Feedback to CVs/ Story distortion # 3 - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

134.6k

Users

95

Likes

4.4k

Frequent Posters

riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Sabhayata

completely agree riti

i have interacted with many karna fans on this forum i can say most of us would have preferred to see karna's full role in VH or other dury's schemes than the distorted scenes in which karna's true glory lies

like you said his conversation with krishna,kunti and indra is what makes karna's character complete.In the epic atleast before his conversation with krishna he is just an ally of dury who hates pandavs and wants to get rid of them kind of an antagonist.But this is where you truly understand his heartfelt feelings the kind if sacrifice this man is capable of making.This conversation shows that karna has more shades to his character than it seems that he is more than just an enemy of pandavas.This is the point where his positive characteristics shines out brightly.But makers have failed to comprehend this and portray it

ofcourse show him wrong when he was really wrong and we all dont mind that... I am sure even we all will condemn along...but why snatching his real feats from him... Why is known as Danveer.. It was not that he followed his dad's advice there...coz genuinely he did have a big heart...and for me that came out more strongly in this particular event...
I really wished makers would realised how much layered and depth Karna's character had..
582445 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
very well said Riti .. we SP MB is a show made by fool n I am not sorry to say it clearly .. They are used with making meaningless saas-bahu dramas what you can expect from them? Their process of thinking is limited therefore they are bend to whitewash all the characters .. Karna, Krishna, Kunti .. as if it is their duty to explain KArna was a poor goody trying best to cope up with situation .. The beauty and depth of Karna's character is way above for the peanut size brain of cvs .. that's y de r not into writing good novels but tacky hindi dramas

n to whitewash Krishna they just omitted most important part of Karna-Krishna talk .. I knew Krishna offering Draupadi to Karna part will be deleted here. CVs have no gut to show this but never thought they will edit the part where he offered karna the crown .. This is the best part where Karna's character shines like thousand sun but anyway do we really need a class-less gibberish adaption of epic to glorify Karna. Karna is glorified with his own aura .. that's y he only gets the status of "Suryaputra" among the Chandravanshi clan .. scholars has depicted him perfectly for several time .. that's enough
-Archu- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Ritu darling, welldone..and thanx a lot for opening this thread...
🤗 🤗
⭐️Bharat did complete injustice to the most awaited conversation between Krishna and Karna...
1.There was no invitation to pandava side
2.No offer of throne..
3.⭐️Krishna was behaving as a person who did take up the duty unwillingly..
4.⭐️Karna was in total disbelief of what he heard and he needed confirmation from his parents...
5.There was no reply from Karna at all.
6.⭐️Karna was in awe and couldn't make the request to Krishna to keep the secret from his brothers...
The scene left nothing for the viewers on fact..
Radh se Radhey Uthar aya...
Hari ke man me vismay chaya...
Bole ki Veer! Shatbar dhany!!
Thuchsa na mitr ,koi Anany..
Tu Kurupati ka hi nahi pran,
Nartha ka hai Bhushan mahan!!
these are the lines from Rashmirathi,which describes Krishna 's opinion on Karna after hearing his reply..StarBharat CVs spoiled the heroic moment of Karna...
Edited by -Archu- - 11 years ago
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: SayaneeH.Lecter

very well said Riti .. we SP MB is a show made by fool n I am not sorry to say it clearly .. They are used with making meaningless saas-bahu dramas what you can expect from them? Their process of thinking is limited therefore they are bend to whitewash all the characters .. Karna, Krishna, Kunti .. as if it is their duty to explain KArna was a poor goody trying best to cope up with situation .. The beauty and depth of Karna's character is way above for the peanut size brain of cvs .. that's y de r not into writing good novels but tacky hindi dramas


n to whitewash Krishna they just omitted most important part of Karna-Krishna talk .. I knew Krishna offering Draupadi to Karna part will be deleted here. CVs have no gut to show this but never thought they will edit the part where he offered karna the crown .. This is the best part where Karna's character shines like thousand sun but anyway do we really need a class-less gibberish adaption of epic to glorify Karna. Karna is glorified with his own aura .. that's y he only gets the status of "Suryaputra" among the Chandravanshi clan .. scholars has depicted him perfectly for several time .. that's enough

Well said Saynee.. He is well understood by so many authors and poets who bring out actual essence of Karna's character. Why to add extra drama where there is already enough...Why creating extra sympathy first for the character with whom many do empathise with...and then later snatching away his actual moments... his winning moments.. Why ..just to show others in positive light.. They could have still retained that... Didnt earlier Mahabharat versions did the same...then why they distorting so much that characters whom we love are beyond recognition....you are probably right...what to expect from them apart from daily soap drama... I thought i was watching an epic onscreen..
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: -Archu-

Ritu darling, welldone..and thanx a lot for opening this thread...

🤗 🤗
⭐️Bharat did complete injustice to the most awaited conversation between Krishna and Karna...
1.There was no invitation to pandava side
2.No offer of throne..
3.⭐️Krishna was behaving as a person who did take up the duty unwillingly..
4.⭐️Karna was in total disbelief of what he heard and he needed confirmation from his parents...
5.There was no reply from Karna at all.
6.⭐️Karna was in awe and couldn't make the request to Krishna to keep the secret from his brothers...
The scene left nothing for the viewers on fact..
Radh se Radhey Uthar aya...
Hari ke man me vismay chaya...
Bole ki Veer! Shatbar dhany!!
Thuchsa na mitr ,koi Anany..
Tu Kurupati ka hi nahi pran,
Nartha ka hai Bhushan mahan!!
these are the lines from Rashmirathi,which describes Krishna 's opinion on Karna after hearing his reply..StarBharat CVs spoiled the heroic moment of Karna...

🤗🤗
I so loved these lines archu... they ruined it all😭
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: -Archu-

Radh se Radhey Uthar aya...
Hari ke man me vismay chaya...
Bole ki Veer! Shatbar dhany!!
Thuchsa na mitr ,koi Anany..
Tu Kurupati ka hi nahi pran,
Nartha ka hai Bhushan mahan!!


archana sorry but what do these lines mean .They seem beautiful but dont understand what they mean.
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Sabhayata


archana sorry but what do these lines mean .They seem beautiful but dont understand what they mean.

I think it is Rath se Radhey Utar aaya- Radhey got down from his chariot.
Hari K mann mein vismay chaya- Making even Lord wonder
Bole ki Veer Shatbar dhany- Lord Said O Brave Soul you are great.
tujhsa na mitr koi anany- There is no friend like you
last line is bit complex for me😕
Justitia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
If you ask me, CVs made Karna's character look a lot worse in this Krishna-Karna convo -
1. ⭐️Karna actually stating to Krishna that he sees "dharma" on Dury's side

2. ⭐️Karna calling Krishna a liar and a cheat

3. ⭐️Karna going to Radha & Adhirath for "confirmation" - this one looked plain ridiculous for me. Did ⭐️Karna really think that EVERY human being is born with kavach & kundals or the ability to look at the sun directly?

4. After Radha's blurt, ⭐️Karna telling Radha,"This world knows me by the name of Raadheya. What name should I respond to now?" Did ⭐️Karna's own respect for Radha suddenly die down on knowing that she didn't give birth to him? 😲

riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: -Shani-

If you ask me, CVs made Karna's character look a lot worse in this Krishna-Karna convo -

1. ⭐️Karna actually stating to Krishna that he sees "dharma" on Dury's side

2. ⭐️Karna calling Krishna a liar and a cheat

3. ⭐️Karna going to Radha & Adhirath for "confirmation" - this one looked plain ridiculous for me. Did ⭐️Karna really think that EVERY human being is born with kavach & kundals or the ability to look at the sun directly?

4. After Radha's blurt, ⭐️Karna telling Radha,"This world knows me by the name of Raadheya. What name should I respond to now?" Did ⭐️Karna's own respect for Radha suddenly die down on knowing that she didn't give birth to him? 😲

Yeah so true...it feels like they did it purposely may be to justify his death.. but it looked so ridiculous..specially when he said i m not radheya..Shocked😡
...Diala... thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
Karna telling Vrishali that he is a Kaunteya is the worst part..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".