another possible reason for pragya's words....

ann5 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
why will I fight this fight if I don't get you... could also mean that I am fighting this fight also knowing that I don't get you...there are so many ways to interpret this line...to futher show abhi what she is saying is the truth...

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

997

Users

5

Likes

19

Frequent Posters

Mitushi_Mitz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Whatever she said, it kind of justified what she did! Though hiding the truth was a mistake but then she realised it and also I am glad that she told the whole truth.. and the way she confronted Abhi, he was forced to listen her. I loved what she said about DNA reports, and he wasn't ready to believe that baby isn't his!! So overall usne apni baat bahut acche se samjhayi!!
TeluguAmmayi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
That is the most selfish line of Pragya!

Going by Pragya's character it should have been "I wanted to let you know the truth because it's not right you got struck in a lie" but she said what is the use if I don't get you.

I ignored it not only that I ignored some of the dialouges this week because I loved many others.

Just saying Beacause this was picked here.

When people are angry, broken and lost they talk a lot everything doesn't need to be taken literally.
nitarata thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
This attitude she shows all along the mission! She always thinks of uniting with him, getting him etc. that was so so off! Especially in a situation where Abhi being blamed as a baby dad was involved! If Tannu wasn't pregnant and if the fight was just about who wins Abhi, then I accept this line! But here she was just lucky to overhear the truth and she took so long to convey it. And somewhere the issue was whether she will get him or not!!

Not that it was a selfless thing to do.. But knowing some truth about someone in a fraud and not telling because you have a motive is such a turn off.

I would have liked her to say I don't care if we get together or not kind of lines and she telling truth.. She could do it a longtime ago too if this was the case!
Edited by -Tia- - 9 years ago
Mitushi_Mitz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
I didn't find anything selfish or wrong in Pragya's dialogues. Throughout this mission her main motive was to expose Tanu and then obviously live a happy and carefree life with Abhi. If her main mission would have only been getting Abhi back in her life, she wouldn't have changed herself to Mogambo. Remember Abhi was ready to marry her when she returned as M.
And she was right, proof dikhane ka fayda hi kya, jab use vo milega hi nahi jo use chahiye. Aisi ladhai vo ladhti hi q jisme usne itna suffer kia, apni sister ko khoya, almost apni maa ko khoya! I know fighting this battle was her choice and Abhi didn't forced her, but she started this mission with a hope of getting her love back. And if it sounded selfish, then be it so! Because we all know what her main motive was!! It was exposing Tanu so that she can get her love back.
ann5 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
yes mitushi_mp...and the fact is there was a very big change that she may not have ended up with abhi...she went into this drama fully knowing what may or may not happen...her ultimate success of reuniting with abhi could have been blown out the window...selfish...I don't think so at all...
Edited by ann5 - 9 years ago
poiu123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Ya. This is appropriate for Pragya , the character.The whole journey has been depicted as fight for Kumkum, the basic premise of the show. The fight to stay united with her husband. If the husband does not trust her or does not want to be with her, the fight is not worth it.
Edited by poiu123 - 9 years ago
TeluguAmmayi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Mitushi_MP

I didn't find anything selfish or wrong in Pragya's dialogues. Throughout this mission her main motive was to expose Tanu and then obviously live a happy and carefree life with Abhi. If her main mission would have only been getting Abhi back in her life, she wouldn't have changed herself to Mogambo. Remember Abhi was ready to marry her when she returned as M.

And she was right, proof dikhane ka fayda hi kya, jab use vo milega hi nahi jo use chahiye. Aisi ladhai vo ladhti hi q jisme usne itna suffer kia, apni sister ko khoya, almost apni maa ko khoya! I know fighting this battle was her choice and Abhi didn't forced her, but she started this mission with a hope of getting her love back. And if it sounded selfish, then be it so! Because we all know what her main motive was!! It was exposing Tanu so that she can get her love back.



Her battle is is not selfish nor her love is.

But why should I tell the truth when i don't get you is def selfish.
Atleast I felt so, others may not.

According to me if I was some one who knows Abhi and I know Tanu is cheating him I would want to let him know that not because I will get something in return. It's because he deserves to know the truth and he is being punished for something he did not do.

If I tell him and he doesn't belive me it's his headache but if I think why should I will tell him I will not get anything if I tell him. That's selfish Na? Because my intention changes from helping him to getting him or something from him.

Anyways That line dint go with me well but I ignored.
Because Ann brought up it here I said what I felt.
Edited by -HappyLove - 9 years ago
Mitushi_Mitz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: -Tia-

This attitude she shows all along the mission! She always thinks of uniting with him, getting him etc. that was so so off! Especially in a situation where Abhi being blamed as a baby dad was involved! If Tannu wasn't pregnant and if the fight was just about who wins Abhi, then I accept this line! But here she was just lucky to overhear the truth and she took so long to convey it. And somewhere the issue was whether she will get him or not!!

Not that it was a selfless thing to do.. But knowing some truth about someone in a fraud and not telling because you have a motive is such a turn off.

I would have liked her to say I don't care if we get together or not kind of lines and she telling truth.. She could do it a longtime ago too if this was the case!

@bold- I would like to share my POV regarding this thing Tia! She always thought of uniting with Abhi because this was the only thing which gave her motivation to fight Tanu and expose her. And Abhi unknowingly used to do that many time.
And even Abhi said such dialogues many times! Remember when she returned as Mogambo, he said chalo shaadi kar lete hain! For him Tanu was pregnant with his child. He was being selfish at that time but I won't blame him. He loves Pragya, and what he did with Tanu was a mistake for him which he didn't even remembered. And now recently when Pragya stopped TaBhi's marriage, Abhi was so eager to find whether she loves him or not. Kahin na kahin he was also thinking of uniting with her. Jabki for him the baby was his!!
ann5 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
pragya said these words after she told abhi the truth...and said she could not show him the prove because in anger she broke her phone...she did not say these words before she said the truth...so the end game for her would be ...if he did not believe the truth...saw the truth in her eyes and face...after all that she said...then what would have been the point of fighting this fight...because she did it for him and yes in doing this for him...she also had a hope for herself that they will reunite...is this so wrong? no...it is not...

Related Topics

Kumkum Bhagya thumbnail

Posted by: Changers · 1 months ago

What the hell is wrong with Zee? Kumkum Bhagya is their only show in the last decade which started with 1.4TRP and touched 7.2 TRP in less than...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".