krishna's argument - Page 5

Poll

How many of you agree with Sri Krishna's argument?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

8.4k

Users

14

Likes

88

Frequent Posters

..Apz.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: ..dreamygatz..


Ooh Dear... Mata Kunti could have done better than letting her newly born baby find its own destiny in River Ganga! Baby would have been drowned.. so literally Kunti tried to kill her baby! Ok forget it! Call it the mistake of a helpless worried unmarried gal! She got chance to redeem it when she knew Karna was her son, why she kept silent all through watching her son getting humiliated? Then she should have remained silent always!

PS: I love Yudi for cursing her! ❤️


She could think about everything else except her baby Thought about her father, her future, he other kids Why didnt she accept Karna during Rangbhoomi? If a mother cant stand by him when his identity is questioned, there is no sympathy from my side. I have heard that mothers are very feisty about their kids. Never seen that protective shade in Kunti.
FeistyQueen thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: ..Apz..


She could think about everything else except her baby Thought about her father, her future, he other kids Why didnt she accept Karna during Rangbhoomi? If a mother cant stand by him when his identity is questioned, there is no sympathy from my side. I have heard that mothers are very feisty about their kids. Never seen that protective shade in Kunti.

I knwww!! 🥱
Neutral2 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#43
Edited by Neutral2 - 11 years ago
JazzyM thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#44
Isn't the argument shown yesterday more like the folklore version than the actual MB? If that's the case, are you asking for a poll on myth or actual facts? Sorry. Confused. 😕
Jin. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: ..dreamygatz..


Ooh Dear... Mata Kunti could have done better than letting her newly born baby find its own destiny in River Ganga! Baby would have been drowned.. so literally Kunti tried to kill her baby! Ok forget it! Call it the mistake of a helpless worried unmarried gal! She got chance to redeem it when she knew Karna was her son, why she kept silent all through watching her son getting humiliated? Then she should have remained silent always!

PS: I love Yudi for cursing her! ❤️


She is sane enough to know that the baby is a demi-god and has invincible kavach and kundal. And surya dev himself said that the boy is "mrityunjaya". Well, on Rangbhoomi she has no reason to reveal it's her son. That will not give him respect, but will drain his respect further calling him illegitimate and questions would arise of kunti's character, and because of this even pandavas will suffer humiliation.

p.s: Yudi did not curse her. He cursed the entire womankind.
Edited by TheDreamCatcher - 11 years ago
Jin. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: ..Apz..

I loved all your explanations and I cant understand them. It is plain simple as that.

Draupadi was forcefully submitted by her lovely dharamraaj patiparameshwar Yudhishtir😆 Dury did not forcefully submit her to him. Oh yes, I forgot. It was Yudi who ordered her VH and called her a prostitute and enjoyed when pulled by hairs and single robe of saree.
And oh please the 13 years of exile is the result of his foolishness🤢 and not the punishment for staking his wife and remaining silent when she was insulted. He got his punishment after war to remain peaceless forever. Foolishness, mistake, sin, crime whatever you call, but exile was his redemption and he ACCEPTED it wholeheartedly and did not make a hue and cry about it. He was never peaceless because he accepted destiny. That is the reason he went to heaven alive without death.
Your IIT and local engineering comment is🤪 I thought IIT entrance tests are open to ALL😎 So did Drona conduct a Common Admission Test for teaching Divyastras and did Karna fail on merit?🤣 Common Admission Test is for teaching Archery i.e to get into IIT-Bachelors. Professors teach tips and tricks/Master's level to selected students or the ones whom they like because Masters isnt their syllabus at all. Karna should have won Drona's heart to learn them like Arjuna and not make his intentions of jealousy clear. If you accuse a professor of partiality why would that professor give you additional knowledge?

Parashurama is a Lord, so stop questioning his revenge and accept it believing God does everything for eternal good. Yup I got you. His purpose may have divine justification, but his intent does not especially when dragged to judge the actions of a human like Karna.

Like IIT-ians are always held above the best student of a State college, a man whose talent is equal to the Kshatriyas should exhibit it where they do🥳See IITs conduct fests every year. If you take IIT-Bombay, TechFest and Mood Indigo every year in February. It is open to all the students i.e non-IITs too who compete with IITians and earn handsome rewards. However there are few fests which are exclusively for IITians like Aakaar and Radiance. Now if a non-IITian wants to show that he is superior to IITians he should take part in TechFest or MoodIndigo, not go in their personal fests and say it's unfair and all. I guess Karna did not want to wait till Febraury. As i gave another example of cricket in one of my above replies. A man cannot jump in between ODI and challenge Sachin and say i'm better thann him let's play a game.

Arjun learnt from Drona and Karna learnt from Parashuram. He had to lie because of social discrimination but ofcourse Karna made sure he doesnt fall short of Arjuna on anything ( like divyastras) and he did not😳 Learning isnt enough, using in right direction and for right people is. You cannot be a best engineer and work for terrorists in making nuclear bombs just because they gave you food, money and job. You see terrorist groups have become very sophisticated, they have people on par with NASA scientists or perhaps even superior!😆


God is flawless. I have no doubts on it. But I am flawed and God knows it. If I question some of His actions, He knows how to answer me. I know my God through my experiences and not through scriptures and translations by humans who are prone to errors. I really do not believe God took sides in the Kurukshetra war. The entire war was fought by God alone and Pandavas and Kauravas were mere pawns in His game. ❤️ I didnt understand your intentions behind getting personal. Did i say that you dont kow God and you dont understand God and all such things? Well i didnt even ask you what you believe in personally. See, good for you that you see God through your experiences, there are million ways on how one sees God. Some see God in parents, some in mentors, some see God in the voice of their hearts, some treat their work as God as they say work is worship, some in experiences, some know him through scriptures and hymns, some in pilgrimage and holy places feel him, some see him in temples, idols and many more. As i said there are million ways. It is a personal relationship between a person and a God. So good for you that you know him through your experiences.


Jin. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: ..Apz..

I agree wih Riti and Gayatri. There is no justification to Kunti's silence. She had enough opportunities to reveal Karna's identity but the woman revealed when she had no other option left. She left him for her other kids' future and revealed to him his identity again for her other kids' lives.

There is nothing I hate like people who keep silent when their closed ones are suffering in front of their eyes.👎🏼

Riti🤗We have lots of things in common😳


Karna gave her word that he wont kill her other sons but she did not reveal it on the intention that he should spare their lives. She knows that her sons are brave and she doesnt fear of her son's death coz they'd only get glory in fighting. She only revealed because she didnt want her sons to kill each other and one of her son join hands with adharma, but then she was asked not to reveal it to pandavas as they'd not fight the war if they came to know that karna is their elder brother and he'd lose his chance at glory.
Regarding not revealing for other kids future, yes, why should all the five kids suffer because of one kid? And that too when the kid (now grown up) has become a king while they were roaming in forests. Dury who is thirsty of pandavas blood wouldnt have spared karna either if said the truth and plan him to send to the same lakshagriha. Why should she risk it when the kid is now leading an izzatdaar and surakshit life?
Jin. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: ..dreamygatz..

@dreamcatcher: you said am asking same question in different way? Actually ua telling same thing over and over.. for that I can only ask same question na? 😕


I'm saying the same thing again because you are asking the same question again in a reverse way, then twisted way and then in a full circle way.
Jin. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: ..Apz..

As to your taunt about fiction and tragic hero- am humbled that my comment impresses certain people Being a literature student I have every right to my view 🥳 Like for me a Gitanjali is the ultimate spiritual scripture. That is the way I see God❤️


You thought that it was a taunt?😆😆 Chill, i just said people these days love to read fictions and tragic heroes. I did not intent any other indirect meanings. Anyways, i did not see that you are literature student and now when did i say you dont have any right to express your views? Nor i have asked you how you see God? I was just generalizing. And it is not a taunt-worthy or a shameful thing to like fictions or tragic heroes. It is just a trend these days hence no one likes to read Bhaghavatam. That is what i said that's it.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".