Mahabharat Episode Discussion Thread #6/ DT's Nt pg-23 - Page 15

the watcher i never said karna never insulted draupadi yes he insulted bt it is to be noted that draupadi also insulted karna in his swayamvar infront of bhari sabha!! if karna's insult can be judged as it was not a insult by draupadi she was only reminding him of his own social class and rejecting to marry her as it was her right to reject smeone he she dsnt like bt there is a way of rejecting smeone!! so same way why do we make big hullabulu of karna's saying a wh**e to draupadi where it was clearly written in dharmashastras that an woman who had more than one husband is called an wh**e!! so if karna's insult is logical then so draupadi's insult is also logical!! as he stated only what was stated in dharmashastras that time

@ the Watcher --- thanks for being so polite to me; much appreciated

Originally posted by: shani88

EDT is turning into a Karna discussion thread - perfect.

drmodel again i have to say that though if karna knew that brihannala is arjuna he cannot fire arroes on a transgendered person as raising arms against kids women and hijras were against kshatriya customs!! here was following his dharma again!! u put up ur criticism wothout proper info that is wrong u knw

Originally posted by: meghumonu

dear rushika you may not admire karna your own choice bt dnt disrespect a character without knwing evrything and the situation he faced in his life time and what forced him to take actions for which he is blamed in histry!! dnt judge smeone jst by seeing the facts laid infront of you understand his situation and place urself in his position and then judge him/her!!

hold on dearie...I neva knew that my words that I don't admire Karna will offend u this way...I simply said I don't admire him...u have ur POVs u have other way of watching the whole scenario. ..I have thought being him but I wouldn't have committed any such mistakes...I'm not saying that he should have been perfect..No no1 was its just that I wouldn't have done what he did n 1stly no where in my post I passed any snide remark or even tried to mock him...I simply said I don't admire him I'm sorry not because I said "I don't admire Karna" but that I will still stand firm on my words that I don't admire him so I'm sorry if it will offend u further but I can't change my POVS just to please anyone 😊

I am a strong opposer of KMG, but I have to follow it to bring citations to this forum

Originally posted by: DrModel

Sorry Shani; I was just responding to bheegi. I did not know in any way that it would start a battle😭

I put forth my criticism without any bashing and as per the rules on page 149 of the previous AT

@ the watcher, again i appreciate your politeness and let us turn this discussion to PM

P.S. please do NOT PM me any hate messages. I will report to the mods straightaway.

My discussion is only with Mr Watcher.

Wht hate msg pm kar rahe h 😲 WTH dear plazzz report it . this is discusting. 🤢

Originally posted by: meghumonu

drmodel again i have to say that though if karna knew that brihannala is arjuna he cannot fire arroes on a transgendered person as raising arms against kids women and hijras were against kshatriya customs!! here was following his dharma again!! u put up ur criticism wothout proper info that is wrong u knw

sorry I wish I could reply u but as shani said I don't want it to b a Karna Discussion thread so I won't pick up any arguments regarding it or try to clear ur misconceptions regarding Arjun's gender at the time of war!

rushika did u even read my post clearly i said that u have ur preferences ok i will not oppose that u can oppose karna ur choice dear bt i said not to disrespect him without knwing evrythng abt him or th situation he faced which led to his historical actions!! i have no intention to tell you to join karna admirers!! before bashing frst read my post carefully dear!! 😊

rushika u r free to clarify my point abt arjuna's gender at the time of virat war at any other posts as u feel like!! 😊 no question of debates dear!!