Why is Soha more emotionally connected to Dev than Sona? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

2.6k

Users

12

Likes

77

Frequent Posters

mily_mathew thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: randommusings

Tbh this is added more for drama rather than being realistic.

Soha dreaming abt Dev holding her as baby or earlier when she dreamt Dev is in some problems What is realistic is Sona calling up Dev n when he doesnt pick up fast, then reaching to conclusion smthing is wrong. Same with Dev right..he doesnt have such telephathic connection whn Sona is in pain. Soha's reaction might be explained as blood relationship like a mother knows when child in trouble.

Infact Soha shud be able to understand n predict Sona's pain but she seems more affected with Dev's emotions than her mother who has raised her for 7yrs. Soha never notices or talks abt Sona's pov but seems inclined towards Dev. Maybe bcoz she has now met Dev so getting more attached to him n worries abt him..also Dev is showering all his love n focus on Soha compared to Sona who also has to discipline Soha as well.

ur bang on. That scene was just added for drama. It's all abt Dev's pain now. Sona and her family's pain always takes a backseat.
Enlightened21 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: _suchi_

Read suyash 's post di
I think u will get ur answer


I read it already Suchi...And that's what is bothering me. Weren't Sona also supposed to have such a soul connection with Dev, now that she has accepted him totally. And wasn't she also lonely and had the void in her, which Dev only could fill?
Enlightened21 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: randommusings

Tbh this is added more for drama rather than being realistic.

Soha dreaming abt Dev holding her as baby or earlier when she dreamt Dev is in some problem. What is realistic is Sona calling up Dev n when he doesnt pick up fast, then reaching to conclusion smthing is wrong. Same with Dev right..he doesnt have such telephathic connection whn Sona is in pain. Soha's reaction might be explained as blood relationship like a mother knows when child in trouble.

Infact Soha shud be able to understand n predict Sona's pain but she seems more affected with Dev's emotions than her mother who has raised her for 7yrs. Soha never notices or talks abt Sona's pov but seems inclined towards Dev. Maybe bcoz she has now met Dev so getting more attached to him n worries abt him..also Dev is showering all his love n focus on Soha compared to Sona who also has to discipline Soha as well.


Bold - Being KRPKAB, there should be some reason for the makers to show it so - whether it be for drama or being realistic. And if you scroll above, you can see from sweety's post that it happens in real too...😊
Suchi_Ejf_fan thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: grace4317



I read it already Suchi...And that's what is bothering me. Weren't Sona also supposed to have such a soul connection with Dev, now that she has accepted him totally. And wasn't she also lonely and had the void in her, which Dev only could fill?

well in this case I have to go for same ans daughters r more connected to their fathers like me. I love my mother more but always fill a connection with my father. Or we should wait and watch what makers store for us 😛
JyotiBThakur thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#15
I differ with you here Grace. I don't think Soha is more emotionally connected to Dev than Sona. No... It's not like that. First of all, i find the comparison in itself very unfair. And emotional connect between a father and a child and that of a husband-wife is always different. That doesn't mean we can consider one of it to be stronger than the other.

Now coming back to the episode, Sona was aware as she has sent Dev all the mails, he must have gone through them and she needs to be there with him. That's the reason she panicked when she couldn't get through him. Because she knew Dev must be in an emotional mess at that time and after coming to know he was in Kolkata, those tears in her eyes and the pain in her voice made it clear that she can feel what he'll go through there.

For Soha yes she had a dream of her father visiting her in her younger days, when Dev was actually in the hospital to feel the emotions when Soha was born. Soha's connection with her father is always shown this way that either she gets a dream or senses that he's in trouble.

With Sona, she's always there with Dev when he's in trouble. If there wasn't a deep emotional connect she wouldn't have been there always when he needed her the most and here i am talking about the post leap incidences. I don't think there's any need to show the same sort of emotional connect between Dev - Sona and Dev - Soha.
Edited by JyotiBThakur - 8 years ago
Enlightened21 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: sp12

Generally, it is believed that girls are more closer to their father whereas boys are to their mother, so maybe it's the same here. Apart from the instances mentioned in the other posts one instance which pops up was during Saurabh's wedding fiasco where she was the only one who understood that her father was not at fault.
Also another reason might be that given the circumstances under which Soha was born and brought up she was taught to be strong, independent and perfect. But with Dev coming into picture she is letting go of some her inhibitions as well. A point in case here is the recent engagement situation where she and golu hid the rings, this was something we could not have expected Soha to do if Dev was not in picture.
Just my POV, no offence.


Thanks for the comments and for reminding that moment from Saurabh's wedding.

Coming to the bolded part, you made me feel that Dev's presence has made Soha start feeling like a fairy, just like how her mom used to feel...No wonder why Dev called her his pari when he was leaving IN after the engagement fiasco.
suma74 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: grace4317


That's true Suma and being a Papa's girl, I can understand that connection. But my problem is that, with the way it was portrayed during their courtship days of S1, we had felt that connection between Dev & Sona. Then later due to the unfortunate incidents that had happened between them, they lost that connect...and still after reconciling that disconnect is continuing. That's what is bothering me.😕



Normally, husband and wife are two different individuals who live together with the relation of man and women , children will have the blood relation of mother and father so they are more connected to mother and father. Its difficult to reconcile between a man and woman after the bitter incidents, but blood relations don't require any, one cry or one sorry is enough. That the relations of marriage and marriage related relations. Thats why daughter and daughter in law is different. You can hate you spouse but cannot hate your child.

My view on Dev and Sona - even though Sona and Dev have reconciled, the wounds are left on their scar, its difficult to heal, thats why Dev told that he his hesistant to hold her hand while he was in the car.

Sorry, if I have bored by writing this.
Enlightened21 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: sweetyidiot

Hi Grace di ,your questions is valid... I may not be good at words but I will try to explain it with my experience

I lost my mother when I was 4 years old and I hardly remember her face ...my family never provoked that matter neither disscused anything about her in front of me and my brother as it is a sensitive topic...but when years passed on my dad once told me that you just behave like your mom remember I never saw her neither know any experience about her behavior but when my dad told that I was curious how can I behave like her I dwell more into this matter ...it was then I felt I never saw her but I always carved for her secretly ...imagined her ...imagined my life how it would be with her ...I created a separate world with her through my dairy entries all I feel is I am.an old soul came in search of her
Similarly soha always carved for her papa .she created her own world with her papa through her drawings she imagined everything how would it be if her papa exists with her...this why I feel she is more connected with Dev rather than sona...
This quote hold good for.the situation
Often your secret desiresdesires has an abilites to resurface in your dream

Hope I made some sense


Aww...idhar aao...ek cute sa 🤗 le lo...Sorry that my post reminded you of your mother.

At the same time, I am happy that I got the answer to my question. The bolded lines were more than enough to convey how Soha's cravings for her Papa's love is making her connected with Dev. And since Sona had to hid her cravings deep inside her, covered with her hurt & bad experiences, she is yet to get connected with Dev. Thank you so much dear for this lovely explanation.
sweetyidiot thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: grace4317


Aww...idhar aao...ek cute sa 🤗 le lo...Sorry that my post reminded you of your mother.

At the same time, I am happy that I got the answer to my question. The bolded lines were more than enough to convey how Soha's cravings for her Papa's love is making her connected with Dev. And since Sona had to hid her cravings deep inside her, covered with her hurt & bad experiences, she is yet to get connected with Dev. Thank you so much dear for this lovely explanation.

Thank you di 🤗 I really fell happy to be in this forum I am able to express myself pls don't feel sorry for reminding me of mom I live her so no worries
I am glad may be you got your answer with the little thought I put ...
Enlightened21 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: JyotiBThakur

I differ with you here Grace. I don't think Soha is more emotionally connected to Dev than Sona. No... It's not like that. First of all, i find the comparison in itself very unfair. And emotional connect between a father and a child and that of a husband-wife is always different. That doesn't mean we can consider one of it to be stronger than the other.


Now coming back to the episode, Sona was aware as she has sent Dev all the mails, he must have gone through them and she needs to be there with him. That's the reason she panicked when she couldn't get through him. Because she knew Dev must be in an emotional mess at that time and after coming to know he was in Kolkata, those tears in her eyes and the pain in her voice made it clear that she can feel what he'll go through there.

For Soha yes she had a dream of her father visiting her in her younger days, when Dev was actually in the hospital to feel the emotions when Soha was born. Soha's connection with her father is always shown this way that either she gets a dream or senses that he's in trouble.

With Sona, she's always there with Dev when he's in trouble. If there wasn't a deep emotional connect she wouldn't have been there always when he needed her the most and here i am talking about the post leap incidences. I don't think there's any need to show the same sort of emotional connect between Dev - Sona and Dev - Soha.

Thank you Jyoti for replying to my post.

I think I was not clear in my post that I didn't mean that Sona was still disconnected with Dev. I could feel her concern & anxiety when she couldn't get across Dev and understood the reason for the same. But, what I meant is that I was missing that connect which they shared during their courtship days or even before that. It maybe only for me, as I wanted to see Sona having that heart-heart connection with Dev.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".