sviren thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
OKK before sultan and sulbala fans start bashing me..hear me out

I came across many posts on Gautam Hegde's tweet...not calling sultan as the villian

What i think is that RK is and will remain the hero..while sultan is and will remain the anti-hero. Now, my idea of an anti-hero is not the same as that of a villian. Rk and sultan are not simply white and black..but belong to the many shades of grey. Both have committed mistakes..afterall even the hero can't be perfect..there has to be some rationality to fiction also..

So, in effect, what i mean is RK = HERO & SULTAN = ANTI-HERO and NOT VILLIAN..

P.S. we can always give the villian tag to balraj, bhujang or dips :))


(an attempt made to pacify the issues in the forum..cheers!!)

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

1.4k

Users

4

Likes

5

Frequent Posters

Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: sviren

OKK before sultan and sulbala fans start bashing me..hear me out


I came across many posts on Gautam Hegde's tweet...not calling sultan as the villian

What i think is that RK is and will remain the hero..while sultan is and will remain the anti-hero. Now, my idea of an anti-hero is not the same as that of a villian. Rk and sultan are not simply white and black..but belong to the many shades of grey. Both have committed mistakes..afterall even the hero can't be perfect..there has to be some rationality to fiction also..

So, in effect, what i mean is RK = HERO & SULTAN = ANTI-HERO and NOT VILLIAN..

P.S. we can always give the villian tag to balraj, bhujang or dips :))


(an attempt made to pacify the issues in the forum..cheers!!)



I admire your intentions (to pacify issues in the forum) but your labelling is wrong I'm afraid...

Definition of Antihero
an antihero (or antiheroine as the female) is a protagonist who has no heroic virtues or qualities (such as being morally good,[idealistic, courageous, noble, and possessing fortitude), blurring the line between hero and villain


So! As Sultan as been portrayed so far...he is DEFINITELY NOT the antihero. ALONE!!
RK too is an antihero!! Lolll

Perhaps we would do better to stop LABELLING? and also understand the difference between a LEAD and a HERO?

The LEAD character in any story is not NECESSARILY THE HERO TOO!

It is however an understandable assumption because Indian soap media advertise it that way and I think in indian soaps, uptil now the lead has always been the hero. But not any more.
DushtDanaf. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
um..
more like:
Sultan=Sadakchaap
but yeah, i don't really see Sultan staying in the long run. Especially after the not so subtle hints the creatives have been giving. I think he's just around for this track and after Bhujang's out of the picture they won't really have much to do with him.
Edited by DushtDanaf. - 12 years ago
-Raichu- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Oh_No_Soaps



I admire your intentions (to pacify issues in the forum) but your labelling is wrong I'm afraid...

Definition of Antihero
an antihero (or antiheroine as the female) is a protagonist who has no heroic virtues or qualities (such as being morally good,[idealistic, courageous, noble, and possessing fortitude), blurring the line between hero and villain


So! As Sultan as been portrayed so far...he is DEFINITELY NOT the antihero. ALONE!!
RK too is an antihero!! Lolll

Perhaps we would do better to stop LABELLING? and also understand the difference between a LEAD and a HERO?

The LEAD character in any story is not NECESSARILY THE HERO TOO!

It is however an understandable assumption because Indian soap media advertise it that way and I think in indian soaps, uptil now the lead has always been the hero. But not any more.


For the first time I agree with you 😳

Yeah Both RK and Sultan are anti-heros there's no doubt about this !
RK can't be called a Hero because of his arrogance, his egocentric attitude ... His has a lot of bad sides still many admire him 😳😳

The same goes to Sultan : being a criminal he can't be called a hero 🥱🥱
and as he has a golden heart we can't call him a villain neither.


Madhubala tries to follow American serials tendency having an anti-hero as lead 😉😉

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".