Poll

Will N accept that A is using M as an emotional surrogate?

Login To Vote
Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Okay, so we all know that AShutosh is experiencing fatherhood vicariously through Mallika and her child. It is an outlet for his emotions and supressed desires. He is doing it subconsciously and hence there is no guilt in him.Also because this is not the sole reason why he is doing it but only a small part of it. But will Nidhi be able to digest the fact that Mallika is more or less an emotional surrogate now, offering Ashutosh an experience that she herself is unable to provide?

And in case you are wondering why this poll suddenly, it is based on a response from KPji on a queston I had about Ashutosh...given that he continues to be extremely passionate wtih Nidhi, despite his support and concern for Mallika, I wanted to know if Ashutosh did not feel any guilt and was completely convinced of the legitimacy of his actions...the following is his response;...


It can be genuine passion because passion knows no guilt. His concern for Mallika is not out of any attraction for Mallika but a humane concern to look after a pregnant woman, and of course, vicariously fulfilling his desire to play a caring husband to a pregnant wife. Guilt comes when the man is cheating on his wife and having an affair.If Ashutosh was feeling guilty (which he was not, he was only feeling sensitive to Nidhi's reactions because of her back story with Mallika), then he would try to cover up his guilt with forced passion.

Edited by Sujatha.rao - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

42

Views

2.4k

Users

8

Likes

35

Frequent Posters

Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
My own answer is yes...she will,,,,becasue his actions are sub-conscious and not pre-planned...and this does not mean accepting Mallika's presence in her life for alltime...surrogates are temporary!
Edited by Sujatha.rao - 13 years ago
subashni thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Voted for no. it is for this reason she has walked out.If she learns it is subconscious she will be more hurt. But i don't take this as a reason for his help. Can he run behind every pregnant woman in Lucknow to satisfy his instincts, It is his usual mallu prem.
Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Voted for no. it is for this reason she has walked out.If she learns it is subconscious she will be more hurt. But i don't take this as a reason for his help. Can he run behind every pregnant woman in Lucknow to satisfy his instincts, It is his usual mallu prem.[/QUOTE

Radfhika...she has walked out...my question is she going to stay out...because even if Mallika leaves their lives, the fact remains that what happened happened...he did turn to Mallika for an emotional experience that Nidhi was unable to give him for her own reasons...!
Edited by Sujatha.rao - 13 years ago
subashni thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao

yes. she has reached a saturation point with mallu.won't tolerate her for whatever reason

Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: radhika72



You are still not getting my point...you are talking about not accepting Mallika...I am talking about getting back with Ashutosh ever...accepting what he has done,...and unless she accepts it, she cannot return ever!

subashni thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
yes she will get back feeling guilty for asking time. Angel mallu will enlighten nidhi about ashu's deep rooted desire.this may happen at the end of the separation track.
Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: radhika72

yes she will get back feeling guilty for asking time. Angel mallu will enlighten nidhi about ashu's deep rooted desire.this may happen at the end of the separation track.



Agreed...so this is about Nidhi realizing that she maybe imposed her choice on Ashutosh without discussing it with him...and he let her do it without opening up to her on what exactly is his mind...and Mallika's pregnancy is helping ease the two year wait for him...

I don't think Nidhi will think of her two year decision as a mistake...but she will realize the need for dialogue before making decisions...but at the end of the day, I don't see this as an empowering track which people seem to think it is...!
ttrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao

Okay, so we all know that AShutosh is experiencing fatherhood vicariously through Mallika and her child. It is an outlet for his emotions and supressed desires. He is doing it subconsciously and hence there is no guilt in him.Also because this is not the sole reason why he is doing it but only a small part of it. But will Nidhi be able to digest the fact that Mallika is more or less an emotional surrogate now, offering Ashutosh an experience that she herself is unable to provide?



Preferring to vote as others coz I really cant determine how KPji is gonna project Nidhi's character in upcoming episodes.
Ans. would be YES if she wishes to come back to Ashu keeping her marriage ahead of anything (including her self respect). This YES, IMO, will be completely against her will but will she hv a choice then? As far as this Mallika chapter is concerned, Nidhi is already suffering her choice to marry the complex, layered and totally intransigent personality w.r.t. Mallika -- Dr. Ashotosh -- who cant let go off Mallika, under any alibi: be it 12 saal purani dost or insaniyat or may be some other reason in future. The tough way, but, Nidhi will hv to accept the fact that if she wants to be with Ashu, she will hv to bear with his special inclination to Mallika. (And, I guess, she is well aware of this fact, but, she isnt fine with it; is trying her best to raise her voice against it; hv once again failed in it and due to that is deeply hurt and hence the decision of leaving marital home - in fact denying to leave with hubby Ashu under 1 roof. She cant avoid her boss Dr. Ashutosh - its not the available option at the moment, o.w. she might hv chosen that too.)
Ans. is a big NO if she wants to hold unto her feminine dignity & self-respect. She hasnt committed a crime in postponing motherhood just by 2yr.s. This is a great decision and perfectly reasonable. Also, acco. to Nidhi, this is their jointly taken decision. And even if Ashu has only half-heartedly consented for it; he hasnt clearly made her aware of his fatherhood pangs and insecurity. So, it's not her fault anywhere -- I mean, like every married woman, first, she has taken care of not advancing her career against hubby's will & then she rejoices in her internship with due consent of her hubby. So, obviously, it would be hard to digest for her that the same hubby is caring for Mallu & her child to fulfil his paternal instinct.
Edited by ttrocks - 13 years ago
Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ttrocks



Preferring to vote as others coz I really cant determine how KPji is gonna project Nidhi's character in upcoming episodes.
Ans. would be YES if she wishes to come back to Ashu keeping her marriage ahead of anything (including her self respect). This YES, IMO, will be completely against her will but will she hv a choice then? As far as this Mallika chapter is concerned, Nidhi is already suffering her choice to marry the complex, layered and totally intransigent personality w.r.t. Mallika -- Dr. Ashotosh -- who cant let go off Mallika, under any alibi: be it 12 saal purani dost or insaniyat or may be some other reason in future. The tough way, but, Nidhi will hv to accept the fact that if she wants to be with Ashu, she will hv to bear with his special inclination to Mallika. (And, I guess, she is well aware of this fact, but, she isnt fine with it; is trying her best to raise her voice against it; hv once again failed in it and due to that is deeply hurt and hence the decision of leaving marital home - in fact denying to leave with hubby Ashu under 1 roof. She cant avoid her boss Dr. Ashutosh - its not the available option at the moment, o.w. she might hv chosen that too.)
Ans. is a big NO if she wants to hold unto her feminine dignity & self-respect. She hasnt committed a crime in postponing motherhood just by 2yr.s. This is a great decision and perfectly reasonable. Also, acco. to Nidhi, this is their jointly taken decision. And even if Ashu has only half-heartedly consented for it; he hasnt clearly made her aware of his fatherhood pangs and insecurity. So, it's not her fault anywhere. I mean, like every married woman, first, she has taken care of not advancing her career against hubby's will & then she rejoices in her internship with due consent of her hubby. So, obviously, it would be hard to digest for her that the same hubby is caring for Mallu & her child to fulfil his paternal instinct.



Thank you for such a detailed analysis, Tupu...but going by all the responses that KPji has made so far, a permanent separation is not in the horizon...so, there is going to be a compromise...Nidhi will end of accepting Ashutosh for the man that he is...this does not mean she will accept Mallika...but she will accept whatever he has done and understand it...and move on with him...!
Edited by Sujatha.rao - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".