Taking things too far..

As much as I have loved watching what the makers have doled out till now..the writing and the dialogues..leads who did not forget to use their head even after they feel in love..who communicated with words amd not with duppatas and trip fall sessions...the great way in which they have shown the growth of the lead characters..I personally feel that they are taking things too far with this public humiliation scenario..

What ever be the reason the reason they choose to justify this track.. that it was plain old revenge ( I still dont buy it because its completely illogical and fraught with loopholes)..that he is dying and wants Madhu to hate him (I know ST denied this track but then if people can come back from dead, makers can change their desicion for trps right)..or that there is some other reason for which he is sacrificing his love and ensuring support for Madhu by humiliating her in public and making himself look bad (which it most likely will turn out to be IMO)...I still thing that this public humiliation is taking things a tad too far..

No reason will ever justify this in my book..
I mean if he wants her and her family to hate him..there are scores of other ways to do that...he already shattered her soul by what he did at mandap...but atleast it was private..announcing it on the mike...its just way too cruel..didnt he once say that a wound to ones soul is worst kind of injury one can get..he just gave her one..even if 2 weeks later we get to know that it was for her own good..it wont matter..because the scar will always be there..

I dont have a problem with them showing a grey or evil RK..but I do have a big problem with the reasons and the way it is being show..

I was a big time Rk fan and always loved his BBB dialogues. I admit I did not even mind everything he did before they confessed their love for one another.

Originally posted by: flower2276

I was a big time Rk fan and always loved his BBB dialogues. I admit I did not even mind everything he did before they confessed their love for one another.

But this publichumiliationis a big turn off. No reason is reason enough for his betrayal.

Contrary to most people I for one failed to read in his eyes (reading eyes takes me back to IPK fiasco so I refuse to read between the lines and react to only what I see) ...

anyways I did not see love in his eyes like everyone is claiming to see. And also I do not understand how anyone can defend his actions by bringing in his past or insecurities. Nothing will ever justify what he did. And madhu will never be the same again well unless CV's make her do nonsensical stuff like forgiving RK.

ST already confirmed it's not a disease and I read in a metromasti article that it will be revealed that whatever RK did is for revenge which is unforgivable. Is he GOD to decide her destiny? What kind of a twisted story is this?

How can a regular viewer connect to RK and wrap their head around his actions? He's beyond redemption now.

I thought eye reading was patented by IPK forum members..they would read only between the lines and choose to ignore what was plainly visible..and we all know what a huge fiasco it turned into..I have still not got over it completely..

and I completely agree that public humiliation is such a turn off..
No insecirity, no past, not even a mahan sacrifice can justify this..If I was pissed at the way he dealt with her today...I was seething in anger after seeing the promo..

What a perfect way to ruin things..
It is possiboe that the trp viewers might love the drama quotient..but they have tainted RK and Rishbala for me..

Originally posted by: -GhostOrchid-

I thought eye reading was patented by IPK forum members..they would read only between the lines and choose to ignore what was plainly visible..and we all know what a huge fiasco it turned into..I have still not got over it completely..

Ha ha... You cracked me up with that. I was really surprsied the number of posts in the forum where everyone is claiming to read love and pain and what not his eyes and trust me I watched the episode again but I did not see anything of that sort..And don't even remind me of IPK fiasco.🥱

and I completely agree that public humiliation is such a turn off..
No insecirity, no past, not even a mahan sacrifice can justify this..If I was pissed at the way he dealt with her today...I was seething in anger after seeing the promo..

Me too. the promo was a big turn off. So far ST has managed to rubbish off almost all the rumors by forumwasis and on twitter. I wonder how they will ever justify RK's actions.

What a perfect way to ruin things..
It is possiboe that the trp viewers might love the drama quotient..but they have tainted RK and Rishbala for me..

I doubt that. Even after reading the analysis of so many analyzers I'm still having a hard time trying to fathom his actions. How can a TRP viewer like our mom or aunt who has no time nor the inclination to discuss at length RK's character will ever be identify with RK. I think they made RK too evil. I'll be surprised if this track clicks.

Originally posted by: -GhostOrchid-

As much as I have loved watching what the makers have doled out till now..the writing and the dialogues..leads who did not forget to use their head even after they feel in love..who communicated with words amd not with duppatas and trip fall sessions...the great way in which they have shown the growth of the lead characters..I personally feel that they are taking things too far with this public humiliation scenario..

What ever be the reason the reason they choose to justify this track.. that it was plain old revenge ( I still dont buy it because its completely illogical and fraught with loopholes)..that he is dying and wants Madhu to hate him (I know ST denied this track but then if people can come back from dead, makers can change their desicion for trps right)..or that there is some other reason for which he is sacrificing his love and ensuring support for Madhu by humiliating her in public and making himself look bad (which it most likely will turn out to be IMO)...I still thing that this public humiliation is taking things a tad too far..

No reason will ever justify this in my book..
I mean if he wants her and her family to hate him..there are scores of other ways to do that...he already shattered her soul by what he did at mandap...but atleast it was private..announcing it on the mike...its just way too cruel..didnt he once say that a wound to ones soul is worst kind of injury one can get..he just gave her one..even if 2 weeks later we get to know that it was for her own good..it wont matter..because the scar will always be there..

I dont have a problem with them showing a grey or evil RK..but I do have a big problem with the reasons and the way it is being show..

Okay, let us break it down. I, for one, am not looking for a perfect relationship in a show. The man is twisted and makes it painfully visible to the people around. He, in no way, represents the ideal lover, son, or any of those relationships. Think of it like Mad Men or Dexter or some unlikable character that is in lead. Their dynamic with their lovers is always that of a controlling, overprotective person who also happens to be severely flawed and things always turn sour. This does not make the viewers hate the character. In some capacity, we come to admire that very aspect of the lead. So much so that if Dexter were to give up killing tomorrow the show would be over. So, kids if you are watching this show, DO NOT model your relationships on what RK is doing to Madhu. Having said that, I am okay with the not your typical goodie two shoes for a lead provided, the affection of the past can be justified.

Originally posted by: iiDona

Okay, let us break it down. I, for one, am not looking for a perfect relationship in a show. The man is twisted and makes it painfully visible to the people around. He, in no way, represents the ideal lover, son, or any of those relationships. Think of it like Mad Men or Dexter or some unlikable character that is in lead. Their dynamic with their lovers is always that of a controlling, overprotective person who also happens to be severely flawed and things always turn sour. This does not make the viewers hate the character. In some capacity, we come to admire that very aspect of the lead. So much so that if Dexter were to give up killing tomorrow the show would be over. So, kids if you are watching this show, DO NOT model your relationships on what RK is doing to Madhu. Having said that, I am okay with the not your typical goodie two shoes for a lead provided, the affection of the past can be justified.

Originally posted by: flower2276

My comments inline...😊

eye reading is a skill you amd I havent acquired yet..I tried real hard in that god forsaken forum..but I guess I just don have it in me to learn it..

@ justifying RK's actions: I am sure they will come up woth a silly reason showing that he was doing this for her own good. because I dont see them wanting to show him comoletely evil unless they plan a tragic end or a third angle..

@trp audiemce accepting the twist: I have seen trp audience enjoying this kind of drama a lot..because if they didnt then serials like SNS and SSK wouldnt have been consostently garnering such high trps..

maybe the reason that we cant get our head around the twist is that we have invested a lot of time in dissecting his moves and analyzing his character..we fell in love with him along woth Madhu and feel that he cheated us as well..however people wo watch it just for entertainment purpose are not so invested..so they dont feel cheated..they will watch it for the drama..

I dont think the makers are hoping that people will identify with RK..they are banking on trp audience to sympathize woth Madhu..coz a female lead who is being totured gets high trps..atleast till now..

Originally posted by: SAnonymous

</div>
<div>

Awesome Post

You are very correct in telling

I mean if he wants her and her family to hate him..there are scores of other ways to do that...he already shattered her soul by what he did at mandap...but atleast it was private..announcing it on the mike...its just way too cruel..didnt he once say that a wound to ones soul is worst kind of injury one can get..he just gave her one..even if 2 weeks later we get to know that it was for her own good..it wont matter..because the scar will always be there..

Thank you..