could Karna ever be friend of Bheem and Arjun if truth was revealed? - Page 2

WELL

question is not being accepted as brother question is being a buddy or comfortable , being brther in true sense , growing the bond with Karna

I don't no what to vote for.bitterness is not easy to forget and somehow I feel evenif truth was revealed karna would never have the place yudi had in his brothers heart. may b due to obedience they would have accepted but being real buddies is something I am unsure of. evenif I accept for a moment arjun sharing somewhat common interest would like karna(hypothetically)but I don't think bheem would. yes but bheem I don't think will revolt against yudi wish but?

exactly sristi i am just like u totally unsure and yes they would never give the same place of yudi to karna

I think jhum evenif truth was revealed to karna before even finalising war it would b better not to join pandava family for karna as whatever b circumstances or how much pandavas were good he will b an outsider. relationship donot have their meaning because they are formed by blood rather they develop with time and love.bloodlink is the root only.it is nourished by trust and affection with time.even at rangbhoomi karna identity was like that of a full grown tree which was nourished by someone else, eventhough his roots were same as pandavas. gen in my pov I donot think karna could b ever part of pandava family , neither it would have been good for him being acknowledged as pandava in later part of his life.

Originally posted by: Patrarekha

and what about karna? i mean from karna's side?

Patrarekha

you have touched the strings of my heart with this topic.I have always wanted karna to be a part of pandavas to be truly their brother .But to be frank i am not sure if this would have ever been possible even if truth was revealed before his death

i mean pandavs would have accepted him as an elder brother because that would have been the right thing to do and all but whether they would have genuinely thought and loved him as an elder brother hard to say.Yudhishtir may have for the reason you stated but it would have been hard for arjuna and bhma to truly love him as an elder brother too much had happened between them for either side to forget and move on

hence i voted for may be later because i hope that if not initially but slowly with time at least Bhima and arjuna and karna would have overcome the animosity between them and become brother's.I mean family bonds are always very strong blood runs thicker than water

I voted yes, but there is one condition: such a revelation would have to happen either

• Before Duryodhan befriended Karna & made him Angaraj
• Before the game of dice, where Karna would have had the opportunity to return Anga, thank him and join the Pandavas, and make peace overtures similar to Yudisthir's

If Kunti made her confession after the first event, there is no way that Karna could have accepted it, w/o doing what's in the second point. If she made her confession after Draupadi's vh, no way could Bhima or Arjun have forgiven him: they'd still have hated him as much as they hated Duryodhan

all believes bheem won't b ready to be his bro but arjun could yet none hit the option

Karna and Arjun could but Bheem wont