Maddam Sir - EDT #1 - CLOSED! - Page 9

Originally posted by: rinki_99

i...am speechless at the progression- or lack thereof- in the storyline. I am going to believe that everyone on the team had collective amnesia and thus have forgotten that they need to solve a murder case. even that is a stretch since they seem to remember that urmilla is not haseena...but then proceed to follow her orders as though she is. yea no I am not going down that rabbit hole.

the past 2 episodes were filler ones and were funny here and there. I would have enjoyed it better if Karishma was leading it instead of what we got (haseena inspired by billu to solve the case). I agree with Deepika di that bua saas could have been a game-changer move. in this particular case about working women, she and Pushpa Ji for that matter have much more at stake than anyone else on the team. the emotional weight they could carry through this case would have been fantastic to watch. instead, they are yet again running around- literally this time- playing doubles because it's funny apparently.

as for the flirting, I would bet my last dollar that it would be used as a comic element for everyone to laugh off after all is said and done. santu's maasumiyat are pretty few and far in between nowadays so it won't really have much of an impact.

@bold; Ikr! At this point why are they even following Urmila's orders?! You're right , it's best to stay off that rabbit hole...

@bold 2; I know it won't have that much of an impact , but still it was a fun scenario to think about

Nowadays even Urmila is shipping Chita and Santu ...in yesterday's episode she called them "Chantu"....she says it as a joke in that scene , I don't think she actually ships them

Why can't they ever show Karishma solving a case all by herself? There are qualified officers in MPT other than HM , the writers tend to forget this all the time...

I just hope there will be a track in future where Karishma solves a case by herself without anyone's help...

Originally posted by: Sainath-394-cid

Does anyone know what episode is this clip from?

https://youtu.be/U0mzoRAdjLM

episode 235. around the 15 minutes mark.

Originally posted by: Sainath-394-cid

Why can't they ever show Karishma solving a case all by herself? There are qualified officers in MPT other than HM , the writers tend to forget this all the time...

star saviour complex I guess. it really weakens the rest of the characters if you think about it.

like one would think that they are all lost without haseena there to steer the boat in the right direction but they really aren't. at least, we dont have an indication of it. that would mean that we witness the station being in an abysmal condition, unsolved cases piling up, discord amongst colleagues, frequent meltdowns of the characters and then finally getting themselves together to do their jobs. they are simply replacing urmilla with haseena and doing things that were previously established as status quo. I should probably just make a new topic for this XD lol.

Originally posted by: Sainath-394-cid

I think the case will end mid episode on Monday....so I guess chandramukhi Chautala is going to make her entry in Tuesday's episode....I saw in interview where kavita Kaushik ma'am said that she's there for only 1 episode :( so it will be an utter waste of she's introduced midway in Monday's episode...

So many of us are so frustrated by how things are going. even the TRP dipped again. The only way I am still enjoying the show is by not looking at the technicalities anymore and completely forgetting about the mission just as the show's writer has forgotten so conveniently. I am also excited about the Chandramukhi Chautala track. I started watching FIR on youtube coz I liked her personality and aura so much. I never knew such a show existed and am enjoying it 😆

I think they meant she will be on the show for a single story and usually, a single story is about 2.5 to 3 episodes so we will see her. Am guessing in their excitement they said one episode rather than one story.

Originally posted by: rinki_99

i...am speechless at the progression- or lack thereof- in the storyline. I am going to believe that everyone on the team had collective amnesia and thus have forgotten that they need to solve a murder case. even that is a stretch since they seem to remember that urmilla is not haseena...but then proceed to follow her orders as though she is. yea no I am not going down that rabbit hole.

the past 2 episodes were filler ones and were funny here and there. I would have enjoyed it better if Karishma was leading it instead of what we got (haseena inspired by billu to solve the case). I agree with Deepika di that bua saas could have been a game-changer move. in this particular case about working women, she and Pushpa Ji for that matter have much more at stake than anyone else on the team. the emotional weight they could carry through this case would have been fantastic to watch. instead, they are yet again running around- literally this time- playing doubles because it's funny apparently.

as for the flirting, I would bet my last dollar that it would be used as a comic element for everyone to laugh off after all is said and done. santu's maasumiyat are pretty few and far in between nowadays so it won't really have much of an impact.

Am trying my level best to have selective memory of things and act like a total Ghajini so that I don't get worked up about the forgotten mission track. They ruined the bua-saas sequence for me by making it a typical saas-bahu conflict. If I had been interested in seeing that I would have seen any other show for such a concept. Every other show on every other channel has that. There was absolutely no creativity or newness in that storyline and such a strong actress's (bua saas) talent has gone to waste. I was really hoping this case to be only of Karishma Singh's and Puchpee's but as usual, Billu inspired HM is back in action. These days Haseena's approach to cases is so lax even in sensitive issues. It's almost like she, herself forgets that she is HM and not Urmila. I don't know if the point here is to give the MPT a chance to do their own gig before she jumps in to save the day or what? and even if it is for this reason, this just makes the MPT members seem more and more incompetent. Honestly, the only character that has been shown to have grown in terms of the profession has been Santu. With her Maddam Sir's death, her masumiyat has been killed too. She is now much wiser, more comprehensive and more understanding of situations and the sweetest part is shown whenever she is guiding Urmila about how to be a good police officer. I do miss the masoom Santu though.

Originally posted by: Chir-Cute

So many of us are so frustrated by how things are going. even the TRP dipped again. The only way I am still enjoying the show is by not looking at the technicalities anymore and completely forgetting about the mission just as the show's writer has forgotten so conveniently. I am also excited about the Chandramukhi Chautala track. I started watching FIR on youtube coz I liked her personality and aura so much. I never knew such a show existed and am enjoying it 😆

I think they meant she will be on the show for a single story and usually, a single story is about 2.5 to 3 episodes so we will see her. Am guessing in their excitement they said one episode rather than one story.

@bold; Yeah that's possible...hope she's there for like atleast 3 episodes.

Originally posted by: Chir-Cute

Am trying my level best to have selective memory of things and act like a total Ghajini so that I don't get worked up about the forgotten mission track. They ruined the bua-saas sequence for me by making it a typical saas-bahu conflict. If I had been interested in seeing that I would have seen any other show for such a concept. Every other show on every other channel has that. There was absolutely no creativity or newness in that storyline and such a strong actress's (bua saas) talent has gone to waste. I was really hoping this case to be only of Karishma Singh's and Puchpee's but as usual, Billu inspired HM is back in action.

These days Haseena's approach to cases is so lax even in sensitive issues. It's almost like she, herself forgets that she is HM and not Urmila. I don't know if the point here is to give the MPT a chance to do their own gig before she jumps in to save the day or what? and even if it is for this reason, this just makes the MPT members seem more and more incompetent.

Honestly, the only character that has been shown to have grown in terms of the profession has been Santu. With her Maddam Sir's death, her masumiyat has been killed too. She is now much wiser, more comprehensive and more understanding of situations and the sweetest part is shown whenever she is guiding Urmila about how to be a good police officer. I do miss the masoom Santu though.

@ bold: I agree di. they honestly didn't need manju and clan to be part of it. bua saas alone would have been enough to raise the stakes. I am not good at stories but here is my two rupees ka idea.

bua saas comes to Lucknow and sure; Pushpa Ji lies because she wants approval. then show us what difference it makes to her life. does she become more confident, self-assured, open to people or change the way she sees things? why is this approval and support system so important to her?

Karishma being the person she is comes clean to bua saas about their profession. that naturally creates conflicts of interest between Karishma and Pushpa Ji. without any outside influences, they try to navigate around their clashes, solves their issues and understand each other better through assertive communication (just like what we saw them do) thus strengthening their bond, giving a message to the audience or whatever cheesiness they want to add. then, they work together, scratch that, Pushpa Ji leads this case and solves it.

what does that achieve? killing two birds with one stone. first, they get to stretch this track while keeping the audience hooked by showing the personal lives of existing characters (people we care about) rather than new entries every week that I couldn't be bothered about. second, Pushpa Ji achieves her dreams of leading a case before retirement.

@italics: LMAO. The urmilla charade has become so irrelevant and pointless in the grand scheme of things that they need her to do stupid things like manhandle manju and lead cases to keep it relevant. yet, it makes no sense. why in God's name would she manhandle Manju? why would MPT even let her do that? I am going down the rabbit hole again but why does she need to jump into everything they do? like Karishma and Pushpa Ji could have handled their relative on their own. she didn't need to introduce a twin sister story. as cheetah would say: nahi pata ka karna hain toh chup raho na yaar. and can they please set boundaries? just a tiny scene where Karishma reminds her and themselves that she is NOT haseena and does NOT need to interfere in their matters. because I don't care about what the audience knows. the characters do not know who she really is. so why they are letting a supposed street vendor who has no knowledge in policing interfere in their work?

@underline: I am in consensus with this. my masoomiyat has grown so much and although I couldn't be prouder, I do wish uff! yeh massomiyat stayed consistent. the way she guides urmilla reminds me so much of the way she handled the junior (arna IIRC) that was assigned to her during the bomb plotline. that maturity seems to have surfaced permanently after losing someone important to her.

Today's episode was okay.....loved how Pushpa ji and Karishma stood up for each other...