Just a thought about a scene - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

3.7k

Users

10

Likes

160

Frequent Posters

Rainy_Days thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: kajal99

Hi
After a long time I'm replying a post

My view about the show is totally different.
1.Rk didn't act to her, since from the beginning. All he showed was his true feelings
I'm weak in explains thing. So could not explain it properly.
He loved her truly. Only thing is he didnt accept it earlier and realized it later
And second point, though he did incomplete wedding, he accepted her as his wife in his heart. Ex... His convo to deepali , "Woh biwi hai meri. Wohmadhubala rishab kundra hai. Ye me kabi nahi boolunga"... He didn't forget though he did unwedding.
In my point of view the reason for unwedding, rk tried to break madhu. He could not succeed in that but fell in love with her. At one point , in the process of breaking her he did that unwedding though he loves her madly
He just wanted to show her and the world that he won her

2. Rk didn't have anybody in his life. He knows madhu loves him and he also. Madhu is the only one Perron that he can trust , love, close to heart, And she also loves the man inside him the rishab, not the rk. That is why he is very possessive ,obsessed about her
But for madhu she had everybody, mother, Malik, Roma and didhi. She was happy in her life
Rk was an addition happiness to her. But for rk she is only happiness, love, soul.

So in one line, I never felt that rk is acting

3. Though madhu said i moved on , deep in her heart she loved him and that time she refused to accept it till rk confess in the studio by promising on his
father


One example to Prove my point... After rk being shot he hold madhu's hand when he is not in his sense. That time nothing big ( love, rks revenge plan)happened between them
That Scene itself tells how madly he was depending her, started trusting her, I would say started seeing true love in her


wow wt a point 👏😊
kajal99 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: silverfire

This quality of hers has landed her in trouble all the time but still she will not change. This is what made RK fall for her in the first place.[/DIV]


Truly accept this
Rk accepted and loved madhu the way she was and madhu also
They didn't expect either of them to change
They were on their own character till the end... But without any compliant to each other and loving madly
That why we are mad about them
ananya2010 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#13
With all the flaws they had they are perfect for each other.
silverfire thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: ananya2010

With all the flaws they had they are perfect for each other.


Two perfectly imperfect ppl, perfect together. That's our Rishabala.😳
ilovebandini thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: kajal99

Hi
After a long time I'm replying a post

My view about the show is totally different.
1.Rk didn't act to her, since from the beginning. All he showed was his true feelings
I'm weak in explains thing. So could not explain it properly.
He loved her truly. Only thing is he didnt accept it earlier and realized it later
And second point, though he did incomplete wedding, he accepted her as his wife in his heart. Ex... His convo to deepali , "Woh biwi hai meri. Wohmadhubala rishab kundra hai. Ye me kabi nahi boolunga"... He didn't forget though he did unwedding.
In my point of view the reason for unwedding, rk tried to break madhu. He could not succeed in that but fell in love with her. At one point , in the process of breaking her he did that unwedding though he loves her madly
He just wanted to show her and the world that he won her

2. Rk didn't have anybody in his life. He knows madhu loves him and he also. Madhu is the only one Perron that he can trust , love, close to heart, And she also loves the man inside him the rishab, not the rk. That is why he is very possessive ,obsessed about her
But for madhu she had everybody, mother, Malik, Roma and didhi. She was happy in her life
Rk was an addition happiness to her. But for rk she is only happiness, love, soul.

So in one line, I never felt that rk is acting

3. Though madhu said i moved on , deep in her heart she loved him and that time she refused to accept it till rk confess in the studio by promising on his
father


One example to Prove my point... After rk being shot he hold madhu's hand when he is not in his sense. That time nothing big ( love, rks revenge plan)happened between them
That Scene itself tells how madly he was depending on her, started trusting her, I would say started seeing true love in her


Ok,I agree.For me it was hard to accept not that RK loved Madhu and did the betrayal(although I once had problem with that how could one love you and do that to you),but the biggest problem for me was that every scene of Rishbala before the betrayal was a lie or to be precise,that RK said it was a lie(and not that I consider that it was all a lie,the betrayal and everything that happened before and after needed a lot of analysis,like mine,like yours and others too so we could understand what happened😊).The writers presented that as a truth(although we know that RK fall in love with Madhu,whether he liked it or not,or whether he admitted it or not),like,when he told her for ex.that in every scene,even in the Balraj scene he thought of his revenge.I think that RK said some things on the betrayal night only to hurt Madhu and that actually he told her lies,because I honestly don't believe that he was thinking of his revenge when he saved her from suffocating from that rope in the Balraj scene or when he wanted to kill Balraj but Madhu stopped him.I know that he loved her and in the candle night studio,and in this scene too.I won't ever believe that he didn't love her and I believe that he lied to her that he did.The thing about RK is that I think of him like in the story about the scorpion and the fox,that he was like a scorpion-he just had to sting.He wanted the revenge,never expected to fall in love with her but he did,and then the revenge happened.I actually always missed a good reason for RK to trigger the betrayal because if somebody said to him and affected his ego,I would understand why he did what he did.But the betrayal seemed like something out of the blue at least for people like me,who didn't had a clue what will happen next in the story,I never could find a enough good reason for him to do it.If Dips or some reporter brain washed him,I would understand.But anyhow,I agree that he did love her but his ego was too big,he never expected that he would fall in love and had problem realizing it and admitting it.He didn't know himself and his heart very well.And I agree that he didn't have anyone and that losing Madhu was unbearable to him.Concerning the scene in the hospital,I agree.Even in the scene before he wakes up(after the betrayal scene) and calls Madhu,it's clear that he loves her.So the biggest issue here(although I wrote it like that in the 1st page of the post)isn't actually whether RK loved Madhu or not,but whether was every scene with Rishbala romance,a part of RK' revenge or not.I will never agree that it was,I will never agree for ex. that the Balraj scene,the studio night scene,or that this scene and many other were a part of his plan.The writters mentioned some of this scenes in RK's speach on the betrayal but I will never believe them and I will always believe that RK told them to Madhu only to hurt her.
Edited by ilovebandini - 10 years ago
ilovebandini thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: aan-rish


Well said Kajal. I totally agree with u. Rk always loved Madhu but was too adamant to admit it


I agree with this too.
PRATHA1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#17
I my opinion Sullu track was okay upto Rishbala's wedding! Actually there was no need to used sullu bhai saga! For that they butchered not only RK's character, but all characters including madhu! I don't thing RK did acting of careful, protective & lovely husband! He was truely in love with madhu! Here i agree with kajal! If you watched episodes before unwedding tracks, such as 6th nov 2012 episode where he was in hallucinate that madhu was with him! 13th dec. 2012 love confession episode where suddenly he came to know that madhu is nearer to him! 23th jan. 2013 episode were after ph. convo. with madhu, he went to the balcony for watching moon & said "Biwi tum to pagal ho hi, saath mai muze bhi pagal kar dogi"! here he was not acting!
I am thinking this way, Sullu track was on cv's card long ago, b
ut due to us(crazy Rishbala fans) they didn't use it! Then they used unwedding track intentionally to kick off RK's character from MB! But viewers couldn't accept their new hero! Thats why they used bhai saga, then phabo, ria track, then leap & ruined MB totally! I couldn't digest that suddenly smart, intelligent, classy Right Kameena superstar turn into dumbo, puppet & bankrupt!
Edited by PRATHA1 - 10 years ago
ilovebandini thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: silverfire

@Ilovebandini.

While watching the rerun in rishety, I came across one scene where madhu apologies to RK for using the photos to blackmail him to apologies to her mom. After watching that scene I don't think she would have pulled off a revenge act. She tells him she has been taught never to knowingly hurt a person. I would loved it if she did a revenge act but madhu is not made like that. For her, nobody is bad, nobody should suffer n nobody should be in pain. This quality of hers has landed her in trouble all the time but still she will not change. This is what made RK fall for her in the first place.


Actually to tell you the truth when Madhu caught Deepali's hand and didn't want to let her go,and when she told RK that Deepali wants to tell him something(before they went on dinner and when she was in that beautiful black dress in the scenes when she wanted to do the revenge),I was kinda shocked.I wasn't used seing Madhu like that,and also I was kinda shocked that she was making RK a fool and manipulating him.I always liked her front speaches "Taras aata mujhe tum par" and stuff.If the revenge did happen it would show that she really lost her heart and that she became a really bitter person which is actually understandable because I don't know who would have strength to forgive the thing RK did to her,but still ...is kinda sad.RK in a way destroyed them both.But luckily for RK,Madhu was not a regular girl,she had strength to forgive him,her heart was too great and RK realizing it he knew he had a crown jewel with him,I love it whe he describes her,when he says pyari(does pyari means loveble?),a girl with soft heart...I love Madhu,beautiful character!
silverfire thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: PRATHA1

I my opinion Sullu track was okay upto Rishbala's wedding! Actually there was no need to used sullu bhai saga! For that they butchered not only RK's character, but all characters including madhu! I don't thing RK did acting of careful, protective & lovely husband! He was truely in love with madhu! Here i agree with kajal! If you watched episodes before unwedding tracks, such as 6th nov 2012 episode where he was in hallucinate that madhu was with him! 13th dec. 2012 love confession episode where suddenly he came to know that madhu is nearer to him! 23th jan. 2013 episode were after ph. convo. with madhu, he went to the balcony for watching moon & said "Biwi tum to pagal ho hi, saath mai muze bhi pagal kar dogi"! here he was not acting!
I am thinking this way, Sullu track was on cv's card long ago, b
ut due to us(crazy Rishbala fans) they didn't use it! Then they used unwedding track intentionally to kick off RK's character from MB! But viewers couldn't accept their new hero! Thats why they used bhai saga, then phabo, ria track, then leap & ruined MB totally! I couldn't digest that suddenly smart, intelligent, classy Right Kameena superstar turn into dumbo, puppet & bankrupt!


I can even accept sullu character as madhu's bro bcos we know BSC character. But RK's bro. NEVER! They even butchered MK character for that. They had a huge insecurity were RK was concerned. Tried their best to put him down in every t but we fans r simply great. We stood by RK in every t never letting them tarnish his personality in our minds. He was the best n will remain the best for ever.
kajal99 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#20
@ pratha, even I didn't mind bhai till wedding
Though I did nt see bhai and mrs rk scenes 😉
Love story without villain won't be good na

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".