I dont like them but it wasnt fair... - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

52

Views

4.4k

Users

27

Frequent Posters

soni_a thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#31
I agree. She is a brilliant actress but she is so biased and unfair. Even her comments about unfair treatment to muslims because she didn't get a flat in mumbai in a recent statement recieved a lot of flak. 🤢
Now she has lost all respect on this show too. Even if the contestants are childish and petty, she could have remained dignified and cool. But what she did to save her contestant was very gross.
It was obvious that what she and Naman did was preplanned.
She has started a very bad trend. All judges will follow it and any contestant can be in danger zone according to any of the judges whim now. 😡
sal44 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#32
0KKK i see people are saying

oh why did she give puneet a 1 when he didnt d0 anythingg..

okk keep in mind that the judges have been tolerating him since day 1 and there c0mes a point when they have had ENOUGH...

soo whatever she did was justified.. she doesnt have to be all nice and fakee she did what she thought was right and giving them a 1 she proved to all the contestants that they cant f00l around like that for no reason at allllllllllll.

and f0r the ppl saying she just did it beacause of naman,,

thats not true cuz she even said if she had the chance of giving him a mark she wouldve given him a 1 also..


and naman isnt even at faultt.

he wasnt the one acting up like mayank..

he was actually pretty calm untill the point where no one could take it anym0re.

so thats why naman acted up..


SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 17 years ago
#33

I don't agree with u, I feel what Shabana Aazmi was a lesson for them, coz they don't stop fighting, they bring personal lives on stage which is totally irriatting, judges gave them so many chances, but they don't even respect them at all, if they do respect them, they would never fight and bring things behind the scene on the stage!!!!!!!, I apperciate what Shabana Aazmi did regarding Puneet - Twinkle and Mayank - Krittika's scores!!!!!!!........

They think that only viewers can save them, if it's like this, why the judges are sitting there so???????, the judgements is 50/50 matlab both viewers and judges are involved in it!!!!!!!, I think the judges told them many times earlier to stop fighting, but they it shows that they don't listen at all and don't respect what the judges said!!!!!!!, if the judges don't put limit for it, then who would do it INSHALLAH????????.........
sweet_JAY_FAN thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#34
^ but in that episode Puneet wasnt the problem
Mayank was
sal44 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#35
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^


PUNEET HAS BEEN THE PROBLEM ON ALL THE OTHER EPISODES..
FROM THE FIRST DAYY

MAYBE SHE JUSS FELT LIKE GIVING HIM A LESSON.!!!!

ITS NEVER TOO LATE



SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 17 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: sweet_JAY_FAN

^ but in that episode Puneet wasnt the problem

Mayank was

Puneet too was the problem, infact he did support Mayank's fight, which kind of making the problem to bigger!!!!!!.......
pksanam thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#37
also, at the end of the last episode, twinkle said 'apparently the judges score aren't making ANY difference'.. that shows disrespect.. so what are the judges doing there.. it is afterall, 50% audience votes and 50% judges scores..
so ofcourse, it is a lesson for them that the scores ALSO matter..! tp didn't show any respect so that had to happen to them.. if is totally fair.. someone of shabana ji's caliber doesn't has to listen to this bs.. she is far above that..
Edited by pksanam - 17 years ago
sweet104 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#38

this is regarding T-P scores. i think it was completely fair to give them 1 by shabana azmi ji. the show was getting really out of control. someone needed to put them right. i'm glad that it was done at right time. this should apply to every1 and i think all the judges should do the same. this is the only way we can watch the show in one piece!!👏

sweet_JAY_FAN thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#39
well u guys make good points but I would never give them a ONE
Puneet as we have seen has been far far worsein many other episodes so why ddi Shabanaji choose to do it now when he is improving?
Okay I dont blame her for giving it there becuz she is probably sick of there natak and set them in their place--thats fine with me
But u have to think abt their partners too
Kritika is one of the sweetest girl in the show
somebody even said that she is eliminated this week, which if she is, is mostly becuzof Shabanaji
Twinkle is not good like Kritika but I agree with her when she asked why she had to be punished with Puneet. She dodnt do anythng wrong.
Puneet and Mayank are at fault. This is a JODI show- so u should think abt two ppl before u give the scores Shabanaji. If Mayank was casuing problems ans she wanted to set him in his place then she shouldve looked at Kritika--Kritika did not deserve a ONE.
This is a big ticket to win and judges scores count 50%
Kritika is now forced to suffer becuz of her partners mediocrerness
Now this is my POV why they shouldnt have gotten a one
Shabanaji couldve found another way to punish P-M without involving T-K. Okay most of u will say Twinkle should be involved in the punishment but not in any way should Kritika be involved. Her partner is at fault.
If Kritika is eliminated Mayank Gandhi and Shabanaji deserve the blame
SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 17 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: sweet_JAY_FAN

well u guys make good points but I would never give them a ONE

Puneet as we have seen has been far far worsein many other episodes so why ddi Shabanaji choose to do it now when he is improving?
Do u really feel that he is improving???????? 😲, well about Shabana Aazmi's scores to Puneet, he did alots of interfering and making problems bigger by interfering!!!!!!.......
Okay I dont blame her for giving it there becuz she is probably sick of there natak and set them in their place--thats fine with me
Exactly!!!!!!........
But u have to think abt their partners too
Kritika is one of the sweetest girl in the show
I didn't like the way she did make the problem of Sanyogeta so big, she did told Mihika and didn't dare to say it her self, she told Mihika about what Sanyogeta that she said like this and this to the dress man, which I really didn't like about her!!!!!!!.......
somebody even said that she is eliminated this week, which if she is, is mostly becuzof Shabanaji
I don't think so it's coz of Shabna Aazmi, I think that Judges did tolerate them all so much, Kritika as I said was one of the people who made the problem of Sanyogeta bigger by talking behind her to Mihika!!!!!!!.......
Twinkle is not good like Kritika but I agree with her when she asked why she had to be punished with Puneet. She dodnt do anythng wrong.
Twinkle did too said so many bad comments to Sanyogeta last time, she even said kind of threat to Sanyogeta, I still remember that she said to Sanyogeta ''Mihika is so sweet, but u can't mess with me!!!!!'', it was kind of threat, and she contiuned later on after the scores by saying bad comments to Naman, I felt that Shabana Aazmi gave them scores not only for the thing they did in this episode!!!!!!!, they did repeat it many times!!!!!!!.......
Puneet and Mayank are at fault. This is a JODI show- so u should think abt two ppl before u give the scores Shabanaji. If Mayank was casuing problems ans she wanted to set him in his place then she shouldve looked at Kritika--Kritika did not deserve a ONE.
I think even their partners deserve these scores for the reason I already gave above!!!!!!!.......
This is a big ticket to win and judges scores count 50%
Kritika is now forced to suffer becuz of her partners mediocrerness
I think they both did many of mistakes!!!!!!!!!........
Now this is my POV why they shouldnt have gotten a one
Shabanaji couldve found another way to punish P-M without involving T-K. Okay most of u will say Twinkle should be involved in the punishment but not in any way should Kritika be involved. Her partner is at fault.
As u said the viewers votes count, Kritika is not yet eliminated with her partners, but as far I see it, both viewers and judges should be at least respected, they did make alots of fights in the stage, do u really expect the viewers and judges to keep silent????????......
If Kritika is eliminated Mayank Gandhi and Shabanaji deserve the blame
I think if any is eliminated so it the person's own mistake, not any other's mistake!!!!!!!.......

I commented on red, no offence, but these are my POV!!!!!!!!!!........

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".