Tanya/Rakshanda Discussion Thread - Page 8

*When a person does something naturally without any bad intentions, you cannot hold them to it. That's just my viewpoint. She gave up the right as Karan's wife, but she is considered Tulsi's daughter.

Nandani didn't come back to SN to be Karan's wife. She came back to SN to take care of Tanya, because she considers Tanya to be her friend. She took care of Tanya when no one else would. Because she took care of Tanya and scolded Bhoomi repeatedly, it changed a bit of Bhoomi too, didn't it? Even Manthan told Nandani that only she can take care of his mom...

When Tanya came back to Karan after Nandani went to jail, she told him she doesn't care if he can't give her Nandani's spot in his life because he was honest with her, so why is she crying about it now? After the 20 year leap, she told Karan she will leave once Nandani came...but she changed her position as soon as the danger of it came, citing that no woman can share her husband.

Didn't she agree to share him when they took Nandani back to the hospital, after she had a re-lapse because she almost found out about his marriage to Tanya? This was her dialogue: "I don't mind sharing you but Nandani will never share you."

I can also say that Tanya gave up the right now as Karan's wife, so why is she crying about it? Why is she still wearing mangulstr and sindoor? Why is she crying for something when she was the one who initiated it?

Also, about your point about talking freely...IF she is pretending to be blind, she could have seen Bhoomi and inadvertently changed her opinion, so Bhoomi can be mislead into thinking something else...

Actually it was shown. She would call Karan, crying to him about how lonely she is, how her life is ruined, etc. Then she would tell him, she wants to meet Bhoomi..., etc. She did raise Bhoomi but because of Bhoomi she did her chance at getting Karan. When Nandani was the one who suggested Bhoomi's name, why did Tanya take credit for it? Why did Tanya made Nandani feel as if she interfered in their life when Nandani came back from the coma? Did Tanya marry Karan, hoping Nandani never comes back?

Her role in Kyunki.., I don't like it. Simply because Tanya is a deceptive character, and she uses circumstances to her advantage, then claims she is the one who is not at fault for anything. Rakshanda is doing a good job but being a HG fan (Not speaking as a KN Fan) I don't like a 3rd person b/n them 2 😉

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

It's quite alright that u saying these...yes u have got this right.....BUT according to me (myviewpoint) i think there are some things which i will disagree. Ok?

I am marking with red colour where i've disagreed and agreed as well...😳

lol, she didn't take the thali from Tulsi to snatch it away, rather it was the other way around. she just took it. it was a symbolic gesture that meant that KN are meant to be and Tan is b/n them two, because Tanya's arm was shown b/n them 2. Didn't you see once Nandani realized what she was doing, she stepped away, surprised...

lolll, when were K-T shown to be happy? I haven't seen them happy together at all. Rather it was Nandani who pretended to be married, so Karan won't leave Tanya. It was Nandani who made Karan realize what wrong he is doing to Tanya after 20 years of marriage. Nandani encouraged him to try to start new, if Tanya couldn't appreciate it, how is it her fault?

a woman in hindu religion wears a mangulstr and sindoor if she is married. once divorced, a woman doesn't wear them.

Nandani shouldn't cry for Karan? Did she cry in front of Viranis about her sacrifices repeatedly like Tanya did? She cried privately, she would be considered emotionless if she didn't. She lost the child, she didn't get a chance to see grow up. The same child she risked her life for. She lost the man she loved forever, for whom she put up so much for. Yet not once has she blamed anyone for her miseries, unlike Tanya who has blamed everyone for the decisions she's made: biggest one-marrying an in-love-with-Nandani Karan.

Karan was wrong too for hiding it, but why did Tanya get upset with him when he did tell Bhoomi the truth? Did she want Bhoomi to keep on thinking bad about Nandani?

Of course she made Nandani feel as if she has no rights. Visiting Karan in jail during KC, not caring that Nandani could see them. Getting upset when Nandani requested little Bhoomi to call her "maa." Seeing Karan behind Nandani's back. Coming into their bedroom, where they were sleeping...Telling Nandani's doctor that she's pregnant...

In Ekta's serials, a 3rd person is necessary to be there. The 3rd person is Tanya, lol

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

I agree with some of the things u have written, but i will also have to disagree with many things...😳

Wow its really nice to see a healthy and mature discussion going on without the fear of being lashed at or yelled by. Bhoomi_fan, I am an HG fan and a Nandini fan but I am not a Karan fan or a Tanya fan so consider that factor as you read my insight to your standpoint...

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

I agree with some of the things u have written, but i will also have to disagree with many things...😳

OMG...I just came back and was this good discussion going on....and really I have to say Well done Labib and Humera 👏 👏 👏 ...

and welcome HG fan 😳 .......

So many theories floating around......but I actually believe that in KNT track everyone is weak.....
Karan - He puts Tulsi's happiness before his own.....and his blind trust in Tulsi 😕

Tanya - She is a very real person for a TV serial...We all have our own positives and negatives.....but if yesterday's episode was not a plan of Tanya...for the first time Tanya has made a real choice by agreeing that BOTH KN love her......K respects Tanya and N also respects T and her feelings coz she stood by her against Ansh and took care of Bhoomi....finally if Tanya understtod this..sadly her role is over in kyunki 😉

Nandini - Gauri's weakness is that she wanted to get a break from this daily soap..understandly 😆 .....so her character had to go away.....otherwise I am sure KN wud ave united...
And Nandini's weakness is that she is too good...she always keeps other's happiness first and her and K's relationship later....so both KN care for others more than themselves...
for once Nandini should stop feeling guilty and say to herself loudly " I have suffered a lot...now God is giving me happiness....let me welcome this because I DESERVE THIS"....

Labib...I think what mods mean by this is than "no tanya bashing" is allowed..but a healthy discussion is welcome...and u r doing so well ........

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

Hee Hee Hee😳 Enough of DEBATES....

Firstly i would like to apologize to Jumaira aand srg_club....yes i thik everone can come here, in this thread.....and everone should participate in our discussion.....

I was surfing in the net....and i found some really, really Cute, hot and Spicy pics of rakshandah.....here they are:

Plz give ur comments whether u liked them or not...😳

thx dear the pix r nice but do u happen to have any videos as well n some old pix of rakshu from kyunki when she entered the show

i rem her entry was great even karan was shown floored by her beauty n he keeps lookin at her as she leaves sayin SHE'S ROCKING irritatin nandini standin thr

Well...how long can we discuss Only Tanya..and her beauty? 😆 we need to discuss the psychology of a character in a daily soap...and that too not a positive one like Tulsi 😆 😆
So I think it wud be too much if we are asked only to praise Tanya..specially when she can become negative anytime 😆 😆 😆

The pictures are really nice Labib.....I like them

For Nandani to think about her happiness, Bhoomi is there to make her realize this. But I do agree about Tanya, except I still feel she is pretending to be blind. Whether I am correct or incorrect, it will be shown eventually.

I want to make one point very clear:

Nandani was shown away because of the ex-creative director and Smriti's insecurity of sharing screen space with Gauri Pradhan, since they are of the same age.

Originally posted by: tvfan1401

OMG...I just came back and was this good discussion going on....and really I have to say Well done Labib and Humera 👏 👏 👏 ...

and welcome HG fan 😳 .......

So many theories floating around......but I actually believe that in KNT track everyone is weak.....
Karan - He puts Tulsi's happiness before his own.....and his blind trust in Tulsi 😕

Tanya - She is a very real person for a TV serial...We all have our own positives and negatives.....but if yesterday's episode was not a plan of Tanya...for the first time Tanya has made a real choice by agreeing that BOTH KN love her......K respects Tanya and N also respects T and her feelings coz she stood by her against Ansh and took care of Bhoomi....finally if Tanya understtod this..sadly her role is over in kyunki 😉

Nandini - Gauri's weakness is that she wanted to get a break from this daily soap..understandly 😆 .....so her character had to go away.....otherwise I am sure KN wud ave united...
And Nandini's weakness is that she is too good...she always keeps other's happiness first and her and K's relationship later....so both KN care for others more than themselves...
for once Nandini should stop feeling guilty and say to herself loudly " I have suffered a lot...now God is giving me happiness....let me welcome this because I DESERVE THIS"....

Read Nimmi's latest post in this thread.

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

Befor going into any more DEBATES and ARGUEMENTS i want to make a point clear: People who wants to critisize Tanya aren't allowed in this STICKY...

It's not my order, it's Lil Ms.Sunshine, viebie of Kyunki forum, who had made this rule. Lil Ms.Sunshine had clearly written it that "NO HATERS ARE ALLOWED HERE" and "THIS FORUM IS ONLY FOR APPRECIATING TANYA."

Here's what she wrote:

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Lil Ms.Sunshine Viewbie Joined: 06 February 2006 Location: United States Gender: Female Posts: 16002	Posted: 20 January 2008 at 11:12am | IP Logged Hello Everyone!

1. This thread is STRICTLY Tanya/Rakshanda discussion thread. NO HATERS ALLOWED HERE. Only positive remarks about Tanya are going to be used here. There is ABSOLUTELY NO, and let me emphasize on one word once more ---> NO read it once again....NO discussion about Karan-Nandini here. Any other topic about Tanya opened on the forum will be closed. I'm sorry but that's how it's going to be for some time now.
   
   Just because this is a Tanya's thread doesnt mean you can bash KN in here. You will discuss Tanya here. Not KN. Any degradatory remarks found about KN/any other character for that matter will get you an INSTANT WARNING LEVEL RAISE.
   
   I know we have prohibited you guys from dicussing about KNT in one topic out in the forum..or in this thread or in the KN thread, but we have no other option! You guys just can't control it! This is going to stay this way until you guys learn to cooperate.
   
   I expect this thread to be a calm and organized thread. Do know, that the KSBKBT Forum Rules apply here, and it will be monitored very closely. Anyone breaking the rules will receive a straight WL raise.
   
   Expecting cooperation from everyone.
   Swati, Nimmi, Sweta.
   KSBKBT Dev Team.
   

Link: http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=841981&T PN=1

Now if u RESPECT ur viewbies Lil.Ms.Sunshine, then u (all the people who wanna critisize tanya) shud go from here.

Sorry, if i'm a bit harsh.

But mind it, its not my order. It's our viewbies order. And if u respect our viewbie and follow her rule, u arent allowed to critisize tanya.

THANK U.