Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

4k

Users

20

Likes

223

Frequent Posters

saumiee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Sarita568

Yes true it was a rushed realization. Sona went upstairs it seems and then she suddenly comes down all happy and excited and everyone is happy suddenly. Even Asha who was angry with her suddenly changed moods...also how was Sona so confident and sure that she will find dev? She was just running randomly somewhere and it seriously looked like she was drunk. So tomorrow Sona will just board an auto and go to the coffee shop? How does she know that dev is there?

Arrey, you forgot she said, She doesn't need any help to find Dev she will just know where he is because She loves him.
Just Daily Soap logic😆😆🤔
Edited by saumiee - 8 years ago
saumiee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: sjain



I guess I am the only one who didnt find episode bad Saumie..It was Okayish for me

Coming straight to last 10 minutes..I could actually understand her overexcited-ness her cheerfulness..Didnt find it wring their..How one gets child like excited when they finally feel free from their fears those clutches were gone and she felt so light and unburdened..that I could feel her happiness..I could related to the moments when I too faced such choking feeling and came out of it feeling like getting anew life..so it was nice for me..her jovial cheerfulness was adorable..she broke that shell and felt a new sonakshi who had streak of old one too who could again dream wish hope fly fearlessly feel enjoy love..It was birth of New Sonakshi for me

Now yes editing was bit her and their..but I choose to ignore it..also her remembering everything was good and understandable she kinda went through the whole journey..the only part missing for me ( even Charu said so ) that was monologue..They should have added that..it would have given more clarity to the realization part ..but why they didnt I would assume thier might be some reason of it..coz Its necessary

Honestly no complaints on acting and all Erica was fab for me in that last sequence..

Oh yes the point where Dev leaves why Sonakshi didnt stop him hmm..even I was thinking the same ..but she looked so guilty and upset in that moment and couldnt react possibly to talk to him..she was too shocked to react I atleast felt so

And dont kill me ..But Nisha was the best part..She was bold direct bang on..even the actress playing it was actually decent..she didnt do any typical drama but kept her points straight in front of the couple..so I liked that..no rona dhona no loud blaming..she asked right questions..which probably dev sonakshi were not bold enough to ask themselves

So it was little filler yet an important episode..I enjoyed it :)

Watch it again you

Awww mahua, you have this capability of looking at only the positives when you want to. . 😊
For the first time I thought even Erica's acting was not up to the mark. I don't know why but that entire scene was looking artificial.
Had this episode been an OS na, it would have come out lovely. . Because the writers knew what they were writing. Like you said, Sona was free, joyful, her old self again. .
But one, the screenplay could have been a little subtler. Not saying that Sona can't jump, scream or run in joy but the words they gave her could have been sooo much better.
Again, just one monologue answering the 'How' and 'Why' could have made the episode a hundred times better.
And I feel when Dev left Sonakshi wasn't that shocked to not react but she actually thought he would calm down and come back after a while. She knew he was hurt but till what extent, that she understood only when Dev called Soha to say he would not come for a few days.
Na, I won't kill you for saying you liked Nisha😆 I loved her scene because she showed the mirror to Sonakshi and I also loved the Dev and soha conversation and hug..Only two good things about the episode.
cscs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#23
Episode was fine for me Saumiee . Specially i loved Nisha and her dialogues were bang on. 👏 The way she lashed out both and Sona was good. Sona's sorry was for "family reputation"mainly n so justified. She was controlling her emotions throughout the drama and even after it. I guess Nisha, Asha and Soha's daant and Dev going away worked and realised there is no point of holding. Like Nisha said, either u love or u don't, so she choose love.

Editing was very bad yesterday which was one of the major drawback in connecting with Sona'a emotions. Although i do understand what she was feeling and how she came out of her cocoon. But there was lack in proper execution. Also, instead of jumping and shouting on streets if they should have given a monologue of Sona. A small one would have been enough.

Baaki lets see what they show today.
Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: saumiee

@shaavi:

Simply wonderful🤗 Like I always say, you have a way with words. Please don't be so modest dear, you are one of the best writers and analysers of the forum, I am toh nowhere near you.😆
I do understand her 'teenage girl in love' behavior neither I thought it was a misfit. My only problem is the series of events that led to this burden free Sonakshi wasn't well portrayed on screen.
What I didn't understand was what exactly was the moment that was like 'This is it. I love Dev and I cannot run away from it anymore' because prior to the scene in Bose house, a lot of things happened and she really did not react to it, She did looked disturbed but not to the magnitude the situation actually deserved. She was the same closed, stone hearted girl in IN, struggling with her feelings and as soon as she entered Bose house, she realised. What happened in between?
What does she think of it all? I hope that we get to see some it it today.

The umbrella symbolism is beautiful Shaavi.
One more thing, Yesterday Bijoy when talking to Asha on the phone said, ab usne galti kardi toh wo meri beti ho gai. .
That means till now Bijoy thought distance was what sona wanted but as soon as he got to know that she was hiding her true feelings, even he felt that she was making a mistake by not expressing.
The mantra jaap dialogue, (as cheesy it may sound) actually showed how Sona acknowledged she was not expressing her love to him till now and to compensate for it, she will say it every day, every minute. . Without any hesitation . .That she loves him.

The episode could have been a gem, we can all see what they wanted to show. .but thanks to the poor execution, it came out as a shabby episode.
Anyway, I would like to forgive them for this episode because I hope the upcoming episodes are going to be lovely.


Thanks for your kind words Saumiee. Sonakshi came a full circle in today's episode. The answer to your question lies in the memories that she remembered. All the fbs are something that shows her, her fairy tale dream, rain dance where they became kids, him loving her flaws and shortcomings yet making her feel special, complete and perfect. Where she thought he had never understood her found that not only he had understood her but had been part of that understanding. It was like a batti jali moment for her very similar to Dev realizing that he loves Sonakshi only when his sisters asked him to look deep within himself. When Dev said "haan" for Nisha's question regarding his love for Sonakshi, it was unexpected for her. She had thought that Dev felt he had settled for second best and not the Best for him. That he had felt ashamed of her because of her shortcomings. But his "haan" told a different story. The other things followed also pointed in the same direction. That all her fears we're unfounded. That Dev had never thought of her as anything less than his equal. That he had accepted her wholeheartedly and had not considered her any less.

As to Bijoy and Asha's talk it is to do with how Bijoy is. In the beginning of season 2 wasn't there an outpour of "perfection".Didn't Sonakshi constantly say that she was perfect, Suhana was perfect, Bijoy was perfect. In one of the episodes, didn't Sonakshi argue with Asha that Bijoy was perfect son, father and husband. Even Bijoy asked the same question to Asha in hospital after Dev asks him "is it possible for anyone to be perfect". Bijoy's question to Asha in hospital was "What kind of a husband am I?. Good, better or "perfect".". In the last few days what they have been showing is this friction between Bijoy and Asha in a subtle way. There were many times where Bijoy constantly told Asha that his daughter is over Dev. Asha told him that Sonakshi was wrong and Bijoy was wrong in thinking that Sona was over him. Yesterday it was proved and also that Sona didn't do the right thing. Bijoy had always been proudly saying that my daughter never makes mistakes had to admit that she made mistake and he made a bigger one by assuming that he was right and had not really paid attention to his daughter's pain and actions. All those times when he had said Asha was wrong was actually him being wrong. That was his outburst at being proven wrong for all those times, not just for what she did yesterday.

sjain thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: saumiee

Awww mahua, you have this capability of looking at only the positives when you want to. . 😊
For the first time I thought even Erica's acting was not up to the mark. I don't know why but that entire scene was looking artificial.
Had this episode been an OS na, it would have come out lovely. . Because the writers knew what they were writing. Like you said, Sona was free, joyful, her old self again. .
But one, the screenplay could have been a little subtler. Not saying that Sona can't jump, scream or run in joy but the words they gave her could have been sooo much better.
Again, just one monologue answering the 'How' and 'Why' could have made the episode a hundred times better.
And I feel when Dev left Sonakshi wasn't that shocked to not react but she actually thought he would calm down and come back after a while. She knew he was hurt but till what extent, that she understood only when Dev called Soha to say he would not come for a few days.
Na, I won't kill you for saying you liked Nisha😆 I loved her scene because she showed the mirror to Sonakshi and I also loved the Dev and soha conversation and hug..Only two good things about the episode.



HAHA I try to and with major makeovers of Ishwari and Bijoy I was well prepared may be ..Dont know what exactly but still I was not so affected like I was when they showed Ishwari's change of heart and even Bijoy's

Like I said that scene was fine to me as they showed a very impulsive over joyous Sonakshi so dialogs matched to the mood of the sequence so I would say their I have no complaints even Erica was fine for me

Yes monologue was major missing thats what made things looks abrupt and jumbled up..the flow was jerky due that..so 100 % I can say monologue was a major miss

When Dev left after showing his disappointement on her she was stunned by the happenings of the evenrts taht she could not react..she was prepared taht Dev has decided to let go and he in all his sense has decided to do this engagement and with her blurting out thigns to Nisha has ruined everything..How they ahve always kept their responsibilities above their emotions..BOTH..because of that she was more worried and even after that she didnt react as she was sulking in her guilt

yes she thought once he will be calm then he will be back but I dont know if him saying he is going to be away for days triggered her mind or anything else..because they directly showed Sona remembering his time with dev and then showed her happily informing family that she is gonna patch up..so that middle part was missing their ( THE MISSING MONOLOUGUE ) LOL

yes Nisha's naked bold words were slashing soankshi's heart soul and emotions..Nisha was brave for me I so loved her <3
Here the sad and ek aur adhoora armaan reh gaya..Dev Sonakshi always needed some third person to drill sense on to their head sighh..wish this awakening had happened on its own..Here Nisha was the link to it..though even after her saying everything Sonakshi's immediately didnt go and run after Dev she took her time to understand..for words to sunk in but how it happened AAHH ( THE MISSING MONOLOUGUE ) LOL

I feel sometimes you need logical connect and sometimes emotional as per me..and it depends on the situation..yesterday's episode was more of emotional connect..Ishwari's change of heart or Bijoy's change needed logical connect..so jo bhi connect miley le lene ka

Oh infact I for to tell you..yesterday's sonakshi confession reminded me of your bird wala post it fit the situation so aptly perfectly

Also I was thinking they took 1 week for Dev Sonakshi confession ..wish they had taken few episodes for Dev Sonakshi's truce as in clearing all misunderstanding and starting with heir friendship ( khatri time) then ..wish they had takes few weeks to show Ishwari's flip..All these major junctures they missed

PS we thought Bijoy is just agreeing for Sonakshi but looks like he is fine with this now LOL..ek aur failed assumption

Edited by sjain - 8 years ago
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#26
Saumee.
Agree with every word you wrote. And it was so beautiful as usual. No need to say it again. You always excel yourself.

I did not find the realisation well executed like you said. The episode left a feeling of dissatisfaction that I am sure of. It was one of the crucial episodes but handled in haste.

Dev Soha scene and Nisha's ability to assess herself,Sona and Dev are the redeeming factors.

After the episode I am habituated to read your take,can't do without it. Continue your good work.I am an avid reader ,enthralled by your write ups.



Lakshmi
Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#27
In Tamil, there was a movie named "Sachein" released in 2005 starring Vijay and Genelia. In that movie both of them are college students and Sachein is a very outspoken person. He tells Shalini (Genelia) that he loves her. She says that she doesn't love him. So he challenges and says that he will make her fall in love with him in 30 days. She does fall in love with him in that 30 days,, but does not accept it as it would mean her "defeat". She lets her ego win and does not tell him even on the 30th day when he admits defeat. On the 31st day, Shalini is excited and goes to propose Sachein. But suddenly she meets Gowtham (Raghuvaran) on the way who is Sachein's father. Gowtham is a billionaire and the entire college gets surprised that Sachein is the only son of a rich business tycoon as Sachein always stays very simple and down to earth. Now Shalini feels bad that if she proposes her love towards Sachein at this moment, then he might misunderstand that she decided to marry him after knowing that he is so rich and decides to stay calm. Sachein leaves to Coimbatore airport and Shalini also follows him. In the airport, Shalini could not control her emotions and proposes to Sachein. She also says that it is her ego that didn't let her convey her love during the last 30 days. Sachein feels so happy and the both are united.

I feel this is similar to what happened with Sonakshi yesterday. I had mentioned regarding the display of trophy case in Sonakshi's bedroom. From the beginning of the series she has been shown to strive to be the best and anything less than that being unacceptable for her. She is someone who is not able to accept that she can fail or she is not the best. This is something that Elena has mentioned few times both in season 1 and season 2. She knew she loved Dev. But did not want to accept it thinking what Dev would think of her. That she came only when she was sure and she also felt bad regarding what she was doing with Nisha. She didn't want to be with Dev at the expense of Nisha and her broken heart. But then Nisha showed her the mirror. She saw what followed due to her inaction. She realized that in trying to be selfless, she had actually been very selfish. The "daants" proved that. But then she remembered the memories. All of them are of those times when she did something less than perfect, yet were times when Dev had made her feel special. Like the dance in Shimla where she was feeling incomplete and imperfect due to her infertility, he had not only told her that she was complete, but had told her that she was special. Same with that bedroom memory where he had told her that she was the most beautiful woman and that there was nothing more that he had wanted in his life. She realized that she had not lost. Just like how his win was with her win(Ishwari's words to her, tere jeet mey hi uski jeet hai), she realized that her win was in his win. That they both had won and none had lost. Dev would lose only if she didn't go to him.

For me the way it was pictured was so Sonakshi. She didn't need too many words for her realization. In a way her monologues regarding her dilemma was spread across several episodes ever since her breakdown in front of Dev's photo after he left home during Khatri track. She has been saying things as to what is happening with her. But was not ready to accept as she felt she would lose if she did so. In those memories she realized that there was no place for ego in love. And she became the Sonakshi who fell in love with Dev originally.
Edited by Shaavi - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".