Created

Last reply

Replies

55

Views

8.7k

Users

39

Likes

353

Frequent Posters

Amoureux thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#21
TFS
All pros and cons of belonging to the online virtual world i guess. I thought RS knew how to handle it all 😊 but then he too is a human so its understandable.
As far as i have understood team MB till date i don't think they would ever bow down to fans demands. They have beleived in their abilities and have shown what they have wanted to all the time, despite of all the compalints and cribbing. So far they have been successful and the numbers speak for them. And the way ST asks fans to watch something else if not liking the current track it only proves it 😊
My message to RS (if you can post it): Sir, Please understand that the more popular your show the more complaints you will have from the different 10000 fans. You should be happy about that and just take the comments in your own stride and let it not deter you. As you want fans to understand where you are coming from and how you perceive a character and its layers please understand that every fan has his own sensibility... and his own layer... You are not catering to a certain age group or a certain geography. You are catering to people from all strata of the society, all age groups and diversified all over the world, belonging to different beliefs, having different personalities. Not every one would be on the same page ofcourse and not everyone would be convinced with what you show.
Despite of all this, please understand that if we decide to come here, spend time discussing and debating or complaining over a character and how he / she behaves its only becuase we love the show and the characters. Had it not been the case why would one even invest anytime here. That too the precious time thats not going to bear anything fruitful 😉
So Sir just take a chill pill... At the end of the day we will have to see what you are showing for its not in our hands to change the course of the story 😆 (only if i wish that could have been the case 😃)
Taiyo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#22
@Anu: If you are trying to write a kafkaesque story, which is what his replies make me believe, there will be thousand different opinions. The writer should stick to his vision and be in his zone, rather than coming out and trying to see what others are saying. Don't blame the audience if they don't see it the same way.

I am unable to see what he is trying to attempt and if that makes me dumb, let it be. 😊
Edited by an12345678 - 12 years ago
bangalores thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#23
TFS

i for one wud never say that RK doesn't love MAdhu... but how is realization of love redemption? RK is a weak character? may be he is weak coz he is not strong enough to admit he loves her and he needs her love, weak because he does not accept that needing someone does not constitute to weakness.

Who wants a weepy RK who drinks like devdas... Cudn't a Man accept his fault without loosing the "layers of character" that makes him interestin?
-Raichu- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
Thanks for sharing !
Yes RK is different, his redemption will be different as well.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: an12345678

@Anu: If you are trying to write a kafkaesque story, which is what his replies make me believe, there will be thousand different opinions. The writer should stick to his vision and be in his zone, rather than coming out and trying to see what others are saying. Don't blame the audience if they don't see it the same way.


I am unable to see what he is trying to attempt and if that makes me dumb, let it be. 😊



An, as far as I understood his post...it is not different opinions that bother him but the utter lack of understanding...as an artist if you try to express something, tell a story, show layering to a character and ppl don't even get the essence of it one bit, it would be frustrating.

Most of the fans just seem to have their own agendas...the DD fans cuz they feel upset that Madhu is mistreated by RK and the VD fans have their own...then there's the Rishbala fans who just want romance, period...there aren't many fans who want to watch this for story and characterization.

He IS sticking to his vision as best as he can and I think he's managed quite well in a time where TRP pressures change perfectly good stories overnight into nightmares...a very good example being NBT.

I don't think he's venturing out and asking fans why they don't like what he's showing...if ppl ask him questions, he'll reply...which seems to be the case here...someone asked him and he replied...

I don't see anything wrong with him questioning the maturity of some fans with the way they've created uproars anytime a darker tone to RK's character is shown...I don't see where he called anyone dumb.

This is a complex story and there aren't many takers for complex stories of such sort on Indian TV...that they've managed to show this much layering to RK is an achievement in itself...don't know how long it will last though.
-Raichu- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: bangalores

TFS

i for one wud never say that RK doesn't love MAdhu... but how is realization of love redemption? RK is a weak character? may be he is weak coz he is not strong enough to admit he loves her and he needs her love, weak because he does not accept that needing someone does not constitute to weakness.

Who wants a weepy RK who drinks like devdas... Cudn't a Man accept his fault without loosing the "layers of character" that makes him interestin?

100% agree with you !!!
I don't want RK to change, because I love him how he is. Madhu loves him the way he is as well.
Rkmadhuawsome thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
U r dumb y did u do this man now they will make rk a boring character plzzz go and tell him nt to do that plzzz we just want that madhu and rk should get togather bt rk shld be lyk this only plzz
Rkmadhuawsome thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

U r dumb y did u do this man now they will make rk a boring character plzzz go and tell him nt to do that plzzz we just want that madhu and rk should get togather bt rk shld be lyk this only plzz
-Raichu- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: AreYaar



An, as far as I understood his post...it is not different opinions that bother him but the utter lack of understanding...as an artist if you try to express something, tell a story, show layering to a character and ppl don't even get the essence of it one bit, it would be frustrating.

Most of the fans just seem to have their own agendas...the DD fans cuz they feel upset that Madhu is mistreated by RK and the VD fans have their own...then there's the Rishbala fans who just want romance, period...there aren't many fans who want to watch this for story and characterization.

He IS sticking to his vision as best as he can and I think he's managed quite well in a time where TRP pressures change perfectly good stories overnight into nightmares...a very good example being NBT.

I don't think he's venturing out and asking fans why they don't like what he's showing...if ppl ask him questions, he'll reply...which seems to be the case here...someone asked him and he replied...

I don't see anything wrong with him questioning the maturity of some fans with the way they've created uproars anytime a darker tone to RK's character is shown...I don't see where he called anyone dumb.

This is a complex story and there aren't many takers for complex stories of such sort on Indian TV...that they've managed to show this much layering to RK is an achievement in itself...don't know how long it will last though.

Well said 👏
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: bangalores

TFS

i for one wud never say that RK doesn't love MAdhu... but how is realization of love redemption? RK is a weak character? may be he is weak coz he is not strong enough to admit he loves her and he needs her love, weak because he does not accept that needing someone does not constitute to weakness.

Who wants a weepy RK who drinks like devdas... Cudn't a Man accept his fault without loosing the "layers of character" that makes him interestin?



Sure he can...but that takes time...To admit his mistakes is tantamount to being vulnerable...and for a man as egotistical as RK, vulnerable is the last thing he wants to be...that is why Mr. Shekhawat is calling him a weak man...cuz it takes STRENGTH to admit your mistakes...to admit that you were wrong...RK uses his ego as a shield...and that is why his redemption will take time.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".