Lord Krishna married none except Rukmini!? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

46

Views

15.3k

Users

14

Likes

89

Frequent Posters

AmruthS thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#11
Thanks for sharing, Is very informative.
_gReenheaRt_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12

Two incidents one from Bhagavad Gita emphasizes that Krishna wants men to follow his actions.He acts to set examples and standards to humans and in Mahabharat he proves that he is truthful and his actions are of truth.

BG-Chapter 3

Krishna said without attachment, do thou always perform action as a matter of duty; for, by working without attachment, one reaches the Supreme.

Therefore, go on efficiently doing your duty without attachment. Doing work without attachment man attains the Supreme.

It is through action ( without attachment ) alone that Janak' and other wise men reached perfection. Having an eye to maintenance of world order too you should take to action.

For whatever a great man does, that very thing other men also do; whatever standards he sets up, the generality of men follow the same.

Arjuna, there is nothing in all the three worlds for Me to do, nor is there anything worth attaining unattained by Me, yet I continue to work.

Should I not engage in action, scrupulously at any time, great harm will come to the world; for, Arjuna, men follow My way in all matters.

If I cease to act, these worlds will perish; nay, I should prove to be the cause of confusion, and of the destruction of these people.

Mahabharat

Shri Krishna to Uttara - Then he of pure soul, said these words in the hearing of the whole universe,--'O Uttara, I never utter an untruth. My words will prove true. I shall revive this child in the presence of all creatures. Never before have I uttered an untruth even in jest. Never have I turned back from battle. (By the merit of those acts) let this child revive! As righteousness is dear to me, as Brahmanas are specially dear to me, (by the merit of that disposition of mine) let Abhimanyu's son, who is born dead, revive! Never hath a misunderstanding arisen between me and my friend Vijaya. Let this dead child revive by that truth! As truth and righteousness are always established in me, let this dead child of Abhimanyu revive (by the merit of these)! As Kansa and Kesi have been righteously slain by me, let this child revive today by that truth!' After these words were uttered by Vasudeva, that child, O foremost one of Bharata's race, became animate and began gradually to move, O monarch.'

chirpy_life19 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: .Vrish.



Krishna had 10 sons from each of his 8 major wives, and I think a son each from the other 16,100.


Vrish Bhai,all the 16100 women had 10 sons and 1 daughter each according to SBP.

It is said that Krishna's family--Krishna and his wives, along with their sons and grandsons and even great-grandsons--all combined together to include very nearly one billion family members.
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#14
^^^ I looked for such a reference in SB, but couldn't find it. Do you have an SB link that confirms it? From what I could get, Krishna's only daughter (from Rukmini) was Charumati, and only his 8 wives gave him 10 sons each - no mention of daughters.
chirpy_life19 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: .Vrish.

^^^ I looked for such a reference in SB, but couldn't find it. Do you have an SB link that confirms it? From what I could get, Krishna's only daughter (from Rukmini) was Charumati, and only his 8 wives gave him 10 sons each - no mention of daughters.


You opened my eyes!SBP has nothing like 10 sons and 1 daughter.All the 16,100 women had only 10 sons each,no mention of daughters.Charumati was the name of Krishna and Rukmini's only daughter.

According to the head of a spiritual organization, Lord Krishna had a daughter by each of His wives numbering a total of 16100.Don't know on what basis this was predicted.He explains that each of the Lord's queens had one daughter, and that this mention of Charumati's marriage is an indirect reference to the marriages of all these princesses.😕

Ok my question.I'll be glad if it is answered.From where did One Lakh Sixty One Thousand Warrior Class Brides come?Who raised those 1,61,000 girls for Krishna's sons!?Were their names mentioned in any Purana?They too(Krishna's sons) must have prospered with 3 -4 wives or atleast 2 wives.

Was there any shortage of Brides!?

Edited by Cool-n-Fresh - 11 years ago
Arijit007 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#16
monogamous or polygamous it does not matter to the davotees of krishna like me, only his geeta gyan, and our bhakti towards him.matters to us,
chirpy_life19 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: SRUJAconscience


Two incidents one from Bhagavad Gita emphasizes that Krishna wants men to follow his actions.He acts to set examples and standards to humans and in Mahabharat he proves that he is truthful and his actions are of truth.

BG-Chapter 3

Krishna said without attachment, do thou always perform action as a matter of duty; for, by working without attachment, one reaches the Supreme.

Therefore, go on efficiently doing your duty without attachment. Doing work without attachment man attains the Supreme.

It is through action ( without attachment ) alone that Janak' and other wise men reached perfection. Having an eye to maintenance of world order too you should take to action.

For whatever a great man does, that very thing other men also do; whatever standards he sets up, the generality of men follow the same.

Arjuna, there is nothing in all the three worlds for Me to do, nor is there anything worth attaining unattained by Me, yet I continue to work.

Should I not engage in action, scrupulously at any time, great harm will come to the world; for, Arjuna, men follow My way in all matters.

If I cease to act, these worlds will perish; nay, I should prove to be the cause of confusion, and of the destruction of these people.

Mahabharat

Shri Krishna to Uttara - Then he of pure soul, said these words in the hearing of the whole universe,--'O Uttara, I never utter an untruth. My words will prove true. I shall revive this child in the presence of all creatures. Never before have I uttered an untruth even in jest. Never have I turned back from battle. (By the merit of those acts) let this child revive! As righteousness is dear to me, as Brahmanas are specially dear to me, (by the merit of that disposition of mine) let Abhimanyu's son, who is born dead, revive! Never hath a misunderstanding arisen between me and my friend Vijaya. Let this dead child revive by that truth! As truth and righteousness are always established in me, let this dead child of Abhimanyu revive (by the merit of these)! As Kansa and Kesi have been righteously slain by me, let this child revive today by that truth!' After these words were uttered by Vasudeva, that child, O foremost one of Bharata's race, became animate and began gradually to move, O monarch.'


Thanks for Sharing these.I read the Mahabharat incident.But the BG Verses you posted are valuable and are to be noted!

Edited by Cool-n-Fresh - 11 years ago
chirpy_life19 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#18

Ok.Something just struck my mind.

By studying the Life Events of Polygamous Kings popularly known in our history/Mythology,a question immediately springs up...'Are Polygamous relations healthy and harmonious?'

1) King Uttanapada could not give love to both of his sons.He was always under the influence of his second wife.Whatever she said he accepted;he never considered whether it was right or wrong.Even when he clearly saw that she was wrong, he was not bold enough to say so.
Finally he lost one of his sons(Uttama).He suffered a lot in his life.

2) Dasaratha had three wives: Kausalya, Sumitra, and Kaikeyi. Because of the youngest wife, Kaikeyi, Dasaratha had to suffer pain due to pangs of separation from Rama. Rama had to be sent into the exile because of boons granted to Kaikeyi.Ultimately, the separation led to the death of Dasaratha. So, the king of three wives had to suffer separation from his son, and ultimately had to even face death."

3) King Sagar's 60,000 sons, (born of Queen Sumati), and his son Asamanja (born of Queen Keshini) were then sent to find the horse. When the 60,000 sons found the horse at Kapiladeva's ashram, they thought he had stolen it. When they prepared to attack the meditating rishi (sage), Kapila opened his eyes. Because the sons of King Sagara had disrespected such a great personality, consequently, fire emanated from their own bodies, and they were immediately burned to ashes.Asmanja was a wild wicked young man who troubled women and had to be banished from the kingdom.

4) King Vasudev,was locked in the Prison immediately after his ceremony with Devaki and had to suffer a lot.His 6 sons were killed before him and he couldn't do anything.He was deprived from Father's love as his 7th and 8th sons were brought up in a different place.I think he spent almost 30 years in prison after his alliance with Devaki.

5) King Pandu - Know idea how his life would have been if Kunti was his only wife.His lust for Madri led to his death.A great suffering to his family.

6) King Shantanu lost his race(his line) only due to lack of self - restraint.The mistake he committed eventually led to great loss,wars and destruction.

7) Though Draupadi had 5 men she had none to support her during tough times.She was dishonoured in the Dice Hall.She faced many insults and had to spend many years in forest leaving her children and worked as a maid during the last year of exile to be spent incognito.Later she lost all her children in the great war.

Even Lord Krishna's entire clan perished due to Jambavati's son Samba,if we consider all the scriptures and tales available.But the topic of discussion is about Lord Krishna being Monogamous in householder life!?,hence couldn't include him in this analysis.

Recently I was going through the life history of Great Indian Warrior Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj.The question of Shivaji's heir-apparent was complicated by the misbehaviour of his eldest son Sambhaji, who was irresponsible and "addicted to sensual pleasures." Unable to curb this, Shivaji confined his son to Panhala in 1678, only to have the prince escape with his wife and defect to the Mughals for a year. Sambhaji then returned home, unrepentant, and was again confined to Panhala.To my surprise there were various rumors regarding Shivaji's death.Shivaji's second wife, Soyarabai, had poisoned him so that his crown might pass to her 10-year old son Rajaram.After Shivaji's death, the widowed Soyarabai made plans with various ministers of the administration to crown her son Rajaram rather than her prodigal stepson Sambhaji.However, Sambhaji took possession of the Fort acquired control of Raigad, and formally ascended the throne.Rajaram, his wife Janki Bai, and mother Soyrabai were imprisoned, and Soyrabai executed on charges of conspiracy.

_gReenheaRt_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Arijit007

monogamous or polygamous it does not matter to the davotees of krishna like me, only his geeta gyan, and our bhakti towards him.matters to us,


I appreciate your spirit of devotion.👏👏

This clearly indicates that you believe Krishna is 'God'!Usually such doubts and discussions arise when one starts exploring God.God = Sinless.😊

_gReenheaRt_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Cool-n-Fresh


You opened my eyes!SBP has nothing like 10 sons and 1 daughter.All the 16,100 women had only 10 sons each,no mention of daughters.Charumati was the name of Krishna and Rukmini's only daughter.

According to the head of a spiritual organization, Lord Krishna had a daughter by each of His wives numbering a total of 16100.Don't know on what basis this was predicted.He explains that each of the Lord's queens had one daughter, and that this mention of Charumati's marriage is an indirect reference to the marriages of all these princesses.😕

Ok my question.I'll be glad if it is answered.From where did One Lakh Sixty One Thousand Warrior Class Brides come?Who raised those 1,61,000 girls for Krishna's sons!?Were their names mentioned in any Purana?They too(Krishna's sons) must have prospered with 3 -4 wives or atleast 2 wives.

Was there any shortage of Brides!?


@ Bold - If this was the case many such indirect references can be made.
May be such guess works were constructed and later added to the original set of events which in due course multiplied the number of chapters in Mahabharat,Bhagavat Puran or any other Puran.
There is possibilty!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".