Episode 407 Discussion: 19th Oct 2013 - Page 4

Originally posted by: arshisfan

By the way Simmy seems to be nice unlike her dayan mom!!!

Originally posted by: river123

Nice in the way Sikky is. 😆 She was initially appalled by her mummy's plan, but then happily went along with it. Gave RK his coffee, so that Mummy could give Madhu hers. And she, along with Mummy was watching anxiously, hoping Madhu would sip the drink.

I don't know but its seemed to me that she was unware of the fact that her mom has put drugs in Madhu's coffee, I thought she was just trying to be nice to Rk and gave him the coffee, what made even more sure that she doesn't know what her mom did, is when she asked the latter "What" when Rk-Madhu left for shot and her mom growled seeing her plan backfire, she might have been asked by her mom to take coffee to Rk, but don't think she knew about the drug

Najat,

There is no norm in India that romantic movies have to have sensual scenes for it to be considered a romantic movie case in point jab we met and ddlj , kal ho Na ho , they become huge hits.

Ajay devgan and kajol are wife and husband , their first home production is a romantic movie and has mental health issue as the back ground , I don't remember that there was any sensual scene in that.

Rk being a husband needs to be responsible and should have a say in how his wife is potrayed as these scenes will result in his wife being ogled at and I do not want to write more ..

There is a reason why you see more sons of industry people than daughters and when daughters enter they make sure they are portrayed properly.

I also seen a Telugu heroine soundarya who was a hit heroine but through out her entire career never wore modern dresses was always fully clad in sarees and chudidaars , inspite of that she was a huge it .


Mehul a heroine turned from simple girl to super confident woman after the movie started and going by mehuls dialogues he wanted a confident and sensuous anamika which means he wanted a very hot scene.


We all understood madhus reservations but rk not having any reservations about it is totally out of character

By the way I too liked simmy she was appreciating mAdhu and did not show any malice

Originally posted by: armummy

Najat,

There is no norm in India that romantic movies have to have sensual scenes for it to be considered a romantic movie case in point jab we met and ddlj , kabhi alvida Na kehnA , they become huge hits.

I'm replying to the whole post but I didn't want to quote it all, already have posted a lot today, didn't want to fill the whole page😆

Yes I agree with you on the fact that a romantic scene is not necessarily a sensual one and a hit movie should not necessarily include sensual scenes, but they haven't shown more than Sharukhan-kajol in Kuch kuck hota hai in the rain sequence, and I didn't find the scene of Karan-anamika as a really hot-red scene, maybe the dori opening is what made people revolte and by the way I also hate films where they show a lot of kissing and love scenes and I prefer a way more films like jab we met. you are right maybe, MC was asking them to get closer, so don't know what would happen later, but I don't think there would have been more than that dori opening because Rk wouldn't like Madhu to show a naked back or any vulgar things!

here is the scene from kuck kuch hota hai ( a lovely one by the way)

YouTube [YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h64V31hD20M[/YOUTUBE]
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h64V31hD20M

As for Rk, I prefer to wait till I see monday's episode to make a proper conclusion on his stand

PS : kabhi alvia na kehna had a love scene

Hey Najat n Meenu..

Originally posted by: arshisfan

I don't know but its seemed to me that she was unware of the fact that her mom has put drugs in Madhu's coffee, I thought she was just trying to be nice to Rk and gave him the coffee, what made even more sure that she doesn't know what her mom did, is when she asked the latter "What" when Rk-Madhu left for shot and her mom growled seeing her plan backfire, she might have been asked by her mom to take coffee to Rk, but don't think she knew about the drug

Najat,

Originally posted by: cardio21

Najat.. She knew about the coffee being spiked.. She tried to stop her initially and later abided by her mom..

I guess you are right, I've watched the scene again and I noted Simmy's disappointment too when Madhu didn't drink the coffee😊

Originally posted by: armummy

Najat,

Sharukj was neither kajols husband nor Kajol was married at tHat point.

Rk and Madhu situation is unique...it needs different handling

Rk went along with scene , he did not have nay reservations. So I only see him trying to explain to her and removing her reservations.

Kabhi Alvida was a typo ,I meant kal ho na no ..any by Karan Johan's standards kabhi Alvida did not do as well as his other movies..

Agree with you, also the fact that Rk is the producer of the film gives him some authority to decide how things will be, generally actors have clauses in their contracts and there everything is specified

I will wait to see Rk's stand and I'll also wait to see the whole scene if they ever show it again to see its extent , because I still don't think it would have gone beyond the dori opening 😊