companies say normal due process applies.

(Reporting By Sarah McBride; Editing by Steve Orlofsky)

source: reuters.com

*****************

How SOPA/PIPA Can Affect You




The United States government has been facing an intense amount of pressure, mostly from the entertainment and computer software publishing companies for years to find some method of stopping the online piracy that is allowing people to own copies of their merchandise for free. This is of course understandable, nobody wants to see something they worked hard on to create something of quality be disrespected by people gaining access to it for free.

However, what the U.S. House of Representatives and the Senate have planned for their respective bills is not a way of just putting a halt on online piracy. Tech giants such as Mozilla and Google who once supported these bills, now are on the offensive in trying to ensure they never get passed. Before going any further into how this affects the everyday internet users, let's first get a good understanding about both bills.


Curious about the image above? It's an infographic from AmericanCensorship.org.

Update:

Internet Blackout Aftermath – Is the Threat of SOPA/PIPA Over?

What is PIPA and SOPA


PIPA

Let's begin by first breaking down the first of the two bills that were introduced, PIPA. PIPA is an acronym for the Protect IP Act, and was first introduced to the U.S. Senate on May 12, 2011 by Senators Patrick Leahy, Orrin Hatch, Chuck Grassley. It is also good to take note that PIPA is a re-written legislation, the original being the failed to pass Combating Online Infringement and Counterfeits Act (COICA) of 2010.

PIPA, if passed, will give U.S. corporations and the government the right to seek affirmative legal action with any website that they see as enabling copyright infringement whether of U.S. origin or not. Here is a breakdown of all that they will have the power to do.

  • Force U.S. internet providers to block access to websites deemed as enablers of copyright infringement
  • Seek legal action by suing search engines, blog sites, directories, or any site in general to have the black listed sites removed from their website
  • Will be able to force advertising services on infringing websites, and those supporting of them, to remove them from their advertising accounts
  • Companies will also have the power to sue any new websites that get started after this bill is passed, if they believe that they are not doing a good job of preventing infringement on your website

SOPA

SOPA is an acronym for the Stop Online Piracy Act, and is a bill introduced to the U.S. House of Representatives by Represenative Lamar Smith on October 26, 2011. In similarity with PIPA, SOPA is a build on a previous legislation. This legislation being the PRO-IP Act of 2008.

SOPA, if passed, will work in conjunction with PIPA. As described by such entities as the Electronic Frontier Foundation, SOPA is nothing more so than the U.S. government and private corporations black list. Here is a breakdown of the power given to the government and private corporations.

  • The U.S. Attorney General can now seek a court order that would force search engines, advertisers, DNS providers, servers, and payment processors from having any contact with allegedly infringing websites
  • It will allow private corporations to create their own personal hit lists composed of websites they feel are breaking their copyright policies, ironically this doesn't have any odd feelings of a legal mafia at all. These companies will be able to directly contact a website's payment processors a notice to cut all off payment involvement with the targeted website. This payment processors and website of question will then have five days to act before it is simply taken down.
  • Payment processors will have the power to cut off any website they work with, as long as they can provide a strong reason of why they believe this site is violating copyrights

Where Do the Tech Giants Stand

Originally, the majority of technology corporations that put their input into these bills, were in support of it. Companies like Apple, Intel, Corel, Dell, Microsoft, Adobe, and 23 other big name tech companies are supporters under the BSA(Business Software Alliance). However, there is still hope in the realm of big name support of tech giants. Two of the biggest in Mozilla and Google, have gone public with their issues with these bills and their reasons why they can no longer offer their support after further research was done.

Mozilla is strongly against both acts because of its use of DNS filtering in both. Mozilla, like the majority of the tech world, believes that by using DNS filtering this will open up more security risks and slow down the system's up and coming extension DNSSEC.

How Does This Affect You


Well by now one probably has gained a good understanding of what both PIPA and SOPA are, and is wondering how exactly will these acts will directly affect how citizens use the internet. Well in all honestly, a lot of things will change.

Blog Sites like 1stwebdesigner could be blocked or shut down

As stated prior in what PIPA and SOPA are and what will they enable U.S. government agencies and private companies to do, the internet will become a hunt for any little bit of possible copyright violation. Of course the government loves blogs and bloggers, so it is only natural to think that they will receive a lot of special attention. These acts make it the blog owners responsibility for everything that is displayed on their site, including the comments of visitors.

So say an article is published one day featuring a logo, or trademark, of corporation and that corporation doesn't like that it is being put on display on the site. Now the author of this article could have used it as a teaching method, critique, praising good design, or anything you can think of, it doesn't matter. With these acts being only direct enough to give an area for attack, and vague enough to manipulate and twist seemingly any possible way, any type of accusation can be made and found true.

Say Goodbye to Innovation

These acts are stopping developers from coming up with the next big thing in the online market that could change how we use the internet. Let's say that these acts were around back when the internet was started, how many of the most popular sites would still have come into fruition. There would be no Facebook, YouTube, MediaFire, SoundCloud, Twitter, DropBox, or any other site that can be targeted as a place where online piracy could take place. Is it even possible to think about what the internet would be like without sites like this?

Legal Action Over A Child Singing A Song

It is quite oblivious that none of the people on sites like YouTube have been given permission from record label execs to sing their favorite song, and then proceed to post it on a video sharing site. However will that be a problem for the record execs?

The site the child will have posted the video on will be put under pressure to resolve this issue, or face their site being put on the blacklist. This child, and her family, could also very well face legal action with either the site or the record label the song that was sung has copyrighted.

The U.S. Government Hope They Will Spark Global Change

The U.S. government officials and private corporations aren't only concerned about how these bills will work out in America, they are hoping that they will have the influence to get other nations to follow suit with these acts passing. That means if these acts pass, then the next country this could be coming toward may be yours.

source: http://www.1stwebdesigner.com/design/how-sopa-pipa-can-affect-you/


Angel-Jot thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Wow. WTH. -__-
This is ridiculously unfair. What happened to Freedom of expression? Our creativity?

I don't even know what to say. 🤣 This is SO stupid. 🤣

-Jot.
Autumn_Bliss thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Wait!!!!!! What! 😳..internet without Facebook,Twitter, YouTube and other sites is not THE internet..😳..i am speechless..i guess the end of the World is really in 2012..😳..we must do something!
dangerouzIshk. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
wait WTH..must be some kind of a joke🤣
this is sooo unbelievablee😳
Edited by -Zunni- - 13 years ago
eminent thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Thank you for this post and the extensive information! Everyone must be made aware of this situation and take a stance! While I agree piracy is wrong, these acts take it too far!Geneva
KYPH-AK thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
ohhh man..I am a law student but this is taking away ppl's freedom of speech by censuring it 😳
If they actually pass the bill then whats the diff between countries like china, iran, syria who controll the net... 😳

I better do something 😳 🤣 otherwise what will happen to Zunni's creation 😲 🤣



KYPH-AK thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -Zunni-

wait WTH..must be some kind of a joke🤣
this is sooo unbelievablee😳


Tere creations ki toh lag gye..!!🤣🤣
Edited by KYPH-AK - 13 years ago
Beautie thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Totally unfair for people like us who live in usa...i cant imagine how my life will be without tht
MysticNights thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
The joke continues...I think if people have issues, they should have copyright everything in start and make programs that are un-hackable.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".