Why do people hat eTanya? - Page 2

Originally posted by: nkapoor

Why do people hate Tanya? I have always felt sorry for her, people only hate her because they are too biased with Karan-Nandani and I mean toooo much biased!

What is Tanya's fault?

-she is a nice human being and took care of Bhumi for 25 years as her own child and just wanted a bit of love back from bhumi?

-she gave her 25 years to a man, she gave him a child, she took care of him, she loved him more then anything in this world, and wanted a bit of love back from him?

Is this too much to ask for? Karan never in the years spent time with Tanya, gave tanya any love, and neither did he give her any sort of regard of her being his wife. She has been dodgy lately because she feels dejected, because her husband doesn't love her, the family that she has supported doesn't love her, and now her children have separated from her also. Karan was always lost in Nandan's thoughts, he cared about the women that he loved, but he disn't care about the women who loves him, who takes care of his children, who is taking care of him and his family! Tanya committing suicide is the biggest slap on Karan Virani he made her life miserable! He deserves to live in the guilt of murdering a women that loved him dearly! Nandini is also somewhat responsible she knew how much Tanya is getting affected so she should've stayed away from her married life, I know she didn't do it knowingly but she could've avoided many functions! Agreed Karan once thought that he'll spend the rest of his life with Tanya, but he never made it obvious, and again started japofyying nandani, he is the only reason Tanya turned somewhat negative! And I hate bhumi to such and extent she now hates the mother who actually brought her up, gave her all the happiness in the world, and was first also reluctant to tie rakhi on that brother's wrist that she spend her whole life with! Disgusting! I hate Karan!

why i hate tanya.

tanya knew it very well on her first day's of marriage karan was agreed to maried with her just for bhoomi's sake and he only and only loves with nandini.then whynot tanya refused to married with him why she was agreed to married wth that man who madly in loves wirth his first wife. infact nobody forced to her infact all virani's forced to karan.

first three years he didn't gives her wifes rights when tulsi came back after completing her 3 years prision she said to him then he gave her wifes rights but when nandini was comeback from coma docter called him he left tanya in their wedding anniversary and happiliy went to met nandini.when nandini was faint when she read his diary karan told infront of tulsi and tanya maine woh sare rishte khatam kardoga jo mere aur nandini ke beech ayen ge.when nandini got 14 years prision karan told him clearly you will never takes place nandi's place in my heart .then why not tanya except it nandini is karan's life and i am nothing infront of nandini in karan's life.then whynot she left him.thata means she is the most chipko woman.zabadasti pyar karo she said to karan so many times when nmandini will retuen i will leave you but she never fulfil her promise ,she said to karan i always respect your and nandini's love oh thats why she kicked out nandini from sn that means she is a biggest lier.plus when she knew abt nandini's marriage she said so many bad things to nandini then why not she was happy in that time and if she was sincerely thinking abt karan thats why she said so many bad things to her then why not she is happy right now and reunite karan nandini.no she was showing jelousy that means she is a double standard woman.

. two more points i wana add here .when nandini came back tanya left karan first of all tanya left karan because nandini wana marry to her with other guy she didn't leave karan for nandini's sake.plus she came back after few days and said i cant live without bhoomi ,but if tanya fans still think its sacrifice then its nothing infront of nandini's sacrifices.

other point tanya was redy to sign divorce papers ont he other han she was crying infront of al virani's and showed she will sacrifice and she went to nandini's house and showed infront of divorce papers sacrifice karne wale sub ko bata aur jata ke sacrifice nahin karte like nandini she stopped her and lying i was married with other guy.plus if tanya truely wants karan nandini's reunion she never kickout nandini from sn .

when karan asked her tumhe mujhe chor ke jane main meri khushi hai then tanya said tumhari kushi ke liye main tumhe chordongi but i cant live without you .then karan said to her tum mujhe kabhi chor kar najana and hugged her.but when mandira called to tanya she told her abt karan nandini then why tanya went to nandini's house whnot he believed karan after all tanya sped 20 yers with him and she knew it very well karan never lie to her .plus when she saw karan nandini hugged with each other and thought now nandini wanna come back in karan's life then why not tanya left karan as she said so many times.

she herself kickout nandini from sn but still taunting.

tanya said to karan i said you were not here because you were deep in your thought and obviously you were thinking abt nandini.

shameless woman if you thinks karan still loves nandini and she is still living in his herat then why not you left him.that means you have no selfrespect.

plus she said to him i gave you and your family 20 yares of my life.

oh thats why karan ko zabardsssasti tanya se pyar karna parega.

she said to karan i always respest your and nandini's love.

oh thats why you kicked out nandini from sn.

and in which angle do you think tanya truely loves with karan and she deserves karan's wifes rights.plz tell me.

she loves with karan thats why she is always blackmailing him,pushing him i gave you 20 years of my .life thats why mujhe pyar karo,i loook after your children thats why mujhe pyar karo sacha pyar karne wale ehsan jata kar pyar nahin mangte.she loves karan thats why she kickout nandini from sn.if you truely loves with somone then your happiness is your lover happiness not like tanya zbardasti pyar karo.she loves karan thats why she said to him apni thakan guest room main jaa kar mitalo.she loves karan thats why she said for tulsi infront of him maar jati to acha hota wapis kyun ayen infact she knew it very well what is the meaning of tulsi in karan'slife.she loves karan thats why she canceled jewerlly order .she loves karan thats why first she herself kickout nandini from sn but still taunting over karan you were not here because you were deep in your thought and obviuosly you were thinking abt nandini .shameles woman if you know nandini is stll leaving in karan's heart then whynot you left him that means you have no selfrespect.she loves him thats why when karan deeply in hurt with his behaviour towards tulsi and mhir and saw bhoomi with abhir instead of supporting him she was planning how to take revange with tulsi.

one more point according to some tany's fans when nandini left karan then why she came back.

she didn't come back in karan and bhoomi's life she just come back in mumbai.have you not seen

nandini was disappered when nandini got accident with karan's car and karan get her in sn.nandini showed infot of bhoomi and karan her fake marriage just for tanya.nandini didn't attend bhoomi's engaement just for tanya,nandini hidden her face in bhoomi's marriage just for tanya.nandini gave karan 24 hours ultimatem just for tanya.nandini is listening so many bad thing from bhooomi just for tanya,nandini is listening you are not a oart iof sn just for tanya,nandini is listening you have no relationship with karan and she didn't say just for tanya.what tanya did for nandini.nandini left karan for tayna two times but what tanya did with her in whaich angle do you think tanya deserve more sacrifices from nandini's side.plz tell me.

Originally posted by: nkapoor

TRUE

and if you people have a strong point towards tanya than how can we fight with you obviously we will except your support towards tanya.and same with nandini if you peeple have strong point against nandini than how can we fight with you we will except.

I have never commented before on the K-N-T triangle, this is the first time. I agree with all the love, the sacrifices etc but what I fail to understand is if a person doesnt love u, but just respects u why would you want to stay in that relationship? I like Tanya's and Nandini's characters, but what I could never understand is why Tanya would never have any self respect or pride regarding this matter. Even if Karan left Nandini, never saw her again, Bhoomi and Manthan for life considered Tanya as their mother, one thing was always clear and that was Karan always respected Tanya and considered her a friend and he would never ever love her the way he loved Nandini. But for some reason Tanya's character kept sticking to Karan's like her life began and ended with Karan. Like if there was no Karan, there would be no Tanya. Come on woman, have some pride!!!! If your husband is telling you on your face that hey today there is nothing between Nandini and me and you will always be the bahu of this house and mother of my children, but at the same time his eyes just speak of love for Nandini why would you want to still hang around? You cannot demand love, he might still give in but there will always always be a doubt in your mind that he actually loves Nandini. There was only a moment in Tanya's life when Nandini was in a coma that Karan and Tanya actually might have had something going for them, though it was more hey I think I am falling for my best friend who is my wife, kind of moment.

If Tanya is really gone it is in a way a sad end to her character. I always wanted her to be a strong willed woman but I guess she was so Karan Karan Karan all the time that I never expected her to stand upright. Cause a stage had been reached where even if Nandini had died, Tanya would be in situation saying now Karan will become a Devdas as Nandini has gone.

If he isnt yours now, he was never yours to begin with.

The twists about her being evil etc harassing Tulsi etc were just to up the TRP's and Ekta and her creatives' plan but her main character and personality itself, it's a very sad and sorry end to it. Wish she had been stronger and not so insecure.

Good job though, Rakshanda.

Originally posted by: nandini80

I have never commented before on the K-N-T triangle, this is the first time. I agree with all the love, the sacrifices etc but what I fail to understand is if a person doesnt love u, but just respects u why would you want to stay in that relationship? I like Tanya's and Nandini's characters, but what I could never understand is why Tanya would never have any self respect or pride regarding this matter. Even if Karan left Nandini, never saw her again, Bhoomi and Manthan for life considered Tanya as their mother, one thing was always clear and that was Karan always respected Tanya and considered her a friend and he would never ever love her the way he loved Nandini. But for some reason Tanya's character kept sticking to Karan's like her life began and ended with Karan. Like if there was no Karan, there would be no Tanya. Come on woman, have some pride!!!! If your husband is telling you on your face that hey today there is nothing between Nandini and me and you will always be the bahu of this house and mother of my children, but at the same time his eyes just speak of love for Nandini why would you want to still hang around? You cannot demand love, he might still give in but there will always always be a doubt in your mind that he actually loves Nandini. There was only a moment in Tanya's life when Nandini was in a coma that Karan and Tanya actually might have had something going for them, though it was more hey I think I am falling for my best friend who is my wife, kind of moment.

If Tanya is really gone it is in a way a sad end to her character. I always wanted her to be a strong willed woman but I guess she was so Karan Karan Karan all the time that I never expected her to stand upright. Cause a stage had been reached where even if Nandini had died, Tanya would be in situation saying now Karan will become a Devdas as Nandini has gone.

If he isnt yours now, he was never yours to begin with.

The twists about her being evil etc harassing Tulsi etc were just to up the TRP's and Ekta and her creatives' plan but her main character and personality itself, it's a very sad and sorry end to it. Wish she had been stronger and not so insecure.

Good job though, Rakshanda.

Very well said...I totally agree with you...She knew that she lost Karan the time Nandini came out of coma...then why did she come back again when Nadini was sent to jail...At least before when Nandini was in coma she had some hope because Nandini was declared as well as dead by the doctors & Karan might move on...but the second time she came back it wasn't karan's fault ...it was totally her decission and her fault.

Rakshanda has played the role very well. The hatred she has managed to evoke is remarkable, which indeed is her job through this character.

I don't hate Tanya. I find her character a bit abysmal. I just fail to understand her uncouth desire to stick around knowing her husband can't wait to be away from her. As a mark of protest and to protect my self respect, if I were her, I'd have walked out on Karan an eternity ago.

Hina

o i dont h8 her bt sometimez i foind her well annoying bt shes ok 😃

Oh so well replied Hina. Even I think same way. I mean u can't thrust yourself on somebody. How u can force someone to love u is indeed beyond my comprehension.

& abt the topic why do we hate Tanya, I think most of us have already explained it countless times. Honestly I have neither the time nor the energy to repeat what we all already know!

well i don't like her charcter but i don't hate it. i think rakshanda portrayed her charcter very well.

Originally posted by: nkapoor

Why do people hate Tanya? I have always felt sorry for her, people only hate her because they are too biased with Karan-Nandani and I mean toooo much biased!

What is Tanya's fault?

-she is a nice human being and took care of Bhumi for 25 years as her own child and just wanted a bit of love back from bhumi?

-she gave her 25 years to a man, she gave him a child, she took care of him, she loved him more then anything in this world, and wanted a bit of love back from him?

Is this too much to ask for? Karan never in the years spent time with Tanya, gave tanya any love, and neither did he give her any sort of regard of her being his wife. She has been dodgy lately because she feels dejected, because her husband doesn't love her, the family that she has supported doesn't love her, and now her children have separated from her also. Karan was always lost in Nandan's thoughts, he cared about the women that he loved, but he disn't care about the women who loves him, who takes care of his children, who is taking care of him and his family! Tanya committing suicide is the biggest slap on Karan Virani he made her life miserable! He deserves to live in the guilt of murdering a women that loved him dearly! Nandini is also somewhat responsible she knew how much Tanya is getting affected so she should've stayed away from her married life, I know she didn't do it knowingly but she could've avoided many functions! Agreed Karan once thought that he'll spend the rest of his life with Tanya, but he never made it obvious, and again started japofyying nandani, he is the only reason Tanya turned somewhat negative! And I hate bhumi to such and extent she now hates the mother who actually brought her up, gave her all the happiness in the world, and was first also reluctant to tie rakhi on that brother's wrist that she spend her whole life with! Disgusting! I hate Karan!

You cannot be more right. If he doesn't want to love her he can just give a certain amount of respect a wilfe.But Nnoooo..that's to much for him...

Rakshanda is great I love her but I dont like the character tanya I did sympathised with her before leap but hated her afterwards............