Maddam Sir - EDT #1 - CLOSED! - Page 37

Originally posted by: Anee2

Yea I didn't even want to get started on this. They're hell bent on acting as if nothing big has happened with anubhav's death. We're being forced to return to the post-HM's-death 'normal'. If that means making everyone dumb, making karishma look like she's the one with memory loss, so be it. Who cares eh.

I don't expect 20 episodes of Karishma crying and lamenting over the fact that she killed Anubhav or Haseena explaining every tiny detail. But even an episode or two where they just closed all this down properly was enough.

Originally posted by: Minionite

I don't expect 20 episodes of Karishma crying and lamenting over the fact that she killed Anubhav or Haseena explaining every tiny detail. But even an episode or two where they just closed all this down properly was enough.

Forget episode, a fleeting expression or change in dialogue delivery would be enough at this point. Yahaan chehre ki ek lakeer nahi badli.

Originally posted by: Anee2

Forget episode, a fleeting expression or change in dialogue delivery would be enough at this point. Yahaan chehre ki ek lakeer nahi badli.

Exactly. And I can understand when Karishma fired, why there was nothing on her face. She had seen Anubhav try to kill her and now she saw him trying to kill Urmila. Her duty kicked in. She needed to save Urmila that's all. But what about after that? Nothing? HOW?

Okay I'll be brutally honest that this was the worst episode of MS till date. I won't even rate it 0.

Why was everything so rushed up? Is it only me who felt the episode was complete cold and boring. The characters liked any emotions for anyone at all.

It hurts to state but I didn't feel anything when Anubhav was shot dead by Karishma. No feeling of hurt, anger or sympathy was felt by me because the scene lacked any emotions at all.

How can Karishma move on without sparing a glance at Anubhav's lifeless body lying on floor.

Then coming to hospital scene. What the hell did they show? When Karishma revealed that Urmilla might actually be Haseena, why did MPT members lack any reaction, not even shock. Forget about being happy or hurt, they weren't even shocked. It seemed as if it didn't matter at all.

And they also didn't have any reaction on Anubhav's death. At least I expected something from Pushpa Ji to console Karishma. Why were character so emotionless towards Anubhav, Hassena and Karishma. The lack of concern did bother me.

Is Karishma that dumb that she isn't able to recognize HM even now. How can a streets side vendor operate a gun with so much of perfection? RIP logic!

And forced comedy from Cheetoshpa and that doctor just irritated me more.

The only light-hearted scene I found was scene between DSP and Haseena when he was trying to make her recognize me.

Today's episode was utter disappointment and I did not have ounce of emotions for any characters at all. Might be because characters themselves lacked it.

And this Ekta's theory of memory loss is adding fuel to fire. Why can't they just bring HM back and end all this. Are they going to drag for next year?

Originally posted by: Sainath-394-cid

What the hell....looks like they skipped a bunch of episodes...

KS had a blank expression when killing Anubhav....no angst nothing?

She could've just said yes and then could've gotten unconscious

Why do these 3 idiots think that she's Urmila....just do the F'ing DNA test with Haseena and her ammi already...speaking of ammi where did she disappear? Why are these people hell bent in proving that she's Urmila? 😡😡😡😡

Yeh kaisa doctor hai? Akela mat chodo....."memory cells are affected" in medical terms memory cells refer to disease immunity....was that even a hospital? He just took a look in her eyes and talked about memory loss.....this was not even a half assed attempt at writing a scene

What sort of a stupid plan is this , pyar mein phasao , sab yaad ajaayega? Just show her pics with Anubhav and the MPT team

Karishma didn't even mourn for Anubhav :(

HM didn't remember when Anubhav's name was dropped but remembered Vada pav 🤣

Loved how Pushpaji spoke like Urmila

First time in MS history that the bald dsp mentioned Anubhav's name , otherwise both of them behaved like they were from parallel universes and didn't even know each other....

Recently we've been seeing so much of illogical stuff that I forgot when a police officer is killed an enquiry session happens....

DSP foodie is back , hmm...

Maybe Haseena will realise she's Haseena during the enquiry thing...

Precap was....rough

Loved Santu's dialogue about how chita is behaving like a broken record....he's developed some guts ever since the fake marriage case...

Today's episode 3/10 ( even the 3 was grace marks only)

At least you rated 3! Only if we had negative ratings😔

I won't comment much on today's episode. Just one line entire episode lacked any emotions at all. It was plain boring today!

Originally posted by: Sainath-394-cid

Idk how they'll get the truth out of HM at this state.....the only other person who knows the entire truth and can vouch for HM is Bakshi sir....but ks and the rest of the team doesn't even know that he exists , plus I think he left the country like he said in Friday's episode....

Hope makers don't show Bakshi revealing the truth at all when he is root cause of this track. Please keep him away from MPT. The man has always been a bad news.

I want truth to either come out of Haseena herself or MPT investigating it themselves.

Originally posted by: Anee2

@bold - These things made me almost tear up. The pure insensitivity with which writers have handled this character's end (even if its not the actual end) is disturbing. Not a single flicker of shock or pain on a single character's face. Anubhav has literally turned into 'just another criminal' for everyone. You knew this guy, some of you were closely related to him! Do you have no questions, no sadness, nothing? The only thing you care about is the legal formalities? How does karishma talk about his death so easily within hours of the shootout. Even months after anubhav left the engagement, haseena couldn't think about him without tearing up.

This episode felt like I was coming out of a funeral and someone suddenly dragged me to go watch a circus as if nothing happened. At best I could only smile half-heartedly. At worst I was rolling my eyes, cringing, and doing a face palm. Mostly though I was sitting as blank and tired as memory-lost HM. Drained.

I'd rate it 2/10. 2 for the two scenes I think kinda smiled at - doctor's nonsense and HM being so out of it.

The only thing I liked was scene between DSP and Haseena. It was kinda funny. Apart from that a big zero!

I am so so so so...just at a loss of words. what did I just watch?

I didn't think anee and my prediction would be so on point but they really swore on making it so lacklustre.

minor issues like the editing of the bullet grazing haseena's forehead being so poorly done and so out of sync I can ignore. It's ITV, I dont expect such realistic graphics.

but the script? what was even going on. the tone and sequencing have changed so drastically adn abruptly...what is even happening. Karishma shoots anubhav and then just stares out into space as if nothing happened. maybe it's a shock, okay fine I'll accept that.

but what about after the whole shot-out sequence was done. haseena just got shot and is in the hospital, where is her mother? the doctor doesn't even know what he is doing. they slipped in a line about "how is kamil (the doctor's wife)". for what? we don't care and neither should they.

how is Karishma so nonchalant having just killed her brother? where is the pain, guilt and sadness when she narrated the incident to the other three? how are the others not having any reaction to that? I admit they weren't particularly close but he was still someone they interacted with. hell, they were playing cupid for and doing his engagement preparations. this man was like a son for Pushpa Ji. their concern isn't, "omg anubhav did what now?", it is "urmilla cannot be maddam sir." even that is a dumb thing to say because really, why are they still thinking this is urmilla?

FFS how are they so stupid. Karishma heard her confession first hand with a poem that maddam sir said before and Santosh pointed out that urmilla doesn't know how to hold a gun or pull the trigger. even a nursery graduate can put two and two together. how are these grown ass adults- cops- not able to figure it out.

like sainath pointed out, just get a damned DNA test done. but I assume that isn't possible because Noor Jahan has gone missing once again.

Originally posted by: rinki_99

I am so so so so...just at a loss of words. what did I just watch?

I didn't think anee and my prediction would be so on point but they really swore on making it so lacklustre.

minor issues like the editing of the bullet grazing haseena's forehead being so poorly done and so out of sync I can ignore. It's ITV, I dont expect such realistic graphics.

but the script? what was even going on. the tone and sequencing have changed so drastically adn abruptly...what is even happening. Karishma shoots anubhav and then just stares out into space as if nothing happened. maybe it's a shock, okay fine I'll accept that.

but what about after the whole shot-out sequence was done. haseena just got shot and is in the hospital, where is her mother? the doctor doesn't even know what he is doing. they slipped in a line about "how is kamil (the doctor's wife)". for what? we don't care and neither should they.

how is Karishma so nonchalant having just killed her brother? where is the pain, guilt and sadness when she narrated the incident to the other three? how are the others not having any reaction to that? I admit they weren't particularly close but he was still someone they interacted with. hell, they were playing cupid for and doing his engagement preparations. this man was like a son for Pushpa Ji. their concern isn't, "omg anubhav did what now?", it is "urmilla cannot be maddam sir." even that is a dumb thing to say because really, why are they still thinking this is urmilla?

FFS how are they so stupid. Karishma heard her confession first hand with a poem that maddam sir said before and Santosh pointed out that urmilla doesn't know how to hold a gun or pull the trigger. even a nursery graduate can put two and two together. how are these grown ass adults- cops- not able to figure it out.

like sainath pointed out, just get a damned DNA test done. but I assume that isn't possible because Noor Jahan has gone missing once again.

The episode lacked any direction and execution at all. There was nothing, literally nothing good about today's episode.

Forget about Anubahv or Haseena being back, someone bring Heman Sir back please. Because if this continues, show will lose its loyal audience as well.

Today itself I mentioned no matter what crap do they throw at us, I cannot leave this show as I'm smitten by the actors. I take those words back.

If this is what will be level of direction and writing, love for cast won't be able to hold many audiences for long. Even kids write better stories than this.

Originally posted by: LogicLover

Okay I'll be brutally honest that this was the worst episode of MS till date. I won't even rate it 0.

I would've said the same if I had brought my brains to this episode. I had prepared myself that a 0 rating must now be the new 10. So my 2/10 is on that renewed scale.

Why was everything so rushed up? Is it only me who felt the episode was complete cold and boring. The characters liked any emotions for anyone at all.

No, it's definitely not just you. When I said I almost teared up, it was precisely because of how cold all the characters were, and how dull the episode was. Are these the same characters I fell in love with, is this the same show that promotes juzzbaat? My eyes just couldn't believe it.

It hurts to state but I didn't feel anything when Anubhav was shot dead by Karishma. No feeling of hurt, anger or sympathy was felt by me because the scene lacked any emotions at all.

I didn't either, because neither anubhav or karishma emoted anything. One bullet, he fell and that's it, no aftermath. Why did they even bother with a dramatic top-down shot, there was nothing we could relate to about this dead man lying there.

How can Karishma move on without sparing a glance at Anubhav's lifeless body lying on floor.

It was only in hindsight, once the scene shifted to the hospital, that I realized how coldly karishma reacted. Sure she fired on instinct seeing anubhav with the gun. But after the realization that he's dead, he was your brother, he was your chachi's son, he became a traitor and did so wrong... Yukti's words in the latest interview are ringing in my head 'you have to move on after someone betrays you'. Yes eventually, but I can't believe writers really did make karishma move on within seconds.

Then coming to hospital scene. What the hell did they show? When Karishma revealed that Urmilla might actually be Haseena, why did MPT members lack any reaction, not even shock. Forget about being happy or hurt, they weren't even shocked. It seemed as if it didn't matter at all.

And they also didn't have any reaction on Anubhav's death. At least I expected something from Pushpa Ji to console Karishma. Why were character so emotionless towards Anubhav, Hassena and Karishma. The lack of concern did bother me.

Is Karishma that dumb that she isn't able to recognize HM even now. How can a streets side vendor operate a gun with so much of perfection? RIP logic!

I was numb through this all, probably because the realization hit me right then. That they will forcefully continue the urmila track as if nothing changed. In that case, of course all emotion and logic have to be covered up. They will talk about facts and be ignorant about it in the very next second, because any thinking means progress means resolution. And we're in a dragfest. More than bothered, I was disappointed that writers sacrificed such good characters just to stretch the plot.

And forced comedy from Cheetoshpa and that doctor just irritated me more.

These scenes made me smile, only because I had joked about some nonsense like this happening right before the episode. It was a smile of passive aggression towards the makers, like really hey, you're really resorting to this, brilliant.

The only light-hearted scene I found was scene between DSP and Haseena when he was trying to make her recognize me.

Yea, this was the only grace, and forced me to smile with sadness. Bechaare kitni koshishein kar rahe hai humein hasaane ki with the memory loss track. But phir bhi, yeh bakwaas band karo jaldi.

Today's episode was utter disappointment and I did not have ounce of emotions for any characters at all. Might be because characters themselves lacked it.

Definitely.

And this Ekta's theory of memory loss is adding fuel to fire. Why can't they just bring HM back and end all this. Are they going to drag for next year?

Why does it feel like actors really want this to drag because they are enjoying urmila so much. I know they don't have a say ultimately, but seems their prayers are being answered more than ours.

my thoughts in bold