RK villain/hero... does it matter? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.9k

Users

10

Likes

67

Frequent Posters

supercool3 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
Awesome post !

I honestly have minimal complaints about what is happening right now. Yes, there are some things I disapprove of. But my reaction cannot simply be based on one episode alone. I've been into this show since day 1 itself and I enjoy the progress it has made. End of the day I do like to believe that the writers know what they are doing and as an avid follower of the show it's my duty to trust them. And just like you said, I do believe whatever is happening right now is to lead to the bigger picture.

As far as characterizations are concerned, I have no doubts with either RK or Madhu. IMO, they have not been butchered. Creatives have kept the original sketch intact, and it's only the situation that keeps changing. From the beginning itself, the story has been based on Madhu and RK, and continues to be that way.
Edited by supercool3 - 12 years ago
BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: cardio21

Thanks for making this post.. It's like an oasis in this desert of posts against the leads.. Even I make posts on leads when I don't approve of anything they do..but not everyday!! May be its a way of showing how involved we are.. But why do we forget the show s about RK, Madhu n their complicated love story..? It will always be between them.. To begin with, we don't endorse all his actions.. But at the end of the day he is the hero of the show and is a strong one at tat,, he has made an impact with his stupendous performance.. There is no way anyone can replace him..

All the CVs will show is his redemption.. When n how, we can just wait and watch..

I think I understand this propaganda.. I am a total outsider when it comes to fandom!! I believe that people want their favorites to be the lead..

But the fact is Madhu n RK are the main leads.. It's their story!! PERIOD!! If the actor playing RK was a bad actor, they would think about replacing or changing the lead.. From whatever minimum I understand, he is the strongest actor in the TV world. The new guy is a great actor, but nowhere close to him in screen presence and histrionics!!
it's the CVs who are painting RK as a villain, it's their job to redeem him. Because there is no MEIEJ without RK or Madhu..

I don't know what we are fighting about.. RK is doing what he is being asked to do by the director.. He doesn't bring these mean ideas and dialogues from his home. Yes, he puts a life to it by his magnificent performance.. I heard he worked in a soap before too.. Was he equally good in his earlier soap too..??
Because he has nailed RK like no one can.. 👏

Same about Madhu, was she this fantastic in her last one ? How was AR in his last soap? Did he do any show before this??


BANG ON! Even I don't understand what people are fighting about. Really. The show was meant to be this way, and come this far. They've kept the characters' intact so the question of the characters' being butchered does not even arise.

I did watch Vivian's previous show, PKYEK. His acting was criticized a lot in that show, but I enjoyed it. It was the character (he was playing a vampire) who was meant to be slightly expressionless. I think VD did justice to the character. But definitely as RK, his acting has improved so much. He is just brilliant now.

And yes, even AR did a show before this on Colors, called Chhal. It was a thriller. The 1st few months of the show were brilliantly written & so interesting but eventually, it lost the plot. AR was good in that.
Edited by prc_fan1 - 12 years ago
BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: DushtDanaf.

nice post; i'd day that i don't have to like everything he does but that exactly doesn't villainize him. people might argue that tv impacts us, but I'd like to ask them how many telly soaps they've actually watched that had a real "social message", what exactly was the social message behind IPKKND or KMH ? if i really didn't like the message being depicted in a show, i would simply not watch it. I would not come onto a discussion forum and annoy anyone and everyone that has a differing opinion; kind of defeats the purpose of the point you're trying to make.


I completely agree with you. Esp your 2nd point, its really annoying to see people coming on the forum and scream "human rights" etc whenever RK is mean to Madhu. The show is meant to be a fiction, and a story of the 2 characters rather than to show domestic violence against women. People need to stop, really. Coming to this forum is really annoying sometimes.
BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Aahaana

Interesting topic, Sam👍🏼.

For me, its the story. I have watched it from episode 1 until now and have never blindly supported any of the characters but have understood why they behave like they do based on the characterization of them. We should appreciate the CVs for keeping the original characterization of RK and Madhu intact from the beginning until now. Its too early to discuss about Sultan but so far its working and the presence of this character makes other characters react hence I assume its serving its purpose.

I guess RK character is criticized a lot because we just want to see what we want see🤔. When it comes to MEJEI main characters, we cannot think with our black and white caps on - we just have to think from the characters perspective and where they comes from. We were promised dark love story hence I am able tolerate some of the tracks and dialogs because it makes sense coming from RK -otherwise I cant digest it👎🏼.



Nothing more to add, Aahaana. You nailed it! Esp, those in bold.
Edited by prc_fan1 - 12 years ago
BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: moniluvskinshuk

I also don't understand that how come RK's character been spoiled when his character was always written in that way . Wheather U love him , Whether U hate him But Fact is that He is the most interesting character in this show & not to forget Unpredictable . BTW Very Nice Post . And me2 love the show and Rishbala 😳


I agree. RK is definitely 1 of the most interesting characters on Indian TV. Period.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".