Tanya - Page 2

Originally posted by: nicki33

I think the tanya karan nandini situation is one where everyone is right with their own views. On the one hand there is a woman who left her husband and daughter and lived a lonely life because she didnt want her best friend to be kicked out espesh since her best friend took care of her daughter, and on the other hand there is a woman who has stayed loyally with her husband for 20 years knowing that he doesnt love her just for the sake of the children. Evidently all three have thus lived very lonely lives even though two of them were together. Its always gonna be difficult to slate one as evil and one as good because u can feel for both of them to some levels. How can you tell one to pack her bags and leave after having this as her home for so long and at the same time how can you tell another to go away to her lonely life away from the people she's cared for when she has been far away for so long??

However, all this aside, this is an ekta serial and there is no such thing as a simple situation.....otherwise the woman wudnt have made millions and managed to drag the story on for so long. Im sure if nandini and karan had been together then now she wud hav tanya in nandinis situation and karan wud hav been made guilty for abandoning her; or tanya wud hav at this point made a mandira style return and everyone wud have cursed her
also I have two questions - even mandira loved karan a lot right?? so will u agree that she has sum gud in her like u wud say tanya has?
and leaving nandini aside, ganga has also been far away from her children so will u tell her to leave them alone for triptis sake?

Im sure I will get people disagreeing wif me but I just want to say that Im just playing neutral party here, Im not critising anyone!!

.very well said

Originally posted by: nicki33

I think the tanya karan nandini situation is one where everyone is right with their own views. On the one hand there is a woman who left her husband and daughter and lived a lonely life because she didnt want her best friend to be kicked out espesh since her best friend took care of her daughter, and on the other hand there is a woman who has stayed loyally with her husband for 20 years knowing that he doesnt love her just for the sake of the children. Evidently all three have thus lived very lonely lives even though two of them were together. Its always gonna be difficult to slate one as evil and one as good because u can feel for both of them to some levels. How can you tell one to pack her bags and leave after having this as her home for so long and at the same time how can you tell another to go away to her lonely life away from the people she's cared for when she has been far away for so long??

However, all this aside, this is an ekta serial and there is no such thing as a simple situation.....otherwise the woman wudnt have made millions and managed to drag the story on for so long. Im sure if nandini and karan had been together then now she wud hav tanya in nandinis situation and karan wud hav been made guilty for abandoning her; or tanya wud hav at this point made a mandira style return and everyone wud have cursed her
also I have two questions - even mandira loved karan a lot right?? so will u agree that she has sum gud in her like u wud say tanya has?
and leaving nandini aside, ganga has also been far away from her children so will u tell her to leave them alone for triptis sake?

Im sure I will get people disagreeing wif me but I just want to say that Im just playing neutral party here, Im not critising anyone!!

You are absolutely right.All the three are right in their places.Nandini and Tanya are mothers.It is wrong to say that they should leave their children.And karan loves Nandini, so no one can make him love Tanya.Evenif Tanya stays wid Karan for whole life,he will be thinking of Nandini.Tanya and Nandini cannot stop loving karan either.Everyone should accept the reality and move on.Nandini has accepted the reality.At one point Karan accepted this but after Tanya's attitude he changed.Tanya is not ready to accept this fact that Karan can never love her and se is insecure abt loosing her kids.Why cant there be 2 mothers instead of one?

agree with u nicki. really well put.

Agreed about Tanya not being an evil woman

The only woman she has ever wronged is Tulsi Ma. Which wife would like to see her husband with someone else? What's wrong if Tanya wishes to be the only one in Karan's mind and heart? People tend to confuse the characters with the performers....instead, put yourself in Tanya's shoes. Would you willingly give up your husband so he could live with a gorgeous woman he is extremely comfortable with? NO!

Hiten and Gauri look smashing together, and the fact that they don't have to be a 'couple' on the show to win hearts proves a lot about their chemistry. But this is not about Hiten and Gauri; it's about Nandini, Karan and Tanya

What if Rakshanda was portraying Nandini? Would you still want Karan to be with her? Based on 99% of the members in this forum, the answer would be NO, because Rakshanda doesn't look as good with Hiten as Gauri does. But TANYA, the character, most definitely has EVERY right to want her husband's love, and has EVERY right to be insecure because she has NEVER got it. She is very well justified to hate Nandini, although the latter is a fine woman (ideal and sometimes too good to be true)

Karan was damn rude when he refused to hold the Thali with her...he is one irritating dude, and no one would want a husband like him (yes, Hiten fits the role to the T, but the role by itself is annoying!)!

Originally posted by: krangara

Agreed about Tanya not being an evil woman

The only woman she has ever wronged is Tulsi Ma. Which wife would like to see her husband with someone else? What's wrong if Tanya wishes to be the only one in Karan's mind and heart? People tend to confuse the characters with the performers....instead, put yourself in Tanya's shoes. Would you willingly give up your husband so he could live with a gorgeous woman he is extremely comfortable with? NO!

Hiten and Gauri look smashing together, and the fact that they don't have to be a 'couple' on the show to win hearts proves a lot about their chemistry. But this is not about Hiten and Gauri; it's about Nandini, Karan and Tanya

What if Rakshanda was portraying Nandini? Would you still want Karan to be with her? Based on 99% of the members in this forum, the answer would be NO, because Rakshanda doesn't look as good with Hiten as Gauri does. But TANYA, the character, most definitely has EVERY right to want her husband's love, and has EVERY right to be insecure because she has NEVER got it. She is very well justified to hate Nandini, although the latter is a fine woman (ideal and sometimes too good to be true)

Karan was damn rude when he refused to hold the Thali with her...he is one irritating dude, and no one would want a husband like him (yes, Hiten fits the role to the T, but the role by itself is annoying!)!

Im sorry but i dont agree with u there. I love hiten and gauri as actors and yes Im a ght fan and all that but I can honestly say that I am not confusing actors with characters and Im sure thats true for many others that want karan and nandini together. if gauri, hiten and rakshanda's characters were being portrayed by random actors called ganga, jamna and charan das I would still say that karan shud go to nandini because of the way their story has etched out from the beginning. tanya and ansh stopped them getting together at first and everyone wants nandinis character to get sum happiness espesh afta the ansh scenario and twenty years or wateva lata karan is miserable without nandini and the two couples are made for each other, and tanya isnt exactly a bunch of roses with karan. I really dont kno why all ght fans are accused of constantly confusing actor with character when I can honestly say that Im not.

and to clarify I just want to say that I am a pulkit fan as well but I still want to see eklavya nd kt make a go of their marriage cos kt neva married lakshya and eklavya wasnt an out and out evil like ansh was (u hv to agree eklavya changing was due to tulsi) nd for once I wud like to see a marriage in an ekta serial that doesnt end up with a separation!! and Im saying this despite the fact that I absolutely love lakshya!

sorry if i sound critical - i just wanted to clarify my point rather than start a fight

Originally posted by: gaurihiten fan

hmm did manthan ever maintain a son's farz???tell me that first,and hw can u told that guys,u r forgetting that when mantha thought that KN r dead,he told that "dad aapne mujhe chalna sikhaya,mere har galti par mujhe maaf kiya,main ek aacha beta ban na saka" remember that guys when they were showing Karan's love for manthan,his care for his son,Karan is not cheap like tanya who uses his childrean againstanyone,if Karan want the he told bhoomi the whole KN truth bohut pehle bt he just kept silent only for his children's sake,poor guy gave his whole 25 years only for his childrean,HATS OFF TO KN yaars they r the most beautiful character in kyunki along with baa

ya agree with u sujata .........karan n nandani r the most beautiful characters of kyunki soo this tanya should be pout now ...........ekta plz unite karan n nandani ...............plzzzzzzzz its high time bc this tanya drama is now irritating to watch she is too much to handle now soooo ekta listen to us otherwise bc of this tanya kyunki will become boring day by day.............

Originally posted by: Eklavya_fan

let me tell u one thing love 😳 karan always gived love to bhoomi more than manthan just becaue she was nandinis kid bhoomi was bad as manthan than why give all the love to her ..........

love wahida 😳

wahida has a point here. I love karan and nandini and all that but karan as a father did show a lot of favouritism towards bhoomi (though to be honest i had thought that was just cos bhoomi was the first child while manthan was born during the major fights in shanti niketan bt guess i was wrong!!). both kids were spoilt brats!!!!

b4 sumone shouts at me though.....i still love karan's character!!

Originally posted by: krangara

Agreed about Tanya not being an evil woman

The only woman she has ever wronged is Tulsi Ma. Which wife would like to see her husband with someone else? What's wrong if Tanya wishes to be the only one in Karan's mind and heart? People tend to confuse the characters with the performers....instead, put yourself in Tanya's shoes. Would you willingly give up your husband so he could live with a gorgeous woman he is extremely comfortable with? NO!

Hiten and Gauri look smashing together, and the fact that they don't have to be a 'couple' on the show to win hearts proves a lot about their chemistry. But this is not about Hiten and Gauri; it's about Nandini, Karan and Tanya

What if Rakshanda was portraying Nandini? Would you still want Karan to be with her? Based on 99% of the members in this forum, the answer would be NO, because Rakshanda doesn't look as good with Hiten as Gauri does. But TANYA, the character, most definitely has EVERY right to want her husband's love, and has EVERY right to be insecure because she has NEVER got it. She is very well justified to hate Nandini, although the latter is a fine woman (ideal and sometimes too good to be true)

Karan was damn rude when he refused to hold the Thali with her...he is one irritating dude, and no one would want a husband like him (yes, Hiten fits the role to the T, but the role by itself is annoying!)!

I don't think Tanya is evil. I think her percpective is faulty. She accuses Nandini, when she should thank her. She bitches about Karan, when she should be grateful that he has given her the right to be called Mrs Karan Virani. Even when Nandini was out of coma, he kept meeting her with Bhoomi, to her give her those marital rights which you are talking about.

She is no more the character she was. Now she is outright annoying. She either smirks that devilish grin of hers, what with that enjoying Tripti's idea of pricking Nandini's heel with a glass piece, she cries inessantly for a fact she has known for years, that she can't receive Karan's affection. I mean why the skittish attitude now?!

I'm a fan of Gauri and Hiten, yes. But I keep reiterating that Karan is an annoying character. He kept vacillating, and he is to be blamed alongside Tanya. But now, he knows what he wants, and he keeps telling Tanya that. She tore the divorce papers, she wrecked his life, the only thing she has done good is that she brought up the kids. None of this is Nandini's fault, you have to admit that. She was only a victim of circumstances. So after everything, I feel, that irrespective of whether or not Gauri plays Nandini... the CHARACTER Nandini is more deserving of her man.

U r soo true , Karan is also fault of marrying tanya for bhomi sake & also had a son, but nandini's character is good for all the 3 characters as she loved karan only & after coming from coma also she agreed the fact that k-t are married.. One thing i would say that if that time nandini can say to tulsi " what will u do tulsi maa if u were in coma like me & mahir marries another women" what will u do u will accept her. Now whenver tanya says to nandini that meiney tumehein apne dost mana hai... Then nandini can say that's why u married my husband when i was in coma.. But nandini never said anything to either karan, tulsi or tanya because they are who spoiled her life...
I like the dialogue of n saying to tulsi that humnein apne zindagi jee liye hain, ab bacchon ke leye jeena hai." Wow i like it.Nandini is one good character, if she is not good like this she would have got karan a long ago.. Also she respect tanya for loving bhomi, & says to bhomi that tanya is ur mom but wheras tanya doesn't accpet bhomi saying nandini as her mom, but now also bhomi calls tanya as mom....

Originally posted by: eshi786

Guyz after todays episode i think tanya is not really negetive. she jus wants her husband bak. wats wrond wid that? i mean if nandani left y does she hav 2 b bak? Doesnt tanya lov bhoomi, manthan, and karan as much as nandani. i no nandani is not wrong either, but i think she should keep distance from karan.

EXACTLY HUN!! EXACTLY!!!👏

VERY WELL SAID!👏

tanyaa rox!😳