Taking things too far.. - Page 2

Originally posted by: iiDona

Okay, let us break it down. I, for one, am not looking for a perfect relationship in a show. The man is twisted and makes it painfully visible to the people around. He, in no way, represents the ideal lover, son, or any of those relationships. Think of it like Mad Men or Dexter or some unlikable character that is in lead. Their dynamic with their lovers is always that of a controlling, overprotective person who also happens to be severely flawed and things always turn sour. This does not make the viewers hate the character. In some capacity, we come to admire that very aspect of the lead. So much so that if Dexter were to give up killing tomorrow the show would be over. So, kids if you are watching this show, DO NOT model your relationships on what RK is doing to Madhu. Having said that, I am okay with the not your typical goodie two shoes for a lead provided, the affection of the past can be justified.

I dont mind a flawed relationship Jasleen...the flaws make it look all the more real..
I kind of understood when he felt the need to test her love back then..
but I dont undrstand his actions now..
If he i acually taking revenge..then ther are a lot of loop holes that canno be explained..so unless they explain them properly..I will have my reservations regarding this..
and if he ia doing his for some unknown reason for her own good..then I seriously dont think a man as intelligent as RK has been portrayed to be would choose this route..

As I earlier said..I dont mind a grey RK or a dark story at all..they are intersting...but I mind the way it has been shown without any logic..

Hmmm...yes I agree to it too in a sense ...but I have decided not to watch this show with a heart that seeks lovey dovey romance...coz this is not an ordinary love story its a saga...there is more to everything... to love,to emotions,to relations, to passion...etc.etc. So judging every act of RK from now on would take a lot of brainstorming...This show is Unique!!!!!

this kind of turn or twist could have become a necessity if the TRP rating is going down, then why in a midst of things which were making the show gradually climbing to its heights, is out of question for the lovers of rishbala.

Originally posted by: -GhostOrchid-

I dont mind a flawed relationship Jasleen...the flaws make it look all the more real..
I kind of understood when he felt the need to test her love back then..
but I dont undrstand his actions now..
If he i acually taking revenge..then ther are a lot of loop holes that canno be explained..so unless they explain them properly..I will have my reservations regarding this..
and if he ia doing his for some unknown reason for her own good..then I seriously dont think a man as intelligent as RK has been portrayed to be would choose this route..

As I earlier said..I dont mind a grey RK or a dark story at all..they are intersting...but I mind the way it has been shown without any logic..

Originally posted by: ninand

<font color="#333333" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">I agree with you completely. Nothing warrants a public humiliation as the one RK is going to subject MB to.. and twice! The first time he insulted and shamed her mother and fathers' relationship in the most objectionable way, and now again..</font>

<font color="#333333" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">I do not think the creators are leaning towards any excuses for his behavior,(as they shouldn't), but then there is no conceivable way MB can forgive Rk let alone trust him again!</font>

<font color="#333333" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">When he wants her to understand that his opening up about his father, accepting his mother, respecting her parents, all was a farce.. when he means to say that her virtues, her goodness, her honor and honesty,( brought to fore on numerous occasions be it when he was revived through her blood, or she got estranged with her father for him.. ) nothing has really mattered so far.. it begs the question , what will?</font>

<font color="#333333" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">what can get to him if these things couldn't? and should Madhu even try? Does he even deserve any lenience whatsoever?! does he deserve goodness from anyone?</font>

<font color="#333333" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">I dunno where they are going with this.. and I cannot digest any justification for such abominable behavior.</font>

<font color="#333333" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">(I am hoping the CVs are sensitive to this fact and will treat it with respect, though how they'll accomplish it I have not the faintest clue.)</font>

I am really hoping they donot try to justify his behaviour with half baked reasons like his past or his insecurities or even worse make it look like some grand sacrifice..I guess what the CVs show hence forth will depend on response of the trps..if they fall then we will definitely see some secret reason bein revealed in the coming weeks..
and that will just suck..because then it will be all about him being the mahaan lover..but no reason in my book can excuse the public mocking that he is putting her through...

I could understand it earlier when he maligned her mother and Mallik's relaionship..but I dont think I can accept it now..after evrything they have shown us (let me rephrase that because I no longer know what was true and what wasnt)..after all she felt for him..

I have the same questions as you tha if all they went through didnt affect him..then what on earth will..
And how will she ever trust him..or anyone for that matter..how will she ever know what is true and what isnt..ecause at this rate you never know when they will turn aound and say it way all lie..

And I for the life of me cannot fathom how the creators will go ahead from here..

Originally posted by: aahaaan_rk

Hmmm...yes I agree to it too in a sense ...but I have decided not to watch this show with a heart that seeks lovey dovey romance...coz this is not an ordinary love story its a saga...there is more to everything... to love,to emotions,to relations, to passion...etc.etc. So judging every act of RK from now on would take a lot of brainstorming...This show is Unique!!!!!

I donot mind absence of lovey dovy romance..its not a pre requisite for a good story..but I mind complete absence of logic..and showing anything in the name of cinematic liberty..

Even a saga needs to be reasonable..

I just hope that the show doesnt end up being so unique and requires so much brain storming that people stop trying to figure it out completely..

Dear tthey are going to loose trp atleast for monday after promo, if u see last week trp was more when padmini kill ballu n coart case, so now a day old ladies too love to watch women fight back not this kind of humialation, all show trp geting increase on good ppl win not evil, they are showing rk evil fine for some reason but now monday no body will see this humialation part, suspense is ok but this are going beyond tolerence

@past,insecurities and sacrifice ---- I'm already reading too many posts on how he's doing this for her good,there must be some reason,he wants her to hate him blah blah blah but my question is if he really loves her that much can't he come clean? He knows she loves him to death as been proven time and time again. Why this elaborate revenge plot?

Originally posted by: iiDona

revenge...Yes, I do not see how this would make sense. But, looks like ST has something up his sleeve.

For her own good, is bullshit. I am not going down with that ship. No way, no how. If his revenge is somehow justified, I would like for him to stay grey and not jump extremes every few episodes.

If ST does actually have something up his sleeve that can explain this extreme behavior in a sensible way then I am game..but I still wouldnt like everthing being made public (its my personal opinion..I dont like it one bit when they hype up things just for the heck of it)
right now I cannot think of a single reason that can excuse this behaviour..maybe he can and thats why he is sittingout there as the maker..

PS: even I would like it if they dont make him go from one extreme to another just for the sake of a twist..

Originally posted by: flower2276

@past,insecurities and sacrifice ---- I'm already reading too many posts on how he's doing this for her good,there must be some reason,he wants her to hate him blah blah blah but my question is if he really loves her that much can't he come clean? He knows she loves him to death as been proven time and time again. Why this elaborate revenge plot?

I'm going by the metromasti article that said this is for pushing Madhu into stardom however my question remains what will he gain by that and who is he to decide her fate?

It doesn't matter if ST had the very best trick up his sleeve Madhu will be scarred for life. Her blind trust in RK will be gone. Even if they get back together God knows when he'll turn the table on her. I really hope she doesn't become like one of those infamous PH heroine who behave as if nothing happened and forgives him easily.

I agree with every word..
This is precisely what I am saying...nothing..absolutely no reason would explain let alone justify this elaborate planning..
He was the one who gave the idea of leaving everything..he promised to take their relationship forward only after they married properly and then he jilted her at Mandap after showing so many dreams..how do you justify that..If you have a reason..directly come clean..she has proved time and again that she is strong enough to bear bad news and deal with it..

I dont think even metromasti kniw what they are going to show next amd are just specukating..but if this indeed is a grand plan to push her into stardom then..
congratulations creators..you have just managed to ruin the most anticipated track..the crux of the story..
because it doesnt make an iota of sense...

And yes I cannot imagine how she is going to believe anything he ever says henceforth..because she would never know when he is being true and when.he is lying..

And if after all this she does forgive him in 2 weeks and that is what the twist actually is..then the joke would be on us..for watching the show.. 😕