Mishal not speaking up is hurtful

TheRager thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Now you guys might be wondering aaj ise kya ho gaya...but frankly speaking I havent been able to get the whole LTL offscreen saga out of my head till now. The saga started last December with the first news appearing on Hindustan Times that Dutta will exit LTL. That piece which we at that time thought was a rumour turned true in four months time. Since then there were lots of media articles on Dutta's exit but we got nothing officially from anyone related to the show or MR. From gossip section of newspapers we majorly got two stories:
-Mishal had become a tantrum king on the sets and he was fired.
-Mishal had got some Bollywood offers and wanted to pursue films and he quit.
-Mishal quit as he was unhappy with his renumeration.
What's the truth? No one has come out officially on the same. So many questions remain unanswered like:
-Was Mishal fired due to tantrums or did he quit as he wanted to pursue films?
-Was Mishal really a tantrum king?
-Has Mishal really got some Bollywood films? If he is pursuing films why is there no news on the same? Even Mishal has denied doing any movie in couple of interviews. One interview he has expressed interest in rerturning to TV in another role. So news of him doing films is untrue?
-Was Mishal approached to return as Dutta again after trps of LTL fell post his exit? If yes why hasnt he returned if he is currently not having any acting job as he himself has said?
-Why is Mishal quiet for so long on his reasons for quitting when every media article paints him as a villian? Is it because the articles do hold some truth?
As a fan its hurtful that he hasnt bothered to clarify on anything related to LTL and stuck to a 'No comments' stance. Contrast that to some of the actors who had quit shows in recent times like for instance today's TOI carries an article on Sushant Singh Rajput taking an indefinite break from PR due to creative differences. Here is the article:
The article is logical and doesnt bad mouth anyone.
Nishant Malkani too is quitting his show Ram Milayi Jodi and he gave an interview to TOI saying he is quitting the show for films.
Yesterday there was another article on the show Looteri Dulhan where the whole cast has been eased out. The article also doesnt bad-mouth anyone and is logical:
So why cant we LTL fans be treated with some decency and get a proper article on the whole saga? Why isnt anyone ready to comment officially? If not that why atleast Mishal is not speaking up for the sake of the fans who have supported him thru all these malicious gossip. There has been so much malicious gossip abt him in the media but I have not a seen a single fan badmouth him here or on facebook. Doesnt he owe us a logical explaination? I am not asking him to badmouth anyone or take names...but atleast say something!

Created

Last reply

Replies

47

Views

5.8k

Users

25

Likes

239

Frequent Posters

yoyo2 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
YAAR SHREYA,,😃 I LOVE U FOR THIS, AT THIS MOMENT THAT IS ALL I CAN SAY,, tujhe kuch nahi huva, u r just being human, good thing u made this post,👏 ab sab log dil khol ke aone dil ke baat keh saqte hai yaha par,,,
-Ritz- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Nice post Kshreya.👍🏼 I wish he would speak and tell us what exactly happened but doesn't look like it'll ever happen. Even after reading countless articles bad mouthing him, we still support him. As more time passes, the more I want to know what exactly happened.

But I guess the mystery man has decided to let this be a mystery as well but it does hurt not knowing what exactly happened. 🥺 🥺


kabeeraspeaking thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Ksh, golmaal hai sab golmaal hai, as the phrase goes. I've felt the two sides of this issue too: irked at times with MR, especially with the no comments stance once that was in a TB article well AFTER 28th March that really got to me, but then at others, understanding that he'd rather stay silent than bring his problems with the channel and the people associated with it out into the public. But that cannot be reason alone not to clear yourself and simply say that this news is wrong or even confirm the exit by politely citing creative differences, which can all be done without badmouthing anyone else in the process. So, the reason why MR said nothing too, I think and IMO as I've said before, must have been as a favour to someone in the PH...for publicity's sake, to keep the speculation alive even well AFTER he was gone. Maybe a gesture of kindness and even pity on his part towards the PH, but unfair on the fans who were kept in an endless loop of uncertainty for an amazing amount of time and even now are bearing the brunt of it. Even the media was in on it, because they neither explicitly reported the exit and nor interviewed about it, when such is done so for all shows. Why? Because they were told so. Only little 'birdies' were let out to fan the flames and keep up the drama. All these people well in league with each other, and latke hue fans doosri taraf. What do to...nothing much that we could or can, then or now...

And I don't think we will get any answers either...would love to be proven wrong, but they were leading everyone on then, and now it has been a while, so it is a buried hatchet that will be marked as 'too old' to speak of.
rama_2010 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Oh Kshreya .. u hv mirrored my feelings...
even i am yet to get over all this messs... every morning i come here to get some news of / from MR... an i look fwd to ur post...
C this week we did not get the updated rankings... the last week of MR in the show we did not get Tam ratings... i hv even contacted the Indian television to update it... they say they wd do it but they still haven't... recently the way LCL is promoted by IF... all irks me to the core... n I feel PS is at his best... but am hoping things will change very soon...
I feel ... he not speaking directly on th eissue is good for him ... but we as fans are left shattered ... His saying he will come back... his heart burns for his fans... does not help much..
Hemalji's reply onthe TC article of 17th march and yesterday's gives me a bit of hope in a way thinking he is trying to get MR back at least to end the show... am sure the channel cannot continue with LCL beyond sep as its then BB starts... n even if SA comes as Dutta it wd only b for a short period...
Edited by rama_2010 - 14 years ago
kabeeraspeaking thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: rama_2010

Hemalji's reply onthe TB article of 17th march and yesterday's gives me a bit of hope in a way thinking he is trying to get MR back at least to end the show... am sure the channel cannot continue with LCL beyond sep as its then BB starts... n even if SA comes as Dutta it wd only b for a short period...


Hemal Thakkar has been the...I don't want to say pot-stirrer, because he hasn't, we know that was someone else...but this man has been the one in the position to know everything all along, yet he intentionally chose to give aloof statements to the media to keep stirring the speculation pot for all of those months and even afterwards. Aaj bhi if he is giving a quote in an interview, for ex. the one about Akshay not coming on the show, it's vague statements about not knowing or later 'updates'...he would honestly be the LAST person on whose words I would keep hanging. This man didn't bother clarifying at ANY point even though he was CONTACTED and quoted numerous times despite being the producer of the show. Yeh bhi koi baat hoti hai? Iss bande koi kabhi koi realization nahi hui ke he owes it to the fans who made his show to set the record straight? And if he is under constrains by the channel, why speak to the media at all? Why not remain absolutely invisible? Or is that he is not so closely associated with LTL anymore, since he hasn't 'known anything' concrete about it for forever? Again in that case, why allow the media to get in touch with you? *snorts* Hopeless case.
Edited by make-believe - 14 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

So why cant we LTL fans be treated with some decency and get a proper article on the whole saga?



Because LTL was never a regular show with a regular history of promotion in any form...so even the downfall ended up being unique...made as ugly as possible by the powers that be...the LTL fans are the last ppl they'd care to treat with decency since they never gave them much respect even during the prime of the show...I honestly have no expectations from anyone...this has all been such a long drawn out mentally exhausting drama to watch unfolding...all questions have now become redundant in my mind.

Would just love to see a Mishal interview, period...even if he doesn't speak about this issue which I doubt he will anyways.
-sourire- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
Bear with me, Ksh as I try to think through these questions you have put forth...which I have not really done before...tried to ignore it for the most part. 😆 Again, the stuff I am writing is just my POV and what I think of the whole situation...And this is for you to make you feel better...🤗

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

Now you guys might be wondering aaj ise kya ho gaya...but frankly speaking I havent been able to get the whole LTL offscreen saga out of my head till now. The saga started last December with the first news appearing on Hindustan Times that Dutta will exit LTL. That piece which we at that time thought was a rumour turned true in four months time. Since then there were lots of media articles on Dutta's exit but we got nothing officially from anyone related to the show or MR. From gossip section of newspapers we majorly got two stories:

-Mishal had become a tantrum king on the sets and he was fired.
-Mishal had got some Bollywood offers and wanted to pursue films and he quit.
-Mishal quit as he was unhappy with his renumeration.
What's the truth? No one has come out officially on the same. So many questions remain unanswered like:

-Was Mishal fired due to tantrums or did he quit as he wanted to pursue films?

Mishal fired due to his tantrums...I don't believe that. Not at all! And I am ready to challenge anyone who thinks otherwise about this tantrum bs. Excuse me for the language. Having seen his off- screen interviews including the ones that were LTL related, never once did I get a feeling of him being arrogant or snobbish because of the success he brought to LTL. His cheerfulness, jovial attitude, his humbleness is all that came across as I saw his interviews, repeatedly! I think even if a blind man has to make a basic judgement on him...he would come up with similar stuff that I have mentioned just by listening to his tone and the realistic approach he has towards things and life in general.

Did he quit because he wanted to pursue a career in films? I don't see anything wrong in this even if we go by this assumption for now. Everyone sets goals for themselves and wants to work harder to achieve them. So what if he has his Bollywood dreams in mind...does he not have a right to pursue them? He has already proved his potential in LTL over a stretch of almost a year. And if he thinks that the show could only give him so much to experiment with and thought that he needed to move on to bigger projects, then I don't see what is wrong in that. Ex: If I work as a manager in a small company and aim to be a CEO of my own company one day...I will have to look at better job prospects, meet new people, network to achieve that goal of mine...that position in that small company will only be able to provide me with limited resources. I think it's the same thing in his situation. Tellyworld and soaps are small...they can only provide so much to him...he is a person of much greater potential than what the Tellyworld is able to give. We, as an audience, might think it is a selfish thing on his behalf to leave a successful show in the middle because he wants to be in Bollywood...but just because we wish to see him, aren't we being selfish too?

-Was Mishal really a tantrum king?

No...NO...NOOO...NOOO! 😆

-Has Mishal really got some Bollywood films? If he is pursuing films why is there no news on the same? Even Mishal has denied doing any movie in couple of interviews. One interview he has expressed interest in rerturning to TV in another role. So news of him doing films is untrue?

I don't know if he has got any Bollywood films or not. But if he has denied the rumors of movie projects himself, shouldn't we take his word for it? And if he is considering returning to TV, then he must have put some thought behind it and might have gotten couple offers...I don't know. From what I have come to realize, he is very open about his work projects, mostly stuff he is currently working on...so if and when there is a confirmed movie project at hand and things have finalized to a greater extent, I am sure he wouldn't mind sharing it with his fans. I mean what good is a half true article, barely, with sources such as 'birdies' and 'khabroos' that make a bharta of bunch of incomplete facts and present it to us...then we end up spending hours here on IF speculating on its validity...so what good is all that? It's better to have confirmed news from people with real names. So we just have to be patient with things...I am sure it will pay off in the future. But on a different note...just because he is a celebrity now...why do we, as an audience, feel the need to know every little detail of his life...what is he doing now? Where is he vacationing or partying? What are his next plans? Does he not have any right to privacy? I feel as a true fan of his, I must and should respect his silence as much as his talks (can't think of a better word here 😆).



-Was Mishal approached to return as Dutta again after trps of LTL fell post his exit? If yes why hasnt he returned if he is currently not having any acting job as he himself has said?

Why should he return to a workplace where the people of 'higher' authority have no appreciation for his hard-work, are not able to give him due credit for his work...is that too much to ask for? If the environment is not sound and peaceful enough for him to work in with all the political hypocrisy that goes on...how is he suppose/going to concentrate on his work if he ends up getting caught in the mess intentionally or unintentionally. A person can only ignore the 'stuff' to a certain point...everyone reaches their saturation state sooner or later with the crap that goes on behind the screen...and when he thought he had reached that state, he made a wise decision and chose to leave rather than getting more caught up in this dirty showbiz. And he is very unique in the sense that he is not going to work just for the sake of earning money...he is one of those few people who puts lot of thought into his projects...accepts those that are meaningful and will take him a step further in life. With the stuff going on lately with Mr. Genius 'controlling' things...that would not have been possible. So what good was it going to do him returning to the sinking ship...just to save their back. Nope...he shouldn't...one doesn't have to be good all the time...it's alright to be 'selfish' (if that is what we, the audience, would like to call it) once in a while. 😆


-Why is Mishal quiet for so long on his reasons for quitting when every media article paints him as a villian? Is it because the articles do hold some truth?
As a fan its hurtful that he hasnt bothered to clarify on anything related to LTL and stuck to a 'No comments' stance.

I don't think the articles hold complete truth...you know that as much as I do that lot of these statements for the most part are very self-contradictory. Media will always keep their priorities on top (regardless of the type of news and the substance in it) which is to spice things up for more publicity, popularity etc. Staying mum on things has created so much of a fuss regarding his character and what not...can you just imagine what the gossip media might be capable of when they actually get their hands on some information...the 'tor maror' of words they are capable of...they have managed to malign his name in his silence...I can only imagine what the result will be if they are able to get their hands on other news info.

There is saying..."Ek chup, sau sukh" meaning, one silent moment can lead to hundred moments of happiness, can save you from lots of troubles...that's what the case is for him...he has maintained his 'No Comment' stance and personally for him that might have been one of the best decisions of his life. If I was in his shoes, I would stick to this old saying as well. When we start worrying about what others are going to say...it becomes a whole mess, one gets caught up in so many things. Duniya ka toh hai kaam tarah tarah kee baatein karna. Kis kis ka muh band karoge. It is better to shut your own mouth and let the duniya think whatever they want to...who cares, right? 😆

I understand your and other people's hurtfulness regarding his 'No Comment' stance...but we have to understand that he is an individual with different beliefs and takes on things. If he is not comfortable sharing the off-screen stuff...be it for his own good or to respect the privacy of the situation, the people...why should we indulge on this thought more than we should. We must respect his decision. The other individuals you have mentioned, who have opened up about their work, might be comfortable doing it...MR might be not. Just because others are doing it and then expecting the same from MR...I don't think that's fair/appropriate.


So why cant we LTL fans be treated with some decency and get a proper article on the whole saga?Why isnt anyone ready to comment officially? If not that why atleast Mishal is not speaking up for the sake of the fans who have supported him thru all these malicious gossip. There has been so much malicious gossip abt him in the media but I have not a seen a single fan badmouth him here or on facebook. Doesnt he owe us a logical explaination? I am not asking him to badmouth anyone or take names...but atleast say something!

Again...I think I have kinda covered these questions above...but would like to just say a few last words. Just because his fans have supported him, why should he be obliged to return the favor. 'Selfless' is the key word here, I believe. He is very thankful for all the support and that should be enough for us.

Lastly, all these questions...this is just expecting too much from an entertainment industry in my opinion. I think, we as an audience, are at fault too for having high expectations. The entertainment industry is here to entertain us and I think we should just leave it at that. When we start seeking answers to things like these...it can really hamper with your peace of mind. This is speaking from personal experience. 😆

Edited by -sourire- - 13 years ago
TheRager thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

@Ritu: I just want to know what is his take on things. I am fangirly enuf to buy whatever he says. And I think most of us are. Right now we are on verge of having another actor play Dutta. I dont grudge that as thats how entertainment or any industry works. But personally I want a closure before the forum is inundated with Shabbir fans and we MR fans give way to them.

@Fatty: Frankly speaking I was really irked with Mishal's "No comments" to the TC interview when asked if he was approached to play Dutta again. Couldnt he say a yes or no? I wouldnt have minded either way whether he chose to come back or not. That made me believe he's in this with the rest. And all this a month after 24th March. The issues he had or the people he worked with are not personal. He can speak abt them politely and give us some answers.

@Rama: I second Fatty. Hemalji is a hopeless case. Either he is no longer closely involved with the show. Or else he wants the speculation to stay alive as any publicity is good publicity in the entertainment industry.

@Anu: "this has all been such a long drawn out mentally exhausting drama to watch unfolding" - Bang on!

KalyWayne07 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
That's terrible news Ksh!! You're not alone girly, I am with you! He indeed owe us a logical explanation. I'm going to cry, why is he treating us so rudely? I didn't expected that from him. ):

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".