To Salvage the Situation!! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

2.3k

Users

13

Likes

126

Frequent Posters

ImmaculateDream thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: tintiny

Sorry Sara, I cannot overlook it, dragging her away would still be bad but somewhat still acceptable, maybe Dutta roaring out who spiked her drink as she does not take alcohol...

I am not big hearted and I just cannot accept such a huge error saying it was high point of the story...nehi ji...women have come a long way...Naku may be all giving and besotted with Dutta but we as viewers cannot just accept his this kind of behaviour!! We have the right to ask for an apology from the PH and rectification of the situation....I am very upset!!


Im not saying that SLApping infront of everyone was Better then him dragging her away... All I'm saying is, his reaction was instantaneous.... such harsh reactions can only be shown in such crucial situations otherwise its taken in complete different direction where an aspect of "intention to hit" comes into picture which is bad!. He never wanted to take such a step .. but think of it! What made him do so ?? in such point of time "thinking or reasoning" just dont come in ...

women have come a long way ???

ok first of all whatever nakusha is doing .. she is doing that at her own will .. Dutta had NEVER EVER thought or imagined of her Reacting like a looney at party and make an idiot of herself .... on top pf that the Man has no idea what the hell has happened to her.. and i guess its enough to justify his reaction last night keeping in mind how hot headed he is... 😊 and nakusha is not acting like she is a backward .... she has a different sort of personality ... when it comes to Love her LOVE nothing can stop her ... not even Dutta...😊 both these people ( naku and Dutta) set their own rules and principles... World main kya chal raha hai . LAW kya hai ?? kya nahi .. log kya kahain ge...Women aur men kitnay aagay yah peechay ja chukay hain .... they NEVER cared ..and never will....




Dancingdoll thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#12
Frankly, I don't know why are we discriminating and then classifying this whole issue under Gender category...
This had nothing to do with a women or men issue,....
It was about ...hmmm.....let me call them....two love birds...It was about one love bird being insync with the other....It was about one love bird not being able to see the other one making a mockery of self....and shocked by the reaction to the extent that the love bird ended up slapping the other.....Now we all can keep scratching our heads on who is the female and who is the male one here only to realize that this was never the issue...There is a broader perspective to it and we are still living within our own sketched boundaries....
When Naku comes into her senses, I am so sure she would atleast be pleased about one thing that Dutta took the ownership on her enough to straighten her for her misbehaviour...."Saab ne mere par haq jataaya"....Her actions still affect him,....He has been going on about how he would have shown the kind gestures towards a stranger too ...well, by this whole drunken track, Naku proved him that he still cared for her and she wasnt in the stranger category.....
To me this slap was a mere gesture of building and rising emotions...And if we wanna raise an issue of violence...then lets talk about violence against human...why are we doing gender discrimination here?....I would be totally fine if Naku slaps him tomorrow, ofcourse it wouldnt go well with her personality but my point was that its about a reaction from a person in love towards the person he/she loves....It wasnt from a man to a woman/wife....I dont advocate violence but then we will take this social issue on Human beings and not just women!
Edited by Dancingdoll - 14 years ago
ImmaculateDream thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#13
Well said DD 👍🏼

This has nothing to do with what men are and what Women can do ..


Fishfish thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#14
Sara, the point I am trying to make is this show is watched by many, of course in the land of serials there are no laws, you kill people and there is no enquiry etc etc., but certain things cannot be shown, it should not be shown....today I watch the show because for Dutta (or Mishal I like his portrayal) I feel Naku is still a bit unreal in my eyes....but then I am an urban working woman so maybe my perspective of seeing things in a woman is different.... Hitting your wife is one of those things which I cannot accept from my most loved character....it cannot be impromptu...I remember about 4 years ago I went to learn swimming and the coach was shouting kick harder, kick kick ...he was not satisfied with my performance and came up to ask me...do you like your boss...I replied not really ...he said then imagine you are kicking him....I laughed no matter how mad I am (I do have a very quick temper) I cannot kick anybody, even my most hated person, I can imagine all right but in reality no....my inner teachings will not allow that....the respect Dutta has for his mother, his sisters or lets say women in general should have stopped him....do you murder a person who is making a fool of himself in public? No nah...even if happens to be your hubby, father, brother etc...
ImmaculateDream thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: tintiny

Sara, the point I am trying to make is this show is watched by many, of course in the land of serials there are no laws, you kill people and there is no enquiry etc etc., but certain things cannot be shown, it should not be shown....today I watch the show because for Dutta (or Mishal I like his portrayal) I feel Naku is still a bit unreal in my eyes....but then I am an urban working woman so maybe my perspective of seeing things in a woman is different.... ...


you are not getting my point Tin, i didn't mean that such actions and no laws are fine or fits in TV shows or not... I meant by the characters only, TO people Like Nakusha and Dutta EMotions comes first, their priorities... Neither of them are in a race to prove what a Man or a women can do .. nor nakusha will question him as why he slapped her as she is a Woman ... no such issues were never or will never come in between them .. they better not!

and REAlity is much more harsh then what is being shown on TV... so, show main kya dikhaya kya nahi .. Jisse jo kerna hota hai woh kerta hai ...

so, such serious issues should not be bothered abt ..


mussy.jamshed thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Dancingdoll

Frankly, I don't know why are we discriminating and then classifying this whole issue under Gender category...

This had nothing to do with a women or men issue,....
It was about ...hmmm.....let me call them....two love birds...It was about one love bird being insync with the other....It was about one love bird not being able to see the other one making a mockery of self....and shocked by the reaction to the extent that the love bird ended up slapping the other.....Now we all can try scratching our heads on who is the female and who is the male one here only to realize that this was never the issue...There is a broader perspective to it and we are still living within our own sketched boundaries....
When Naku comes into her senses, I am so sure she would atleast be pleased about one thing that Dutta took the ownership on her enough to straighten her for her misbehaviour...."Saab ne mere par haq jataaya"....Her actions still effect him,....He has been going on about how he would have shown the kind gestures towards a stranger too ...well, by this whole drunken track, Naku proved him that he still cared for her and she wasnt in the stranger category.....
To me this slap was a mere gesture of building and rising emotions...And if we wanna raise an issue of violence...then lets talk about violence against human...why are we doing gender discrimination here?....I would be totally fine if Naku slaps him tomorrow, ofcourse it wouldnt go well with her personality but my point was that its about a reaction from a person in love towards the person he/she loves....It wasnt from a man to a woman/wife....I dont advocate violence but then we will take this social issue on Human beings and not just women!



I agree completely..........The slap was like ceasefire I guess.........dutta has been keeping his emotions inside him.........he did not appreciate it.........because its Nakusha who did it, hence he slapped her.......Justified even in normal circumstances any father or husband would slap his daughter/ wife on a/c of this misbehavior.....reaction was justified....but I m happy as the emotions got out as thappar.....those ill feelings that he is keeping inside him post FR.......it just got him boiling ? why? because he still feels he owns Nakusha......look at the brighter side or lets say he felt as a husband or beloved he has a right to stop her from embarrassing herself further....lets not talk about public/private slap ......I agree with Anu .........atleast public slap was unintentional.......it was his instant reaction..........if he had slapped her inside the room, then we call it intentional.......if naku will be guilty of her misbehavior after she gets consciousness, then same holds for dutta........he will apologize for slap I guess...
I wish he interrogates later who spiked nakusha's drink........atleast he should know her by now.....she knows that he is infuriated, why would she put water on her efforts by further flaming him up........😕 Lets see how it goes tonight............
I have no high expectation from this slap......may be nothing comes out of it but high possibility of some positive outcome......😛
Fishfish thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#17
Sorry I am not in the mood to accept it in the name of emotions of characters...I know reality it is a lot harsher...I remember watching in TV a woman athlete winning the highest honours for her country some years ago while her husband throwing out her trophies from the house in front of the assembled journalists who had gone to congratulate the family....yes the lady's face upon being told is something I still cannot forget....
As I said TV should act as a responsible media atleast to certain extend....in the name of high drama somethings should still not be shown and if they have shown it...then my dear Naku grow a backbone and walk out on Dutta....is all I can say!!
lizdarcy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#18

Okay, one thing I wanted to ask...would our reaction be the same if Dutta had slapped Kala or Baji,??

And why weren't we this vehement when Kala slapped Naku?
A man hitting a woman is something despicable, but I don't know why...y'day it seemed quite in character for Dutta. I didn't find it odd at all. If Kala can hit Naku for supposedly betraying her brother(to save her own skin actually)...can't Dutta slap her to bring her back to her senses?
I would've been surprised if Dutta hadn't reacted the way he did. His anger, don't we all know what he is capable of when angry? This is the same man who dragged the poor girl and forcibly married her when he thought she'd betrayed him. The same man who manhandled her on the first night after their wedding.
The problem is, we have placed Dutta on this pedestal. Well, he himself said that he will not stand anyone hitting his wife. Double standards?? Or maybe, he meant he will not stand anyone other than him touching her!😆
Dutta is capable of being a beast, when provoked. We've seen enough examples. So, we can forgive him for killing men in cold blood as long as he stays sane around his wife?!! No, that wouldn't do for me. For a character, or a person to grow...they first have to sink rock bottom. Unless they've done the most despicable things, and unless they live to regret it...they can never truly heal. I am not justifying Dutta's actions, I'm just asking you to look at what motivates a character like Dutta. In his case, emotions have always ruled over reason. Which is why he's never stopped to think why someone like Naku would try and make a complete fool of herself.
For me, Dutta's reaction y'day signified his anger, and a hint of possessiveness. More than anything, it was because she is his wife. The woman he loves. When it comes to Naku, Dutta can never think straight. She does something to his brain I suppose! I'm hoping he'll drag her to the room and continue the drama there. Well, if it's gonna be out in the open, that's also okay with me. AS LONG AS we have a confrontation!!!
ImmaculateDream thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#19
@ Tin

Its ok . 😊 to each their own ... i hope u get over with it soon though ..😊


TheRager thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: tintiny

Sorry Sara, I cannot overlook it, dragging her away would still be bad but somewhat still acceptable, maybe Dutta roaring out who spiked her drink as she does not take alcohol...

I am not big hearted and I just cannot accept such a huge error saying it was high point of the story...nehi ji...women have come a long way...Naku may be all giving and besotted with Dutta but we as viewers cannot just accept his this kind of behaviour!! We have the right to ask for an apology from the PH and rectification of the situation....I am very upset!!

Dutta has acted several times against his principles of not hitting women. The first he pushed her when he was drunk. Then later on dragged and pushed her around during the first marriage and then got married to her. Then again dragged her to the room after the second marriage and pushing her so hard that she hit her head. The first time he hit her he was apologetic once sober. The second time again he was apologetic when he started feeling he shouldnt have married her in such an insulting manner.
But frankly speaking dragging Naku away would be as bad as slapping her and everyone would know what's coming up next for Naku. Much better would be handling Naku gently and taking her away but thats not Dutta. Basically what I am trying to say violence against women in any form is bad whether is dragging or slapping. One cannot be better than another. But yes Naku maybe ok with the slap...many others wouldnt. Afterall Naku comes from a background where its ok for a father or husband to beat their wives and kids.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".