my comments are in blue and closing remarks are at the end after the quote (in black)😆:
Originally posted by: neha_bbsr2005
Major Nair is justified because Alekh had broken KMA's discipline by setting fire in the academy..In real life there are more severe punishments for this act. - agreed neha that aalekh broke kma's rules ... but the punisment maj nair has given him is inhumane .... i know that someone might argue as he did to abhi that the battle ground is worse .... but the point is that kma is a pre-nda academy and a first year cadet - actually orderly at the moment - should not be treated that harshly .... the kind of punishment maj nair gave aalekh is the kind that gets scrutinized everyday .... there are so many stories coming out of guantanamo bay, afghanistan and iraq of troops treating the prisoners inhumanely .... just think about it .... if these troops are in violation of the un's ethical standards in their treatment of prisoners who are terrorists, murderers, rapists, and god only knows what else .... how can major nair be justified in dishing out this punishment to a cadet/orderly in an academy? .... another point that could be brought up is the fact that when an army officer is caught by the enemy, they are tortured and they must be able to endure it and not give up their country's secrets ..... and i guess major nair would be justified in that sense ..... but again, considering that this is a pre-nda academy .... its too early for the cadets to be exposed to this when they haven't been fully given the training to endure it .... i mean other than the temperature drop chamber the cadets really haven't been put through torture endurance training - Major Nair must be thinking that Alekh-Neelu's story has harmed KMA's reputation as a civilian Mr.Sahni said bad things about KMA. - i have to disagree here neha .... i think maj nair would actually be happy about this because technically the aalekh-neelu thing would have happened while he was away and while bc was still in charge .... technically he could use this as the final nail in bc's coffin and get him permanently thrown out of kma .... and i really don't think maj nair has any feelings for mr. sahini since his son is technically an abandoner as bc said - Major Nair is not bad from heart.He is strict and that too for the betterment of his cadets. - honestly neha, i gotta disagree here too .... we've actually seen proof that maj nair is bad at heart .... just look at the way he helped maj bhargav frame raj and naina .... that was before the whole nair-bhagao operation .... and considering the fact that these cadets were the ones who got him temporarily suspened .... i don't think his treatment of these cadets has anything to do with being strict and everything to do with taking out his personal differences - Unfortunately Alekh was at the receiving end today.He also asked Alekh to explain why did he did it.If Alekh had given the reasons he would have leave him because his friends are at fault who broke the discipline by going out of KMA. - okay now bringing back the point i made earlier about being tortured if caught by the enemy .... the fact that aalekh stood his ground proves that he would be a good soldier since he'd be able to keep his country's secrets a secret .... but again i don't think this punishment was correct for the level of training that these cadets have received thus far - It was not Alekh's fault anyways.But I would have happier if Major Nair had punished Yudi too.He also rang up the fire alarm.I think he informed Major Nair about the incident,so that Alekh gets in trouble.So blame Yudi.😡 😡 😡 😡 - well firstly, don't worry .... i'm pretty sure that sadly yudi ka number bhi aayega😕 ... if maj nair has his way ... sab cadets, raj, abhi, suriji, bc, lolita, aur shalini ke numbers bhi aayenge .... phir academy mein sirf woh aur navin ka bhoot rahenge😆 .... but seriously we can't be sure that yudi said anything .... i know he's upset with aalekh, but i think he or at least i hope and pray that he knows that by doing that to aalekh he risked getting his other friends and himself in trouble - Major Nair is not antaryami that he'll get the info..Yudi must have told him about it or else how will Major Nair know about it..😡 - okay i know that maj nair is not psychic .... but remember he said that he was keeping his eye on pooja and the other cadets .... i'm sure that includes aalekh ... plus, from what we've seen maj nair is pretty good at putting two and two together .... this man knows what's going on in the academy and the fact that four cadets are missing - remember he has lolita ma'am keeping tabs on pooja and naina so i'm sure he makes her take daily attendance😆 - and maj nair is smart enough to see that the fire couldn't have been spontaneous ... otherwise why would he have automatically taken aalekh's name to handle the fire alone - aren't fires put out by fire-fighters not orderlies😕 .... so it isn't necessary that yudi told him .... i'm not saying he did or didn't - although i hope for my sake yudi-boy didn't .... but really it isn't necessary for nair to be psychic to figure this all out -
okay .... now neha ... 🤗 .... i disagreed with most of what you said but i know what you probably meant by this post ... i know you admire maj nair for his discipline and strictness .... don't forget i loved the way maj nair was in season one as well .... strict .... exactly what a military academy needs .... but even then he wasn't "good at heart" (example about setting up naina and raj above - that was spurely to vent out his personal differences with raj - i'm sure he disapproved of the way bc bent the rules for raj and not for him - remember how bc once told major nair that he was only the "vice"-principal of kma so he didn't have complete authority .... but bc would let raj get away with certain things - i'm sure maj nair was upset with that) .... but ever since season two started and maj nair has returned .... his character has become much much much more vindictive .... he's out to get everyone who had a hand in getting him suspended ... be it the cadets who planned and executed everything, bc who believed the cadets over him, raj who felt that maj nair deserved what he got, and even suriji, lolita ma'am, and dr shalini who helped the cadets on different occasions (although lolita ma'am didn't explicitly ever help them as far as i remember😕 .... i think he just sorta grouped her together with suriji who did help them😆)
Cricket
