when child pays for parent did.... - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

62

Views

5.4k

Users

20

Likes

222

Frequent Posters

Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: sadumaneet

@charu but today AK wants punish Jr. Madhu its because she is Rishabala's daughter ... i will never justify AK's reason of revenge because its absurd and it doesn't make sense it just another way of creating drama... at the time of AK's movie drama RK was driven by ego i which make way for Pam and lamba to plan against HK which ultimately lead to Rishabala's death so in that sense doesn't RK is responsible for current situation of Jr. Madhu ... so all said and done so just lets agree to disagree on this...


yes dear we can agree to disagree, i didn't deny that RK was wrong to not protect his family but Jr Madhu's condition is not only bec. of RK's ego , its also bec. of her own decisions, destiny, low intelligence of Abhay Kapoor and Radha's decisions taken for her...Radha didnt want to fight, she gave up and they led a life of poverty...she may have her reasons but everyone have their reasons for doing what they did..including RK..if Madhu decided to not fight with RK for the accident, her destiny wud be different..hence blaming RK alone is wrong..quietly suffer and not raise your voice against injustice, for few ppl. this way of living is acceptable, for others its not..tht does not mean one of them is right or wrong..

what RK did with HK was morally & ethically wrong but they were not innocent either..the man getting provoked and the provacating party, both r at fault...if RK did a mistake, he paid for it heavily...after that point, he was not responsible for misery caused in anybody's life..😊
Edited by _charu_ - 11 years ago
sadumaneet thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: Poluk

Every child is born with a particular destiny and that is accentuated or modified according to his own karma. Now how would it look like if someone would say that JM was so unlucky that caused her parent's death within a few months of being born?

Unfair, gross and wrong but yes it can be said. The way it is absolutely wrong to blame the innocent child, it is wrong to blame the parents who were themselves victims of avarice and greed.

In professional field everyone tries to bring down his competitor. It is not so wrong so as to justify murder. Before someone says that it was Pam's doing, yes I know that HK was innocent in it.

And I will also agree that AK was the spectator of his father's cruel death and has shouldered that burden for his entire life making him today a highly frustrated human being who has even lost the sense of right and wrong.

But therein lies the summary of this which is that Life is never ever fair. Why expect it to be? All are victims of someone or other's greed and have been dealt a bad hand by fate. All are victims here be it JM, AK, RK, MB or AK. But that is how a story is made. If everything was fair, good and nice there would not be a tragedy or the beginning of a story.


let me first tell u that its beautiful write up... i really like the way u explain everything... obviously its wrong to blame anyone but somehow the thought that situation would have far more different if RK would have behave little sensibly in that sense i hold RK responsible.. anyway as u said no one can change one's destiny... anyway thanks for beautiful comment dear
sadumaneet thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: ANNMT.

obviously blind obsessive fan will never accept msk was a abuser n u seems like one ,though i use asr name to but somebody saw only 1 name , wat i wrote det was truth it was show in show , but ya people love to justify abuse n harassment by making excuse if their fav charecter does it , nothing new

@ bold mind ur language ur accusing me firstly u don't knw me secondly to comment on ASR i never follow that show lastly MSK was never accuser at least for me if u have different pov then its not my concern and ur post is again not related to my post so if u have anything said abt RK or Madhubala then go ahead iam going to report u for personal attack which i never done to u lastly get a life
..PlayfulKiss.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#54
So, are you saying, when that evil Nikhil and and Harsh were playing their dirty tricks or were insulting RK, he should have kept his mouth shut, and not say anything? He should have acted like the other goody goody male leads of the TV, by keeping mum? Sorry, then I don't agree with you. Whatever RK did was the right thing. If someone else was in his shoes, then I am sure, that person would have done the same thing!
And how is AK right? His father was the one who threatened RK of burning him alive, and not the other way around. And most importantly, RK DIDN'T kill his father. Then what the heck is he revenging JM for? 😕
poorvab thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#55
this logic doesnt make sense, what mistake have Jr.madhu's parents made?
and so by the logic that innocent children suffering because of their parents, it goes for RK too, he had his attitude and anger etc in life because of his parents and his mom's second marriage etc. his parents can be blamed for all his behavior then!
and in this situation, ideally Jr.madhu should be the one taking revenge from AKs family, because she lost her family and future first and as a consequence AK lost his father! here madhu should be taking revenge and AK should be suffering because of his family's "mistakes/crimes"

edited typos
Edited by poorvab - 11 years ago
Poluk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: sadumaneet

let me first tell u that its beautiful write up... i really like the way u explain everything... obviously its wrong to blame anyone but somehow the thought that situation would have far more different if RK would have behave little sensibly in that sense i hold RK responsible.. anyway as u said no one can change one's destiny... anyway thanks for beautiful comment dear


Here I have to disagree. RK had no idea that HK had a wife who would kill him to get rid of her husband. The way HK himself had no idea. Both paid for Pam's greed.

Human beings are neither omnipotent nor omnipresent. They have absolutely no way of knowing how others are going to take advantage of their actions.

What RK did was also not classifiable as sin or mistake. HK and his family provoked him and he retaliated. What he did is something most people do in one way or the other in professional field. No one is kind hearted enough to let their competitors succeed or surpass them. No one is a saint that way.

Only RK had no way of knowing that there was a mad killer lurking in the background.
Edited by Poluk - 11 years ago
sadumaneet thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: SNoshin

So, are you saying, when that evil Nikhil and and Harsh were playing their dirty tricks or were insulting RK, he should have kept his mouth shut, and not say anything? He should have acted like the other goody goody male leads of the TV, by keeping mum? Sorry, then I don't agree with you. Whatever RK did was the right thing. If someone else was in his shoes, then I am sure, that person would have done the same thing!

And how is AK right? His father was the one who threatened RK of burning him alive, and not the other way around. And most importantly, RK DIDN'T kill his father. Then what the heck is he revenging JM for? 😕

AK 's revenge thing completely absurd doesn't make sense but if today Jr. madhu gone suffer is only because she is Rishabala's daughter whom she never seen ... HK was very much provoked by RK it was his ego which he want to satisfy by making HK's loss i never said AK is right but one thing sure is Jr. Madu gone suffer where as she is not at all at fault ... i will kindly agree to disagree in my pov RK could have handled situation way more differently which could have save so many life including his...
sadumaneet thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: poorvab

this logic doesnt make sense, what mistake have Jr.madhu's parents made?

and so by the logic that innocent children suffering because of their parents, it goes for RK too, he had his attitude and anger etc in life because of his parents and his mom's second marriage etc. his parents can be blamed for all his behavior then!
and in this situation, ideally Jr.madhu should be the one taking revenge from AKs family, because she lost her family and future first and as a consequence AK lost his father! here madhu should be taking revenge and AK should be suffering because of his family's "mistakes/crimes"

edited typos

yes i totally blame Mohan Kundra for RK's disturbed and traumatised childhood of RK i even held Radhaji responsible she might have married for his son but she choose wrong person and moreover she never try to console RK or at least tried to understand his trauma so his attitude is always been very much right as he had suffered a lot and they explained it very well
ya there is always option of Madhu taking revenge which i like to watch but i don't want her to take revenge because its wrong and it will always wrong ... i will stick to my point
sadumaneet thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: Poluk

but its completely another scenario that there was killer lurking but RK 's ego had always got him in trouble same happen during Amar Behl time he will go on making people loss their money and they will not react thats not gone happen and thats the point no one saint but JR. Madhu is saint she gone suffer just because of tag being Rishabala's daughter ... lets just agree to disagree on this😊

Poluk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: sadumaneet


During Amar Behl's time more than RK's ego it was his wife's stupidity at play. If she had not been so pally with a gangster then things would not have come to this juncture. RK slapped AB in defence of his wife's character.

That is what I am trying to say here. At any point of time there are lot of things into play and what happens is the mixed outcome of them all. That is why blaming RK is wrong. But as you said let us just agree to disagree and close this discussion.😊


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".