Bashing the show..

ArushiSagar

@ArushiSagar

Beginner

3

Posted: 12 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: armummy

6

Reply

Quote

DANGGG

@DANGGG

Dazzler

23

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#12

yaar u giving me jhatkes with another post of ur here,

totally agree, some ppl only know how to mourn, and they'll alwasy find a reason. be it sultna or the other, who cares, loved rishbala, loving sulabala, will always will madhubaal ek ishq ek juoon, cause for me mu only junoon is my madhu, my dhak dhak

Reply

Quote

kar1538

@kar1538

Voyager

15

Posted: 12 years ago

#13

Agree with you and I am liking Sultan-Aryan track otherwise how the CV's will show RKs junoon.

Reply

Quote

RSP04

@RSP04

Voyager

15

Posted: 12 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: ArushiSagar

You are talking about reality and you are passing judgement on people based on thier liking of fictional serial track...

You may want to re-read my statement. I am NOT passing judgement on anyone. It was merely an observation. I did not say that these people are stupid or foolish. YOU are making an assumption that I'm somehow looking down on these people. I like realism in my stories. Some of my friends do not. Hence, I watch a lot more drama and they prefer rom-coms. Doesn't make either of us more right than the other. It's just our preference and everyone is allowed to have those.

Yes, I understand that the story is fictional, but each story has its own version of reality. You, as the viewer, can either buy into it or not. Given the show's version of reality, I don't find Madhu's behaviour erractic with respect to Sultan. In fact, her going out of the way to help Aryan and Sultan is EXACTLY in keeping with her character. The truth is when Madhu does this for RK, no one bats and eyelid and everyone justifies her behaviour as RK is the hero of the show, but since Sultan is not the hero, there outcry against Madhu's "stupidity" is deafening.

I wish a lot more people could see just what the CVs are doing with the characterizations of RK and Sultan. It's not as black and white as hero and villian. They are trying to show us the grey areas of their characters. A movie star is often idolized by millions, but no one really knows him or her as an individual. Only those close to him or her can say exactly how super he or she is in real life. Similary, a gangster exists on the fringes of society, but who really knows what led him or her to become that way? Moreover, I love what they are showing with Madhubala's journey not just through life, but also love. And I applaud the CVs' genius in handeling this. Every question that comes across your mind as you get over a relationship has been dealt with such sensitivity and attention to detail. I really don't care who Madhu ends up with as long as the CVs continue to handle these questions with care...

Awesome post..

1

Reply

Quote

Rohit Monga

@TheGreenArrow

Voyager

19

Posted: 12 years ago

#15

One side they wanted VD to enjoy other side they blaming writers why unki kya galti hai they gave there best in handling one week without one lead... Show ki bashing toh har roj karte hai kyunki unhe show mein 20 min sirf VD chahiye phir usse statue ki tarah khada kar do

Reply

Quote

ArushiSagar

@ArushiSagar

Beginner

3

Posted: 12 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: JuhiRockz
Bringing in a new character is perfectly okay, separation track is acceptable too, but connecting Madhu with a criminal is difficult to accept. CVs could have brought in a positive character for a change who could bring back laughter and happiness in Madhu's life. It would be much easier to accept such a character.

Why do CVs think that Madhu is destined to be with a dark character all the time? And why do they think that she has magical power to cure everyone with her love and care? Why it is not the opposite? Why can't be there a man in her life who cures her broken heart?

Interesting questions Juhi. You made some valid points there.

I'm not sure that Sultan is necessarily a dark character and I believe our perception of a character changes as we learn more about them. Sultan is still an unknown quantity. Once his backstory unfolds more fully, we can make that call.

But, even if we take the fact that he's a criminal to mean that he's a dark character, I think the CVs are trying to show a couple of things with this track:

1. Appearances can be deceiving - We are beginning to see a lot of good qualities of Sultan hidden behind his tough exterior. On the other hand, we saw a lot of bad qualities of RK hidden behind his glamourous exterior.

2. Redemption - Perhaps bringing Madhu and Sultan together (as friends or more) will bring about redemption for both of them. I am a strong believer in the fact that not everyone comes into your life to stay, but everyone comes into your life for a reason and inevitably leaves a lesson behind for you.

3. Personal strength - Very rarely do people magically appear into your life to take all your pain away. In the end, we all have to learn to be our own healers and counsellors. This is an especially important lesson for us women, as we are told from childhood that our knight in shining armour will come to rescue us. Well, we are not victims. If someone helps, great! If not, we can save ourselves.

Reply

Quote

armummy

@armummy

Dazzler

21

Posted: 12 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: ArushiSagar

You are talking about reality and you are passing judgement on people based on thier liking of fictional serial track...

You may want to re-read my statement. I am NOT passing judgement on anyone. It was merely an observation. I did not say that these people are stupid or foolish. YOU are making an assumption that I'm somehow looking down on these people. I like realism in my stories. Some of my friends do not. Hence, I watch a lot more drama and they prefer rom-coms. Doesn't make either of us more right than the other. It's just our preference and everyone is allowed to have those.

Yes, I understand that the story is fictional, but each story has its own version of reality. You, as the viewer, can either buy into it or not. Given the show's version of reality, I don't find Madhu's behaviour erractic with respect to Sultan. In fact, her going out of the way to help Aryan and Sultan is EXACTLY in keeping with her character. The truth is when Madhu does this for RK, no one bats and eyelid and everyone justifies her behaviour as RK is the hero of the show, but since Sultan is not the hero, there outcry against Madhu's "stupidity" is deafening.

I wish a lot more people could see just what the CVs are doing with the characterizations of RK and Sultan. It's not as black and white as hero and villian. They are trying to show us the grey areas of their characters. A movie star is often idolized by millions, but no one really knows him or her as an individual. Only those close to him or her can say exactly how super he or she is in real life. Similary, a gangster exists on the fringes of society, but who really knows what led him or her to become that way? Moreover, I love what they are showing with Madhubala's journey not just through life, but also love. And I applaud the CVs' genius in handeling this. Every question that comes across your mind as you get over a relationship has been dealt with such sensitivity and attention to detail. I really don't care who Madhu ends up with as long as the CVs continue to handle these questions with care...

Good for you that the cuurent track matches your expectation and like what you see.

For me the PH still need to work developing parallel tracks not involving the leads to run this show for long..

.

Edited by armummy - 12 years ago

Reply

Quote

ornella_mg

@ornella_mg

Voyager

15

Posted: 12 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: ArushiSagar

You are talking about reality and you are passing judgement on people based on thier liking of fictional serial track...

You may want to re-read my statement. I am NOT passing judgement on anyone. It was merely an observation. I did not say that these people are stupid or foolish. YOU are making an assumption that I'm somehow looking down on these people. I like realism in my stories. Some of my friends do not. Hence, I watch a lot more drama and they prefer rom-coms. Doesn't make either of us more right than the other. It's just our preference and everyone is allowed to have those.

Yes, I understand that the story is fictional, but each story has its own version of reality. You, as the viewer, can either buy into it or not. Given the show's version of reality, I don't find Madhu's behaviour erractic with respect to Sultan. In fact, her going out of the way to help Aryan and Sultan is EXACTLY in keeping with her character. The truth is when Madhu does this for RK, no one bats and eyelid and everyone justifies her behaviour as RK is the hero of the show, but since Sultan is not the hero, there outcry against Madhu's "stupidity" is deafening.

I wish a lot more people could see just what the CVs are doing with the characterizations of RK and Sultan. It's not as black and white as hero and villian. They are trying to show us the grey areas of their characters. A movie star is often idolized by millions, but no one really knows him or her as an individual. Only those close to him or her can say exactly how super he or she is in real life. Similary, a gangster exists on the fringes of society, but who really knows what led him or her to become that way? Moreover, I love what they are showing with Madhubala's journey not just through life, but also love. And I applaud the CVs' genius in handeling this. Every question that comes across your mind as you get over a relationship has been dealt with such sensitivity and attention to detail. I really don't care who Madhu ends up with as long as the CVs continue to handle these questions with care...

Totally agree with you here. Madhu is very much in her character which people are refusing to see. They keep questioning her intellegence. She has always been the emotional kind, her heart rules over her mind. If one analyses her past, one can see how her actions were always governed by her heart. Examples are Mukund, RK and now Sultan.

Madhu has to go through her share of failures and disappointments to achive success in her life. Her brush with the underworld will give her character certain depth and dimension. This not and out and a love story between RK and Madhu. It is the journey of this simple girl to stardom. The different characters, she meets in her journey will play a pivotal role in shaping her character and future.

I am really liking the track and i hope they dont change it under the pressure of the fans. I am very eager to see how the story unfolds. Hope they do justice to all the characters.

2

Reply

Quote

Neferet

@-Neferet-

Voyager

18

Posted: 12 years ago

#19

yes agree with you..but do u remember he had taken a 15 day leave when he got married?but they had pulled it off quite well..

and yes..when you are an actor,taking a leave can't be just his decision,they need to see that the show isnt focusing on him,they need to give 1 mnth prior notice,its not like aaj cllg nai jana paak gai hun 😔

Reply

Quote

JuhiR

@JuhiR

Voyager

17

Posted: 12 years ago

#20

Originally posted by: ArushiSagar

Interesting questions Juhi. You made some valid points there.

I'm not sure that Sultan is necessarily a dark character and I believe our perception of a character changes as we learn more about them. Sultan is still an unknown quantity. Once his backstory unfolds more fully, we can make that call.

But, even if we take the fact that he's a criminal to mean that he's a dark character, I think the CVs are trying to show a couple of things with this track:

1. Appearances can be deceiving - We are beginning to see a lot of good qualities of Sultan hidden behind his tough exterior. On the other hand, we saw a lot of bad qualities of RK hidden behind his glamourous exterior. True, agree. But don't forget we started to see a lot of good qualities in RK too, and like Madhu we were deceived. All those good qualities were fake.

2. Redemption - Perhaps bringing Madhu and Sultan together (as friends or more) will bring about redemption for both of them. I am a strong believer in the fact that not everyone comes into your life to stay, but everyone comes into your life for a reason and inevitably leaves a lesson behind for you. I would not have any problem with that idea if that angel came in the guise of a regular nice guy; a creative director, or a broad-minded actor, a producer who is a widower with a kid, or perhaps a bachelor outside Films who is just good at heart. I just cannot take this criminal connection any more -Ballu, Malik shooting RK, Ballu again, and now Sultan who is good at heart, but he is a killer and a fugitive. And I am uncomfortable about any girl, let alone Madhu, spending a night with a stranger, however good at heart that person is. And she ignores her mother. If they wanted to bring in a friendship in Madhu's life, then why not a man with a clean background?

3. Personal strength - Very rarely do people magically appear into your life to take all your pain away. In the end, we all have to learn to be our own healers and counsellors. This is an especially important lesson for us women, as we are told from childhood that our knight in shining armour will come to rescue us. Well, we are not victims. If someone helps, great! If not, we can save ourselves. Yes I agree 100%, Madhu has to fight her own battles, that is why I don't like Madhu to right away get trapped into another man's life. And it is a precarious life, not enjoyable at all. I don't care to see Madhu becoming the healer in every case. I like to see her being treated with love and respect. Tired of watching anti-heros in her life. She should fix her life on her own strength.

@Arushi,

Great answers. I like them. My responses in red.

Reply

Quote

Bashing the show.. - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics