Mahabharat Episode Discussion Thread #6/ DT's Nt pg-23 - Page 16

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

117.5k

Users

74

Likes

5.4k

Frequent Posters

RosChel.Lobster thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: meghumonu

rushika did u even read my post clearly i said that u have ur preferences ok i will not oppose that u can oppose karna ur choice dear bt i said not to disrespect him without knwing evrythng abt him or th situation he faced which led to his historical actions!! i have no intention to tell you to join karna admirers!! before bashing frst read my post carefully dear!! 😊

I neva bashed u...y will I even do so...I was quite polite n will carry on wid my politeness n I read ur post twice dearie n hence I asked y did u find my post a disrespecting 1? My sincere apologies if u found anything disrespecting!! Let's leave it here 😊
meghumonu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
yes i have also same opinion letz stop this discussion in a friendly way 😊
anyway though i am silent member bt i guess am relatively new to this forum!! my name is sayandeep am frm kolkata!! nice to meet u rushika!!
guenhwyvar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
just watched today's episode ... i was cursing at the TV the entire time. Partly for the silliness they showed in the serial, partly for the curses, partly because of Krishna's randomness (not cursing Krishna, more so the serial) ... mostly for the Draupadi being staked part 😭 surprisingly no cursing due to distortion today. I'm so proud of myself!
Anyway a few things I noticed:
1. We all know that Krishna was in war with Salva, but did you guys notice that Krishna had no charioteer again. 😆
2. One thing I never got was the whole series of curses. FYI, this entire post is going to be independent of distortions from the epic. I just found it hard to believe that Bhishma would actually curse Duryodhan as such. Sure Duryodhan did bad things, but I would find pretty weird for a grandsire such as Bhishma to be characterized as someone who seems to be very anti-Duryodhan. I mean, even parents forgive their children for their crimes right?
3. Did Drona actually curse Ashwatthama or was it just one of those "if you weren't my son you will get this curse .."
4. Arjun's curse to Karna is also a bit odd, but what disappoints me more is that this marks the end of KaJu. And this is coming from a staunch KaJu fanatic.
5. One thing I couldn't understand was that Yuddhistir did revolt a bit, which was awesome to see. But one thing I'm hoping SP will include is why, after all these events that show the gang's loyalty to Draupadi, they remained silent. Yuddhi was still a slave when he broke the dice and thereby disrespecting his master. Yuddhi was still a slave when he spoke to Duryodhan in a high voice... Even the other Pandavas found their voice...
6. A phoorvabhas is a prediction of the future. So can it be prevented?
7. I also am curious to see SP explain the silence of Bhishma and Drona. Surprisingly, Vidura isn't speaking against the dice game much. The last time I think I heard anything from him was when he delivered the invitation.

Oh and some good news folks. I think I've cracked why Draupadi can be staked. See when Yuddhi lost himself, Dury became the self proclaimed emperor .. the samrat. Naturally, his wife will be the samragini. This makes it equivalent in a sense -- samragini Bhanumati vs. samragini Draupadi. Of course it's still unclear why Draupadi remains a Samragini, but she was called a Samragini after Yuddhi lost himself so ...
All in all ... it wasn't a bad episode in a SP sense. Props to the actors
Edited by shyam09 - 11 years ago
DrModel thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
@ Shyamu kaka😛😉 --- the precap is the worst...
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: TheWatcher



Karna always knew that while Krishna is with arjuna the latter will be invincible, but he had to pay the debt of getting respected by only one person throughout his life, though he was not entirely loyal to Dury and betrayed him at the end.


well at the end krishna ji comes and offers karna everything not protection but everything kingdom,family,brother;s and even Draupadi..If Karna was really that evil krishna ji wouldn't have offered him all the above all the riches of life and its happiness

Karna is no way a hero but he isnt a villian as well and that is why even after everything krishna ji offers him to lead pandavas.Now why karna refuses him is purely out of his loyalty to Dury now some may think that rejecting krishna ji's offer for Dury is wrong that is their POV but i personally admire him for the same very fact that he refused all the happiness that he could get out of life for death for loyalty .That requires a lot of courage

Personally i would never support karna when he is wrong like in Draupadi's and Abhimnayu's case but where he is right,great,courageous or tragic whatever you want to call it i will fully support him
Ashwini_D thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
By Starbharat's logic and portrayal of Draupadi so far, she does not have to be dragged to be presented in court. She should jump at the opportunity to come to court, give the Kauravas a piece of her mind and rebuke Yudi for daring to stake her.
The main reason why Draupadi had to be dragged by Dushasana in the original was because she refused to be presented in court in clothes not fit to be worn in public and in front of elders and also because she was menstruating.
Edited by ashwi_d - 11 years ago
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shani88

EDT is turning into a Karna discussion thread - perfect.


ya see how popular he is😆
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: ashwi_d

By Starbharat's logic and portrayal of Draupadi so far, she does not have to be dragged to be presented in court. She should jump at the opportunity to come to court, give the Kauravas a piece of her mind and rebuke Yudi for daring to stake her.

The main reason why Draupadi had to be dragged by Dushasana in the original was because she refused to be presented in court in clothes not fit to be worn in public and in front of elders and also because she was menstruating.


well may be she will refuse to come to the court as a dasi on dury's demand
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
Best things about today's episode were

1)Karna acted some what like epic's karna today rather than StarKarna i love whenever i get to to see epic version of any characters

2)Very high on drama whether it be Yudi breaking the dice for panchali or Bheema and Arjuna threatening people with so much happening didnt get bored at all

what i did not like is showing krishna ji in the middle of a battle explaining what will happen to each and every one.THis serial loves to show its character's predicting the future so sometimes they should just let it be,They have made StarAshwathama completely villain,I guess since there are no upapandavas this will be reason why Ashwathma will led an immortal life

And shakuni cried OMG thanks SP for showing even villains have emotions
Ashwini_D thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
There is one thing I admire about Starbharat. However convulated thier portrayal of the dice game is, they tried to make sense of everything quite elaborately. They did strive to show the deplorable incident from everybody's point of view. Their depiction of the dice game disaster put forth the idea of fallibility of dharma as we know it quite clearly. They might not have shown Yudi as a gambling addict, but they did show his weakness where he faces a conflict between his personal dharma and dharma towards his family and chooses the former. I will give them credit for this interpretaton, however true or false it may be with respect to the epic. And yeah kudos to Rohit.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".