Created

Last reply

Replies

54

Views

4.5k

Users

20

Likes

243

Frequent Posters

FarhaadkiMahi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#21
arshi rofling post .epi is so so .
love shiva n pro talk baki sub bakwas one interesting word karma bandhan
is dadi hinting maya is garud nahi...
dono milenge but not due to love but for mission
appukrish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#22
Arshi ek idea aur request bhi hai aap ek liye.
Through out this thread and other threads, we are all going 'Kya Maya, kyon Maya, God! Ye Maya and the writers are pulling us deeper and deeper into their Mayajaal of this prem kahaani.

In your inimitable style ek fun post ho jaye is Maya aur Mayajaal ke baare mein.
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#23

You, my dear Arshi, are far more entertaining than the episode. I am sure you could recite all these lines very nicely too, and keep us more engaged than Rudra did tonight.

So-so is too kind an assessment. I found myself fast forwarding all the parts of Rudra wandering around and I almost did the same with the scene of him moping and weeping all over an empathetic daadi, who of course was only too glad to lend him a shoulder for this purpose. I do not like men or boys who weep all the time like a watering pot, and by now I am tired of Rudra mourning his losses.

The only good parts tonight were

(1) the Greyerson-Katharine interchange, hinting that (a) he has some hold over her and (b) that he knows that she is a garuda, which is why he wants her to tell Shivanand that and thus insinuate herself into his plans (her refusal is intriguing and the reason she offers appropriately cryptic and confusing),

(2) the scene between Prof. Rao and Shivanand, where Shiva betrays the depth of his disappointment with his son and his emotional weaknesses. It showed that even an iron man can have his moments of depression, and finally

(3) the precap where Shiva shuts up a pleading Rudra, who wants him to toe his mother's line and presumably junk all the research he has been doing. His line Parivaron ke rakshak hote hain, rakshak ke parivaar nahin hote!, is classic by any standards.

Incidentally, Rudra's plea put paid to the argument advanced here after he sided openly with Daadi against his father, that it was merely a tactic that he had adopted in order to effect a reconciliation between Daadi and his Baba. It was clearly no such thing. Rudra is on the same page as Daadi, and he has, as of now, no stomach for or interest in his father's mission.

I suppose another dozen episodes, if not more, will be consumed in getting Rudra to swivel by 180 degrees on this issue, for the pace is far too slow and has been so all this week. That will bring us to near the mid-point of 60 episodes.

For now, I simply cannot stomach all these lachrymose goings on, and if Maya, after denying all knowledge of him, begins a weeping competition with Rudra, I shall be strongly tempted to run away. I cannot understand why this unconvincing love story, between a pair with zero chemistry (alas for Saras and Kumud!), is being force fed to the viewers; this Rudra is no Saras, not by any manner of means. Surely Utkarsh could have found other reasons for Rudra being reluctant to join in his father's crusade? Is it that just because they have named her Maya, she has to haunt not just us but Rudra as well?

Shyamala


Edited by sashashyam - 10 years ago
happychappy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#24
^^^^
You are equally entertaining dear Shyamala!

Now Rudr cries even at the sight of bhindi... 😛 I am far more sympathetic to his cause than you are, though!!! Especially because that bhindi scene struck some personal chords with me...Rudr's devdas act will find its counterpoise at some stage where the action-hero will take over... it's only a couple of weeks since we were cribbing about his animal ferocity, so the writer regularly gives us a new bone to chew over...😉 How kind!

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#25
Thank you, my dear..

It is simple, Shubha. I am not given to facile tears and I do not like crybabies. Especially, being old enough to be old fashioned, I do not like men who cry so much at the drop of a hat.

Moreover, such weeping is a cop out for the actor by the director. Instead of stretching the actor, the director, unsure of the audience's capacity to appreciate nuance, takes the cliched route. When he does not, the results are often wonderful. Remember the deep sadness, the corrosive loneliness, the chronic insecurity and fear of abandonment that Siddharth, as the young Rudra, brought out so effectively without shedding a single tear?

And then this current Devdas act of Rudra's has no real basis or rationale, which makes it worse.

I did not like the animal ferocity of the early Rudra-as-adult for the same reason; that too was a cop out, instead of getting the actor to bring out controlled rage in a subtle manner. So I have no patience with either extreme, and this Rudra makes me want to take a quick nap!

Shyamala

Originally posted by: happychappy

^^^^

You are equally entertaining dear Shyamala!

Now Rudr cries even at the sight of bhindi... 😛 I am far more sympathetic to his cause than you are, though!!! Especially because that bhindi scene struck some personal chords with me...Rudr's devdas act will find its counterpoise at some stage where the action-hero will take over... it's only a couple of weeks since we were cribbing about his animal ferocity, so the writer regularly gives us a new bone to chew over...😉 How kind!

Edited by sashashyam - 10 years ago
pasumarthisa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Incidentally, Rudra's plea put paid to the argument advanced here after he sided openly with Daadi against his father, that it was merely a tactic that he had adopted in order to effect a reconciliation between Daadi and his Baba. It was clearly no such thing. Rudra is on the same page as Daadi, and he has, as of now, no stomach for or interest in his father's mission.

Hmm. My hypothesis. I think I was looking for sense and logic. Aaj kisi par jaan-lewa hamla karke doosre din marham patti ki baat karein tho yahin matlab nikaaloongi.
But Rudra was still listening to his dad at that time. But suddenly kyaa ho gaya. Mysterious.
PS: didnt see the episode yet.
Anu-Reddy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: sashashyam

You, my dear Arshi, are far more entertaining than the episode. I am sure you could recite all these lines very nicely too, and keep us more engaged than Rudra did tonight.

So-so is too kind an assessment. I found myself fast forwarding all the parts of Rudra wandering around and I almost did the same with the scene of him moping and weeping all over an empathetic daadi, who of course was only too glad to lend him a shoulder for this purpose. I do not like men or boys who weep all the time like a watering pot, and by now I am tired of Rudra mourning his losses.

The only good parts tonight were

(1) the Greyerson-Katharine interchange, hinting that (a) he has some hold over her and (b) that he knows that she is a garuda, which is why he wants her to tell Shivanand that and thus insinuate herself into his plans (her refusal is intriguing and the reason she offers appropriately cryptic and confusing),

(2) the scene between Prof. Rao and Shivanand, where Shiva betrays the depth of his disappointment with his son and his emotional weaknesses. It showed that even an iron man can have his moments of depression, and finally

(3) the precap where Shiva shuts up a pleading Rudra, who wants him to toe his mother's line and presumably junk all the research he has been doing. His line Parivaron ke rakshak hote hain, rakshak ke parivaar nahin hote!, is classic by any standards.

Incidentally, Rudra's plea put paid to the argument advanced here after he sided openly with Daadi against his father, that it was merely a tactic that he had adopted in order to effect a reconciliation between Daadi and his Baba. It was clearly no such thing. Rudra is on the same page as Daadi, and he has, as of now, no stomach for or interest in his father's mission.

I suppose another dozen episodes, if not more, will be consumed in getting Rudra to swivel by 180 degrees on this issue, for the pace is far too slow and has been so all this week. That will bring us to near the mid-point of 60 episodes.

For now, I simply cannot stomach all these lachrymose goings on, and if Maya, after denying all knowledge of him, begins a weeping competition with Rudra, I shall be strongly tempted to run away. I cannot understand why this unconvincing love story, between a pair with zero chemistry (alas for Saras and Kumud!), is being force fed to the viewers; this Rudra is no Saras, not by any manner of means. Surely Utkarsh could have found other reasons for Rudra being reluctant to join in his father's crusade? Is it that just because they have named her Maya, she has to haunt not just us but Rudra as well?


@Bold : Couldnt have said better.

Rest I agree with everything you said, we share the same sentiments. Even i cant take men who weep like there is no tomorrow.


Edited by Anu-Reddy - 10 years ago
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#28
😆 I think it's the first time where no one wants to see romance, that's zero chemistry for you!
Waise, CVs if you are reading this, the whole viewer base is saying the same thing:

(Rudra ke) thappad se dar nahi lagta sahib, pyaar se lagta hai!
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#29
After the super fast pace of the initial weeks, i think this week was a week of thehraav.
A pause so as to say, everyone and everything pretty much status quo.

Not much of progress in terms of events or relationships or most important the war

It sas if the UN decided chalo jisko bhi chutti vutti lena hai, abhi le lo

Interval chalu hai, ja ka chai vai piyo

Ek baar amrit appear ho gaya, phir time off nahi milega



The romance of mr weepy willow with miss blank face is not really making any of our dils go DHAK dhak

We all are desperately rooting for that sunny deol dhai kilo ka haath wala Rudra over this mr gopi vahu

It's high time those hunky naga men appeared and upped the game

Bahut ho gayi baatein vaatein, ab kuch kar ke dikhao na Jaani!
rosame thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#30
Arshics, Excellent poetic post . " (Rudra ke) thappad se dar nahi lagta sahib, pyaar se lagta hai! " ROFL . Rudra's should come out of his grieving avatar .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".