Did Naina have to tell Maj Bhargav...

her friends' plans. Knowing Maj Bhargav's nature and how hellish he could make life for the cadets, she went ahead and told him of their plan, just to prove how loyal she is to the system. These are the very same friends who are more against the major for his rude treatment towards Naina.

Nowadays I just don't seem to understand Naina at all. On one hand she keeps yelling on how she will face any given situation and on the other hand she fumbles at every task given to her and needs CApt. Rajveer's help and support on everything. Even a dimwit like pooja could hold the rope and save the load from falling on their mentor's head, but Naina had to tumble !!!!

The only bravest thing she did was to stand by her belief that her brother was not a traitor.

I had a different image of Naina but everytime she really lets everyone down.

Michelle

m sry but i beg 2 differ...
naina told bhargav...but bhargav has NO PROOF...its nt like hes gone n recorded wat naina sed..
n ya...he really was scared wen naina told him dat...n frankly....shes landed herself into more trouble den ne1 else..
nainas seen how terrible it is wen ne1 misuses d system..shes faced it, which is why she dint want her frnds doing d same...she dusnt want even her worst enemy to go thru wat she did..
QUOTE]

Sorry, but this doesn't justify her action of squealing on what her friends were about to do to Bhargava. I am talking of trust here. If she did the wise thing of stopping her friends from getting into trouble, it should have been just between her and her friends. Whether Bhargav has proof or no, whether he'll harass the cadets or no, whether she'll get into trouble or not, all that is not relevant. The point here is Naina did not keep her friends' trust !! Inspite of Capt. Rajveer and Alekh knew of her brother's identity, they kept it a secret right through.

Talking about misusing the system, Naina doesn't have to worry as much as the other cadets as long as her favourite and ever helpful and strong support system is there - Capt. Rajveer !!

Michelle

Originally posted by: coolgirl_13

m sry but i beg 2 differ...
naina told bhargav...but bhargav has NO PROOF...its nt like hes gone n recorded wat naina sed..
n ya...he really was scared wen naina told him dat...n frankly....shes landed herself into more trouble den ne1 else..
nainas seen how terrible it is wen ne1 misuses d system..shes faced it, which is why she dint want her frnds doing d same...she dusnt want even her worst enemy to go thru wat she did..
n as 4 her failing in d tests...dusnt every1 need a support? so, naina needs rajs support..is dat so bad? naina stood up 4 her bro..she dint need ne1s support 4 dat did she?
n even wen she fell during d rope test..ne1 culd hav fallen...even pooja culd hav..wats important is dat she dint jus fail or jus sit n cry in desperation..she went ahead n saved raj...
as 4 raj n naina romancing..has naina ever dun dat? if deir eyes speak luv, its nt deir fault...naina herself has denied dat she luvs ne1 2 huda...which means dat shes nt pushing it...luv happens..n u cant really stop it..

m sry if i hurt ne1 ...its jus my point of view..

Originally posted by: mich09

nainas nt worried...frankly....naina wuld hav gained d most if bhargav was suspended..coz shes d one hes basically out 2 suspend....n she wuld hav gt a nice revenge...

she dint let dem do wat dey did coz she dint like misusing d system..sumthin dat she herself is fiting against..how cool wuld it be if she fought against sumthing n den went ahead n used d very same thing 2 help herself...