Whoa who writes the dialogue of krpkab - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

3.9k

Users

11

Likes

84

Frequent Posters

kvys thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: mily_mathew

unrealistic drama is not there. But logic has taken a major hit. Also sona her mind is totally unreadable. A few days ago she said Dev ko jab dekhungi toh saari pickle baatein yaad aengi, toh if all is her fault. Why was she angry with Dev. This lack of connection between scenes is what I'd don't get. Or did she say that coz she was scared Nisha mite call off the engagement if she thinks dev is not perfect.


Why ll you find the logic here. ??😛

I feel they have shown here feelings properly..
From the beginning she said mistake is not only from dev's side for their broken relation.
And she was not in a place to accept her feelings because of her fear, scared of broken past relationships. She took forward step only after ish accepted her mistake yesterday and day before .. I don't think they have shown illogical things. Just that in few places they have shown few things which doesn't have connection. There was a discontinuity.. but not in this case. That too w.r.t dev's engagement and her feelings towards Dev..
mily_mathew thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#12


My point is simple. This is serial not the real life.
Even in real life I am sure most of us have teased our elders one or the other time. Went against their decision one or the other time. Even we did fightings with parents..


Hey I din mean to offend anybody. But that was too much. I mean it felt like cvs were trying to get away by making sona and bijoy the scapegoat. When the lion share of mistake is with dev ish
I mean the show does not make any sense.
Even I felt they missed few things.. like confrontion from Sona about throwing their family out of their house.. few things missed the track.. but
The other way.. Life is all about mistakes realization forgiving.. . Love support care.. Parenthood, protecting their childern, they have yet shown bijoy's track.. I think there ll be a track where they give justification to Bijoy's char as well..

At least here they are not showing unrealistic drama that is what I feel..
unrealistic drama is not there. But logic has taken a major hit. Also sona her mind is totally unreadable. A few days ago she said Dev ko jab dekhungi toh saari pickle baatein yaad aengi, toh if all is her fault. Why was she angry with Dev. This lack of connection between scenes is what I'd don't get. Or did she say that coz she was scared Nisha mite call off the engagement if she thinks dev is not perfect.
Why ll you find the logic here. ??😛

I feel they have shown here feelings properly..
From the beginning she said mistake is not only from dev's side for their broken relation.
And she was not in a place to accept her feelings because of her fear, scared of broken past relationships. She took forward step only after ish accepted her mistake yesterday and day before .. I don't think they have shown illogical things. Just that in few places they have shown few things which doesn't have connection. There was a discontinuity.. but not in this case. That too w.r.t dev's engagement and her feelings towards Dev..
She din say mistakes from both side, she said I was the one who made the mistakes. I tried to change dev blah blah, which was clearly out of context with respect to the previous scenes. So what's exactly her fear. All this time she kept fighting with dev and today she says I was at fault. Come on that was a bit too much. Everybody knows what went wrong.
mnx12 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: mily_mathew

Hi

But what was wrong there. I just expressed my opinion.

Atleast please could you clarify
.

It's explained in pm.
kvys thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#14
Mily Mathew.
You might have missed few episodes.

She accepted that mistake was from both the sides in many episodes.

Why to take this so seriously.. this is just a show. Watch it or forget it. Else if you don't like this leave it and watch someother serial. There are plenty..

This is entertainment not a life lesson.

Most of us watch this serial just for Dev and sona's chemistry..

I watch this just because this is one of the rarest of rare serial where I don't find actual zoo. grandparents are getting younger day by day.. more over I like the storyline.

I feel we don't need to find the logic that too in serial..
Logic is different for different people. If ish is wrong to one person she might be right to others..

I am not arguing. I am just trying to say that expressing your opinion is not wrong but finding the logic in any serial is not logically proven..
Edited by kvys - 8 years ago
mily_mathew thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: kvys

Mily Mathew.

You might have missed few episodes.

She accepted that mistake was from both the sides in many episodes.

Why to take this so seriously.. this is just a show. Watch it or forget it. Else if you don't like this leave it and watch someother serial. There are plenty..

This is entertainment not a life lesson.

Most of us watch this serial just for Dev and sona's chemistry..

I watch this just because this is one of the rarest of rare serial where I don't find actual zoo. grandparents are getting younger day by day.. more over I like the storyline.

I feel we don't need to find the logic that too in serial..
Logic is different for different people. If ish is wrong to one person she might be right to others..

I am not arguing. I am just trying to say that expressing your opinion is not wrong but finding the logic in any serial is not logically proven..

I have not missed any episodes. The episodes are contradicting.
But great art always want logic. And it's true people do expect logic and reason in a show they considered close to their heart.

Thats how it is. That's how great pieces of art work shape up.
Shaheena2703 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#16
Sorry to say this but I didn't find the dialogues irrelevant...
1) when u have a fight with it frd or spouse or anyone for that matter...u blame the other was wrong..and when the same issue is solved and patch up we take the blame...that's what sona did.
2) was sona always right? Was she perfect ...answer is NO..she might not have done mistakes as much as ish or dev...but she did mistakes of her part as well...don't u agree?
Like, interfering in neha's issue..will she be okay if Ronita pokes nose in her matter definitely not...
She called him mamma's boy (nothing wrong we do tease our partners) first time when she asked dev to do his work by himself (which I agree) but the way she imposed on him was not right(this sld happen slowly)...she very well knows ish -dev likes to do such thing..and they have a special bond...but by doing this ish and dev's feeling were hurt ...I didn't understand how would folding, ironing and arrange cloths will make her relationship better or good with dev... everything requires time but she rushed...
Dev asked sona to go out of frm the place(he didn't mention his house...but probably he meant so)...but sona decided to move out of his life (maybe right in her pov) ...it was rushed decision..still I felt how wld she misunderstand dev(my pov of view)..

3)maybe being a mom now..she can understand a part of ish and dev relationship...

Here it's not that I don't like sona or I'm supporting dev and ish..in fact I like sona's character a lot...I just want to tell that no one is perfect...all character have their own flaws...

Just one more thing making or breaking a relationship depends upon the ppl involved in it...whether it is lovers, frds, spouse ... how much ever good or bad the external factor is, it can never break or make relationship ...it's my belief ...sona and dev bond lacked maturity (both of them)...and that's the only factor which made them lonely...




mily_mathew thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Shaheena2703

Sorry to say this but I didn't find the dialogues irrelevant...
1) when u have a fight with it frd or spouse or anyone for that matter...u blame the other was wrong..and when the same issue is solved and patch up we take the blame...that's what sona did.
2) was sona always right? Was she perfect ...answer is NO..she might not have done mistakes as much as ish or dev...but she did mistakes of her part as well...don't u agree?
Like, interfering in neha's issue..will she be okay if Ronita pokes nose in her matter definitely not...
She called him mamma's boy (nothing wrong we do tease our partners) first time when she asked dev to do his work by himself (which I agree) but the way she imposed on him was not right(this sld happen slowly)...she very well knows ish -dev likes to do such thing..and they have a special bond...but by doing this ish and dev's feeling were hurt ...I didn't understand how would folding, ironing and arrange cloths will make her relationship better or good with dev... everything requires time but she rushed...
Dev asked sona to go out of frm the place(he didn't mention his house...but probably he meant so)...but sona decided to move out of his life (maybe right in her pov) ...it was rushed decision..still I felt how wld she misunderstand dev(my pov of view)..

3)maybe being a mom now..she can understand a part of ish and dev relationship...

Here it's not that I don't like sona or I'm supporting dev and ish..in fact I like sona's character a lot...I just want to tell that no one is perfect...all character have their own flaws...

Just one more thing making or breaking a relationship depends upon the ppl involved in it...whether it is lovers, frds, spouse ... how much ever good or bad the external factor is, it can never break or make relationship ...it's my belief ...sona and dev bond lacked maturity (both of them)...and that's the only factor which made them lonely...




Agree with all that u said. But Dev ish relationship honestly imo was disfunctional. That's the story abt. And the way ish treated sona and her family is not right. So yes sona made mistakes but Dev and ish in no way was a normal mother and son. I don't know now but honestly lot of people had issues with the way ish manipulated dev. My issue still is with the script. And the way they are masking off ishs insecurities as her protective Ness. I came for a great story din get it, hence the dissatisfaction. And yes there is a limit to toleration. Sona walked off when she reached the saturation.
Shaheena2703 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#18
S ur right ish and dev relationship was/is not normal... especially after dev and sona marriage...and also the fact ish character taking u turn which I'm also not convinced..CVs sld have taken some more time for realization ...but still I feel this is one of the good shows I have ever watched
mily_mathew thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Shaheena2703

S ur right ish and dev relationship was/is not normal... especially after dev and sona marriage...and also the fact ish character taking u turn which I'm also not convinced..CVs sld have taken some more time for realization ...but still I feel this is one of the good shows I have ever watched

Yes exactly. That was my problem. And since they have made sona go back to old please Ishwari mode. We have more torturous scenes awaiting us.
Shaheena2703 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#20
S ish is a complex character..in fact I felt in pre marriage episodes many times her pov was justified...like I feel even prenuptial agreement according to her pov was right ..I just an example I trust my frd but I can't have same trust on my frd's frd... likewise dev trusted sona and to some extent ish also knows abt her...but this trust will pass on to trust's trust ..I mean ish trusting sona's family...NO ..how can a person trust someone whom u haven't interacted or build relationship?
Her pov was right ...But the way she manipulated things were very bad or dirty...

But post marriage ish , none of her act will be justified...

Just my pov

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".