A little TOO HARSH with Madhu? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

77

Views

5.9k

Users

49

Likes

322

Frequent Posters

StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#31
Very well written chakku,each and every point cant agree with you more,indeed we are harsh on her,we are exhausted too,glycerine is consuming out of limit glycerine these days which is unbearable that's all,I want her to fight this out and be strong but after reading this post I feel that she's in a terrible state these days,madhu's my favorite character and these days I was so disappointed in her but yesterday her cursing sultaan was a proof that she's not weak and like she said if she cant be with RK she will never be sultaan's either and like you said:

  • Maybe she has this tiny bit of hope that after she separates from RK, she somehow exposes Sultan and then get back with RK? If she becomes RK's widow, then everything is FINISHED forever. Atleast after giving in to Sultan's whims she has a second chance!

that's a very valid point and quite logical but I rather wish that RK think over again about sultaan being dead and all madhu's efforts to expose him but no one believed her and that madhu might be correct.

Once again brilliant post and superb analysis.

Mallu
akankshasehgal thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#32
i love u chakku...i was so depressed seeing everyone bashing madhu for no reason ...she is doing it for rk , ready to risk her life to save rk, wat would you do if your husbands life is at risk.
and did nobody noticed the way she was abusing sultan when she unwrapped the frame i mean she gave him shrap.


khair thank you so much atleast their are some who are understanding madhu's condition.
-Raichu- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#33
I'm not disgusted with Madhu because I know she's pretending to be in love with Sultan but I'm very much irritated with her !!

I can't recognize the former Madhu who did everything to send a SUPERSTAR to jail ! She fought till the end but where is she now ??

And as others said, where's the guarantee that Sultan won't continue to blackmail her ??

I'm also kinda disappointed with Madhu, I always said that Madhu is a typical heroine, and with this track I thought that she would prove that she's DIFFERENT from others heroine, sadly it's not the case !


Anyways, I'm happy because Right Kameena is back 😎
So in a way I should thank Sultan and Madhu 😉

Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: dramacrazy12

Sultan is holding RK hostage but what makes Madhu think that he will not use the same tack again and again. Interestingly the moment Madhu threatened to harm herself ...he backed off...so Madhu too can manipulate him but she does not even try.


exactly ! she can manipulate him by threatening to kill herself..then why did she agree to divorce..isn't it better to kill herself as "honorable suhaagan" (😃) and not let RK go through this torture of heartbreak & betrayal ? not letting that lech touch her ? (in melodramatic language of MB 😃)

also, the life which Madhu is gifting RK in a silver platter, is it worth it? Will he stay happy with Madhu's betrayal? with her sacrifice ? without Madhu ? with a guilt that he was responsible for whatever happened to her post divorce?
Edited by _charu_ - 12 years ago
xodramalover thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#35
Thanks for posting. You make many valid points. However, I thought RK didn't believe her when Madhubala told him that Sultan is alive...
Poluk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: _charu_


I think Shruti, it depends on the situation..If someone kidnaps my child, I may try to contact the police & do every possible thing to make sure he's safe but agree to pay ransom if my child is safe..I pay the ransom & get my child back, end of the story...If a don demands extortion money from someone & threatens to kill him , that guy pays the extortion money & the story is finished..it's not wrong to care for your safety or the safety of your loved ones...aise toh a car may hit me if I step out on the road so does that mean i keep sitting in the house?

kisi andhe ko bhi dikhega ke Madhu is doing this on gun point..aur humari toh do aankhen hain (i loved this dialogue from Dips 😆) but this is one situation where her own future , her life, security, honor & respect is at stake...this is not like the examples which i quoted where agreeing to the blackmailer's condition may yield a good result in the end and they will be bailed out ...the blackmailing is not gonna stop at any point bec. he can anytime threaten to kill RK & get his job done...whatever he wants..so getting into that situation is far worse than the death threat which RK is facing now...so why not try to face this rather than ruin everything completely & then think ? apni life ka gur gobar karke bhi sab theek NAHI hoga... that's all i wanted to say...


No Charu at times one cannot think about one's own safety. Remember Shazzie yesterday said that if a dog is trying to bite your child you would protect your child or bite the dog. That time I could not reply properly because I was very busy.

Suppose a mad rabid dog comes and the only option left is whether he would bite my child or me I would offer myself. I would become a shield for my child whatever might be the consequence for me. When killing the dog is not possible for me.

This is what love does to you. It is not a weakness, it is a strength.

MB tried facing Sultan but got no support because CVs have made RKs common sense disappear. and MB is to scared to think that she can now get some other help. Because Sultan has proved to her (as per her understanding) that he can kill RK anytime he wants.

And as regards, Sultan renegeing on his promise? For that I think she proposes to keep her life as a security. The way she told Sultan I will commit suicide if you hurt RK. Her priority is save RK somehow. Whatever it takes.


Poluk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: _charu_


exactly ! she can manipulate him by threatening to kill herself..then why did she agree to divorce..isn't it better to kill herself as "honorable suhaagan" (😃) and not let RK go through this torture of heartbreak & betrayal ? not letting that lech touch her ? (in melodramatic language of MB 😃)

also, the life which Madhu is gifting RK in a silver platter, is it worth it? Will he stay happy with Madhu's betrayal? with her sacrifice ? without Madhu ? with a guilt that he was responsible for whatever happened to her post divorce?


Charu, RK's happiness post divorce or guilt is irrelevant to her now. She has only stopped on the point of saving his life. Tell me if the legs of a person's body gets gangerine would his family think twice before getting them amputated. He would never stay happy after that. All his dreams, aspirations everything would be shattered. He might even become depressive.

But the only concern at that point of time is to save his life whatever might be the cost. In MB's eyes she has become that limb which needs to be amputated from RK to save his life.
leelaa9 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: _Mojo.Jojo_

I guess I am in the minority but I think everyone's a little TOO HARSH with Madhu here and giving extreme reactions to what she is doing.


  • Is she doing anything for her own selfish reasons? Then why are her actions disgust evoking for everyone? Just because she says that she loves Sultan, doesn't mean that she actually loves him and means it. So, I am OK with it.

  • It's not like she didn't ever try to tell anyone the truth about Sultan being alive. She did try. But did anyone believe her? Only RK did. But when she was unable to get Sultan caught, she was accused of ruining the case and her sanity was questioned. So Madhu thought of not ruining the case further, otherwise along with her people would have called RK also insane.

  • Why should she face the brunt of befriending Sultan? She did not befriend him thinking that he would turn out to be a cheap lowlife later and obsess over her. She befriended him out of sympathy and she thought that he was a good human being. I don't think girls should stop befriending guys thinking about how they'd turn out to be in future. Blaming Madhu for all this is so much similar to cheapo Politicians blaming rape victims for getting raped than the rapists.

  • It is clearly visible that Madhu is more hurt while hurting RK than he is while getting hurt. I am very much sympathetic towards Madhu's current state. The girl is in a fix. She can neither tell the truth to anyone, nor is RK allowing her to leave.

  • Madhu is sherni and jungli billi with RK and not Sultan because RK doesn't manhandle or abuse her like Sultan does. She tried being one with him, but he is bullheaded. So, I find it better that Madhu ignores him.

  • Lastly, everyone's saying that it is better to tell the truth to RK and get him killed by Sultan than hurting him like this. It is easy for us to say this, but can Madhu ever see RK dead? Maybe she has this tiny bit of hope that after she separates from RK, she somehow exposes Sultan and then get back with RK? If she becomes RK's widow, then everything is FINISHED forever. Atleast after giving in to Sultan's whims she has a second chance!

P.S. How is everyone so sure that RK would be able to track Sultan if he believes Madhu? What if Sultan kills RK before he is able to track him? Then who would be blamed for RK's death? Madhu for spilling the beans?😆😆

It is Sultan who is to be blamed for all this mess and not RishBala or Madhu.



A little TOO HARSH with Madhu?

Excellent post, Chakku.👏
They have sacrificed Madhu's fierce courage and RK's shrewdness to keep the villain winning a little longer, so they can extend this excruciating track by a few more episodes.🤢🥱
Padmini was shown killing Ballu so damn fast.😡😭
Here Madhu is being shown giving in to the villain's threats instead of being determined to kill him by whatever means.😕
😡☢️
They have redefined 'interesting'.🥱

Edited by leelaa9 - 12 years ago
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: Poluk

[


Suppose a mad rabid dog comes and the only option left is whether he would bite my child or me I would offer myself. I would become a shield for my child whatever might be the consequence for me. When killing the dog is not possible for me.

This is what love does to you. It is not a weakness, it is a strength.


that's a different issue Shruti..I agreed with Shazzie's reply that in this scenario, I'll protect my child but I won't hide the dog and bite my son to protect him from rabies..this is what Madhu is trying to do..yest. this point came up when we were discussing whether Madhu's method is okay or not..she is ruining RK's life with her own hands and then giving this excuse of saving his life from a gangster...by telling him that she never loved him, that she loved Sultan, that she wants divorce, she hates him, she betrayed him, so on and so forth will add to RK's misery..his life will be finished aise hi , Madhu wants him to live, he will live but how? she's destroying him emotionally & mentally..

she was forced to do this so that RK divorces her..in that case, when she was aware that she had to ask for a divorce, she shouldn't have coochie poochied him a night before 😆
Poluk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: _charu_


That is the best part. RK seems to have developed amnesia over it.

And RKs emotional destruction- MB is not even realizing it. She was never a person who could do cause and effect analysis. Forget future she can not even think about the next immediate impact of her actions.

That is why I never liked her character much. In fact her trying to save RK at personal cost is the only thing I am sympathizing with right now.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".