Is Mamta Justified? - Discuss - Page 2

First Mamta never believed Satya was Akshaye's wife; she just stopped arguing for the peace of the family. Second Krish would deff. pay the biggest price if his parents separate but, not as big a price as having been told your father is dead when you know he's alive and in front of you, things like that are sure to mess a kid up, also it seems that Krish spent most of his time with Sid than Akshaye.

I know I'm sounding like a big Akshaye basher, but I'm not, actually I prefer Akshaye w/Mamta, always have and always will, but I don't think he's truly remorseful for what he's done, and until he is he should not be rewarded by getting his family back.

And for you Sid haters out there, think of this: If you had a friend who was loyal and true, gave of them selves w/no ques. asked, what would be your thank you, a 🤗 and a kiss or a kick to the head?

sid wasn't loyal..........he lied to akshay's family and mamta that akshay betrayed mamta by already being married to someone else.......he should have asked akshay a straight question, the day they met at teh beach before akshay got in an accident.

sid has changed ever since the accident...........he is a very confused person...........with no sense of direction.

Originally posted by: Aviance

And for you Sid haters out there, think of this: If you had a friend who was loyal and true, gave of them selves w/no ques. asked, what would be your thank you, a 🤗 and a kiss or a kick to the head?

Well....

First of all, I aint a SID hater...I loved Sid A LOT at one point of the show... However.. Let me give you a little flashback ride...

Sid took mamta to pune.... Tried to persudae her to go agaisnt her hubby and to love him.... He created such a bad impression of mamta infront of everyone... Is that truely a good deed in the FRIENDSHIP rule book?? 😊

Originally posted by: Aviance

Mamta is right. Akshay choose to belive stranges over his wife and best friend whom he's know longer, also Mamta has on many occasions proved to him that her love is true and faithful. He was more forgiving to Tanisha after he found out she cheated on him and after he found out Krish was not hers, and he had evidence. Here he was working on assumtion (and you know what happens when you ass-u-me)and was blinded by his hatered. She can't be going through all the trials and tribulations and he's sliding on butter all through life.

i agree

Mamta shouldn't have to go thru proving her love for Akshay everytime someone points a finger at her...can't he think for himself?...is he so jealous that he believe everyone else other than the one person who loves him more than anything??...

i'm with Mamta in this one....sorry akshay fans...as much as i like him and want him to get back his family...he need to think for himself!!!

Originally posted by: tripler

sid wasn't loyal..........he lied to akshay's family and mamta that akshay betrayed mamta by already being married to someone else.......he should have asked akshay a straight question, the day they met at teh beach before akshay got in an accident.

sid has changed ever since the accident...........he is a very confused person...........with no sense of direction.

sid did not lie...he said what he believe to be the truth...if you recall...akshay was brushing him off at the time he found out about satya...and sid did see the report naming akshay satya's husband...

i feel so sorry for sid having to be mixed up with akshay and his family...he can do much better than that...

This is not a clash between Sid haters and lovers.. This is probably the way in which Mamta sees both and understands both Akku and sid..

Let me give an example: Sid along with Tani plans to seperate Mamta and Akku... He is mislead by Tani, who instigates Sid and tells him that Akku does not love Mamta, so Sid has every right to get Mamta for himself.. so Sid starts on a mission, to save Mamta from Akku.. He does lots of things , faking that he has lost his memory so that he could live under the same roof with Mamta.. Sid did not want Akku to reach Krishu's school on time for the function.. Hence tried to prove to Mamta that Akku does not care for her and her kid... He wanted to prove to Mamta that Akku is an irresponsible father..Above all, he wanted to snatch Mamta from Akku.. The funniest thing was when Mamta got to know of all this , Sid pleaded to her, asked for forgiveness. Mamta eventually agreed, she even hid this fact that Sid loved Mamta and did everything to get her... She did not utter a single word to Akku about it.. So here Mamta did not live upto the trust that Akku had in her.. did she?

Now, when Akku has accepted his mistake and is pleading to Mamta, she will not forgive him.. The dialogue in today's episode where she says - Sorry is such a simple word to say. But does it mean that you do all things and then ask for a simple sorry? Now, when she can accept the "Sorry" from Sid , then why not Akku?

"This is not a clash between Sid haters and lovers.. This is probably the way in which Mamta sees both and understands both Akku and sid..

Let me give an example: Sid along with Tani plans to seperate Mamta and Akku... He is mislead by Tani, who instigates Sid and tells him that Akku does not love Mamta, so Sid has every right to get Mamta for himself.. so Sid starts on a mission, to save Mamta from Akku.. He does lots of things , faking that he has lost his memory so that he could live under the same roof with Mamta.. Sid did not want Akku to reach Krishu's school on time for the function.. Hence tried to prove to Mamta that Akku does not care for her and her kid... He wanted to prove to Mamta that Akku is an irresponsible father..Above all, he wanted to snatch Mamta from Akku.. The funniest thing was when Mamta got to know of all this , Sid pleaded to her, asked for forgiveness. Mamta eventually agreed, she even hid this fact that Sid loved Mamta and did everything to get her... She did not utter a single word to Akku about it.. So here Mamta did not live upto the trust that Akku had in her.. did she?

Now, when Akku has accepted his mistake and is pleading to Mamta, she will not forgive him.. The dialogue in today's episode where she says - Sorry is such a simple word to say. But does it mean that you do all things and then ask for a simple sorry? Now, when she can accept the "Sorry" from Sid , then why not Akku?"

i agree with your comments 100% sree........very strong comments.

i still think akshay needs to accept some of the blame (which he did by the way).

also, mamta should accept some blame as well.........she didn't even wait for what?.........a year or two until she got re-married again....what is up with that?....and what is her excuse?........she did it fo her family's happiness?.........that's complete rubbish.....i'm sorry but when it comes to marriage, your happiness should count in this decision, not only your family's happiness.

please!!!!!.....so much for her undying love for akshay...which is (at the moment) worth nothing.

i hope akshay ends up with someone very pretty, large-hearted, and someone who doesn't "mother him" all the time.......someone who has a great personality.

then the directors could show mamta realizing her mistake and make her repent for what she said to akshay.

my sympathy for mamta has ended

Yes, I do think Mamta is justified. It seems every time Akshay hears something about her from someone else he believes it. That happened earlier before they married and the whole family humiliated her. She has always loved Akshay, but Sid has been a loyal friend no matter what. Even when he was "bad Sid" it was because he thought the family wasn't good to her. And the family letting lunatic Tanisha back in the house shows that Vandana is the best MIL for Mamta. She treats her like gold. And if Akshay had come forward earlier and told everyone what he knew about Natwar and Satya maybe the whole kidnapping, miscarriage thing could have been avoided. But he wanted revenge on Sid and Mamta so he held out with the information. Akshay does not have good taste in wives, so I don't think he should have someone else. Who knows who or what he'll end up with the next time. 😆 😆 😆 He and Mamta will get back, it will just take time.
Lastly...just keep in in mind that all of these poor characters in this show are victims of the same fate--poor writing and creativity. 😡 Getting the principals together too fast usually kills the show, hence they have to break-up to make-up and so on and so on. But while that happens its up to the writers to make realistic or atleast non painful storylines. And the writers in this show seem bent on giving pain for their viewers. So pain is what we will have. 🤢

Thank you Sree.

You are right. Although in a way she is justified for her angry but at the sametime it was wrong of her to choose Sid instead of Akhshey. 😒

Because both Mamta and Akhshey were victims of deception. 😭

Mamta's action was so bizarre. 😒

Originally posted by: tripler

"This is not a clash between Sid haters and lovers.. This is probably the way in which Mamta sees both and understands both Akku and sid..

Let me give an example: Sid along with Tani plans to seperate Mamta and Akku... He is mislead by Tani, who instigates Sid and tells him that Akku does not love Mamta, so Sid has every right to get Mamta for himself.. so Sid starts on a mission, to save Mamta from Akku.. He does lots of things , faking that he has lost his memory so that he could live under the same roof with Mamta.. Sid did not want Akku to reach Krishu's school on time for the function.. Hence tried to prove to Mamta that Akku does not care for her and her kid... He wanted to prove to Mamta that Akku is an irresponsible father..Above all, he wanted to snatch Mamta from Akku.. The funniest thing was when Mamta got to know of all this , Sid pleaded to her, asked for forgiveness. Mamta eventually agreed, she even hid this fact that Sid loved Mamta and did everything to get her... She did not utter a single word to Akku about it.. So here Mamta did not live upto the trust that Akku had in her.. did she?

Now, when Akku has accepted his mistake and is pleading to Mamta, she will not forgive him.. The dialogue in today's episode where she says - Sorry is such a simple word to say. But does it mean that you do all things and then ask for a simple sorry? Now, when she can accept the "Sorry" from Sid , then why not Akku?"

i agree with your comments 100% sree........very strong comments.

i still think akshay needs to accept some of the blame (which he did by the way).

also, mamta should accept some blame as well.........she didn't even wait for what?.........a year or two until she got re-married again....what is up with that?....and what is her excuse?........she did it fo her family's happiness?.........that's complete rubbish.....i'm sorry but when it comes to marriage, your happiness should count in this decision, not only your family's happiness.

please!!!!!.....so much for her undying love for akshay...which is (at the moment) worth nothing.

i hope akshay ends up with someone very pretty, large-hearted, and someone who doesn't "mother him" all the time.......someone who has a great personality.

then the directors could show mamta realizing her mistake and make her repent for what she said to akshay.

my sympathy for mamta has ended

Agree to Sree and you both. Its just that Akshay was her husband so she has a high expectation bar for him than Sid so accepting Sid's apology was quick and Akshay's appology is supposedly going to take a leap 😡