Coming back to KRPKAB - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

58

Views

7k

Users

12

Likes

117

Frequent Posters

beguiling thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: -JaprilForever-

Okay, lakshmi u really need to stop dismissing others' opinions on characters of this show. What u have is a perspective, it isnt actually what makers wanted to show. What others have is their perspective. None of us have gone into the writers mind to accurately guess what he wanted to convey. Every story can be interpreted in a thousand ways, and yes i apologise if in my earlier replies to u i might hv sounded like i believe only i am right. Because that is never the case.

Who even said Dev wasnt selfless? The TM? Nope. She was praising Sonakshi. Why does that bother u? Sona had a 1000 things worth praising about her. She was a good friend, good daughter, good sister, good wife, good dil, good sil, and a good mother. If it wasnt the case, why would ishwari's family become happy after 7 long years? Why Dev, who was lost suddenly come back home in the truest sense after his wife and daughter entered his life. This is my perspective. Sona was neither a villain, nor was Dev some God. Everyone in the show was flawed. Everyone who watched the show had different perspectives. Kindly respect that and move on.



Really appreciate your response. I feel being a woman myself I do tend to empathize more with the female characters in a show ( not saying that I do not loathe female characters in a show if they act annoying or do something immoral. )


Whilst Dev as a character became a lot more interesting for me post leap, I still can't help but point out that he did act like a complete asshole at times. Like him saying in an print interview that Sonakshi just wants to become like Dev Dixit, him blaming and insulting Sonakshi's family time and again while not being able to bear a single word said against his own mother and as I have mentioned already the way he used to manhandle Sona. In one of the scenes he even goes on to the extent of insinuating that Sonakshi might have done something intoward to become successful 😕 But when Vicky does the same he becomes angry.


Also though it was cute to see Dev getting jelly on seeing Jatin and Sona, it also largely pointed out on his hypocrisy that while he was okay dating girls, he acts oh so wronged and hurt if Sona dares to see someone else..infact he gets mad at her as if she has done a crime by "hiding her secret relationship with Jatin".


That Dev suffered a lot and loves Sonakshi like crazy despite of everything, that he extremely sincerely apologizes for his mistakes and tries to make amends for it - is what makes him so likeable. Infact this is something I adore about Dev and Sona the most that even in the times when they were driving each other crazy, fighting and pretending as if they don't love each other at all, still there were times when they would go out of their way to protect each other and do certain things which reflected that they do love each other.


That's what love in real life is like. We get to see the best and worst of our loved ones and continue to love them still.


Sowwy about the long rant again!
404_NotFound thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 7 years ago
#22
If I remember correctly, I never saw Dev insulting Sonakshi's family but he always respected them despite getting insulted by his FIL .In the day if Diwali he sent gifts , he never said a word when he was thrown out of his in laws house at midnight , he never made a big issue when his so called FIL advised his daughter to keep secrets from her husband.I pity Dev's character despite doing everything he is blamed for disrespecting his in laws .I guess he should have really done that for people to understand what insult is

People feel proud that Dev apologized but forget that Sonakshi failed to do so ...in my opnion If Dev had physical affairs then Sonakshi had emotional affair with Jatin ...she hid her pregnancy from her husband instead took Jatin's support at every stage of pregnancy.I am sure if Dev had done this he would be blamed and labeled as sinner

gmgi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: beguiling



Really appreciate your response. I feel being a woman myself I do tend to empathize more with the female characters in a show ( not saying that I do not loathe female characters in a show if they act annoying or do something immoral. )


Whilst Dev as a character became a lot more interesting for me post leap, I still can't help but point out that he did act like a complete asshole at times. Like him saying in an print interview that Sonakshi just wants to become like Dev Dixit, him blaming and insulting Sonakshi's family time and again while not being able to bear a single word said against his own mother and as I have mentioned already the way he used to manhandle Sona. In one of the scenes he even goes on to the extent of insinuating that Sonakshi might have done something intoward to become successful 😕 But when Vicky does the same he becomes angry.


Also though it was cute to see Dev getting jelly on seeing Jatin and Sona, it also largely pointed out on his hypocrisy that while he was okay dating girls, he acts oh so wronged and hurt if Sona dares to see someone else..infact he gets mad at her as if she has done a crime by "hiding her secret relationship with Jatin".


That Dev suffered a lot and loves Sonakshi like crazy despite of everything, that he extremely sincerely apologizes for his mistakes and tries to make amends for it - is what makes him so likeable. Infact this is something I adore about Dev and Sona the most that even in the times when they were driving each other crazy, fighting and pretending as if they don't love each other at all, still there were times when they would go out of their way to protect each other and do certain things which reflected that they do love each other.


That's what love in real life is like. We get to see the best and worst of our loved ones and continue to love them still.


Sowwy about the long rant again!


Hi Nikita, such a lovely response. Agree with everything you said. That is more or less my perspective too. I love both Dev and Sona as they are. I won't change a thing about them. They both have innumerable faults and weaknesses just like you or me. But they have so many lovely and adorable qualities too which makes it too easy to love them. I don't have to white wash their faults to like them because when you love someone you accept them as they are. So your response resonated so much with my thoughts. Happy to see you around.🤗
Japrilforever thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#24
I do agree that Dev's share of mistakes is greater than Sona's. But what also needs to be kept in mind was that none of those mistakes were intentional. He did not reveal about prenup and about sona's infertility,two main reasons why they broke up because he did not want to hurt sona. And when sona did not understand that and left him, he deliberately hurt her, as though punishing her for leaving him. I agree that dev was one of the most selfless characters in the show. But he was flawed and perfectly human.
Sona's character was the best until the reunion. She was perfect for any being. Post reunion, they just butchered her character imo. They tried to show her too mahaan and and they also did it to Dev's character role reversal track onwards. Thats where makers faltered, they lost touch with the very essence of the show which was its relatability. And no, i will not say that sona was selfish just coz she kept soha with her and didnt meet dev. She had her own reasons, she tried patching up with him 6 months after soha was born. But was snubbed. So her already hurt ego was bruised a little more. Both dev and sona post this separation track just held on to their egos, not willing to relent until soha intervened. If sona was selfish, she wouldnt have let soha bond with dev once she came to know he is her father. She wouldnt have tears of joy when she heard soha call dev papa, in her eyes. She wouldnt think about getting sisters back after getting back with dev after 7 long years. She wouldnt have let ishwari meet soha when she came to fight with boses when soha was sleeping. After all that she went through in ishwari niwas, being treated like an outsider with no say in some of family"s major decisions, like riya's wedding,neha's divorce, being forced to undergo fertility treatment for ishu's sake, being lied to about prenup, her father being slapped by her husband(even if accidentally), being thrown out of her own house supposedly by her own husband...for a woman who has gone through all of this,i think it is a little fair that she keeps her guard on and is slightly possessive about her daughter who was her only source of support for 7 long years. Yet she never restricted soha from bonding with dev,she solved the khatri matter, she did a lot for ishu's family even when she had no intention of reuniting wuth dev. And that can never be selfish.

Both dev and sona were wonderful humans with some very basic human flaws which do not get them crucified. But their biggest flaw was letting ishu and bijoy control their relationship. Both ishu in bijoy in their love for their children and somewhere their ego always kept Devakshi's happiness secondary. And that is what ruined everything.

404_NotFound thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 7 years ago
#25
Sona did not do any favors on Dixits by allowing Soha to mingle with Dev Infact they have ringed him big time by keeping her away .Its crimiminal offence

Dev was treated as an outsider too but he was too selfless to make an issue like Sonakshi .A wife expects her husband to allow her to make decisions for her Sil's divorce but the same wife hiss about her business plans from her husband .A classic case of Hypocrisy.

Dev hid her medical records so that she can enjoy her wedding but Sona hid his daughter so that she can use Soha to get back at Dev .This specks about the characters and unconditional love was never sona's cup of tea .

If a women is allowed to seperate Father and daughter because she went through a lot then I am sure even a father is allowed to seperate Mom and daughter too as he went through hell but I guess Dev is too good and won't use his daughter for his battles .This speaks a lot of about the characters ..who is mature and who is immature
404_NotFound thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 7 years ago
#26
If Sona and Bihoy's mistake can be justified then Dev and Ishwari's can be too but I forgot Sona is a women and is allowed to commit sins but Dev is a man .My bad I still didn't get Makers message .

@Lakshmi

Even after so many discussions we are unable to make peace with Sonakshi's character because we did not really see her repenting for her mistakes or learning to respect Dev . I guess we cannot lie that both the characters are at fault and keep criticizing one character in the pretext of praising another one .
Edited by yyyy - 7 years ago
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: yyy

If Sona and Bihoy's mistake can be justified then Dev and Ishwari's can be too but I forgot Sona is a women and is allowed to commit sins but Dev is a man .My bad I still didn't get Makers message .

@Lakshmi

Even after so many discussions we are unable to make peace with Sonakshi's character because we did not really see her repenting for her mistakes or learning to respect Dev . I guess we cannot lie that both the characters are at fault and keep criticizing one character in the pretext of praising another one .

Yes Nitu you are right. We are like that.What we feel we say that..


Lakshmi
Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: yyy

If Sona and Bihoy's mistake can be justified then Dev and Ishwari's can be too but I forgot Sona is a women and is allowed to commit sins but Dev is a man .My bad I still didn't get Makers message .

@Lakshmi

Even after so many discussions we are unable to make peace with Sonakshi's character because we did not really see her repenting for her mistakes or learning to respect Dev . I guess we cannot lie that both the characters are at fault and keep criticizing one character in the pretext of praising another one .



Nitu, understanding Sonakshi's greatness is like being able to see the Emperor's New Clothes. Only smart people are able it. Sonakshi is an angel, a goddess who came to this earth only to facilitate salvation for the Dixits. Before she came into their lives, they didn't know how to live. Without her they wouldn't have understood the meaning of life. It is only through her that Dixits were able to find happiness in life. I mean she is so independent that she was able to get pregnant and give birth to child without anyone else's contribution. I mean isn't Suhana's legal name Suhana Bose. If Dev has given any contribution, then her name would have been Suhana Dixit like common people. But Sonakshi is a complete human in herself. She doesn't need anyone's help in anything.

We are not smart women to understand all this greatness of Sonakshi. That is the reason why we feel that she is wrong in the first place. Maybe in a hundred years or so, we probably will become smart enough to realize her greatness and goodness.
Japrilforever thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#29
Well, being forced for treatment against the will of the patient is also a criminal offence. Did sona sue dixits for that?
If in every relationship u go about suing ur partner then no relationship will ever get a second chance when its crumbling.
I dont have much knowledge about laws but on an emotional front, if sona could forgive the dixits after all that they did to her and think about their well being then she cannot be termed as selfish.

And dev was never treated as an outsider in bose house while they were married pre leap. In fact all issues like saurav's business, elena-vicky had dev very much involved. In elena vicky's case dev came to know later when things got out of hand because sona did not want to disturb dev's peace of mind and bring enmity in the two families and thus tried to solve it internally itself. Once he came to know, he and sona solved the issue as a team.

There is no point taking sides. Im not taking sona's side. Im presenting her pov as some ppl seem to have complaints with her, so many complaints that they dont seem to get over it even after 6 months of the show ending. I presented dev's pov as well. I love Devakshi equally. Dev and Sonakshi were what made the show special. So guys stop ruining it for ppl who cherish this show by praising one character as if he is some God,and painting the other character as some vamp who had no good points about her. Both characters were highly flawed. And thats what made the show relatable.

Ishwari and Bijoy too were human. None of them had evil intentions. They both were blind in their love for their respective kids,and this love made them unaware about the harm they were causing their children.
Japrilforever thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#30
I dont want to reason with u, Shaavi. Because its not like u will understand. I disagree with a lot of things u have mentioned above. But this discussion is not going anywhere. The show is over so just chill.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".