Does Mahabharat belong to one religion only? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

3.6k

Users

14

Likes

132

Frequent Posters

varaali thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#21
Actually IMO, the fanatic elements within the Islamic or Christian or other religions prevent their members from reading anything outside their scriptures..
Hinduism or- Sanatana Dharma- is one of the most inclusive religions possible. It is unfortunate that you have had undesirable experiences in some social networking sites, but in my experience, the other religions are more closeted.


As fas as the MB is concerned, you can enjoy it at various level:

  1. As a story
  2. As a literary work without believing / agreeing the philosophy entrenched in it (one of my gurus is a foreigner by birth but a great great Sanskrit scholar and can quote, at random, from just about any Sanskrit text - but not a practicing Hindu. Till this day he cannot appreciate why someone would want to touch his feet )
  3. As a truly philosophical work (this is the approach adopted by our great saints and acharyas)

If you are reading MB for its story content, it is no different from a Bollywood thriller. Heroes, villains, romance, drama, damsel- in distress, hero- comes to rescue, fight sequences, tragedy...a ready made script for the Karan Johars of today. As far as the story plot goes, it is religion-free. You can forget that it is a Hindu scripture and enjoy it as you would any other thriller novel.

But having said that, I would like to add a caveat here. There is so much of philosophy entrenched in here that it may be difficult for a non Hindu (even Hindus, I would say) to appreciate and understand. Not impossible...but just a little bit difficult. Now, I know there are exceptions...Please don;t give me a list of Max Muller and his disciples..

If you have been in a Hindu family...you would have been taught from your infancy to worship a certain God who happens to have the face of an elephant. But for others, it may seem a bit quaint. Or the image of Durga inspires only awe and respect from us. But for outsiders it may seem grotesque. Hence, it becomes that much more difficult for others to appreciate out philosophy.

Just as you have been subject to unpleasant situations, I too have come across many people / institutions who openly mock our religious values. That hurts and that's when we too draw the line.

There are several websites (funded by organizations of other religions) which highlight only the unpleasant facts from the RY or the MB and make the whole epic seem a third rate po*n novel. You can check it for yourself. That's when we too become wary of non- hindus' sentiments and become cautious


Please don't misunderstand me. It is the same way I feel when I see someone eating non-vegetarian food. Just the way our mental outlooks has been shaped.

Of course, if you are genuinely interested, you do have every right to read not just the MB, but other Puranas, Upanishad as well.

Bon reading!







Edited by varaali - 11 years ago
Surya_krsnbhakt thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#22
Ah, finding knowledge..
You know there is the saying that the lamp is what is important, and not the person who carries the lamp? (Lamp=knowledge)
So modifying that, it is the light that is important, not the material with which the lamp is made - like it can be a brass lamp, or silver, or even wax, what is important that it gives you light. (Material = religion). Hope you can understand what I am blabbering.
Angela_Grokes thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: varaali

Actually IMO, the fanatic elements within the Islamic or Christian or other religions prevent their members from reading anything outside their scriptures..

Hinduism or- Sanatana Dharma- is one of the most inclusive religions possible. It is unfortunate that you have had undesirable experiences in some social networking sites, but in my experience, the other religions are more closeted.


As fas as the MB is concerned, you can enjoy it at various level:

  1. As a story
  2. As a literary work without believing / agreeing the philosophy entrenched in it (one of my gurus is a foreigner by birth but a great great Sanskrit scholar and can quote, at random, from just about any Sanskrit text - but not a practicing Hindu. Till this day he cannot appreciate why someone would want to touch his feet )
  3. As a truly philosophical work (this is the approach adopted by our great saints and acharyas)

If you are reading MB for its story content, it is no different from a Bollywood thriller. Heroes, villains, romance, drama, damsel- in distress, hero- comes to rescue, fight sequences, tragedy...a ready made script for the Karan Johars of today. As far as the story plot goes, it is religion-free. You can forget that it is a Hindu scripture and enjoy it as you would any other thriller novel.

But having said that, I would like to add a caveat here. There is so much of philosophy entrenched in here that it may be difficult for a non Hindu (even Hindus, I would say) to appreciate and understand. Not impossible...but just a little bit difficult. Now, I know there are exceptions...Please don;t give me a list of Max Muller and his disciples..

If you have been in a Hindu family...you would have been taught from your infancy to worship a certain God who happens to have the face of an elephant. But for others, it may seem a bit quaint. Or the image of Durga inspires only awe and respect from us. But for outsiders it may seem grotesque. Hence, it becomes that much more difficult for others to appreciate out philosophy.

Just as you have been subject to unpleasant situations, I too have come across many people / institutions who openly mock our religious values. That hurts and that's when we too draw the line.

Please don't misunderstand me. It is the same way I feel when I see someone eating non-vegetarian food. Just the way our mental outlooks has been shaped.

Of course, if you are genuinely interested, you do have every right to read not just the MB, but other Puranas, Upanishad as well.

Bon reading!

You are correct but let me tell you that only a few days back when I joined this forum I reached India and I am currently living as a PG what they say with a Hindu family. Sunandha aunty (the house owner), she has much influenced my life earlier I used to watch MB and search for the story they show on the web but now Sunandha aunty she explains the episode to me with great care and though it has hardly been a week living in India now but Sunandha aunty, she is like my mother to me. And now when I see the vast difference between the people I faced on the sites and the people whom I'm living with. And slowly and gradually I am also adopting some Hindu beliefs from her like - I bath daily early morning and worship Jesus and then I worship Shri Krishna with her. I have started liking vegetarian food . My life has completely changed and I'm happy instead very happy with my new life.







You are correct but let me tell you that only a few days back when I joined this forum I reached India and I am currently living as a PG what they say with a Hindu family. Sunandha aunty (the house owner), she has much influenced my life earlier I used to watch MB and search for the story they show on the web but now Sunandha aunty she explains the episode to me with great care and though it has hardly been a week living in India now but Sunandha aunty, she is like my mother to me. And now when I see the vast difference between the people I faced on the sites and the people whom I'm living with. And slowly and gradually I am also adopting some Hindu beliefs from her like - I bath daily early morning and worship Jesus and then I worship Shri Krishna with her. I have started liking vegetarian food . My life has completely changed and I'm happy insted very happy mwith my new life.

MS-meghasharma thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#24
nice post.
everybody has a right to read mahabhrat or any other book. those who object to it seriously need to change their mindset.
gita gyaan is applicable to all irrespective of caste or religion.
Myraluvpanchali thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#25
Hello Angela... 😛
Wonderful post... 👏 I agree with each n every word of yours.N I don't think that to respect another religion we need to be a part of it n Infact all this casteism,racism is not made by Jesus or Krishna but all this is made by human beings. I don't think lord Krishna would be unhappy if a "Christian" watches mahabharat.All this is just a crap made by orthodox people,any god have not made such rules.n whether it is geeta or bible the very premise of it is humanity.you know my grandfather is a Hindu,my grandmother is a Muslim n my mother is a Christian but as a whole we all follow Hinduism.i believe whether it is geeta or bible both of them are an asset to humanity and everyone should gain knowledge from it rather than making them the basis of discrimination...
Angela_Grokes thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#26
Thank You!!!! Everyone... I am very happy to be a part of this forum and also i'm very happy to know that members of this forum are not the same as the members of other social sites who just feel that Hinduism, Christianity or any other religion should not know are read about one another.😊
Spring-Dew thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#27
i m also christian and not a hindu but i do watch Mahabarat 😳 coz i find this show good than other hindi shows😊 i went to the rules thread to see whether they mentioned that only hindus are allowed but i didn't saw any rules like that so i started to post here and i really like to join with other people and know about mahabarat 😊
naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#28
well im a muslim too n i have watched brc's mahabharat before too as my dad used to watch, but i dont rem much other than flying arrows. I have watched many hindu mythological shows as i do not know much about then so im keen to know. I have watched dkdm also & i loved the potrayal of Mahadev in the serial. the calmness & detachment etc etc. Also it was something new to know other than ramayan & mahabharat.
when star mahabharat was launched i loved the graphics they showed in the promo. i was watching dkdm n just had a passing thought that wud SRJ who plays vishnu would also play the role of krishna as i loved his acting as the ever smiling Vishnu. N it was to be so. So i started watching mahabharat coz of that. also i liked the gyan krishna gave in the promos n then in the episodes. i could relate to it in these times too.. how excessive moh leads to destruction, etc etc...N i think SRJ plays it perfectly well you tend to want to believe what he says. I must say that being from another religion i was not that attached or had a special type of liking of respect towards krishna. but after watching mahabharat i have that. (though SRJ has become the face of krishna for me like it may have been with many other ppl too).
from whatever geeta gyan ive seen n then read on this forum, I believe it is a way to live life & learn for ppl from all religions. though all religions mostly say the same but in muslims( not to offend any1 here) i feel bhakti towards allah part is more highlighted & given importance than "how to live ur life" part. So we do not get to hear much of it.
Also this forum though i dont visit regularly has shed light on so many things which are not shown in the serial. So its always good to know & learn new things.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".