Do you still think Madhubala will stay for long ? - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

108

Views

13.7k

Users

61

Likes

231

Frequent Posters

LordVikrant thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#81

Originally posted by: mymagic13

u r such a sicko,, u come here and praise geet n their jodi,,
u go to another forum n say guru has better show post geet n indirectly bash this show,, i think u r most jobless person,,
if u think this show is not worth watching u should get out this forum,,
get well soon



Hmm I am just sharing my feedback,where is bashing in it...
Arnav90 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#82
Vikrant every post of your suckss... That you are Puzari of sum else celeb n show or you are trying to fight in all forums...
leverne thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#83

Originally posted by: LordVikrant

Dont you think Rakhee vijian is too loud and her character keeps promoting film industry in a very filmy manner.

No i agree to disagree with u...her role is that of a carefree and a very practical Mumbai person, which i believe she is playing perfectly. If you see the life of a single woman living in Mumbai u might just relate to Roma. she belongs to the film industry, so to behave or promote film industry is just in her blood. any ways the show itself is about the film industry so its doing its job there 😃


The mother is given far more filmy,dramatic and emotional dialogues,where she keeps crying in every scene.

I dont think so. I guess you missed watching the first episode wherein she runs away from her cruel husband. she is not the type to sit and cry but to take decision. She was very proactive in her instincts and she chose to save herself and her daughters from her husbands clutches. I for one never saw her cry so much in this show.👏

The actor is brother's role is good , the actor in thakur's role is also good and so is his mother.
Now here i agree with you.😃

The elder sister of drashti in the show cant act,she is just getting footage becoz she is a film actress from south.

I disagree with you, she is a nice actor and she does fit well in her role. Dont u think it is a bit too soon to judge her capabilities


Drashti's presence and screen time is compromised and the way she is presented she is looking like one aunty if not aunty then definitely not a teenager,she is looking matured and its her make up to blame.
Okies...so you think that she didnt get enough screen time...really..from the day she has entered she has been there in most of the scenes...may not have been saying the dialogues but she was there in the scene...please goo back and watch the episodes...
Her look in the show- let me tell you she is a college going girl working in a parlour not some riich girl or a film star that she will have tons of makeup on. Her clothes to her makeup to her language is just like any other Mumbai girl.
😃

The way story jumped seems the story writers dont have any plan to take the series beyong 6 months.

How do you know that the writers dont have plans to take the show for more than 6 months. The channel and the producers have invested in the show a lot and they would have taken care that it delivers good returns for a long period of time. You and I dont need to worry about that
😃

The presentation style is making the show and its story predictable.
I agree the presentation of the show is nice, but do tell me what are the circumstances that force Madhubala to work in Film industry against her will if the story is predictable. It will save us lots of efforts on thinking😛

Vivian and Drashti's pair might click and it might there is still doubts
I think you should wait for them to be seen together then judge. I loved the dream dance sequence

Do share ur view on the above points and hope u dont bash and reply politely



I hope you got all the polite answers.

PS: We will talk again when its beyond 6 months of the show and OUR show is still ON AIR.


gk_09 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#84
Please keep Gurmeet or GurTi OUT of discussion. This show is about Madhubala so please stick to that. Similarly, commenting on an actor's appearance is big no no. The result can be seen by all.

Everyone is entitled towards their opinion. You may not always agree. However, that does not mean you bash other members within the forum. What happened in the Geet forum stays there. Please do not bring it here.

As for now, the topic will remain open but will be monitored closely. Those who have violated the rules will be dealt with accordingly.

GK
- MB Devt Team
pippa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#85
Since this is a public forum, I firmly believe that every member has the right to have his or her opinion...the rest may agree or disagree with the said opinion.

Here, the TM was offering his. What went askew is that he broke certain forum rules by bringing in comparisons and commenting on the physical aspect of actors which are wrong.

I have no issues with the rest of his opinions...those are his and he has a right to have them.

@mistydrashti: The forum rules also say that you can't write in capital letters...it's considered as shouting.😊
Edited by pippa - 13 years ago
LordVikrant thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#86

Originally posted by: pippa

Since this is a public forum, I firmly believe that every member has the right to have his or her opinion...the rest may agree or disagree with the said opinion.

Here, the TM was offering his. What went askew is that he broke certain forum rules by bringing in comparisons and commenting on the physical aspect of actors which are wrong.

I have no issues with the rest of his opinions...those are his and he has a right to have them.

@mistydrashti: The forum rules also say that you can't write in capital letters...it's considered as shouting.😊



Nice and decent polite and sensible comment...thanks for educating me with forum rules..it will help me in future.
LordVikrant thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#87

Originally posted by: mishtydrashti

GK,

THE TM HAS MADE A POST IN PV FORUM SAYING GC HAS GOT THE BETTER SHOW AFTER GEET AS COMPARED TO DRASHTI ...BLAH BLAH BLAH!
THIS IS A VERY INFLAMMATORY POST! WOULD REQUEST YOU TO MONITOR HIM CLOSELY CAUSE HE IS A KNOWN TROUBLE MAKER!


I am not a trouble maker,people bash me for true feedback.

My opinions are different from others that is why I am bashed..

To the moderator:

In my article I have not discussed about actors from other shows or any other channel or show,one of the respondents highlighted my feedback on some other forum...to ignite feelings of others which was wrong.

The two article are no where related but are tried and potrayed in a manner there is some relationship between them

I hope i am not responsible for that.

I have shared two independent feedbacks

One on this show and other on other forum,I do not understand why respondents mix the two feedbacks meant for two different shows.

Hope this fact will be considered...
LordVikrant thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#88

Originally posted by: gk_09

Please keep Gurmeet or GurTi OUT of discussion. This show is about Madhubala so please stick to that. Similarly, commenting on an actor's appearance is big no no. The result can be seen by all.

Everyone is entitled towards their opinion. You may not always agree. However, that does not mean you bash other members within the forum. What happened in the Geet forum stays there. Please do not bring it here.

As for now, the topic will remain open but will be monitored closely. Those who have violated the rules will be dealt with accordingly.

GK
- MB Devt Team



Hi if there is anything which is against rules and is not allowed,please go ahead and edit it I have no issues...

I believe the article was a feedback only towards Madhubala and its initial episodes which did not go as per expectations and the series in itself does not promise to stay for long.

All I did was highlight the pitfalls with a feedback which will not go down well with many.

You are welcomed to edit parts or words against rules.

Regards,

Vikrant Khatri
601348 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#89
hey though i dont completely agree with u that this does not have proper screenplay and all as producers have spent a lot on this show 😆 but i appreciate that u came up with some criticism which ppl here confuse with bashing 😆...prolly thay dont know what real bashing is 😆
LordVikrant thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#90

Originally posted by: Nishi.Singh

hey though i dont completely agree with u that this does not have proper screenplay and all as producers have spent a lot on this show 😆 but i appreciate that u came up with some criticism which ppl here confuse with bashing 😆...prolly thay dont know what real bashing is 😆



Ohh thank god someone understood what I wanted to convey, also requested Indiaforum and moderator to start a seperate discussion thread for constructive criticism,but they had issues.

Anyways right, I never meant the show was a flop,I said few technical things which are important are not going well.

Becoz when i watch the show i am not able to enjoy it,either i feel the scenes are not fresh or they are repeated or too filmy and loud.

if one sees madhubala he will realise the scenes are too filmy and repetitive and the makers are under the wrong impression they have upper hand with VD and DD.

Their hard work can go to vain if they dont work on story flow and presentation.




Related Topics

Madhubala - Ek Ishq Ek Junoon thumbnail

Posted by: Heja · 24 days ago

Madhubala's character in the series was portrayed as a character who showed mercy even to her well-intentioned enemy. But when I watched the...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".